Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how much longer it will be before all teachers quit?

459 replies

FunionsRFun · 06/03/2024 15:09

Been called a bitch and screamed at today. Kids are making no progress because 90% of the leason is dedicated to bad behaviour.
My detentions have been taken off the system to make behaviour look better.
Why would anyone do this job?

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 07/03/2024 20:45

@cremebrulait

Teachers shouldn't have to learn these things that you want them to, there should be systems in place that support the children and the teachers.

The answer isn't to load more work on overworked people.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 20:43

And people immediately get upset with the suggestion they need to learn more.

No. That's not it. Most teachers like learning. We have regular training about all kinds of aspects of our job. We want to do our job as well as we can. We want kids to learn. We want behaviour to be easier to manage.

But... we've heard it all before, especially those of us who have been in the profession a really long time. Too many initiatives we don't have time to think about and which sound great in theory in the training session, but turn out not to work very well in practice. Or work well with some students but not others. Or, more often, things that are presented as new ideas with shiny new names, but are actually things we've all been doing for donkeys' years.

threatmatrix · 07/03/2024 20:43

Go and work in a private school. It’s so much better and you have the parents total backing.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 07/03/2024 20:42

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 20:33

Yeah, it was all Goodbye, Mr Chips under Labour.

🙄

Well teaching was much better.

Smaller class sizes
Loads of money
Functioning IT instead of 20 year old computers with no keys
Equipment refreshes in practical subjects
Beaviuor, learning and mental health support
Enough materials for every child
The introduction of ‘Every Child Matters’ and SureStart centres which fed through to schools.
Beacon schools

Tories
Massive classes
No money anywhere
Crap IT
Practical equipment so crap it’s affecting grades
No support at all
Materials bought by teacher
Closed all majority of Sure Start

JamSandle · 07/03/2024 20:41

I think if you trained teachers to be all those things it would end up like training to be a doctor!

FrippEnos · 07/03/2024 20:40

cremebrulait · 07/03/2024 19:12

I'll probably get slayed for this...

When is the education system going to train teachers sufficiently to handle the classrooms they're in? If you talk to experts in child psychology, trauma, and behaviour - they're shocked at how schools treat children.

For example: Detention? Old school. Doesn't work. Makes things worse. You've got children who're coming to school hungry, getting picked on online, at school, at HOME, etc etc....they act up in school which is supposed to be a safe place and they get DETENTION?? When they keep getting singled out and and don't have a sense of safety - they're behaviour gets worse.

It is really appalling how teachers are not given sufficient training in psychological and behavioural issues in order to manage the children in their care. It's not their fault. I'm not blaming the teachers.

The reality is that schools are creating pressure cookers when they have kids with problems outside of school, are SEN, and school is not a safe place where they are treated in a way that enables them to learn appropriate behaviours.

So you want teachers to not only have a degree in the subject that they teach but a psychology degree as well.

Then to teach the curriculum and also be able to put right the issues that children have all on 25hrs p/w and topping out at £43K per year whilst still doing all the other stuff that the job now entails?

Maybe you would like the moon on a stick as well.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 20:33

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 07/03/2024 20:17

When is the education system going to train teachers sufficiently to handle the classrooms they're in?

When class sizes return to the size they were and funding increases like it was under the Labour government. And it could go further than that. It’s NOT the teachers. It’s the underfunding that causes the problems.

Yeah, it was all Goodbye, Mr Chips under Labour.

🙄

cremebrulait · 07/03/2024 20:32

PickledMumion · 07/03/2024 20:10

So what you're saying, is that the concept of classroom teaching just doesn't work.

Of course it would be better if we had the staffing to teach in groups of 4-5. That way we would have 15 mins with each child every lesson, we'd build fantastic relationships, learning could be tailored around each child's needs and interests.

But when we have 30(+) in the room, we need to spend at least 20-30 mins of any hour addressing the whole class, 5 mins waiting for everyone to sit down and write the title, 5 mins at the end supervising putting all the books away properly etc, which leaves approx 40 seconds per student. (And they only get their 40 seconds if the other kids don't take up more than their 40 seconds!)

No I'm saying that system doesn't prepare teachers enough to understand and manage behaviours. I'm not blaming the teachers. People get their credentials to teach and the system hasn't equipped them enough to deal with what they've go to face.

It's not the teacher's fault. But as long as they are not getting sufficient training the will keep having more and more issues because they can't control the children or situations. It spirals.

And people immediately get upset with the suggestion they need to learn more. Well in most vocations we do...the world changes. Right now and post-pandemic we have more children with more challenges and teacher's have not been taught effective strategies. They're left to use tactics which don't work and can make things worse. If they got updated skills in managing these issues they'd have better environments for everyone.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 20:31

For starters: are teachers taught ABC Behaviour Model: Antecedent, Behaviour, Consequence?

It's amazing how often people seem to think that an acronym is the answer to everything. Let me guess... antecedent = what triggered the behaviour, behaviour = the behaviour that was triggered, consequence = what happened as a result of the behaviour? And you tackle future behaviour incidents by trying to avoid or preempt the antecedent? Or is there more to it than that? Because that just sounds like common-or-garden common sense to me.

Notmyuser · 07/03/2024 20:30

noblegiraffe · 07/03/2024 19:14

Detention is what we've got.

Do you want us to have no sanctions available at all?

Have you tried giving them a sticker, a hug and a bars bar when they misbehave?

DisabledDemon · 07/03/2024 20:28

I work as a private tutor now and love it. My pupils are motivated and no one physically threatens me.

You wouldn't get me back into a classroom at the point of a gun.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 20:25

I think to some extent, a teacher is accountable for what is happening in their classroom. You are dealing with minors, you are the adult in the room.

Teachers know full well they are accountable for what's happening in their classroom. They are held accountable. That does not mean that what happens in classrooms is always manageable. If a teenager decides to kick off, it is not necessarily possible to prevent them from doing so. How would you do it? Many parents don't seem very able to control their own one or two children’s behaviour. Try controlling the behaviour of multiple different groups of 30 other people's children all day. We are trained. We aren't magic.

cremebrulait · 07/03/2024 20:25

noblegiraffe · 07/03/2024 19:14

Detention is what we've got.

Do you want us to have no sanctions available at all?

Don't skip my point which is that teacher's need more training. The world has changed and the system is not preparing teachers for a lot of the issues that exist. Detention is all you have? When I hear about kids in Y3 being put in detention I shake my head because for many kids it will make matters worse. And that's all teachers have. And it seems a lot of teachers are saying the behaviour is unmanageable. It's becoming unmanageable. So my POV is the only way to fix problems is to go to the source.

For starters: are teachers taught ABC Behaviour Model: Antecedent, Behaviour, Consequence?

DancefloorAcrobatics · 07/03/2024 20:19

rather than providing support and making parents accountable, you believe that it is up to teachers to fix these failings

How do you propose to make parents accountable? Detention? Fines?

I think to some extent, a teacher is accountable for what is happening in their classroom. You are dealing with minors, you are the adult in the room.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 07/03/2024 20:17

When is the education system going to train teachers sufficiently to handle the classrooms they're in?

When class sizes return to the size they were and funding increases like it was under the Labour government. And it could go further than that. It’s NOT the teachers. It’s the underfunding that causes the problems.

AngelinaFibres · 07/03/2024 20:13

I had a year 2 class in an infants school. Once they'd finished year 2 they went across the field to the junior school. Different head, different governing body, completely separate school with little contact between the 2. I was required to write reports for teacher to teacher information and to do assessments to inform the junior school as to where children were in key subjects. Along with end of year parental reports it was hours and hours of work ( done in the evening at home). I took my class up to visit their new junior teacher. I mentioned to her that the reports were nearly done. "Oh we don't know why you do those" she said " they just go in a cupboard in the office and we do our own assessments when they come back after the summer. No one looks at them". I said this to my head teacher. She insisted that I did them anyway because OFSTED liked it. Hours of utterly pointless work that took time away from my young children. I was a single parent. It was pointless, stupid and soul destroying. I would love to have told her where to shove them but I needed the money .

PickledMumion · 07/03/2024 20:10

cremebrulait · 07/03/2024 19:12

I'll probably get slayed for this...

When is the education system going to train teachers sufficiently to handle the classrooms they're in? If you talk to experts in child psychology, trauma, and behaviour - they're shocked at how schools treat children.

For example: Detention? Old school. Doesn't work. Makes things worse. You've got children who're coming to school hungry, getting picked on online, at school, at HOME, etc etc....they act up in school which is supposed to be a safe place and they get DETENTION?? When they keep getting singled out and and don't have a sense of safety - they're behaviour gets worse.

It is really appalling how teachers are not given sufficient training in psychological and behavioural issues in order to manage the children in their care. It's not their fault. I'm not blaming the teachers.

The reality is that schools are creating pressure cookers when they have kids with problems outside of school, are SEN, and school is not a safe place where they are treated in a way that enables them to learn appropriate behaviours.

So what you're saying, is that the concept of classroom teaching just doesn't work.

Of course it would be better if we had the staffing to teach in groups of 4-5. That way we would have 15 mins with each child every lesson, we'd build fantastic relationships, learning could be tailored around each child's needs and interests.

But when we have 30(+) in the room, we need to spend at least 20-30 mins of any hour addressing the whole class, 5 mins waiting for everyone to sit down and write the title, 5 mins at the end supervising putting all the books away properly etc, which leaves approx 40 seconds per student. (And they only get their 40 seconds if the other kids don't take up more than their 40 seconds!)

Rosejasmine · 07/03/2024 20:07

worstofbothworlds · 06/03/2024 15:45

I'm at a university and they may be polite but they still threaten to sue, write their essays using ChatGPT and deny it, take drugs, write petitions to get lecturers fired who indulge in wrong think, or in the case of Rosa Freedman or Kathleen Stock, throw urine or smoke bombs.

😨OMG. Not like that in my kids first year at uni but she did say a lot of students talk through lectures and have little respect. In her state school they’d have been lynched for such behaviour which maybe why she noticed - her feeling is the more privileged the student, the worse the behaviour. Drugs are everywhere though that part isn’t a surprise.

cremebrulait · 07/03/2024 20:07

Noonelikesasloppytrifle · 07/03/2024 19:26

I am somewhat intrigued that, rather than providing support and making parents accountable, you believe that it is up to teachers to fix these failings. To somehow manage the manifestations of individual trauma/experiences so that all children can have an education.

I absolutely do not disagree that the system doesn't work but that, in most part, is not due to the teachers.

How exactly do you provide this magic training for teachers?

I did not write the teachers were responsible. I wrote when is the education system…above them.

CestLaVie123 · 07/03/2024 20:04

When is the education system going to train teachers sufficiently to handle the classrooms they're in?

Second-most absurd thing i've seen on Mumsnet. I mean really, what?! Obviously written by someone who either has no idea how children currently behave in UK classrooms, and/or someone who has no idea how to deal with current classrooms

twoboyssolucky · 07/03/2024 19:56

NotVWoolf · 07/03/2024 19:06

A lot of experienced, knowledgeable, excellent teachers have been bullied out of the profession by senior management. Once you’re on the upper pay scale, you’re too expensive, so they want newly qualified, cheaper teachers. Rather than having the guts to say it’s budgetary constraints (because that would be discrimination leading to a potential tribunal) they destroy the teacher’s mental health by putting them on ‘capability support plans’ which are a lot of extra work and a huge amount of pressure on an already insane workload. So teachers leave in their thousands and there’s a huge shortage/retention crisis.

This. I’ve seen this happen too many times.

Some schools are toxic.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 19:56

Oops sorry @Noonelikesasloppytrifle ! I meant @cremebrulait . In my defence, you both have dessert-related names Grin

AngelinaFibres · 07/03/2024 19:56

juraandme · 07/03/2024 19:09

I left at the start of the year and became a dog walker. The relief the day I handed in my resignation was insane.

I hope to never spend another day in front of a class unless it is for career day 😂

When I left I vowed that I would never set foot in a classroom again unless it was to collect my grandchildren. I thought I might miss it when we got to the first Christmas after leaving. It was the first Christmas for years that I wasn't ill. My late teens children said that that was the first time for years that we had had a proper Christmas. I have never regretted getting out. I have 10 friends from teacher training that I am still in touch with 40 years later. We are all 57/8. Not one of us is still teaching. Not one of us regrets getting out.

Noonelikesasloppytrifle · 07/03/2024 19:44

AllProperTeaIsTheft In think you must have meant a different poster - I'm in agreement with you.

cardibach · 07/03/2024 19:40

DinnaeFashYersel · 06/03/2024 17:03

Agree - none of the recently (last 3 years) qualified teachers I know have managed to secure a permanent job.

Another friend is applying to one of the Scottish teacher training colleges and has been told that their are 800 applicants for 100 places.

There's clearly lots of people still choosing to become teachers.

Those who hate teaching should leave and do something else.

In Scotland they are paid a lot more and their work life balance is better. Maybe that’s the answer…