Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how much longer it will be before all teachers quit?

459 replies

FunionsRFun · 06/03/2024 15:09

Been called a bitch and screamed at today. Kids are making no progress because 90% of the leason is dedicated to bad behaviour.
My detentions have been taken off the system to make behaviour look better.
Why would anyone do this job?

OP posts:
LakieLady · 07/03/2024 16:18

GoodnightAdeline · 06/03/2024 18:15

I would feel dramatic if somebody spat at or punched me. Or called me a bitch, for that matter. Luckily where I work this doesn’t happen. Why should they put up with it?

Doesn't happen to me or my colleagues, either. And we have the luxury of being able to withdraw our service from clients if they are abusive or violent.

No-one should have to put with abuse like that in the workplace.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 15:55

I think teaching is a job which has a lot of negativity and complaining around it because of its very nature. Working with children is always and was always going to be hard.

I have been a teacher for 29 years. The job has changed dramatically. Anyone who's been in teaching for a couple of decades or more would tell you that.

Yes, there have always been difficult kids, but the level and amount of difficult behaviour has increased enormously, particularly over the last 10 years, and even more sharply since covid.

But, more than that, the expectations of what teachers do have changed, leading to an excessive amount of hoop-jumping, cynical initiatives which don't help children, and budget cuts which make everything harder.

I work in a lovely school with very well-behaved kids. I am a lot more stressed and over-worked than I was in the school where I worked early in my career, which had worse-behaved kids. Yes, it would be even worse if I had my current workload but also badly-behaved kids, but the point is that it's not just about it being hard to work with kids.

So, as someone who 'would never want to work with children', @Calamitousness, I'm wondering what you think qualifies you to tell us how obvious it is what's wrong with the job, and why you're so confident that you know it was always like that.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 07/03/2024 15:34

*Calamitousness · Today 05:02

I think teaching is a job which has a lot of negativity and complaining around it because of its very nature. Working with children is always and was always going to be hard. Imagine your work life interactions were mostly with children. Ooft. Yes you have some lovely ones and yes you’ll have some not lovely ones but it only takes one horror to make life unbearable. Unfortunately I don’t think people appreciate that when they choose teaching. I would never want to work with children because I want to have civilised interaction at work with mutual respect. But I do worry some teachers think teaching is going to be something different. There are people out there who are amazing teachers and really can connect and inspire the children and are natural teachers but it’s rare*

No, most teachers love the kids. It’s the rest of the job that pisses them off and makes them ‘so negative’

fussychica · 07/03/2024 15:02

DS is a HOD in a shortage subject at a large school in London. In the main he loves his job and the students, some of the parents, not so much! His school has a strict discipline policy and a very supportive SLT. Together these things make his job easier than it is for many teachers who have to work in crap schools and who get little or no support from either management or parents.

twoboyssolucky · 07/03/2024 14:45

Calamitousness · 07/03/2024 05:02

I think teaching is a job which has a lot of negativity and complaining around it because of its very nature. Working with children is always and was always going to be hard. Imagine your work life interactions were mostly with children. Ooft. Yes you have some lovely ones and yes you’ll have some not lovely ones but it only takes one horror to make life unbearable. Unfortunately I don’t think people appreciate that when they choose teaching. I would never want to work with children because I want to have civilised interaction at work with mutual respect. But I do worry some teachers think teaching is going to be something different. There are people out there who are amazing teachers and really can connect and inspire the children and are natural teachers but it’s rare.

What a sad point of view of children!
When I trained to be a primary teacher I went into it as I wanted to spend my day with children and the joy they bring rather than whiny, grumpy adults.

‘a civilized interaction with mutual respect’ you really have a low opinion about of children and young people. Very adultist comments.

And you’re wrong if you think most teachers don’t consider this when they decide to teach.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 07/03/2024 12:14

Workworkandmoreworknow · 07/03/2024 11:06

I'm not sure why you think teachers don't have the capacity to check emails and prioritise or highlight what needs attending to. I get easily 40 emails each day. If I don't prioritise and filter out the junk, I'll be soon overwhelmed. And my current job isn't a pure desk job either so this has to be done on the side.)

I am a head of department for my subject in a school with around 260 students in each year. In all seriousness, do you think I should be available to each and every student and their parents to discuss whatever it is they want to discuss? Year 9 options can generate a huge amount of extra work and yes, it's important to discuss with teachers and parents. But most schools have an options event (not always well attended) and obviously, children can discuss with their teachers at any time whether or not they consider they should be doing the GCSE in their subject. But it can't be a meeting for everyone, or more than a few minutes discussion because there isn't the time.

I was at an open evening earlier this week with parents moaning about the school closing at the time that it said it was closing (8:30pm) with an overwhelming ignorance as to the fact that teachers are people with families and lives that also need their attention . It's really not unreasonable that when you've walked in the door at 8am, you get to walk out of it at 8:30pom

You sound bitter.

One of the teacher didn't attend tthe GCSE ptions evening, so again, we were told to ccontact them via email.

I think it's fair to expect a response from them via email to discuss.

Yes of course teachers have a life outside work- who doesn't?
But things like open -, parents - and options evenings are part and parcel of the job. It's where you sell the school and ensure that your pupils have the best possible results for their exams. Again a huge selling point for the school to attract a certain type of pupil.

you know to reduce the numbers that swear, spit and throw things at you

sheflieswithherownwings · 07/03/2024 11:31

It's a mess I agree. But blaming parents for all bad behaviour (which is what I read on here EVERY single time this comes up) is really unhelpful and just creates animosity between parents and teachers which just adds to the toxicity of the system. Of course, sometimes it is the parenting that's the problem - but even 'good' kids can behave badly in certain environments and some of them probably just join in with what they see their peers doing, especially if the lessons are boring and they have little 'bond' with that subject teacher.

It also pushes the problem on to something that cannot be fixed by the government or by the school - and if you're just expecting parents to 'step up' and solve the issue of the terrible behaviour of their teens, that is not going to happen - for many complex reasons. Therefore the system needs a massive overhaul and having more PRUs and more specialist SEN schools (not saying that SEN kids are the route of this, but certainly there are some kids who cannot cope with being in such a loud and over stimulating environment) would help.

In addition, I honestly think a lot of kids whose behaviour is out of control are getting an awful lot of attention (negative but still attention) from the teachers. If a student sits quietly and gets on with their work you're lucky if the teacher even remembers their name.

CaptainMyCaptain · 07/03/2024 11:28

Sae3005 · 07/03/2024 10:21

From the parent side of things I can see where some parents are coming from. I've had parents have their children sit for 6 hours in period blood, holding their bladder because they're told not to go. The situation like this happens because of teachers that don't allow children to do normal human things (go to the toilet, change their pad etc). However, the teachers that aren't like this don't deserve to be treat like crap.

That's awful but it won't be an individual teacher's decision. It will be a whole school decision because some students left to go to the toilet whenever they like/need either disappear altogether or vandalise those toilets rendering them useless for your DD to use at any time.

I think sitting 6 hours is an exaggeration though. There must have been a lunch break, at least, at that time.

CaptainMyCaptain · 07/03/2024 11:22

Calamitousness · 07/03/2024 05:02

I think teaching is a job which has a lot of negativity and complaining around it because of its very nature. Working with children is always and was always going to be hard. Imagine your work life interactions were mostly with children. Ooft. Yes you have some lovely ones and yes you’ll have some not lovely ones but it only takes one horror to make life unbearable. Unfortunately I don’t think people appreciate that when they choose teaching. I would never want to work with children because I want to have civilised interaction at work with mutual respect. But I do worry some teachers think teaching is going to be something different. There are people out there who are amazing teachers and really can connect and inspire the children and are natural teachers but it’s rare.

I loved working with the children. I loved teaching. There were a few rogues that were difficult to deal with and some difficult parents at my school but on the whole, with support from higher up, I could cope with it. What I hated was the target setting culture, the ridiculous expectations of a Head Teacher who knew nothing about young children, the 'divide and rule' strategy with staff and the lack of support with behaviour or parents after a change of management.

I managed to stay in the job until I was 60 but wouldn't recommend it to anyone now. The expectations of some parents as shown on Mumsnet are just unbelievable.

Workworkandmoreworknow · 07/03/2024 11:06

I'm not sure why you think teachers don't have the capacity to check emails and prioritise or highlight what needs attending to. I get easily 40 emails each day. If I don't prioritise and filter out the junk, I'll be soon overwhelmed. And my current job isn't a pure desk job either so this has to be done on the side.)

I am a head of department for my subject in a school with around 260 students in each year. In all seriousness, do you think I should be available to each and every student and their parents to discuss whatever it is they want to discuss? Year 9 options can generate a huge amount of extra work and yes, it's important to discuss with teachers and parents. But most schools have an options event (not always well attended) and obviously, children can discuss with their teachers at any time whether or not they consider they should be doing the GCSE in their subject. But it can't be a meeting for everyone, or more than a few minutes discussion because there isn't the time.

I was at an open evening earlier this week with parents moaning about the school closing at the time that it said it was closing (8:30pm) with an overwhelming ignorance as to the fact that teachers are people with families and lives that also need their attention . It's really not unreasonable that when you've walked in the door at 8am, you get to walk out of it at 8:30pom

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 07/03/2024 11:05

I used to put the naughty kids at the back too. I got sick of all the lessons being about them.

When l put them at the back l could then focus on the ones who actually wanted to learn.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 07/03/2024 10:51

Noonelikesasloppytrifle · 06/03/2024 22:45

Have you ever figured that maybe the sheer volume of parents wanting the same information as you do from one person might just be a tad overwhelming?

Let's say a teacher has a class of 30. They teach a minimum of 4 different classes and have a tutor group. So that's 150 kids. Everyday they will receive multiple emails off parents. They will have planning and marking on top of the very demanding classroom time. They will have duties and assemblies to plan. Every Time they call a parent, that parent will want at least ten minutes of their time. Parents expect schools to fix everything but there simply isn't the resource to do it. They need more people on the ground but the budgets are decimated.

The profession has been utterly devalued. I would never encourage my DC to be teachers (or drs for that matter). I have worked in prisons and probation and am now in a school. It is awful and I am fearful for us as a society with what is about to come.

I don't think you read my post properly.

The instances about the luck of response were not send willy nilly.
DD was told to contact her teacher via email to arrange a tutorial. (Teacher was in for 2 days every fortnight... but that's another issue.)
I was told by school to contact the teacher in question via email to discuss GCSE choice for their subject.

...and yes, DD and myself have stated the reason for contacting the teacher in the subject line.

I'm not sure why you think teachers don't have the capacity to check emails and prioritise or highlight what needs attending to. I get easily 40 emails each day. If I don't prioritise and filter out the junk, I'll be soon overwhelmed. And my current job isn't a pure desk job either so this has to be done on the side.)

fitzwilliamdarcy · 07/03/2024 10:25

I have several friends in teaching and two of them have now left. The one that remains feels like she can't because she's single and needs to keep a roof over her head. Watching her is like watching someone in an abusive relationship, honestly. She's a shell of her former self.

All three experienced verbal abuse daily and physical abuse weekly, and when this was reported to parents, the parents either took on the baton and started verbally abusing as well, or reported the teacher to SLT in an attempt to have them disciplined. For the temerity of somehow causing children to call them slurs, spit on them or hit them.

They all say that they're in teacher groups where tens of thousands are reporting the same thing, and are leaving the profession.

I guess all those wanting teachers to leave will get their wish, and it'll be your kids and grandkids who suffer.

I know this is MN and so will go down like a lead balloon but at some point parents have to actually be held accountable for something. We see so often on here people justifying the public money they receive for raising the next generation of taxpayers but it seems like the majority of parents are 'raising' children that will not be fit for society, let alone the world of work. There's going to be an astronomical bill in a couple of decades time once these kids become adults and can't cope with any kind of civil society.

Sae3005 · 07/03/2024 10:21

From the parent side of things I can see where some parents are coming from. I've had parents have their children sit for 6 hours in period blood, holding their bladder because they're told not to go. The situation like this happens because of teachers that don't allow children to do normal human things (go to the toilet, change their pad etc). However, the teachers that aren't like this don't deserve to be treat like crap.

Bushmillsbabe · 07/03/2024 10:04

MrsMurphyIWish · 07/03/2024 06:53

Qualified in 2000, here’s how I have survived:

-Find your voice or your advocate. When I was heavily pregnant with DS I was pushed down the stairs by a horrible Yr 9 (had many suspensions, most likely in prison now). School wouldn’t move him from my class until DH rang my head and threatened to go to the press. I left 3 years later.
-I work at a school now where we are directed to work in our undirected time (so have morning and lunch duties). I now refuse to run clubs or go on trips. I’m also disabled and now take my monthly physio sessions in school time where I would used to book it in my own time.
-I used to have my seating plans so all the poorly behaved students sat at the front. Now, I place them far away from me as possible and surround myself with the good kids. Want my time? Engage!

Find strategies to help you through the day - or change schools! If you’re a qualified teacher then your pupils are lucky that you’re still in the classroom!

I'm so sorry this hapenned to you when pregnant, thats terrible.
And its great to set boundaries for your own self preservation.
But it's a shame re trips and clubs, these really enriching activities which can be make or break for some children. After a horrific experience earlier in year 2, we had a very anxious school refuser, and completly justifiably considering the trauma she had been through at school. It was the before school 'talk and toast' club and the after school drama club which helped put my daughter back together again, gave her back her calm and her confidence and I will be forever grateful to these kind and generous staff who did these clubs.

worstofbothworlds · 07/03/2024 09:48

ItsallIeverwanted · 06/03/2024 17:16

@worstofbothworlds oh I agree, there's lots wrong with the university sector. I do feel well protected in terms of not being spat on or having chairs thrown though which my children have seen in their classrooms. There are threats to academic freedom, but very few lecturers run the gauntlet that say secondary teachers do, which is why I enjoy uni lecturing.

I agree, and I'm also lucky that my union have my back (and I know that's unusual - have had a few run-ins with HR/my boss over things like flexible working).

worstofbothworlds · 07/03/2024 09:45

AngelinaFibres · 06/03/2024 21:25

In the case of several male students , they also watch porn whilst masturbating IN THE MAIN LIBRARY because the WiFi is better there than their halls of residence. They cannot see why there would be a problem with this.

Oh god. And mine have the gall to say unisex toilets are OK because male students are nice even though it's only men that rape women in mixed sex toilets.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 07/03/2024 09:43

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 06/03/2024 15:57

The difficulty with raising issues of attitude and conduct of pupils on MN is that crowds of posters will descend to justify the behaviour of children without knowing anything of the circumstances.

I strongly believe that the widespread malaise in the English school system is a function of discipline and behavioural expectation - and the absence of effective sanction - rather than money.

I’m convinced we’d have hundreds of thousands of good, committed teachers and aspiring teachers in all subjects if they weren’t subject to the routine abuse and aggression that’s prevalent in schools.

Bingo. Now to read the dozens of pages of justification...

Shinyandnew1 · 07/03/2024 09:10

I think teaching is a job which has a lot of negativity and complaining around it because of its very nature. Working with children is always and was always going to be hard. Imagine your work life interactions were mostly with children. Ooft. Yes you have some lovely ones and yes you’ll have some not lovely ones but it only takes one horror to make life unbearable. Unfortunately I don’t think people appreciate that when they choose teaching.

I disagree here. Teaching isn’t horrible because of the children. It was a pretty good job when I started-not so many decades ago. Autonomy in the classroom, sensible and realistic curriculum, support from management, pay keeping up with cost of living, workload expectations not ridiculous, parents generally supportive and funding for staff and external services.

All of those things have gradually changed and those are the bits that are dreadful. It’s not that I went into teaching not knowing what it was like. The problem is it’s changed, massively for the worse, increased workload hugely, and now pupils are unhappy, stressed, don’t want to go to school, standards of what the kids can do is no better, and teachers are leaving in droves. What was the point?

Shinyandnew1 · 07/03/2024 08:56

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 07/03/2024 07:34

Honestly you are misunderstanding the issue. I taught for 20 years. It's not that there will be less than positive interactions with kids.
Its the fact that this doesn't happen by magic. Creating an environment to which enables positive interactions and learning behaviours takes time, skill and resources.
Larger class sizes, increased numbers of learners with complex SEND but without additional funding and resource, teacher shortages, classes being covered by lower skilled TAs because you can't get a supply teacher for love nor money, kids still very much dealing with the fall out from COVID on their wellbeing, key parts of the school building being closed due to RAAC. These are the things that are making it hellish and directly correlate to government funding and policy. Throw in parents who aren't supportive due to a culture of teacher bashing or are unavailable to their kids because they have their own problems (CoL, unstable employment, inadequate or temp housing) and that makes things 100 times worse. Again directly correlates to government policy and has got exponentially worse under the Tories.
And that fact that some mumsnetters' lovely little home counties villages school hasn't been hit by the issues to ths same degree is hardly shocking, but surely posters realise this is not representative of the vast majority of schools and locations.

Exactly!

Dc schools are great. No retention issues, small classes. Good SEN support. Long term staff who appear happy.

We had a ‘nice’ school like that locally-lovely catchment, local staff had been there forever and it seemed great. Till those staff who had been there for years had enough/retired/moved on and it was virtually impossible for them to get staff because they couldn’t afford to buy or rent anywhere near the school. They eventually went into SM, were taken over by an academy and had a new interim head and are a fairly corporate enterprise now which has to take teachers from the academy sent there for a year or two on rotation as nobody wants to stay permanently.

Just watch out what happens when those ‘long term staff who appear happy’ leave.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 07/03/2024 07:34

Calamitousness · 07/03/2024 05:02

I think teaching is a job which has a lot of negativity and complaining around it because of its very nature. Working with children is always and was always going to be hard. Imagine your work life interactions were mostly with children. Ooft. Yes you have some lovely ones and yes you’ll have some not lovely ones but it only takes one horror to make life unbearable. Unfortunately I don’t think people appreciate that when they choose teaching. I would never want to work with children because I want to have civilised interaction at work with mutual respect. But I do worry some teachers think teaching is going to be something different. There are people out there who are amazing teachers and really can connect and inspire the children and are natural teachers but it’s rare.

Honestly you are misunderstanding the issue. I taught for 20 years. It's not that there will be less than positive interactions with kids.
Its the fact that this doesn't happen by magic. Creating an environment to which enables positive interactions and learning behaviours takes time, skill and resources.
Larger class sizes, increased numbers of learners with complex SEND but without additional funding and resource, teacher shortages, classes being covered by lower skilled TAs because you can't get a supply teacher for love nor money, kids still very much dealing with the fall out from COVID on their wellbeing, key parts of the school building being closed due to RAAC. These are the things that are making it hellish and directly correlate to government funding and policy. Throw in parents who aren't supportive due to a culture of teacher bashing or are unavailable to their kids because they have their own problems (CoL, unstable employment, inadequate or temp housing) and that makes things 100 times worse. Again directly correlates to government policy and has got exponentially worse under the Tories.
And that fact that some mumsnetters' lovely little home counties villages school hasn't been hit by the issues to ths same degree is hardly shocking, but surely posters realise this is not representative of the vast majority of schools and locations.

Shadowchaser · 07/03/2024 07:29

DH is an experienced teacher of 15 years/SLT, always gets good results and honestly cares for the kids but he’s desperate to get out. Anything that means we can have a life again!

For example this week it’s been meetings every night, a complusary school trip Saturday, data entry Sunday as well as marking and a pointless SLT task he has to do every week. For the pay he’s working for pennies by the time you work out the hours put in.

My son in a different school has had a substitute for 3 out of 4 years because nobody wants to do the job for the money.

GrammarTeacher · 07/03/2024 07:28

HRHElizabeth · 06/03/2024 21:30

I work in Education HR and always get good responses to Teacher adverts, we never fail to recruit and the standard of candidates is excellent - could easily appoint a number of shortlisted applicants.

That doesn’t marry with posts like these - maybe we are the exception to this trend I don’t know.

You are. I had 8 applicants for a recent teacher job. I was only prepared to interview 3 of them. And one of those turned out to be only good on paper. We've just had to readvertise for the third time for an SLT role because the candidates (plenty of them) are just not good enough to employ. Absolutely awful.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 07/03/2024 07:21

ToastyBreads · 06/03/2024 15:22

@Sk8erboi teachers have been moaning for decades. I have family members who are now retired tired teachers and they complained constantly throughout their careers about the same things that are being moaned about now. It’s just we hear about it more now on social media and they have each other to agree with.
I have been a TA at two schools in the past and loved my job with the children. I left because of the staff who dragged everything down, hated the kids, treated them with utter contempt and threatened to leave every single day (never did though, most had been there years - wonder why).
Op - if it is that bad, then leave.

That's the point. If everyone just leaves there will be no teachers left. We are getting to that point ...

GrammarTeacher · 07/03/2024 07:19

JamSandle · 06/03/2024 19:20

So you can't really blame people for not wanting to deal with it.

One of the issues is now staffing levels and lack of time. This where the money needs to go. We don't have enough time. And to give us the time we need more people.