Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be terrified DD might have ASD?

190 replies

Helfs · 06/03/2024 15:45

DD is nearly one, and since DH was diagnosed as an adult a few months ago I’ve gone into a rabbit hole around early signs of autism.

When DH received his diagnosis our GP did say they’d let our HV know as there can be a genetic element and they would therefore send out some support and guidance on things to monitor in DD between her 1-2 year checks. As they’d not be able to diagnose or do anything until then.

I didn’t think much of it until she recently started moving her fingers strangely, googling it, it looks like stimming, then she started squinting a bit more than normal - so of course I did the stupid thing of googling that as well.

It has got to the point where it’s consuming me. Although DH scored pretty high in the testing, he is minimally impacted by his ASD, holds down a good job, and although you can tell there are ‘issues’ in terms of large social situations etc. is pretty ok in all other areas (if you didn’t know he had ASD you’d probably just assume anxiety)

My younger brother however is the opposite end of the spectrum, very severely impacted and still needs care at 27 years old.

Growing up seeing how my brother struggled it really is worrying me. And I don’t know whether it’s normal to worry about this or not as she is our first baby (and likely our last too - as if she does have ASD I could never bring another child into the mix based on how badly my brothers diagnosis impacted me growing up)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BertieBotts · 07/03/2024 23:55

I have ADHD which suffers from a few of the same issues with the "quirky/fun/superpower" angle which I do find dismissive as it masks the very real struggles that people go through.

But I do think that the neurotype arguments and neurodiversity movements are in general positive. It sounds to me like your husband is going though a very common process which often happens shortly after diagnosis, a sort of grieving process where it's easy to focus on the difficulties. I can understand that. I definitely went through a bit of that too. Over time though I do think that many neurodivergent people come to terms with their diagnosis and start to see it more neutrally, as being part of who they are. It's been enormously helpful to me to learn about common patterns of ADHD, the research about ADHD brains and what the differences are etc.

I know that autism is different because there are autistic individuals with a very high level of needs that is not the same as somebody who can manage things like marriage, family life, a job. But I do also honestly think that is possible to come to see this in a more neutral way.

My eldest son also has ADHD. My middle one is probably neurodivergent in some way but we don't really know how yet. Because he's already 5 I don't have the worries of any severe general delays or issues because I can see he's not that far out of step with his peers. Still, there's definitely something a little different, and autism has been suggested so I'm branching out from my ADHD-understanding stuff to autism-positive stuff.

It's not because I'm sitting here thinking ooh yay, how brilliant would it be if he's autistic?! It's not like that at all. It's more like - ok. He's clearly quirky and has his own way of being. I want to learn more about that. I wish I could see inside his head. I wish I could understand more of his world. It would make it easier to understand him and help him. And honestly looking at the autism positive content gives that to me. For example, there's a common hand movement that expresses joy. The other day I was at speech therapy with my son and he was entranced by this mechanical bear toy and he was doing the hand movement, and I could recognise that very very pure, very clear joy for him. It made me really happy in that moment to see how excited he was and how that really activated him. But if I had been looking at that hand movement with fear, I might have missed out on that moment. I'm very glad that I didn't because it was very special. I don't know if he's autistic. He might be or he might not. But I know that he was very happy in that moment and he shared a mannerism that is common in autistic individuals. The happiness was the point though. Understanding that this can be a way that some people express excitement helped me spot that in my child and understand him better.

Jellycats4life · 07/03/2024 21:41

And with your husband - what I was trying to say was that it’s not just the negative things about him that are autistic. It’s all of him. So the positive parts of him are also autistic.

Exactly that. You can’t separate a person from their autism. They have an autistic brain thinking autistic thoughts. An autistic personality inside an autistic body.

That’s why it’s sad to hear OP say her DH wishes he wasn’t autistic - does he honestly hate everything about himself? No? Well then start reframing things.

It’s not his fault his brain is wired differently. It’s not his fault he finds it hard to do neurotypical things in a neurotypical world.

It’s honestly quite freeing once you rid yourself of all the self-blame and emotional baggage of thinking you’re defective.

Newsenmum · 07/03/2024 20:23

neverbeenskiing · 07/03/2024 20:11

I personally loathe the whole "autism is a superpower" schtick, but you are wrong to make definitive statements about it being a tragedy. That is not necessarily the case.

My children are not "tragic". They have their challenges, sure but they have so many strengths and excellent qualities not in spite of their Autism, but because of it. Their intense interests mean they are extremely passionate and knowledgeable about subjects that interest them, and will hyper-focus and persevere on a task until they've mastered it. Their ability to find joy in small things that others may not even notice is lovely to see. I have never, not once, wished they weren't Autistic. It's a part of who they are and I wouldn't change them for the world.

I completely agree. I know you’re struggling atm op but it’s quite sad you would see it a tragedy. Your daughter is not your brother.

And with your husband - what I was trying to say was that it’s not just the negative things about him that are autistic. It’s all of him. So the positive parts of him are also autistic. The bits that made him choose him. If there’s nothing you like about him then why are you with him? I really think it’s important to remember that. It’s not some kind of disease, it’s his entire person. It’s who he is. Please try and see it this way. And please love and enjoy your gorgeous girl! She needs that from you. Forget the label if it makes you this unhappy. You won’t get it for years anyway if you ever do!

neverbeenskiing · 07/03/2024 20:11

Helfs · 07/03/2024 18:49

It is. I don’t know of anyone who sits there wishing their child has ASD.

It’s a disability. Not a super power

I personally loathe the whole "autism is a superpower" schtick, but you are wrong to make definitive statements about it being a tragedy. That is not necessarily the case.

My children are not "tragic". They have their challenges, sure but they have so many strengths and excellent qualities not in spite of their Autism, but because of it. Their intense interests mean they are extremely passionate and knowledgeable about subjects that interest them, and will hyper-focus and persevere on a task until they've mastered it. Their ability to find joy in small things that others may not even notice is lovely to see. I have never, not once, wished they weren't Autistic. It's a part of who they are and I wouldn't change them for the world.

Newsenmum · 07/03/2024 20:07

And my son has a lot of struggles right now but he is also adorable. He has an incredibly memory and he is very good at his current fixation. I’m sure if we can foster the right one he will do fine. Yes we have bad days as the world is not set up for him. However, I have hope. And I know there are many different ways to live life. It’s up to us as parents to help them find their way.

Newsenmum · 07/03/2024 20:03

perhaps as the world changes you will feel differently and it will be like being gay, which used to be seen as a mental illness. I’m not saying it’s exactly the same, but having a different neurotype could be a little like having a different sexuality. It’s just different. It’s still normal within humanity even if it’s not the standard.

Can you really see no positives to your husbands personality? because being autistic is his entire person. You chose to marry him for part of that!

im pretty sure my husband is. He gets fixated, repetitive and struggles sensory wise. He is also incredibly loyal and committed, very empathetic (a lot of autistic people often are), very successful in what he does. He’s so driven. He’s very different to most men and I love him for it.

Newsenmum · 07/03/2024 19:55

Helfs · 07/03/2024 18:49

It is. I don’t know of anyone who sits there wishing their child has ASD.

It’s a disability. Not a super power

There is a middle ground. It’s just another neurotype. Do you really not love your husband as he is? Is he a tragedy?? A lot of autistic people have commented on this thread.
Many have also stated that for girls it’s very different.
And not all autistic people like thinking of it as a disability.

Daffodilclover · 07/03/2024 19:41

Helfs · 07/03/2024 19:38

I did indeed

That man wishes he didn’t have ASD every day of his life. He hates the idea that because of him DD might struggle like he does. And he is very mildly impacted

It’s not a few more struggles either.

I understand what the OP is saying.

It may not be a very popular point of view and I understand that too.

I have a close relative with ‘high functioning’ autism. I was looking at jobs he could possibly do yesterday. I couldn’t find a single one.

It isn’t all doom and gloom and we are more enlightened. Girls in particular mask and therefore sometimes cope better (though at a cost to their mental health.) But overall the picture can be a bleak one and we are allowed to fear that.

Helfs · 07/03/2024 19:38

Jellycats4life · 07/03/2024 19:35

You married an autistic man. Clearly you can appreciate that many autistic people have happy lives, albeit with maybe a few more struggles than NT people,

I did indeed

That man wishes he didn’t have ASD every day of his life. He hates the idea that because of him DD might struggle like he does. And he is very mildly impacted

It’s not a few more struggles either.

OP posts:
Jellycats4life · 07/03/2024 19:35

Helfs · 07/03/2024 18:49

It is. I don’t know of anyone who sits there wishing their child has ASD.

It’s a disability. Not a super power

You married an autistic man. Clearly you can appreciate that many autistic people have happy lives, albeit with maybe a few more struggles than NT people,

pinkpip100 · 07/03/2024 18:51

It really isn't, but I can't see you're just not interested in listening to anyone else. I hope you can find peace, whatever the outcome.

Helfs · 07/03/2024 18:49

pinkpip100 · 07/03/2024 18:45

OP, I understand you are worried, but honestly can't believe you have been so dismissive and rude to someone who is trying to help you understand how varied the experience of being autistic can be. You seem determined to believe that autism is a tragedy, full stop. It really isn't.

It is. I don’t know of anyone who sits there wishing their child has ASD.

It’s a disability. Not a super power

OP posts:
pinkpip100 · 07/03/2024 18:45

OP, I understand you are worried, but honestly can't believe you have been so dismissive and rude to someone who is trying to help you understand how varied the experience of being autistic can be. You seem determined to believe that autism is a tragedy, full stop. It really isn't.

ntmdino · 07/03/2024 16:03

Jellycats4life · 07/03/2024 15:54

I'm not clear on the terminology you're using there, in terms of "spectrum" - I've not encountered any research that says there isn't a spectrum of traits,

I think what @Newsenmum meant is that the autism spectrum is often considered to be quite linear, when it’s more like a constellation of traits that are unique to the person and change all the time

Fair - in which case, I also agree ;)

When people say "spectrum" as though it's a linear colour scale, I tend to show them the colour wheel from Photoshop (or similar) - that usually prompts a lightbulb moment :)

Jellycats4life · 07/03/2024 15:54

I'm not clear on the terminology you're using there, in terms of "spectrum" - I've not encountered any research that says there isn't a spectrum of traits,

I think what @Newsenmum meant is that the autism spectrum is often considered to be quite linear, when it’s more like a constellation of traits that are unique to the person and change all the time

To be terrified DD might have ASD?
ntmdino · 07/03/2024 15:47

Newsenmum · 07/03/2024 15:33

A lot of modern research actually disagrees that autism is a spectrum. Some children who are non verbal until aged 5 or so will suddenly start speaking and be able to succeed in a more ‘typical’ way. Others who seem less impacted at a young age will appear more impacted when older. Everyone is different and it’s hard to pinpoint what is due to being autistic or due to years of trauma due to ABA therapy and various other ‘treatments’ that were seen as helpful in the 90s/00s and before. And sometimes there are learning disabilities alongside which are causing issues - not just being autistic in itself.

I’ve found the books by Luke beardon pretty good on this!

Edited

I'm not clear on the terminology you're using there, in terms of "spectrum" - I've not encountered any research that says there isn't a spectrum of traits, but it seems more like you're saying that it's not static, in which case I absolutely agree with you. The implications of the condition can vary even from day to day, but also trend in different directions over much larger timescales.

My experience would (anecdotally, obviously) agree with that - I exactly hit all my early milestones in terms of crawling, walking, speaking etc, only to regress and become non-verbal for a couple of years. Then I picked up again and raced ahead of my peers in developmental terms for a few years. Also anecdotally, I've encountered quite a few autistic folk with similarly "lumpy" development.

Then I continued being ostensibly "normal" to the outside world until around 40, when I suddenly found myself struggling to keep it up, and as a result I retreated significantly from the world. Essentially, my ability to mask and suppress meltdowns/shutdowns had dropped off a cliff even before COVID happened, and that's what prompted me to seek an assessment.

There's very little available research into middle-aged autistic experiences, but I really hope somebody can get a decent-sized study funded at some point. That's probably a topic for another thread, though.

Newsenmum · 07/03/2024 15:33

Helfs · 07/03/2024 14:12

The struggle is that Autism is still classified as a disability.

I don’t know if any other disability where people claim it makes them superhuman in quite the same way.

I can’t imagine struggling to communicate with 80% of the population is anything other than a massive issue for most.

A lot of modern research actually disagrees that autism is a spectrum. Some children who are non verbal until aged 5 or so will suddenly start speaking and be able to succeed in a more ‘typical’ way. Others who seem less impacted at a young age will appear more impacted when older. Everyone is different and it’s hard to pinpoint what is due to being autistic or due to years of trauma due to ABA therapy and various other ‘treatments’ that were seen as helpful in the 90s/00s and before. And sometimes there are learning disabilities alongside which are causing issues - not just being autistic in itself.

I’ve found the books by Luke beardon pretty good on this!

KreedKafer · 07/03/2024 15:32

I’m terrified my perfect baby girl will have more struggles than most, and that worst case scenario she might need a lifetime of high support needs

I mean this kindly:

If that was a rational justification for the way you feel, you would also be terrified of all the millions of other things that could go wrong in your child's life, rather than fixating purely on the possibility of not just autism, but autism at the most extreme end of a very broad spectrum.

Nobody here can tell you whether your daughter will be diagnosed with autism, any more than they can tell you whether she will ever be knocked down by a car, or develop a brain tumour or leukaemia, or anything else. But my guess is that you aren't spending all your waking hours worrying obsessively about those other things, because you know it's fairly unlikely that they will happen and also that they are beyond your control.

It is understandable, because of your experiences with your brother, that you've picked this one thing to channel your anxiety into. But it's not reasonable.

Anyone's baby might turn out to be autistic. If yours does, the chances of her being at the extreme end of the spectrum are very low because the extreme end of the spectrum applies to a very small number of people. Terror is a disproportionate reaction.

PoochiesPinkEars · 07/03/2024 15:12

But isn't that how worries work? You worry about the worst case scenario?

I think all people that find contentment and enjoy their life are fortunate in many ways (never all obvs), obviously this is not an outcome exclusive to NT people, but that's not the outcome op is concerned about.

Your experience is certainly encouraging to anyone worrying about their child's future, but doesn't negate the other possibilities (not that you said it did, it just seems to be a moot argument).

In op's shoes I'd be acknowledging the fears are real and based on her family history where Nd has meant no independence for her dB and frequent violence for others to cope with.
Trying to manage those fears so they don't eclipse these early days for her or her DH or DD.
Accepting that only as time goes by will the situation become clear.

ntmdino · 07/03/2024 14:58

Helfs · 07/03/2024 14:49

And I a responding that your experience will make up 10% of those diagnosed with ASD

You are not the norm

Its foolish to believe that it’s likely for a child diagnosed with ASD is just as likely to have your outlook compared to the average.

That's not what I said in the comment you quoted at all!!!!!!

The point is that the eventuality you claim to be so concerned with is just as likely as my experience. You can't dismiss one as unlikely unless you dismiss both.

And, on top of that, you're conveniently ignoring all the negatives in my life (as many people do, I'm pretty used to it).

Here's the thing: I've spoken to orders of magnitude more autistic people than you have. I know the prevalence of issues, and how autistic people can be happy with their lives (often more so than NTs), and how they wished their parents had been able to show them how to build a life that works for them rather than being forced to struggle to do so by trial and error and eventually finding a community that could help them through experience. I was trying to get you to understand that, as a parent to a potentially ND child, it's possible and you have a big part to play in it.

You had an opportunity to actually learn something here, which might have helped both you and your child, but you've chosen to continue trying to Win On The Internet instead.

Until you accept the fact that your understanding of the autistic experience is catastrophically flawed, being influenced only by other NT people with equally poor understanding and ignoring actually autistic people, there is no helping you.

Until then, enjoy your anxiety spiral.

Helfs · 07/03/2024 14:49

ntmdino · 07/03/2024 14:46

Good grief...are you deliberately trying to miss the point here?

You start off with "ZOMG, I can't believe anybody could be happy with a disability like autism!". Then I describe the actual experience of an actual autistic person (me) and how it relates to happiness, and you ignore almost everything in it so you can focus on the same ignorant rubbish regarding "superpowers".

Less than a third of autistic people are born with comorbid learning difficulties, and in at least half of those cases it's dyslexia or dyscalculia (or both); difficulties, sure, but not massively life-impeding with the tools available in this day and age. That puts the number of "severe" cases that you're concerned about at 10-15% - roughly the same number as you're dismissing right here.

So...which is it? Is 10% a massive concern or something unlikely enough to be unconcerned about?

And I a responding that your experience will make up 10% of those diagnosed with ASD

You are not the norm

Its foolish to believe that it’s likely for a child diagnosed with ASD is just as likely to have your outlook compared to the average.

OP posts:
ntmdino · 07/03/2024 14:46

Helfs · 07/03/2024 14:31

Less than 10% of those diagnosed with autism have any savant talents. Based on that it’s very unlikely for a child born to be genuinely in the ‘super power’ camp.

Good grief...are you deliberately trying to miss the point here?

You start off with "ZOMG, I can't believe anybody could be happy with a disability like autism!". Then I describe the actual experience of an actual autistic person (me) and how it relates to happiness, and you ignore almost everything in it so you can focus on the same ignorant rubbish regarding "superpowers".

Less than a third of autistic people are born with comorbid learning difficulties, and in at least half of those cases it's dyslexia or dyscalculia (or both); difficulties, sure, but not massively life-impeding with the tools available in this day and age. That puts the number of "severe" cases that you're concerned about at 10-15% - roughly the same number as you're dismissing right here.

So...which is it? Is 10% a massive concern or something unlikely enough to be unconcerned about?

willowthecat · 07/03/2024 14:39

Autism is derived from the greek word 'autos' meaning self - meaning a condition in which the person is locked within the self and not expressing and communicating language as typically developing people do. In the US, they have Level 1 autism which is high functioning and verbal, level 3 which is non verbal low functioning autism and Level 2 anything in between. I think though it was a mistake to expand the definition so much, individuals considered high functioning thirty years ago would be seen as significantly learning impaired by today's standards. If a description describes everything in the human condition , it's not going to be very specific or very meaningful. If someone tells me there will be weather tomorrow as i plan a trip to the mountains, i might want more information.

Helfs · 07/03/2024 14:31

ntmdino · 07/03/2024 14:21

Really? That's what you took from that whole post?

The fact that it's classed as a disability is completely irrelevant to the experience of being autistic.

Look, I get that you want to look at autism as nothing but entirely negative and you see autistic people as nothing but "less than". I'm trying to get you to see that it's nowhere near as cut-and-dried as that.

And please, at least try to understand that what are colloquially called "superpowers" are not superhuman; nobody's claiming that. They're simply things that our perception of the world, caused by our differently-structured brains, allows us to do which most people can't.

These are things that only exceptional NT people can do, but a lot of ND people can do with ease - in the same way that there are many things that only exceptional ND people can do, whereas many NT people can do them with ease.

Less than 10% of those diagnosed with autism have any savant talents. Based on that it’s very unlikely for a child born to be genuinely in the ‘super power’ camp.

OP posts:
ntmdino · 07/03/2024 14:21

Helfs · 07/03/2024 14:12

The struggle is that Autism is still classified as a disability.

I don’t know if any other disability where people claim it makes them superhuman in quite the same way.

I can’t imagine struggling to communicate with 80% of the population is anything other than a massive issue for most.

Really? That's what you took from that whole post?

The fact that it's classed as a disability is completely irrelevant to the experience of being autistic.

Look, I get that you want to look at autism as nothing but entirely negative and you see autistic people as nothing but "less than". I'm trying to get you to see that it's nowhere near as cut-and-dried as that.

And please, at least try to understand that what are colloquially called "superpowers" are not superhuman; nobody's claiming that. They're simply things that our perception of the world, caused by our differently-structured brains, allows us to do which most people can't.

These are things that only exceptional NT people can do, but a lot of ND people can do with ease - in the same way that there are many things that only exceptional ND people can do, whereas many NT people can do them with ease.

Swipe left for the next trending thread