Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how much longer it will be before all teachers quit?

459 replies

FunionsRFun · 06/03/2024 15:09

Been called a bitch and screamed at today. Kids are making no progress because 90% of the leason is dedicated to bad behaviour.
My detentions have been taken off the system to make behaviour look better.
Why would anyone do this job?

OP posts:
Whitestick · 07/03/2024 22:06

cremebrulait · 07/03/2024 19:12

I'll probably get slayed for this...

When is the education system going to train teachers sufficiently to handle the classrooms they're in? If you talk to experts in child psychology, trauma, and behaviour - they're shocked at how schools treat children.

For example: Detention? Old school. Doesn't work. Makes things worse. You've got children who're coming to school hungry, getting picked on online, at school, at HOME, etc etc....they act up in school which is supposed to be a safe place and they get DETENTION?? When they keep getting singled out and and don't have a sense of safety - they're behaviour gets worse.

It is really appalling how teachers are not given sufficient training in psychological and behavioural issues in order to manage the children in their care. It's not their fault. I'm not blaming the teachers.

The reality is that schools are creating pressure cookers when they have kids with problems outside of school, are SEN, and school is not a safe place where they are treated in a way that enables them to learn appropriate behaviours.

I'm at a loss to think what kind of training would equip teachers to prevent behavioural issues with children living in poverty, undiagnosed (and undiagnosed) SEN, trauma etc. Never mind the ones who have no such issues in their background but are just arrogant and disrespectful. What kind of training would stop bad behaviour, that is not reinforced by a plethora of other services (adequate CAHMS support for one), smaller class sizes, consistent behaviour policies and adequate government funding?
Unless you know a training provider for Jedi mind control?

noblegiraffe · 07/03/2024 22:03

They've hardly left the country in good nick, have they?

Anyway the Tories spent most of their 14 years in office blaming the previous Labour government for any of their foul-ups so fair's fair. They've recently switched to blaming the Welsh government or the future Labour government. Anything to avoid taking responsibility for their abject (and obvious to everyone) failure.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 22:01

cardibach · 07/03/2024 21:59

They weren’t last time. I taught before, during and after the last Labour government. It was significantly better in schools under Labour.
Mind you, John Major’s government didn’t spend the last year of it’s tenure salting the earth, so that might make a difference I guess.

I see “salting the earth” is the Labour campaign of preparation in case of abject failure in office.

cardibach · 07/03/2024 21:59

Isitovernow123 · 06/03/2024 20:57

I think we’ll find Labour will be exactly the same as the tories. No difference except for a few words.

They weren’t last time. I taught before, during and after the last Labour government. It was significantly better in schools under Labour.
Mind you, John Major’s government didn’t spend the last year of it’s tenure salting the earth, so that might make a difference I guess.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 07/03/2024 21:58

spirit20 · 07/03/2024 21:41

I would bet the government doesn't actually care if more teachers leave, or rather, I would bet they are aware that they cannot do anything to stop them (apart from funding schools better so that class sizes drop).

You only need to look at the recent initiatives such as Oak Academy to guess what their plan is - create a centralised curriculum and have specialists prepare resources that can then be sent to schools where they'll just need a warm body to click through pre-prepared Powerpoint slides, and it won't really matter (at least according to the government anyway...) if the Powerpoint clickers understand the content themselves or not. Many schools have already moved to employing non-teaching pastoral staff on pathetic wages and I bet it won't be long before we see the same thing happen with the people who stand in front of classes.

The government is also already making a huge push to attract people from abroad to train as teachers here, by offering them up to 10k in relocation allowances. In my more cynical moments, I do wonder if their plan is to flood the education system with cheap labour from overseas like they have done with other public services.

…create a centralised curriculum and have specialists prepare resources that can then be sent to schools…

Oh FFS. The French school system has had a tightly academic centralised curriculum and exam scheme for decades. It used to be said that every French child should be doing the same work at the same time all over the country.

The problem with the English system is pupils’ disruptiveness and a tolerance of it.

It’s not about money. And it’s not about studying Shakespeare v studying rap lyrics.

Supergirl1958 · 07/03/2024 21:52

*SEND rising. No support, no funding. Teacher/SENCOs trying their best only for parents to say teachers/SENCOs don’t care/wont listen/wont do anything even though we try our best in a broken system

this is one of many things! I say this as a teacher and parent of a send child!!

spirit20 · 07/03/2024 21:41

I would bet the government doesn't actually care if more teachers leave, or rather, I would bet they are aware that they cannot do anything to stop them (apart from funding schools better so that class sizes drop).

You only need to look at the recent initiatives such as Oak Academy to guess what their plan is - create a centralised curriculum and have specialists prepare resources that can then be sent to schools where they'll just need a warm body to click through pre-prepared Powerpoint slides, and it won't really matter (at least according to the government anyway...) if the Powerpoint clickers understand the content themselves or not. Many schools have already moved to employing non-teaching pastoral staff on pathetic wages and I bet it won't be long before we see the same thing happen with the people who stand in front of classes.

The government is also already making a huge push to attract people from abroad to train as teachers here, by offering them up to 10k in relocation allowances. In my more cynical moments, I do wonder if their plan is to flood the education system with cheap labour from overseas like they have done with other public services.

Smartiepants79 · 07/03/2024 21:41

twistyizzy · 07/03/2024 20:51

Your school should set communication boundaries for contacting teachers. DDs private school says teachers will only reply between the hours of 8am-7pm (boarding school so open for longer hours).
Our Yr WhatsApp only tends to be used for lost items of uniform and very infrequently low level grumbles about food, never about teachers. There are generally excellent relations between staff/parents/pupils and is the main reason why we chose the school. Obviously not everything is perfect but then life isn't either!

I was not expecting a reply til the next day at the earliest!
For most relationships between staff/school and parents are very good. We have absolutely no complaints and are extremely happy.
I would just say that’s it naive and disingenuous to think that working in the private sector is magically amazing. It comes with a different set of stresses and pressures. And many of the same ones. Twatty parents exist everywhere. And this time they’re directly paying your salary and you’re expected to be grateful for their business.

Daisyb1080 · 07/03/2024 21:37

Sk8erboi · 06/03/2024 15:17

I know people only post/speak about negatives but I do worry that I see so many threads on here of teachers slagging their job off.
Maybe the children are picking up on your negative vibes and not engaging fully with you because of it.
My child is year 8 and some of the teachers sound like they don't want to be at work at all going on what I'm told at the end of the day. Some of them sound fantastic and there seems to be a correlation between behaviour and progress and the teachers.

I dont doubt it's a hard and thankless job but there must be some positives surely

Seriously would you be happy being abused all day 🙄

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 21:34

Yes I’m happy that ex teachers actually took action to improve their situations. I hope they are much happier.

Like every other shortage, pay and or conditions will then need to improve to attract new teachers in and parents/voters will need to champion this and vote accordingly.

Pay and or conditions will need to improve? Hahahahaha. They won't though. Recruitment and retention have been a problem for years. They have been missing their targets for trainee applications for years. The profession is haemhorraging teachers. Vote for whom? What is any party going to do about it? Parents don't champion schools, they complain about them.

Anyoneknowanything1 · 07/03/2024 21:32

Don't blame them. I love teaching - currently covering for an out of class colleague which means my class needs cover. Can't get a long term supply to stay because they don't want the responsibility (fair enough) but guess whose fault it is? Mine apparently - both that we can't get supply and my colleague is off. Tired of the Facebook rants about how crap we all are and how far the school has fallen - we are all trying our best in difficult circumstances.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 21:29

A huge problem with pupil behaviour isn't that teachers don't use ABC but that pupils use CBA.

Grin So true.

The suggestion that kids are pissing around because they're traumatised or triggered or whatever is laughable when some of them clearly just find pissing around more fun than tackling solving quadratic equations.

I know. Unfortunately, nobody wants to admit that poor behaviour is ever actually a choice, or is ever the child's fault. But of course it is sometimes. The students themselves know exactly who the non-traumatised trouble-makers are. Most adults will have gone to school with plenty of them, but it's amazing how they forget that, and allow themselves to be convinced ththatll bad behaviour is a result of trauma.

Yourcatisnotsorry · 07/03/2024 21:23

FrippEnos · 07/03/2024 20:49

40,000 teachers last year took your advice.

There is a major recruitment and retention crisis in teaching.

Fewer and fewer children have qualified teachers in front of their classes.

Are you happy about that?

Yes I’m happy that ex teachers actually took action to improve their situations. I hope they are much happier.

Like every other shortage, pay and or conditions will then need to improve to attract new teachers in and parents/voters will need to champion this and vote accordingly.

individuals need to make the right decisions for themselves. They aren’t martyrs nobody is forcing you to be a teacher.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 07/03/2024 21:20

KickHimInTheCrotch · 07/03/2024 20:57

I've just attended parents evening online for my year 8. One teacher didn't bother attending our booked appointment, one refused to put her camera on, one was trying to give me feedback for 3 subjects (2 of which she had no clue about) and one didn't let me speak at all, she just droned on about how she tries to challenge the students. I get that it's a hard job but I was left feeling that my daughter is being "taught" by a group of people who really would rather have been anywhere else.

They probably would.

Look at it from another angle.

One was ill/ absent and you weren’t informed
One wanted to protect herself so don’t put the camera on
The feedback on 3 lessons would have been to cover absent colleagues or reduce pressure on colleagues with too many parents to see
The droner had 4 minutes to say her stuff. What more do you want?

noblegiraffe · 07/03/2024 21:19

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 07/03/2024 20:31

For starters: are teachers taught ABC Behaviour Model: Antecedent, Behaviour, Consequence?

It's amazing how often people seem to think that an acronym is the answer to everything. Let me guess... antecedent = what triggered the behaviour, behaviour = the behaviour that was triggered, consequence = what happened as a result of the behaviour? And you tackle future behaviour incidents by trying to avoid or preempt the antecedent? Or is there more to it than that? Because that just sounds like common-or-garden common sense to me.

A huge problem with pupil behaviour isn't that teachers don't use ABC but that pupils use CBA.

The suggestion that kids are pissing around because they're traumatised or triggered or whatever is laughable when some of them clearly just find pissing around more fun than tackling solving quadratic equations.

Whataterror · 07/03/2024 21:10

I don’t know how you do it. It’s infuriating for parents as well. I have two DC (one primary, one secondary - both ‘good’ schools ie. OFSTED outstanding, affluent area etc), and the behaviour I hear of daily is terrible, with seemingly no (or certainly not obvious) repressions for said bad behaviour. Zero discipline, awful behaviour continues and so the other children aren’t being taught to the standard they should be, they’re starting to think this bad behaviour is typical/acceptable, and sorry to say that kids are starting to lose respect for teachers who they are seeing as permitting these behaviours. I get that teachers hands are tied. It’s just shit all round.

Hadsuchahardday · 07/03/2024 20:59

DS13 attends a local secondary- far from the best in the borough but not the worst either. At a recent parent evening- without fail- every teacher (8 of them) commented on what a well behaved, polite, hardworking, helpful, gentlemanly son I had and how they wished the class was full of kids like him. I was even told well done for doing such a good job bringing him up! I do think there is a huge parental responsibility to raise kids to be decent human beings. Teachers could actually teach if they didn’t have to spend all lesson controlling the behaviour of the class. Who knows it might even help ease the teacher recruitment /retention crisis.

KickHimInTheCrotch · 07/03/2024 20:57

I've just attended parents evening online for my year 8. One teacher didn't bother attending our booked appointment, one refused to put her camera on, one was trying to give me feedback for 3 subjects (2 of which she had no clue about) and one didn't let me speak at all, she just droned on about how she tries to challenge the students. I get that it's a hard job but I was left feeling that my daughter is being "taught" by a group of people who really would rather have been anywhere else.

Lancrelady80 · 07/03/2024 20:56

(I am not that teacher in a class of 44 btw, but know a local school where that really is the case.)

Notellinganyone · 07/03/2024 20:53

This is incredibly depressing and frustrating. I started my career in the state sector 30 years ago and it was nothing like this. I’m now in an independent school and loving it still but suspect I might well not have survived as long if I’d stayed in state schools.

Lancrelady80 · 07/03/2024 20:52

Yes, ABC is commonly used for the especially disruptive kids. But you need staff to be able to observe closely the A...which often isn't even rooted in anything school related. We also need time to do that effectively and to properly analyse for every significant event. How does one teacher in a class of 44 (KS2 class...true story!) even begin to do that when three or four incidents happen most lessons? Perhaps the answer is linked to the recently published report showing primary teachers regularly work on average 15 hours per week overtime / unpaid.

We also do restorative conversations, where we reflect with the child on what happened; what triggered it; their feelings at the time; impact of their behaviour on others including how they felt; what they could have done differently and alternative strategies to use in a similar situation; how to put things right and restore positive relationships. Again, time and adult intensive. Often pointless as the behaviour and subsequent conversations are repeated over and over. Those conversations can be really valuable for the children who engage with them, but sadly there are a few who just don't give a damn - say all the right things, then do exactly the same again.

twistyizzy · 07/03/2024 20:51

Smartiepants79 · 07/03/2024 20:47

Is this sarcasm?
My kids go to private school and the parents WhatsApp is a never ending stream of moaning.
I think it’s better in many ways but it’s very high pressure with very high parental expectations and a similar issue with lack of personal responsibility and entitlement.
The teachers seem to be available 24 hours a day almost. I emailed one the other evening and got a reply at 11pm!

Your school should set communication boundaries for contacting teachers. DDs private school says teachers will only reply between the hours of 8am-7pm (boarding school so open for longer hours).
Our Yr WhatsApp only tends to be used for lost items of uniform and very infrequently low level grumbles about food, never about teachers. There are generally excellent relations between staff/parents/pupils and is the main reason why we chose the school. Obviously not everything is perfect but then life isn't either!

FrippEnos · 07/03/2024 20:49

Yourcatisnotsorry · 07/03/2024 20:47

So why don’t you? Nobody is making you teach so unless the good aspects (satisfaction from the impact you have, autonomy in delivery and yes the holidays!) outweigh the negatives (agree there can be many) leave and retrain for something else. Teachers have moaned about teaching for my entire lifetime and yet most do precisely nothing about it. If you think the grass is greener why don’t you leave?

40,000 teachers last year took your advice.

There is a major recruitment and retention crisis in teaching.

Fewer and fewer children have qualified teachers in front of their classes.

Are you happy about that?

Smartiepants79 · 07/03/2024 20:47

threatmatrix · 07/03/2024 20:43

Go and work in a private school. It’s so much better and you have the parents total backing.

Is this sarcasm?
My kids go to private school and the parents WhatsApp is a never ending stream of moaning.
I think it’s better in many ways but it’s very high pressure with very high parental expectations and a similar issue with lack of personal responsibility and entitlement.
The teachers seem to be available 24 hours a day almost. I emailed one the other evening and got a reply at 11pm!

Yourcatisnotsorry · 07/03/2024 20:47

So why don’t you? Nobody is making you teach so unless the good aspects (satisfaction from the impact you have, autonomy in delivery and yes the holidays!) outweigh the negatives (agree there can be many) leave and retrain for something else. Teachers have moaned about teaching for my entire lifetime and yet most do precisely nothing about it. If you think the grass is greener why don’t you leave?

Swipe left for the next trending thread