Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how much longer it will be before all teachers quit?

459 replies

FunionsRFun · 06/03/2024 15:09

Been called a bitch and screamed at today. Kids are making no progress because 90% of the leason is dedicated to bad behaviour.
My detentions have been taken off the system to make behaviour look better.
Why would anyone do this job?

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 19:40

@Noonelikesasloppytrifle Detentions often work as a deterrent for low-level issues with the many students who aren't living the kind of home life you describe. I'm intrigued to know what you think does work for the studentswho are in crisis. They are often working a lot with the pastoral team, sometimes also with outside agencies, and teachers are often told not to issue detentions to these students.

You can train teachers (if you have the funding), but at the end of the day, subject teachers' job is to deliver the curriculum to the whole class. There is a limit to what we can do in terms of managing traumatised children within the classroom, especially when we often have multiple students with varied and potentially conflicting needs in every class.

Noonelikesasloppytrifle · 07/03/2024 19:26

cremebrulait · 07/03/2024 19:12

I'll probably get slayed for this...

When is the education system going to train teachers sufficiently to handle the classrooms they're in? If you talk to experts in child psychology, trauma, and behaviour - they're shocked at how schools treat children.

For example: Detention? Old school. Doesn't work. Makes things worse. You've got children who're coming to school hungry, getting picked on online, at school, at HOME, etc etc....they act up in school which is supposed to be a safe place and they get DETENTION?? When they keep getting singled out and and don't have a sense of safety - they're behaviour gets worse.

It is really appalling how teachers are not given sufficient training in psychological and behavioural issues in order to manage the children in their care. It's not their fault. I'm not blaming the teachers.

The reality is that schools are creating pressure cookers when they have kids with problems outside of school, are SEN, and school is not a safe place where they are treated in a way that enables them to learn appropriate behaviours.

I am somewhat intrigued that, rather than providing support and making parents accountable, you believe that it is up to teachers to fix these failings. To somehow manage the manifestations of individual trauma/experiences so that all children can have an education.

I absolutely do not disagree that the system doesn't work but that, in most part, is not due to the teachers.

How exactly do you provide this magic training for teachers?

PurpleBugz · 07/03/2024 19:25

My son has incredibly high needs SEN and is violent and soils himself. The LA are fighting me in tribunal saying he needs to go mainstream school. I pulled him out as he was being restrained and getting traumatised by it then the school kicked him out anyway. I'm friends with a TA at the school and she said I did the right thing his 1:1 was crying in the staff room over getting hurt by him. But say he wasn't violent- his EHCP requires a fully difrinciated curriculum tailored to his interests, monitoring for his sensory needs, sensory breaks regularly and also as needed. A considerable amount of additional training required of his teachers and 1:1. How can a teacher possibly do all this and still do all they do for the other children in the class?? How many other children have high support needs for their SEN?

I then have a nice well behaved SEN girl who gets no help or support because the teacher is dealing with the terrible behaviour of the boys. One who I obviously don't know the facts on but to me he is clearly autistic like my son a very disruptive challenging child who is struggling because of unmet needs that just cannot be met in mainstream so the behaviour will not improve. Dd scared to ask for help or say she's confused because the teacher is irritable and snappy. Having seen the behaviour in the playground of the kids in the class she's having to manage I'm not surprised.

I care for my son because I love him and he's my responsibility. No mainstream teacher is paid enough to take that abuse. I always think better Sen support earlier would help these kids behaviour before it gets this bad and more Sen schools for those who need it would make a massive difference. I work in early years and started when labour was pouring money into every child matters and really working on early interventions but over the years I've watched everything get cut- to the point early years setting are trying to avoid Sen kids as it's too much work not enough money so these kids are hitting school having had minimum in early help and some can't even get a nursery/childminder place. With the state of early years I can see this is only going to get worse.

But I do think some parents expect school to do everything that should be parents responsibly. If I get a call saying my child was messing about in the toilets I would punish my child not do nothing then kick off at school when the toilets get locked. The bitching on class WhatsApp over teacher telling their kid off has me biting my lip as I want to say "well fucking parent him then I can't believe you are not embarrassed he did that and insisted are ranting on here?!"

cardibach · 07/03/2024 19:18

Sk8erboi · 06/03/2024 15:17

I know people only post/speak about negatives but I do worry that I see so many threads on here of teachers slagging their job off.
Maybe the children are picking up on your negative vibes and not engaging fully with you because of it.
My child is year 8 and some of the teachers sound like they don't want to be at work at all going on what I'm told at the end of the day. Some of them sound fantastic and there seems to be a correlation between behaviour and progress and the teachers.

I dont doubt it's a hard and thankless job but there must be some positives surely

There used to be. It was the best job in the world. That was eroded by paperwork and stupid expectations, and since covid behaviour has gone through the floor. Most teachers find the classroom the best bit - I doubt they are birding negative in the bit they actually like. People aren’t ’being negative’ - the job is becoming utterly undoable. I am now semi retired, thank fuck.

noblegiraffe · 07/03/2024 19:14

Detention is what we've got.

Do you want us to have no sanctions available at all?

cremebrulait · 07/03/2024 19:12

I'll probably get slayed for this...

When is the education system going to train teachers sufficiently to handle the classrooms they're in? If you talk to experts in child psychology, trauma, and behaviour - they're shocked at how schools treat children.

For example: Detention? Old school. Doesn't work. Makes things worse. You've got children who're coming to school hungry, getting picked on online, at school, at HOME, etc etc....they act up in school which is supposed to be a safe place and they get DETENTION?? When they keep getting singled out and and don't have a sense of safety - they're behaviour gets worse.

It is really appalling how teachers are not given sufficient training in psychological and behavioural issues in order to manage the children in their care. It's not their fault. I'm not blaming the teachers.

The reality is that schools are creating pressure cookers when they have kids with problems outside of school, are SEN, and school is not a safe place where they are treated in a way that enables them to learn appropriate behaviours.

juraandme · 07/03/2024 19:09

I left at the start of the year and became a dog walker. The relief the day I handed in my resignation was insane.

I hope to never spend another day in front of a class unless it is for career day 😂

NotVWoolf · 07/03/2024 19:06

A lot of experienced, knowledgeable, excellent teachers have been bullied out of the profession by senior management. Once you’re on the upper pay scale, you’re too expensive, so they want newly qualified, cheaper teachers. Rather than having the guts to say it’s budgetary constraints (because that would be discrimination leading to a potential tribunal) they destroy the teacher’s mental health by putting them on ‘capability support plans’ which are a lot of extra work and a huge amount of pressure on an already insane workload. So teachers leave in their thousands and there’s a huge shortage/retention crisis.

Notmyuser · 07/03/2024 18:37

LakieLady · 07/03/2024 17:20

That's so sad. We had some amazing day trips when I was at school.

But having heard some of the accounts of bad behaviour in this thread, I'm not sure I'd want to take a party of kids on a boat trip on the Thames, or a tour round HMS Victory.

And the risk assessments alone would be onerous!

Honestly, behaviour on trips is good (as a whole!) and the risk assessment is fine too. I get why we can’t do trips, but it also frustrates me.

Workworkandmoreworknow · 07/03/2024 18:31

DancefloorAcrobatics · 07/03/2024 12:14

You sound bitter.

One of the teacher didn't attend tthe GCSE ptions evening, so again, we were told to ccontact them via email.

I think it's fair to expect a response from them via email to discuss.

Yes of course teachers have a life outside work- who doesn't?
But things like open -, parents - and options evenings are part and parcel of the job. It's where you sell the school and ensure that your pupils have the best possible results for their exams. Again a huge selling point for the school to attract a certain type of pupil.

you know to reduce the numbers that swear, spit and throw things at you

ODFOD. Bitter!

sure, part and parcel of the job. Night after bloody night - parents evenings twice a year for exam years, once a year for others, teaching from years 7 to 13. Options veinings, open evenings, observations, book scrutinies, learning walks…Sell the school, sure, it sells itself, given the quality of our provision, the reports, the exam results, the fact we go the extra mile and then some. I don’t particularly care about what type of pupil we attract - I give a shit about all kids, and want all of them - including the ones who spit, swear and throw things - to get the best possible education they can, to see that there are alternatives, to open minds, to support and improve outcomes now and in the future. That’s the job. Not hour after hour of pointless paper pushing, justifying my subject’s place on the curriculum, worrying about finding replacement staff when the resignations inevitably come in, children and parents who think nothing of complaining when you haven’t responded to the email a sent at midnight by 8:30am, constant budget reductions, no SEN support…..yeah, just about my bitterness and not a frustration that our children, for a myriad of reasons, are not getting the education they deserve. Fluff around the edges.

anon666 · 07/03/2024 18:30

It's happening already.

Covid - lots of experienced teachers quit or retired.

My husband is a senior teacher and he is the recruit. There is no-one out there.

Annierob · 07/03/2024 18:29

I was a teacher and had to cope with bad behaviour - from a minority of students but even two or three in one secondary school class can wreck a lesson.
However, when I went into teaching I was already a mum with three teenage sons (all who did well) and my instinct was that these ‘difficult’ pupils were unhappy.
Now I foster teenagers and see that I was correct. What we need is a different way of dealing with the disengaged students. Often traumatised, these young people may have low self esteem and are behind in their work. They would rather have an excuse to walk out of a lesson, then do some work as it’s easier. The vaping trend isn’t helping either. For many of them, school is their safe place where they meet their friends.

Disengaged pupils need help and understanding but they shouldn’t be able to undermine a lesson and prevent the rest of the class learning.
Teachers need to be able to do their job with the Majority of pupils who are there to learn. It really is a stressful, difficult job which takes hours of work every day.

I haven’t got answers except to say in my teenage years you could work for half a day at 13 (I used to pack car parts in Birmingham); now it is hard for young people to work until they reach the age of 18. Academic learning doesn’t suit them all. I have looked after young people who were difficult at school but were transformed when they got jobs and earned money. Maybe apprenticeships from age 14 should be available.
A big thank you to all our teachers. You do an amazing job, even on days when it doesn’t feel that way. Honestly, write down how many pupils you have taught in one day and then write down how many caused problems. It just feels like you are hitting your head against a brick wall; most pupils are fine.

Gettingonmygoat · 07/03/2024 18:04

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 06/03/2024 17:34

What turned you away?

A really bad Head whose only interest was what she would wear the next day. She used one of the Senior T.As has her PA. She had no interest in the children or the staff. One of her favourite sayings that was thrown around at every meeting was " my pension was sat there waiting for me". She allowed one member of staff to basically bully and bad mouth other staff, children and parents. The final nail was when she out and out lied about a child and have him removed from the school. The woman should never have been allowed near chidren.

mydrivingisterrible · 07/03/2024 18:03

HelloMiss · 06/03/2024 18:14

Teachers seem So dramatic.... I mean who doesn't moan about their jobs?

Where will you go to work which will be moaning - free?

I looked to train as a teacher - got some work experience in a school - then promptly left and cancelled my PGCE application.

Other jobs are easier. So I've kept to other jobs.

Arsenal1968 · 07/03/2024 18:01

Got to remember certain types of schools may have more challenging pupils e.g. SEMH

OnceinaMinion · 07/03/2024 18:01

Multi academy trust.

mydrivingisterrible · 07/03/2024 17:59

@OnceinaMinion Sorry what's a MAT?

CestLaVie123 · 07/03/2024 17:46

Maybe the children are picking up on your negative vibes and not engaging fully with you because of it.

The most absurd thing I've ever read on Mumsnet. And I've been an active member for 10+ years. Poster must have a very badly behaved child - it's a mystery why the child is badly behaved- must be the teachers' fault 😂

Shinyandnew1 · 07/03/2024 17:43

Does each school need a really scary disciplinarian figure to lay down the absolute law?

Well, on here, if a parent even suspects their child’s teacher has raised their voice at them, there are cries to complain to the head/governors/Ofsted and complaints that no teacher should ever need to shout as they should be able to instantly create a cosy fuzz of tranquility without noise, threats, rewards or sanctions and if they can’t, they shouldn’t be doing the job.

tangycheesythings · 07/03/2024 17:38

I am sure things are worse now but it was already pretty bad when we were at secondary in the mid-late 80's. Kids were smoking all over the place, playing truant was rife, gluesniffing and stealing chemicals from the lab to try out, after school planned fights, lunchtime fights, kids throwing chairs, bullying was constant, a lot of messing around in class, constantly someone sent outside to stand outside the door for 5 minutes, people being sent to the head, whole class detentions, no one did any homework or we copied each others, eating in class, answering back.

The only real difference I can see is that I don't remember any actual physical violence towards teachers.

We had a really scary deputy head who could be heard absolutely yelling and losing the plot at some poor kid sent to his office at various times throughout the day. We were ALL scared of being sent to him and that's what made us reel it in ultimately.

Does each school need a really scary disciplinarian figure to lay down the absolute law?

PassingStranger · 07/03/2024 17:24

It won't be long. Someone shared something on Twitter today. It was from a teacher detailing all the abuse and rudeness he was having to put up with on a daily basis.

How low can society and lack of discipline go?

LakieLady · 07/03/2024 17:20

Notmyuser · 06/03/2024 23:27

We are banned from trips now. Can’t be asking parents to pay for trips as parents have no money, and schools can’t fund trips because they have no money either.

That's so sad. We had some amazing day trips when I was at school.

But having heard some of the accounts of bad behaviour in this thread, I'm not sure I'd want to take a party of kids on a boat trip on the Thames, or a tour round HMS Victory.

And the risk assessments alone would be onerous!

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 16:41

Sorry if I overreacted, @Calamitousness . Busy day. Taking a short MN break before settling down to my marking turned out not to improve my mood... I need to re-hide the Education board and AIBU.

JaneAustenshandbag · 07/03/2024 16:41

C

Calamitousness · 07/03/2024 16:28

Apologies to any teacher offended. I merely find many of complaints are around children and behaviour. I know I wouldn’t have wanted to work as a teacher and do apologise for any assumptions which are incorrect. Children were always a mixed bag of abilities and behaviour is all I meant in reference to those complaints around children. Targets/reduced staffing etc are a way of life in current climate and I agree that can make a teachers load more onerous. Again. Sorry teachers. I agree a badly written post which was done in the middle of the night and didn’t convey what I meant to very well at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread