Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think children have a duty to help out elderly parents?

192 replies

Kendodd · 06/03/2024 18:48

YANBU = yes they do
YABU = no they don't

Lots of threads on here recently about this and also about asking grandparents to babysit. General view (that I seem to be picking up) is they GP have no reason to help out with GC, even as a one off/emergency but children should help elderly parents.

OP posts:
theprincessthepea · 06/03/2024 23:35

I find this attitude pretty sad. It’s no surprise that lonliness and other issues are more common for older people in the west to experience. And even the anxiety that now comes with motherhood. We don’t have a culture where we look out for eachother anymore.

Nobody is entitled to do anything at all. I don’t feel like I have to look after my parents and the truth is you don’t have to look after your children either if you don’t want to. But there is something in me that values family enough to see it as a lifetime of give and take. Strong families in my opinion build strong societies.

Personally if I have the capacity, I will do everything I can to take care of my daughter, family and when the time comes grandchildren. Of course it depends on circumstance. But I think we should all have the heart to at least want to help out.

JamSandle · 06/03/2024 23:30

I must admit I'm curious about the cultural background of most posters.

I think culturally beyond the UK/West people help each other more. The West doesn't really care about family in the same way as is engrained in many other cultures, at least not anymore.

TempestTost · 06/03/2024 23:30

Yes, I do think that generally speaking there are obligations. What those are will depend somewhat on the situation, but this applies both to grandparents helping the younger generation and kids helping parents. And actually I would include extended family as well. I have an aunt and uncle with only one daughter and I and my siblings are very conscious that she may need help supporting them as they age. My elderly disabled aunt now is largely supported by her siblings, not financially directly, but administratively, even though she is deeply disagreeable.

I don't see these kinds of obligations about being just about a good relationship. They are the obligations we have to others in society which make it functionable - if family doesn't step in, who will? Taxpayers? A random neighbour? These people have even less connection than family. Many of the things that need to happen to take care of elders, or young kids, can't just be provided through the market. Someone has to pay attention.

I'd also add that the idea that everyone will just be able to manage things if they plan correctly financially is incredibly middle class, but even naive in that instance. Even fairly well off people will need help from a friends or family at times.

Of course, if someone has the kinds of parents who seem to have no interest in supporting their grandkids and family themselves, it's going to be unlikely that the kids will go out of their way to do more than the bare minimum.

JamSandle · 06/03/2024 23:28

Misthios · 06/03/2024 21:10

These threads always make me laugh. All the people saying that of course they’d “care” for a parent as to them care means popping to Tesco, picking up a prescription or running the hoover round. Helping out things which don’t impact at all on their lives. They don’t mean that they are prepared to be 24/7 carers for a parent who has some sort of condition which requires personal care with washing and toileting. They haven’t a clue.

How do you know this? How do you know who has and hadn't provided care on this thread? Many people do every day.

SheerLucks · 06/03/2024 23:20

It's not an obligation by any means, but it really depends on the bond.

We lived next door to my parents. They both sadly passed away in 2022, but we had a great reciprocal relationship before then.

They really helped out physically and financially once we'd had DCs, and we were ever present as they became very old and more dependent on us.

I couldn't have asked for more, and still miss them every day.

buswankerz · 06/03/2024 23:13

I think if you want to or able to take on that role then do so if you choose to.

I don't feel that children are obligated to look after elderly parents.

My husband and I have done funeral plans, we've told our children not to look after us and to move us into care homes when the time comes. We will be looking to downsize in the future.

NewName24 · 06/03/2024 23:10

I don’t see it as a ‘duty’. If parents built a strong healthy relationship with their children I believe the children would willingly be helping and not out of duty. If parents think just because ‘blood’ they are entitled to help, they are BU.

This.
If you and your parents have a strong and loving relationship then you want to do what you can to support them when they need it, just as they wanted to support you when you needed it.
That - for me - means "within reasonable limits" and where the 'reasonable line' is will be different for different people. Logistically it is more difficult for some than others. Getting the balance right is key.

KohlaParasaurus · 06/03/2024 23:10

I'll be a much better daughter to my parents when they need care if I'm not having to provide full time hands-on nursing including things like bathing and toileting, which would be a miserable, undignified, and probably unsafe experience for everyone concerned. I've told them that I'd expect them to spend what they refer to as "our grandchildren's inheritance" on professional care if necessary. Likewise, I don't expect any of my own children to take responsibility for me if I'm no longer able to look after myself.

Spectre8 · 06/03/2024 23:09

No but equally once a child is an adult and working they should expect there parents for handouts or childcare.

Everyone needs to provision for their old age and giving money away for house deposits whilst is nice to do if it means u then can't fund care u are absolutely screwed if ur kids then also decide not to help or do bare minimum.

Same eith having kids do so having worked out if u can afford childcare cos u can't predict GP help or they might be healthy and well enough too.

Everyone needs to really prioritise ensuring they are in the best position they cna be to not have to depend on a family member as must as possible

RantyAnty · 06/03/2024 23:09

Kendodd · 06/03/2024 18:59

My view - children owe their parents nothing. The children didn't ask to be born, parents didn't have to have them, they chose to bring more human beings into the world just because they wanted to. But parents do have a duty to their children and this doesn't just end at 18. This isn't to say GP should give up work to be full time carers for GC either, just that things are much harder for young people now so we should help them were we can.

My age, for context, mid 50s, young adult/late teen children, elderly parents. I never recieved a single day of help with my children from my parents (nor would I have left my children with them though if they had offered). I don't/won't help my parents. They live other end of country anyway.

I guess they don't have any inheritance to leave you?

Pallisers · 06/03/2024 23:07

I had wonderful parents and any care I gave them was out of love. Any care they gave to my children was also out of love for them and love for me - wanting to make my life easier. I hope my children will feel the same about me. That they will want to help and support me if I am old and vulnerable because they love me.

I have a friend in a situation now where her mother is in her 80s and has had a health issue. Other family members are supporting -organising the nursing home/going to A&E for the night, organising what needs to happen for this woman to get back to her own home. My friend has no issues with her mother - mother babysat extensively for her when needed - as in regular babysitting and minding children for 2 weeks at a time while she went away. But she hasn't even visited her mother once because it isn't really convenient for her. I can't get my head around that tbh. I think it is very cold.

No one owes anything to abusive or bad or absent parents.

Station11 · 06/03/2024 23:06

No, not at all, it's nice if they can. I also think though that elderly parents can't expect help if they haven't helped their own children.

My kids are late/early teens and I can't imagine not helping, but I also wouldn't do regular childcare (so instead of nursery). I would maybe expect the same help back - ad hoc (when they are free) rather than regular

JudgeJ · 06/03/2024 23:02

The children didn't ask to be born,

I can hear my 10 year old self saying that, such a high standard of debate!

iwafs · 06/03/2024 23:01

Depends really.

If parent has been kind, loving, supportive etc - then yes.

If parent has been selfish, nasty, abusive or not supportive/not given a shit - then no.

gealen · 06/03/2024 22:59

No, I've gone NC with my whole family in the past few years and it's so liberating not to feel duty-bound for anything.

Temuaddiction · 06/03/2024 22:57

No my dad has always been shit. I will be around when he's old but not a lot

Chasingthewilddeer · 06/03/2024 22:52

Yes children should take some responsibility for elderly parents if they can but other responsibilities such as children may take precedence and if a parent didn't responsibly parent then no they shouldn't expect the child to care for them in their old age.

redalex261 · 06/03/2024 22:46

I find it really depressing that people are not willing to help out their family at both ends of life! I think in most families IRL there is some give and take, mostly because there is some genuine affection and good relationships in spite of occasional friction. I did help both my father and MIL quite a bit in the last few years of their lives. It did ramp up towards the end and frankly was really hard going - I couldn’t have managed without help from other family and paid carers, don’t know how folk manage it without support. Both of them had done school runs, overnight stays, hours here and there so I got to Tesco in peace years before. They did it because they wanted to spend time with GC and help out. Both always doled out too many sweeties and let GC away with murder, just had to bite my tongue and tell myself it wasn’t an everyday thing.

It’s true no-one has a duty to provide childcare for grandkids same as no-one should feel compelled to care for infirm relatives. But it is nice to think that if relationships are generally good families would help each other within reason. There are some selfish gits on both sides - unreasonable grandparents who refuse point blank to even take GC to allow parents out for dinner; equally some parents expect free weekly childcare to allow them to work and then complain if granny doesn’t adhere to all their exacting rules. From what is reported on MN by the (mostly) mothers themselves the bulk of the moaning about rules, boundaries and red line crossing is directed at in-laws more their own parents.

Some elderly parents are really demanding and expect instant attention for minor crap - do not see their adult children simply do not have the time to jump to it immediately and hate being guilt tripped constantly.

However, I have always noticed the adult children adamant they cannot/will not help their parents as they are too busy/too important/don’t want to are often those most concerned about their inheritance being preserved!

SpilltheTea · 06/03/2024 22:36

No, it depends on the family. I'd do anything for mine, but that's because they're not arseholes.

LuciferRising · 06/03/2024 21:46

I would do whatever I am capable of offering for my parents and step father. And I would help with grandchildren, including step grandchildren, if I am able. I don't want to live in a disconnected society. People should not do something they do not want to do but I believe we've become too insular and inward looking.

My parents weren't perfect. My step father was great.

Whiskersoff · 06/03/2024 21:46

Yes, I believe all family members have a loving duty towards one another, and to be honest I think most people believe that. It only seems to be online where people come out and say "my elderly parents should have made provisions for themselves" or "I didn't ask to be born", which suggests some people are picturing a scenario where indifferent elderly parents have squandered everything and are now demanding endless bailouts. I don't think that's most people's experience. Obviously if a family member is taking the piss, then you protect yourself and keep firm boundaries. That's very far from the defensive, dog-eat-dog individualism espoused by some on this thread.

And no, I did not expect my parents to provide regular childcare for my children (they live too far away anyway), but I would be amazed if they ever turned round and said "no I certainly won't ever take them for a day or two in the holidays, I didn't ask for them to be born". I mean... Who acts like that, in real life?

No wonder other cultures think we're nuts and indeed we are collectively losing our marbles - one of the few things we are doing collectively!

Mary46 · 06/03/2024 21:45

We never had help. Always negative and putting me down. Anyways not always straight forward with elderly. Would def not get run ragged either. It does upset me at times expects loads help now.

CaramelMac · 06/03/2024 21:43

I won’t be looking after my parents when they’re elderly.

A little while ago DH was admitted to hospital unexpectedly, I was working full time and looking after two toddlers, my parents were coincidentally coming to stay with us the next weekend which would’ve been a great help with the kids while he was in hospital. As soon as they found out he was in hospital they made all manner of excuses not to come, they didn’t want to help me when I needed them.

Selfish doesn’t begin to describe them.

I’ve asked them repeatedly to sort out POAs and they refuse because they don’t want to pay the fee, I think it’s £80, so they’ll have to be at the mercy of the council or whoever steps in when you’ve got no one else, because I won’t be there.

MrsBook · 06/03/2024 21:40

Yes, I believe we do have a duty to care and look after close family members. I also think it is an honour that allows an experience of love that is complicated, difficult but profoundly significant.

I also understand why in some circumstances it is not possible or not appropriate.

It's a duty no one can make you perform. And I wouldn't go around judging other people on it. But for me, yes, I think I have a duty to look after my parents, and I hope I do right by them. They are wonderful people and I want them to feel loved and secure right through to the end.

ErinAoife · 06/03/2024 21:40

I have a French friend who is giving a percentage of her salary for the upkeep of her mother in a retirement home, all her siblings do as well. She explains to me that it is law in France if the person cannot pay for her care, the close family has to foot the bill. They look at your salary to decide what amount you had to pay.

Swipe left for the next trending thread