Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Personal allowance frozen - yet 2p off National Insurance

115 replies

MikeRafone · 06/03/2024 08:56

AIBU to think that instead of reducing the tax on NI that the personal allowance raising a couple of hundred pounds would be better for less well of families and pensioners?

PA is frozen until 2028 whilst the last budget knocked off 2p on NI and suggested the same will happen today another 2p

whilst income tax will rise for many as NMW rises in April by £1.01

AIBU no PA shouldn't rise and 2p is ok of NI
YANBU PA should rise and leave NI as it is

OP posts:
MikeRafone · 06/03/2024 13:07

And NI is a horribly flawed tax that should have been folded into income tax long ago.Edited

but won't be as its 2% once you reach £50,000 not the 10% rate under £50,000, folding it into income tax would mean a very large jump of 38% for those earning over £50k

OP posts:
SpinyNorma · 06/03/2024 12:52

They feel politically that they have to cut a tax but they can't afford to cut income tax (or at least slow the rate fiscal drag is increasing it) so here we are.

Even if they were forced into it, it's not a terrible outcome. Cutting a tax on work isn't the worst thing to do in a productivity crisis. And NI is a horribly flawed tax that should have been folded into income tax long ago.

sleepyscientist · 06/03/2024 12:17

More money in our pockets to spend is always a good thing as we are choosing what to spend it on not being forced to spend it on public services.

For those on the borders of income tax thresholds it likely won't make much difference to what they pay in tax vs what they put into pensions. So the government gets the headline, helps PAYE, and actually keeps a good proportion of the income as people will hide slightly more in pensions (which is taxed years down the line) vs them hiding raising thresholds so people pay less tax overall

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 12:08

taxguru · 06/03/2024 12:02

Rather than always concentrating on tax and public spending, this NIC cut could actually grow the economy as it's whole purpose is to "make work pay" to encourage currently economically active people to work, and part timers to work more - if that works, it will get the economy moving again rather than the stagnation we've been suffering for years with staff shortages in key areas.

We all know bribing gullible people with a 2p tax cut isn’t going to grow the economy or “make work pay”. If there’s headroom in the Treasury better by half spend it on reducing HS waiting lists to get sick people back to work.

PawsisShady · 06/03/2024 12:03

@taxguru yes I get that. On at least three threads this week I've seen
"Low earners will be topped up anyway"
"There's a massive amount of help and benefits for those with disabilities/health conditions"

Neither of which are true if
You don't have children and you have a mortgage
You don't qualify for PIP because you're too well to get PIP but too sick to work extra hours on top of what you already do

taxguru · 06/03/2024 12:02

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 10:36

As a pensioner I’m happy the NI route has been chosen, hopefully it will avoid a huge increase in pensioner bashing here. The fact is that we can’t afford any tax cuts. Public services are cut to the bone and the country’s on its knees. It’s a blatant bribe to vote Tory, I hope it fails.

Rather than always concentrating on tax and public spending, this NIC cut could actually grow the economy as it's whole purpose is to "make work pay" to encourage currently economically active people to work, and part timers to work more - if that works, it will get the economy moving again rather than the stagnation we've been suffering for years with staff shortages in key areas.

taxguru · 06/03/2024 11:59

PawsisShady · 06/03/2024 10:16

Why is there such a presumption that lower earners get benefits? I'm not the lowest earner out there but I do get min wage so I'm not a high earner in any way
No benefits. I get 25% off my council tax

It's just really fucking irritating because someone now will ask if I have DC, and the people who are single and don't have children are totally forgotten about like we can live off fresh air when we are paying everything alone

If you're on NMW you'll benefit from the NIC reduction as NMW is roughly £20k p.a., so with the threshold at £12.5k, you'll be paying NIC on £7.5k of your wage.

SerendipityJane · 06/03/2024 11:50

this is ever only going to be a budget to try and gain votes for the next election.

An election that the Tories will lose no matter how much of our money they spaff all over the place. That's what makes it so criminal.

MikeRafone · 06/03/2024 11:21

There are ways of doing things so everyone propers not just the high earners - that’s not disdain for high earners

OP posts:
MikeRafone · 06/03/2024 11:20

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/03/2024 10:14

not as much as those on higher incomes

And? God the contempt against higher earners on these threads is getting so tedious.

If you have many people with money to spend the economy will grow, if you have only 1% of workers with money to spend or even 5% the economy will falter

if the economy grows everyone wins

OP posts:
MigGirl · 06/03/2024 11:19

YouveGotAFastCar · 06/03/2024 10:43

We haven't got the money, as a country, to fund a tax cut.

The NI cut is a bit of a gimmick to make it seem that we're doing something, because we do need to do something - but we also can't afford to.

Totally this, this is ever only going to be a budget to try and gain votes for the next election. They don't actually care if they send the country onto more deta they just want to be voted back in.

Unfortunately most of the voting population will fall for it.

SerendipityJane · 06/03/2024 11:06

All chancellors for the next couple of decades will be wearing the handmade shackles the Truss/Kwarteng dream ticket put on the economy. With every passing month (and I've had to hear it at work) people are coming off their fixed rate mortgages and having to find a few extra hundred quid a month.

1dayatatime · 06/03/2024 10:47

@YouveGotAFastCar

"We haven't got the money, as a country, to fund a tax cut. "

+++

Exactly and if somehow we do have the money then I would rather it is used to either reduce the national debt or fund education.

It is insane that we spend more money on just the interest payments on the national debt than we do on education.

YouveGotAFastCar · 06/03/2024 10:43

We haven't got the money, as a country, to fund a tax cut.

The NI cut is a bit of a gimmick to make it seem that we're doing something, because we do need to do something - but we also can't afford to.

Overthebow · 06/03/2024 10:42

LightSwerve · 06/03/2024 10:19

Not threshold changes, that's the point.

A small threshold change won’t help middle earners enough. £10 extra a month won’t go far when nurseries are up £50-£200 a month, mortgages up hundreds too plus no help from benefits for childcare or anything else. Any tax cuts need to be directed to the middle who are just above the benefit thresholds. That’s not me, I’m not advocating all help goes to people in my situation!

Overthebow · 06/03/2024 10:36

MikeRafone · 06/03/2024 09:56

most benefit claimants are workers, in work. Those workers would have their tax burden reduced and also their benefits would reduce leaving them the same money - but the tax payer paying less and the old age state pension will not increase to over £12000

The workers on benefits will get the NI cut and the 6.7% benefit rise.

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 10:36

As a pensioner I’m happy the NI route has been chosen, hopefully it will avoid a huge increase in pensioner bashing here. The fact is that we can’t afford any tax cuts. Public services are cut to the bone and the country’s on its knees. It’s a blatant bribe to vote Tory, I hope it fails.

loudbatperson · 06/03/2024 10:34

My personal opinion is that cutting at this time is the wrong step, but putting that aside.

I think the NI cut is beneficial over the longer term to all earners, be they higher or lower. As wages increase, which happens over time albeit slowly for some, the value of the tax cut increases.

Also the NI change helps those who miss out on other help that have been made available due to recent pressures. Those who receive no state help but are not wealthy. Yes this does includes higher earners however will be felt more by lower earners who do not qualify for benefits.

Those receiving some state income either via pensions or benefits have benefitted from increases in the rates and various cost of living payments and grants, however workers, particularly lower paid ones who receive no state assistance, have had very little bar the limited fuel bill assistance last year.

Personally I would rather not get a tax cut and have more invested into our economy, however I know I am speaking from a place of privilege about being able to afford that.

If there has to be tax cuts I can support this one as it benefits those who need help, but are being missed by current policy.

muddyford · 06/03/2024 10:30

I wrote to my MP about the continued freezing of personal allowances and she didn't even bother to reply. We are stashing away as much as we can in ISAs, rather than spending anything we don't have to. It's not good for the economy not raising the PAs.

Goldenbear · 06/03/2024 10:29

LightSwerve · 06/03/2024 10:16

YANBU, but Hunt is not trying to improve the economic situation of the whole UK, he's trying to alter the opinion polls so he wants a short term gimmick only.

Yes, I mean desperation written all over it. Then again Rishi is very relatable in that like ordinary families, they disagree on how to load a dishwasher and tbf to him I actually thought he would have people to load his dishwasher!

pinkwaterbottle9 · 06/03/2024 10:25

@PawsisShady same situation as you

LightSwerve · 06/03/2024 10:21

MikeRafone · 06/03/2024 10:19

well his last budget took us into a recession - so do more of the same will not be helpful

Not helpful for the UK economy, no, but as I say that's not Hunt's priority.

MikeRafone · 06/03/2024 10:19

LightSwerve · 06/03/2024 10:16

YANBU, but Hunt is not trying to improve the economic situation of the whole UK, he's trying to alter the opinion polls so he wants a short term gimmick only.

well his last budget took us into a recession - so do more of the same will not be helpful

OP posts:
LightSwerve · 06/03/2024 10:19

Calculuses · 06/03/2024 10:13

But that applies to any tax cut

Not threshold changes, that's the point.

LightSwerve · 06/03/2024 10:16

YANBU, but Hunt is not trying to improve the economic situation of the whole UK, he's trying to alter the opinion polls so he wants a short term gimmick only.