Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think children have a duty to help out elderly parents?

192 replies

Kendodd · 06/03/2024 18:48

YANBU = yes they do
YABU = no they don't

Lots of threads on here recently about this and also about asking grandparents to babysit. General view (that I seem to be picking up) is they GP have no reason to help out with GC, even as a one off/emergency but children should help elderly parents.

OP posts:
Comms · 07/03/2024 04:51

It depends on the parents and what type of relationship you had with them really.
My parents are fabulous. They always put us kids, their grandchildren and great grandchildren first, no matter what.
While I don't feel duty bound to help them, I will help them if I need to.
They always did their best for me and in appreciation of that, I'll always do my best for them.

BruFord · 07/03/2024 01:36

@PixieLaLar Well yes, expecting your children to look after you is absurd, but most posters are talking about helping out their parents to make their lives abit easier, not full-time care.

My elderly Dad’s pretty hopeless with technology so me ordering him things online or doing an online shop for him is a way that I can help him. Same with regular phone calls, especially since my step-Mum died.

These types of things aren’t outrageous expectations, are they? It’s just helping them out.

PixieLaLar · 07/03/2024 00:59

Totally backwards way of thinking IMO.

If you choose to have children then they are no one else’s responsibility but your own.

Grandparents should not be expected to do anything, YOU chose to have children. And even more outrageous that people then have a hold over their children to expect care of them. If you are having a child for this sort of reason alone then you should not be breeding, it’s outrageous.

itsachange2024 · 07/03/2024 00:55

It's down to individual circumstances.
I was close to my dad but neither of them helped much after becoming an adult - but were kind, and caring. I would have done anything for them. They died when I was in early 30s. I helped my mum and arranged dads funeral.
I do a lot for my adult dc but don't want to be a doormat and need some space after many years of child rearing and a stressful job. I am trying to negotiate a close but more equal relationship with them. Ie not me doing and providing everything.
I don't want or expect them to vent carers, but I do expect them to care and try to help me with some things if they can as I get older.

Astonetogo · 07/03/2024 00:54

Kendodd · 06/03/2024 18:59

My view - children owe their parents nothing. The children didn't ask to be born, parents didn't have to have them, they chose to bring more human beings into the world just because they wanted to. But parents do have a duty to their children and this doesn't just end at 18. This isn't to say GP should give up work to be full time carers for GC either, just that things are much harder for young people now so we should help them were we can.

My age, for context, mid 50s, young adult/late teen children, elderly parents. I never recieved a single day of help with my children from my parents (nor would I have left my children with them though if they had offered). I don't/won't help my parents. They live other end of country anyway.

I voted yanbu for your OP, but I disagree with your point of view in this post.

I think people who had loving upbringings should do what they can to support their aged parents, and parents do not have an obligation to their offspring past 18 (although most want to support beyond this out of love).

HeddaGarbled · 07/03/2024 00:47

Here in the UK, people leave the raising of their kids and the care of the elderly to the government. What a lazy society we have become

Nonsense.

sittingingold · 07/03/2024 00:42

I do hope my child will feel they owe me, in that I hope to give them a wonderful life where they are content and secure and have enough that they can be generous to others, including me.
I will feel I've failed as a parent it they didn't want to support me in my frail years, even if that's not physical care but arranging that care and hopefully allowing me some dignity.
Being a parent can be a thankless task for many years, and full of sacrifice. It would be nice if that was recognised in old age when the tables are turned.

Stompythedinosaur · 07/03/2024 00:40

I think that families try to support each other.

But there's an element of "you reap what you sow". I'll support my mam, but wouldn't have supported my dad, because I don't owe him a thing.

sittingingold · 07/03/2024 00:37

My parents died before I had my child so no free grandparent childcare here.

I did help them out a fair bit and look after them/care for them but I didn't live terribly close to them so it was in fits and bursts rather than daily.

My parents weren't the best parents at all, but they were decent people in their own way.

The first parent was very ill and died before our relationship repaired properly and I regret to the bottom of my heart even many years later I wasn't there for them as much as I could have been.

The second parent (who didn't deserve it!) got the benefit of this regret and my understanding about the finality of death and so got a-lot more help & care from me (& also from my sibling who felt the same regret I did).

I'll be honest, as much as my parents aren't the best I find it very upsetting to hear people (not on this thread I haven't read it, more in RL) slagging off their very reasonable parents and getting annoyed with them for every little thing.

You don't know what you've got until it's gone.

OnlyTheBravest · 07/03/2024 00:37

As a poster has previously mentioned it is not black and white and is very much dependent on family dynamic but in my opinion the only people with a 'duty' are parents with dependent children. Adults are responsible for themselves. However. if you have built healthy relationships within the family. It is more likely that people want to put themselves out for you. Therefore, grandparents will baby sit and adult children will support elderly parents.

On the cultural issue we are in a time of redefining the rules. Women are now more likely to be working up to 60+/have children later and are not available to baby-sit or provide elderly care without reducing their working hours. House prices and job availability have forced families to move further away from each other and it is no longer the sole responsibility of the eldest or the women in the family to provide caring responsibilities.

People are now expected to plan for their old age with less family support. In the same way that if you have children you are expected to have thought about who is going to look after your children if you wish/need to return to work.

It can be lonely for those who have not planned appropriately or who have toxic family relationships and incorrectly expected that family would be there for them.

XenoBitch · 07/03/2024 00:31

I don't have kids, so expecting my parents to help out with DC wont apply. My sister had kids, and our folks have said that they have done their time with little ones... they wont be baby sitting etc.
TBF, we all live miles away from each other anyway, so it is a moot point.

I know my DM wont want help from us DC. My dad... well, he is an ass, and if my mum goes first, he will rot alone in their house anyway.

I can't look after myself, let alone a parent.

fancypants1989 · 07/03/2024 00:27

CinnamonJellyBeans · 06/03/2024 23:59

Here in the UK, people leave the raising of their kids and the care of the elderly to the government. What a lazy society we have become.

I don't think that's fair. Many people have to move out of their area to find work. More and more people can't find work or homes in the area they grew up in and called home. Property prices in cities are ridiculously expensive. Nice towns and villages are being overrun with second home's people

mondaytosunday · 07/03/2024 00:05

You may not have chosen to be born, but they did not choose to be grandparents.
Frankly I had a wonderful relationship with my parents but they were mid 70s when my kids came along a while they did babysit occasionally in the evening I didn't ask them to do daytime or overnight. My in laws were never interested.
But my parents took great care of me and sacrificed a lot for us so I would do whatever to support them as they age. And I certainly do not believe things are 'harder for young people now' - both my parents worked, they had to deal with cloth nappies and much fewer conveniences we have now (not to mention growing up during the war in the case of mine).

Babyroobs · 07/03/2024 00:00

My dad has always been good to us, helping with childcare even when he was suddenly bereaved, helping us with a house deposit when we returned to the Uk with nothing, has always been supportive and there when we needed him. Now he is 85, reasonably independent but this won't last. i will do everything I can to support him. I want to leave the area I live in but won't until my dad is no longer here, fortunately we are only a few streets away from him.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 06/03/2024 23:59

Here in the UK, people leave the raising of their kids and the care of the elderly to the government. What a lazy society we have become.

BruFord · 06/03/2024 23:57

@SinisterBumFacedCat It’s definitely harder when you’re an only child and you sound as if you’ve had an especially difficult time. 💐

My Mum died decades ago so I’ve only had to deal with my Dad who’s cognitively OK aside from his long term MH problems, so that’s made it easier. I still wish that I could clone myself sometimes. I hope that your DH is supportive.

Withinthesewalls · 06/03/2024 23:56

stayathomer · 06/03/2024 19:35

I think people have a duty to help out anyone they know who needs a bit of help. Given that your parents gave up so much for you, I can’t see why people wouldn’t want to help, but get that some can’t

Parents have children for their benefit, because they want children. If that means they give stuff up for the children, that’s the choice they made.

The only duty care wise is from parents to their children (when they are actually children, not when they are adults themselves)

everything beyond that is based on the relationship and how happy/functional it is- plenty of people don’t want to care for their parents because their parents just aren’t very nice and weren’t good parents.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 06/03/2024 23:52

fancypants1989 · 06/03/2024 23:49

No I absolutely don't think anyone has a 'duty' to help out elderly parents but I'm coming from a situation where my parents didn't feel like they had a 'duty' to care for me as a child.

Dad left when I was a kid, never to be seen again and my mother obviously wished that he'd taken me with him. I have kids and we're close but there's no way I'd want them to feel any obligation to take me in or make any sacrifices for me.

I don't have much of a relationship with my mother and she's very close to my other siblings and their children but I'm the eldest so I'm absolutely hoping that I'd don't have POA etc

Sorry for the rant

Don't worry, you won't have PoA without agreeing to it first... you have to sign the forms before it is put in place.

I'm sorry that your parents failed you.

HeddaGarbled · 06/03/2024 23:50

I think culturally beyond the UK/West people help each other more. The West doesn't really care about family in the same way as is engrained in many other cultures, at least not anymore

Maybe because U.K/Western women are more likely to rebel against the misogynistic expectation that they, and not the men in the family, will be unpaid family carers whether that’s for children or the elderly.

It’s not necessarily a bad thing that women are saying “hang on a minute, why’s this my job?”

That said, there is no way I wouldn’t be involved in the support of my parents, just not doing it all by myself to the detriment of my own health, career etc.

fancypants1989 · 06/03/2024 23:49

No I absolutely don't think anyone has a 'duty' to help out elderly parents but I'm coming from a situation where my parents didn't feel like they had a 'duty' to care for me as a child.

Dad left when I was a kid, never to be seen again and my mother obviously wished that he'd taken me with him. I have kids and we're close but there's no way I'd want them to feel any obligation to take me in or make any sacrifices for me.

I don't have much of a relationship with my mother and she's very close to my other siblings and their children but I'm the eldest so I'm absolutely hoping that I'd don't have POA etc

Sorry for the rant

Hedgerow2 · 06/03/2024 23:47

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 06/03/2024 23:44

I think it's a choice in either direction. There is no obligation as such.

But I think in any functional family, it is natural for people to want to help their family members as much as they possibly can, and I do think it's sad when people don't have the type of relationships in which this is taken for granted.

My parents did what they could when dd was younger, and I was grateful for it. I do what I can for them now, and they are also grateful. It isn't transactional though...I am not paying them back for the help they gave me previously. It's just how our family operates. I also help another elderly relative who wasn't ever in a position to help me with childcare etc.

Personally, I do see it as a kind of duty, but it is a duty that I have imposed on myself because of the way I think about family. I wouldn't judge others for feeling differently because every family has its own unique relationships and ways of operating.

Totally agree

MigGirl · 06/03/2024 23:45

Wellhellooooodear · 06/03/2024 19:12

Only on mumsnet do grandparents not babysit and people don't help out their family in general. It's actually pretty depressing if this is really the case for some people and I would have to ask them what the fuck is the point of having a family it this is your attitude?

Well it's my reality in real life not on mumsnet and yes it's bloody upsetting that not only do my IL'S seem to want nothing to do.with there grandchildren but also they aren't even supportive of their own son. And I do wonder often why they ever bothered to have children if this is how they feel about them.

And no I've already told DH that we won't be providing support for them in their old age as they have burned their bridges.

My dad on the other hand does actually try he just happens to be the other end of the country, unfortunately helping him will probably fall to my sister as she is local. Bit I think he expects to go into a home rather then have physical care from us.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 06/03/2024 23:44

I think it's a choice in either direction. There is no obligation as such.

But I think in any functional family, it is natural for people to want to help their family members as much as they possibly can, and I do think it's sad when people don't have the type of relationships in which this is taken for granted.

My parents did what they could when dd was younger, and I was grateful for it. I do what I can for them now, and they are also grateful. It isn't transactional though...I am not paying them back for the help they gave me previously. It's just how our family operates. I also help another elderly relative who wasn't ever in a position to help me with childcare etc.

Personally, I do see it as a kind of duty, but it is a duty that I have imposed on myself because of the way I think about family. I wouldn't judge others for feeling differently because every family has its own unique relationships and ways of operating.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 06/03/2024 23:36

I’m an only child with both parents who have needed help and care with different types of dementia. It’s more than 18 years worth now so more than a childhood’s worth. Both are now in care homes but I’m still doing all the admin/financial/healthcare planning and visiting. I don’t believe it’s an automatic duty to care for your elderly parents and I do not expect this of my children. It’s lovely that some of you use words like an honour and a privilege but honestly it’s never felt like that for me, mainly isolating and demoralising. I’ve aged way more than my peers who aren’t looking after their parents and I’m financially worse off, nearly 20 years of being on standby prepared to drop everything for the next crisis whilst simultaneously being called a thief. It’s also meant my own kids and DH have had to take a back seat on occasion. They were good enough parents and fun but they were also very young when they had me and I generally had to fit in around them and their priorities so really not much has changed. Neither of them provided any help or care to their own parents, who definitely needed it.

TempestTost · 06/03/2024 23:36

JamSandle · 06/03/2024 23:30

I must admit I'm curious about the cultural background of most posters.

I think culturally beyond the UK/West people help each other more. The West doesn't really care about family in the same way as is engrained in many other cultures, at least not anymore.

In many places people aren't wealthy enough to pay for all elder care even if they wanted to, and also the state isn't going to do it. There is much more dependence on family and people take that obligation seriously.

It's interesting in the west that we see it as an obligation to pay taxes to the state so the state can become the carer, including for those they are unrelated to, but don't see any personal obligation help family directly and in fact think it's a bit crazy.