Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how much longer it will be before all teachers quit?

459 replies

FunionsRFun · 06/03/2024 15:09

Been called a bitch and screamed at today. Kids are making no progress because 90% of the leason is dedicated to bad behaviour.
My detentions have been taken off the system to make behaviour look better.
Why would anyone do this job?

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 07/03/2024 07:15

Tryingmybestadhd · 06/03/2024 23:05

A bit of a generalisation , some teachers have great jobs . Example , my youngest school has classes of 10 to 16 students . I’m sure it’s not that hard . This being said I know it’s not alway the case . But what job is easy anyway ? Look at junior doctors , gaining a pittance working 16 hour shifts . Look at electricity engineers who have to restore life cables during storms , look at nurses working for such low wages .
we are all in the same boat , we just need to fight for better working conditions for everyone

I have to agree with this.

Dc schools are great. No retention issues, small classes. Good SEN support. Long term staff who appear happy.

I'm sure there must some issues rumbling behind the scenes but no more than for any other profession. I guess it depends where you live but I don't think the horror stories are representative of all schools.

MrsMurphyIWish · 07/03/2024 06:53

Qualified in 2000, here’s how I have survived:

-Find your voice or your advocate. When I was heavily pregnant with DS I was pushed down the stairs by a horrible Yr 9 (had many suspensions, most likely in prison now). School wouldn’t move him from my class until DH rang my head and threatened to go to the press. I left 3 years later.
-I work at a school now where we are directed to work in our undirected time (so have morning and lunch duties). I now refuse to run clubs or go on trips. I’m also disabled and now take my monthly physio sessions in school time where I would used to book it in my own time.
-I used to have my seating plans so all the poorly behaved students sat at the front. Now, I place them far away from me as possible and surround myself with the good kids. Want my time? Engage!

Find strategies to help you through the day - or change schools! If you’re a qualified teacher then your pupils are lucky that you’re still in the classroom!

Rainyblue · 07/03/2024 06:37

I think that there has been a fundamental change in the expectations of what schools should provide. Whenever the government decides children / families need extra support in xyz issue, the first thing is ‘schools can provide this’.

Mental health support, food vouchers, SEN support, Covid testing etc etc so that schools have moved away from places of education to be places of social support, often with no additional / minimal funding. Other sources of support (eg CAMHS, specialist schools) are completely overstretched.

This has changed the relationship with parents. Parents now expect much more from schools in terms of support for all sorts of things, and if they don’t receive it they blame and criticise the school. This damages the relationship between parents and school and makes it harder for schools to enforce discipline.

Rainyblue · 07/03/2024 06:22

The oddest thing is that, going by MN, it seems like everyone are perfect parents who don't allow their children a single minute of screentime, any UPFs, always offer healthy home cooked meals with at least 5 a day and meeting all their emotional needs.
^^
You just need to read the smugness and outrage at threads about late potty training, children's typical diet in a day, screentime or social media guidance. If the vocal majority are parenting so perfectly, how come older kids are so fucked up that schools can no longer function?

Because any parenting forum is a self-selective group … and for a start, parents in the most dysfunctional families are unlikely to be on a parenting forum asking for advice.

For the rest, I doubt most people are going to post really honestly about their worst parenting decisions!!
Just because the ‘smug’ ones are so vocal, doesn’t mean they are the majority….

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 07/03/2024 06:08

coxesorangepippin · 07/03/2024 01:47

The excuses being made on this thread make me realise that a large part of the problem is many parents not having a similar approach and kids not respecting authority

^

This.

Awful combination. Children need authority. They are looking for guidance, not free rein in life.

Absolutely! Especially the early post straight away blaming the teachers for causing the pupils to act like they are!

Elendel · 07/03/2024 06:06

My day yesterday started off having to manage a child who thought nothing of sitting on the floor ratting a desk back and forth during instruction time, refused to step outside and then complained when they were eventually moved out by another member of staff. I teach 11-18 year-olds, not primary kids.

Completely reasonable requests (like sitting down, taking their equipment out and coats off in a room that is regularly too hot or staying silent while I am explaining a task) are met with actual wails, screams, walking off. Not the majority, by far, but it only takes 2-3 students to do this every lesson of every day for it to be a massive drain on mine and other students' time and energy.

I get told by support staff that behaviour in my room is better than in many others. I dread to think what the kids have to put up with in some lessons when I feel like I barely get anything done.

I am also one of many staff to leave soon and while I feel bad for the many kids who will now have supply teachers (because we can't recruit, especially in my subject) and even more disruption every day. It's the reality of many comprehensive schools these days, though, and I feel awful thinking my own children will still have many years of this left.

Calamitousness · 07/03/2024 05:02

I think teaching is a job which has a lot of negativity and complaining around it because of its very nature. Working with children is always and was always going to be hard. Imagine your work life interactions were mostly with children. Ooft. Yes you have some lovely ones and yes you’ll have some not lovely ones but it only takes one horror to make life unbearable. Unfortunately I don’t think people appreciate that when they choose teaching. I would never want to work with children because I want to have civilised interaction at work with mutual respect. But I do worry some teachers think teaching is going to be something different. There are people out there who are amazing teachers and really can connect and inspire the children and are natural teachers but it’s rare.

Acapulco12 · 07/03/2024 02:01

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 06/03/2024 15:45

That’s a tad victim blamey!
I am sure there is a connection but it probably goes both ways. If op is being called a bitch that suggests there’s a degree of misogyny involved. I can imagine it’s easier to focus on being positive and enthusiastic if you’re the 6 foot male teacher who even the lairy Andrew Tate fan boys naturally treat with respect, than if you’re the small middle aged woman they try it on with, sometimes to the point of violence, because she reminds them of their mums.

This is such a good point. For context, I tried teaching for a bit - I lasted 10 weeks. It was awful. I now work in a different industry.

I feel terrible for everyone involved in the teacher recruitment/retention crisis we’re having. The pupils are suffering, the teachers are suffering and there are no winners.

I won’t pretend that the situation will magically improve with more funding, because that’s not true, as it’s a very complex situation that doesn’t have easy solutions. However, more and regular funding will certainly help to improve the current situation.

coxesorangepippin · 07/03/2024 01:47

The excuses being made on this thread make me realise that a large part of the problem is many parents not having a similar approach and kids not respecting authority

^

This.

Awful combination. Children need authority. They are looking for guidance, not free rein in life.

Zodfa · 07/03/2024 00:23

My impression is that most of the problem (apart from parents) lies with ineffective, cowardly SLTs. Also why are class teachers (in secondary school) having to answer emails from parents? Any parental inquiries should be fielded via SLT (maybe HoY/form tutor) and the pettier type swiftly dismissed with a form reply.

noblegiraffe · 06/03/2024 23:57

I usually blame the government.

twoboyssolucky · 06/03/2024 23:49

Macaroni46 · 06/03/2024 23:35

Curriculum won't allow it. One of the (many) reasons I left. Overcrowded timetable, unrealistic, irrelevant and boring curriculum. No room in the day for extras. No room for autonomy.

This is yet another of the problems with school as it is today. Zero creativity. Just ‘teach to the test’ one-size fits all outdated curriculum. Kids are generally switched off and disengaged in a system that was designed hundreds of years ago for a different age.

Combine this with lack of send support/places, underfunding, burnt out teachers, teachers leaving in droves, draconian rules, locked toilets, crumbling buildings and it’s the perfect storm.

But let’s all carry on in-fighting and getting nowhere. Let’s all carry on blaming each other. Teachers blame kids and parents, parents and kids blame teachers and SLT but nothing changes. I’m getting bored now of saying this on endless school-related threads.

Macaroni46 · 06/03/2024 23:35

Sae3005 · 06/03/2024 20:30

I'm studying children at uni and someone mentioned there's a lack of creativity in the school? So wouldn't children benefit more with more opportunities to learn outside if the classroom? Holidays, school trips etc

Curriculum won't allow it. One of the (many) reasons I left. Overcrowded timetable, unrealistic, irrelevant and boring curriculum. No room in the day for extras. No room for autonomy.

Notmyuser · 06/03/2024 23:30

Tryingmybestadhd · 06/03/2024 23:05

A bit of a generalisation , some teachers have great jobs . Example , my youngest school has classes of 10 to 16 students . I’m sure it’s not that hard . This being said I know it’s not alway the case . But what job is easy anyway ? Look at junior doctors , gaining a pittance working 16 hour shifts . Look at electricity engineers who have to restore life cables during storms , look at nurses working for such low wages .
we are all in the same boat , we just need to fight for better working conditions for everyone

No teacher is saying that other people don’t also have jobs. This post isn’t about junior doctors, or “electricity engineers” or nurses. Feel free to start a post about their conditions too; but this isn’t the place.

Notmyuser · 06/03/2024 23:27

Sae3005 · 06/03/2024 20:30

I'm studying children at uni and someone mentioned there's a lack of creativity in the school? So wouldn't children benefit more with more opportunities to learn outside if the classroom? Holidays, school trips etc

We are banned from trips now. Can’t be asking parents to pay for trips as parents have no money, and schools can’t fund trips because they have no money either.

Kurokurosuke · 06/03/2024 23:14

FunionsRFun · 06/03/2024 15:22

I'm professional enough for them to never know. I know how to turn it on in the classroom and the countless interventions and clubs I run. Unfortunately, I do a lot of crying at home in front of my own children. They are the ones suffering.

Yep. I don’t work in the UK, but I turn it on in the class, but cry faaar to much at home. I hate the impact it is having on my own children.

User7825525 · 06/03/2024 23:12

JMSA · 06/03/2024 22:53

Unfortunately we're paying the price for piss poor parenting.
I sometimes wonder how some of them even got their children through babyhood Sad

The oddest thing is that, going by MN, it seems like everyone are perfect parents who don't allow their children a single minute of screentime, any UPFs, always offer healthy home cooked meals with at least 5 a day and meeting all their emotional needs.

You just need to read the smugness and outrage at threads about late potty training, children's typical diet in a day, screentime or social media guidance. If the vocal majority are parenting so perfectly, how come older kids are so fucked up that schools can no longer function?

GoodnightAdeline · 06/03/2024 23:08

If I said what I truly thought I’d be ripped apart on here and be accused of not caring, being an awful teacher etc etc etc.

I’m very interested to hear it, can you share?

Tryingmybestadhd · 06/03/2024 23:05

A bit of a generalisation , some teachers have great jobs . Example , my youngest school has classes of 10 to 16 students . I’m sure it’s not that hard . This being said I know it’s not alway the case . But what job is easy anyway ? Look at junior doctors , gaining a pittance working 16 hour shifts . Look at electricity engineers who have to restore life cables during storms , look at nurses working for such low wages .
we are all in the same boat , we just need to fight for better working conditions for everyone

ladykale · 06/03/2024 23:03

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 06/03/2024 15:57

The difficulty with raising issues of attitude and conduct of pupils on MN is that crowds of posters will descend to justify the behaviour of children without knowing anything of the circumstances.

I strongly believe that the widespread malaise in the English school system is a function of discipline and behavioural expectation - and the absence of effective sanction - rather than money.

I’m convinced we’d have hundreds of thousands of good, committed teachers and aspiring teachers in all subjects if they weren’t subject to the routine abuse and aggression that’s prevalent in schools.

When I was at school I was so scared of my parents finding out I had misbehaved because they had implemented sufficient boundaries and authority at home. They made it clear misbehaviour at school was completely unacceptable.

The excuses being made on this thread make me realise that a large part of the problem is many parents not having a similar approach and kids not respecting authority.

PurpleClovers · 06/03/2024 23:01

Bushmillsbabe · 06/03/2024 18:49

This. My daughters are in a lovely village school, with smallish classes, great facilities, fantastic teachers. But a child in my oldest class hit her or smashed her head into a table most days of year 2. And the teachers couldn't do anything as the child had SEN, and 'couldn't control her behaviour'. Outside a school this would be assault, and my daughter had to sit in a room every day knowing she would likely be attacked. Imagine the damage that does, the level of fear she was carrying, holding onto.

Until enough was enough, and I removed her and kept her home until this child was moved. But not every parent could do that, i used my annual leave. But teachers are working in a system where they can't do their job for fear of being labelled 'discriminatory'. Where children are being failed by a system where a few disruptive children are allowed to damage the learning of, and hurt the rest of their class, in the name of "inclusion'.

And before anyone comes for me, this is not an attack on the rights of children with SEN. But my daughter also has rights, the right to learn effectively. The right to feel safe in her classroom. The right to not come home bruised and crying. The teachers also have the right to be respected, rather than attacked.

I work in the NHS but the principle is the same. My pay is decent, my workload is ok, my colleagues are great, I love my profession. But the utter contempt with which some patients treat me just destroys you. And it's my family who suffer when I come home sad, angry, frustrates at another day of people treating me like sh*t.

This is another reason I left teaching. If I said what I truly thought I’d be ripped apart on here and be accused of not caring, being an awful teacher etc etc etc.

The full education system is fucked, there’s very little specialist provision for children who have special educational needs, many children do not cope in mainstream and a few parents use school for respite care. Some mainstream schools can’t cope with the complex needs of many children.

Children are entitled to an education and they shouldn’t suffer due to the complex needs of others should they? Children and teachers shouldn’t be attacked in classes. Children should not be scared to go to school. There really needs to be more specialised schools who can effectively support any child who who finds mainstream difficult.

Temuaddiction · 06/03/2024 22:56

Disgusting.
Teachers aren't paid enough.
I think AI will be teaching these brats soon.

JMSA · 06/03/2024 22:53

Unfortunately we're paying the price for piss poor parenting.
I sometimes wonder how some of them even got their children through babyhood Sad

Isitthathardtobekind · 06/03/2024 22:51

Buuty · 06/03/2024 15:47

Plus parents never believe their kid could do any wrong. Years ago the teacher was always believed and if you messed around in class, you knew about it when you got home. Not so much now.

true!

AngelinaFibres · 06/03/2024 22:50

Rainyblue · 06/03/2024 22:39

It’s not just teachers, my school has a high turnover of administration staff. They often get the brunt of the angry parents coming in to school demanding all sorts of things (my child won’t ever be sitting a detention, get me the Head Teacher right now etc), and answer the phone just to get shouted out.
I have had a variety of office jobs but have never been spoken to so rudely as I have answering the phone in a school.

The passive aggressive emails from parents don’t bother me too much. I do wonder though, why don’t they just ask questions normally?

I think there is a general increase in entitled and rude behaviour. I think it reflects society as a whole.

I worked in a school where we would lock ourselves in during the day and once the children had gone home the door was only opened only to let staff out. We were not allowed to be there alone or to walk to the carpark after dark. If the last but 1 person was leaving then you had to leave too. You could not go in at weekends or during the holidays because it wasn't safe. This was a primary school. The female children finished their education at the end of year 6. I was genuinely frightened at times in that school.