Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fleeting comments that still sting years later

708 replies

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 08:29

I was early 30's and single. Dating, but having zero luck and wondering if I'd die alone at the bottom of the stairs with my cat eating my big toe.

I confided in my best friend at the time, I was feeling low about myself and sad. Fed up of the dating world.

She said, her partner had told her that "if I lost a bit of weight I could have anyone I wanted".

Was it a back handed compliment? Meant to hurt me? Meant to make me feel better? Why would she say that? I had no idea.

Years later, it still pops up in my head like that unexpected morning pimple.

I've always carried a few extra pounds, I love my food! But, I was by no means what you'd describe as "big".

Anyway, it stung. A lot. And certainly didn't make me feel better.

It made me wonder if anyone else had a carefree passing comment, that probably meant nothing to the person who said it, yet hit you to the core and stayed with you years later?

OP posts:
morningsnig · 06/03/2024 22:23

My cousin can draw and his Christmas he was drawing caricatures of us. When it came to me he said "I can't do morning as she's too plain". He wasn't wrong tbf

gluenotsoup · 06/03/2024 22:23

Loads.
Family visiting from abroad commented on my sister looking lovely and slim, my mum piped up “Yeah, Glue’s little and dumpy like me..”
My chief bridesmaid: “are you sure you want me to be your bridesmaid, I’m taller and blonder than you.”
On holiday in a tankini after three babies and expressing my lack of body confidence- “ Well, you’re not the worst…”
After dc was born very ill with a rare genetic condition- “ it’s because you and dh are incompatible “.
I’d been having my hair cut at a trendy and expensive salon. I was exhausted after having dd, she was extremely ill, I was out of my mind with worry, and it was my treat to myself. There was a photographer doing a promotional article and the owner was looking around for prime candidates, and his eyes landed on wet haired, sad and shattered me and he made a noise of contempt and disgust and huffed a bit as he flapped me away as too unattractive. It was the straw that broke me and I never went back.

localnotail · 06/03/2024 22:16

OP, I don't think you friend meant anything else apart from what she meant...

I hope I'm not going to get slaughtered for this, please note this is my personal opinion only! So here it goes:

I'm not massively overweight myself but I know I would look much more attractive if I lose that extra 10-12 pounds... I know I will look good because I only put on weight recently, because of peri/ stress/ etc and I was thinner and better looking before. The thing is, I don't really care what I look like as dating is not on my list at all and I'm very happy and content the way I am, I might try to get fitter and more active but my looks are fine to me whatever. But, IF I wanted to date, I would probably try to lose weight to increase my chances. That's how life is I'm afraid! You might meet someone who would love you for you, but this definitely is not going to happen on OLD.

coofffeee · 06/03/2024 22:15

I told someone they were a big mouth once, they were very chatty but lovely and they were really hurt, I was mortified, I hadn't said it with any ill intent I'd been thoughtless really. I said it because I was worried she would tell this guy I fancied that I fancied him. I was way too shy to say anything myself and he was very shy also.

Well she did tell him and and she gave him my phone number which he used to call to ask me out and that guy is now my husband of 25 years and we've been so happy together. If she hadn't told him then I'd probably never have seen him again.

I still feel awful every time I think of it but I am so grateful to her and I hope where ever she is her life is lovely and she never gives what I said a second thought.

Happilyobtuse · 06/03/2024 22:12

ChishiyaBat · 06/03/2024 22:01

They are still attractive when they are overweight though, it's people's perceptions that make them think they look better when they lose weight. I also have personal experience, I know what you are saying, but I have a picture on my bedroom windowsill of me when I was a size 8, i'm now a size 12-14, in between those 2 points I was a size 22-24, but my face is still the same. I mean i'm not pretty so it doesn't affect me really, but I still look the same facially no matter my weight.

Ah I guess you are one of the lucky ones whose face is not affected by weight gain. I am definitely not one of those lucky people. I go from super attractive/ pretty to fat faced. I tend to gain weight on my face first. But similarly when I lose weight my facial features are really enhanced. So losing weight definitely makes me more attractive.

justintimberlakerivertears · 06/03/2024 22:11

When I was 5 my dad pointed at a deep scar on my leg which should have had stitches but my parents had ignored it, so it had closed up in quite an unsightly way after an infection and no treatment, he and told me that he hoped I knew that I could never be a model because of that

Aurora93 · 06/03/2024 22:10

I can remember wearing one of my older sisters t-shirts as a teen and my dad saying ‘you’re going to stretch that out’.

A boyfriend I had just started dating left his phone open on messages to his best friend and was telling him he had started seeing someone, the friend asked ‘is she good looking?’ And he replied ‘she’s alright’.

Someone aimed a status at me on social media and posted a photo of an unattractive celebrity straight afterwards, I’m guessing trying to say I looked like them. I still think about it randomly if I hear the celebrity’s name.

thankyoujeremy · 06/03/2024 22:07

Ah so many over the years...
One choice one though was when I worked in a rural-ish pub in my early 20's. The car park was often dark and empty at the end of the shift and I would ask for someone to watch out the door to check I got to my car okay. The landlord said, and I repeat "what have got you got to worry about? I'd understand it if you looked like x" (the barmaid I was working with at the time).

Nice 🙄

He was no oil-painting himself...

Calliopespa · 06/03/2024 22:03

All2Well · 06/03/2024 21:57

I totally agree with you.

I am currently clinically obese (and,
to pick up on a pp, a size 12...it is possible to be a size 12 and obese, and imo it's right of HCPs to make patients aware as obesity is associated with negative outcomes, they are doing their job). I am not currently "pretty"...maybe "plump but with a kindly face" but definitely not pretty - obesity has definitely made me look facially less attractive. Before I gained weight, I was definitely more facially attractive. In a totally different league to now. It's the weight gain, nothing else, that's affected my face. I literally look like a different person.

If someone said to me "you'd be pretty if you lost weight" it would sting. But most likely because there is an element of truth in it for me. I didn't realise it at the time, but I was pretty before I gained weight. So they'd be right.

That's not to say you can't be pretty and overweight...some people can pull of both overweight and slim and be pretty both ways. But it's definitely not everyone and it's certainly not me.

Actually I think quite a lot of people look nicer heavier. I’m not a great fan of the lean, mean, gaunt and wrinkly look some middle aged women go for. They often look so pleased about their waist, with their jeans right up round it and all belted in tight and it makes me think of that comment about having to choose which you care about more: your bum or your face. Or the “ she’s pretty from behind” quip. I wouldn’t be so mean if I thought they were self conscious about their haggard face, except they always look so smug in the way they have dressed. I guess the bottom line is none of us are perfect.

Whatthechicken · 06/03/2024 22:01

Beansandneedles · 06/03/2024 21:42

It is. I'm so sorry you're dealing with it. The degree thing is crazy. It makes me feel sad for them on many levels. There's some extremely poor self esteem going on there.

My mum still refers to "our gcse's" as she helped me study. I'm 37 tomorrow. I wouldn't think about gcse's at all if she wasn't bringing them up. Mental! But I'm trying to be kind whilst maintaining boundaries and self respect for myself and the children. She's the product of her upbringing and education. Mostly I think she can't help it. Doesn't affect me the way it used to since I've had therapy. Water off a ducks back mostly now. Been interesting to watch her adapt since her comments no longer provoke the reactions she's used to.

Yes it is very interesting when what they say can't provoke anymore. I got to a point where I just thought 'no, no more now, you are not in control of me anymore', and I told her that. Yep, my mum would have you believe that she supported me through all of my studies...the truth is she wasn't really interested, and when I got a letter from the headmaster congratulating me on my GCSE results, she wrote on it telling my brother to take the dog for a walk...I still have the letter. She also let my brothers believe that she financially supported me through Uni, which one of my brothers told me about a year ago (he had been very bitter about it). Truth is, she didn't pay a penny, I paid for everything.

The thing is she knows that if she falls out with me, she has no one to turn to on a day-to day basis, because my brothers aren't there for her - and they somehow don't have this people pleasing infliction. She comes to me for all of the holidays, xmas, easter, mothers day, birthdays...all of them, my brothers don't even check if she has somewhere to go. but if I pull her up on the way she behaves, she says 'Will you stop me seeing the kids?' and I reply: "of course not, they love you, that sounds quite manipulative mum, why would you think I would do that". Then we get the tears and she says: "I'm not manipulative".

I don't want o be in conflict with her, I want to move forward, she just can't seem help herself.

ChishiyaBat · 06/03/2024 22:01

Happilyobtuse · 06/03/2024 21:46

People are nasty and making mean comments are totally unnecessary.

But if you look at people who are obese and then they lose weight, there are literally 1000’s of videos on social media, nearly all of them go from very ordinary to super attractive,beautiful, pretty etc.

I have this experience personally also, when I am thin I am very attractive ( have been a model) , when I gain weight I just look fat faced with a double chin. It is super hard to keep the weight off as I love eating but I am finally seeing some success with combo workouts with weights.

They are still attractive when they are overweight though, it's people's perceptions that make them think they look better when they lose weight. I also have personal experience, I know what you are saying, but I have a picture on my bedroom windowsill of me when I was a size 8, i'm now a size 12-14, in between those 2 points I was a size 22-24, but my face is still the same. I mean i'm not pretty so it doesn't affect me really, but I still look the same facially no matter my weight.

Calliopespa · 06/03/2024 21:57

SwoopingIsBad · 06/03/2024 18:28

When I was 19, I was seeing a boy who was at university in my city. He was from down south. He was a student and I was trying to do my A levels and working 2 jobs because my parents weren't working.

I drove him home for Easter and met his dm. She immediately called my accent common. She asked why I was still doing A levels. Had I failed them? When I explained that I dropped out because I had to work full time to help out at home, she said she had heard that our area was quite impoverished and said it must be hard being poor.

When I was leaving, she told me quietly to "get back to my council house and stay there".

I cried all the way home. The relationship ended a few months later and I had a huge chip on my shoulder about my background for years afterwards.

😳

All2Well · 06/03/2024 21:57

Happilyobtuse · 06/03/2024 21:46

People are nasty and making mean comments are totally unnecessary.

But if you look at people who are obese and then they lose weight, there are literally 1000’s of videos on social media, nearly all of them go from very ordinary to super attractive,beautiful, pretty etc.

I have this experience personally also, when I am thin I am very attractive ( have been a model) , when I gain weight I just look fat faced with a double chin. It is super hard to keep the weight off as I love eating but I am finally seeing some success with combo workouts with weights.

I totally agree with you.

I am currently clinically obese (and,
to pick up on a pp, a size 12...it is possible to be a size 12 and obese, and imo it's right of HCPs to make patients aware as obesity is associated with negative outcomes, they are doing their job). I am not currently "pretty"...maybe "plump but with a kindly face" but definitely not pretty - obesity has definitely made me look facially less attractive. Before I gained weight, I was definitely more facially attractive. In a totally different league to now. It's the weight gain, nothing else, that's affected my face. I literally look like a different person.

If someone said to me "you'd be pretty if you lost weight" it would sting. But most likely because there is an element of truth in it for me. I didn't realise it at the time, but I was pretty before I gained weight. So they'd be right.

That's not to say you can't be pretty and overweight...some people can pull of both overweight and slim and be pretty both ways. But it's definitely not everyone and it's certainly not me.

HaggisHhahaha · 06/03/2024 21:56

Randomly on a post school summer holiday with friends in magaluf 1994 with a guy who kept flirting with me who after a few days said if you lost some weight you would be gorgeous…

we were both 18 (so where had he for this world view from?)
5’7 and I remember I was 60kg as I was thinking about joining the armed forces and needed to know my weight

my weight had never been mentioned to me before or the way I looked and it was such a shock

luckly I didn’t give a shit about the thoughts of some nobber as I was very secure in who I was/am

Sam0207 · 06/03/2024 21:49

One that gets me (and still hurts 40 years later)....

Year 7 (or First year of secondary as it was then) French trip. Mum had scrimped and saved for it.

Lunchtime - group of girls, we were all discussing who to put down on our "3 preferred roomates" options list in order to manipulate the teachers into putting us together (as you do when you're 12).
After school, I go past the French teachers room to collect something and hear the whole gang of girls asking said French teacher not to put me with them because "She's weird". I ended up in the only twin room with the girl that picked her nose and ate her bogies while the rest had a jolly time in the 8 bed dorm rooms.

Never forgot it, damaged my self esteem for YEARS.

I could still cry for 12 year old me.

Orlandobaby · 06/03/2024 21:46

My grandmother told me when I was 18: “I hate you and everything you stand for”. Made for a tricky Christmas lunch. Then six months after I got married, her daughter (my aunt) congratulated me on losing so much weight since my wedding day. Family relations have never been great 😀

Whatayear2023 · 06/03/2024 21:46

Just to add I was sacked as I didn't return after lunch and wasn't on the sick... it still haunts me now and I wear baggy clothes no make up havent had hair cut at hairdressers in 8 years and this happened 20 years ago

Happilyobtuse · 06/03/2024 21:46

ChishiyaBat · 06/03/2024 21:18

All these weight related posts make me so angry, i've been fat as fuck for most of my life despite my best efforts, I have a good diet and I exercise, plus my job is physical, so i'm pretty fit, but still fat. I've had all the comments shouted in the street, oinked at, you name the insult i've probably had it.
The thing that annoys me the most are the people who say you'd be pretty if you weren't fat. No that isn't how it works, you are pretty or you aren't, if they were saying oh you are pretty, but i'm not attracted to overweight people then fair enough, but to say someone isn't pretty because they overweight is bollocks.

People are nasty and making mean comments are totally unnecessary.

But if you look at people who are obese and then they lose weight, there are literally 1000’s of videos on social media, nearly all of them go from very ordinary to super attractive,beautiful, pretty etc.

I have this experience personally also, when I am thin I am very attractive ( have been a model) , when I gain weight I just look fat faced with a double chin. It is super hard to keep the weight off as I love eating but I am finally seeing some success with combo workouts with weights.

Changingnameagain · 06/03/2024 21:45

When my first proper boyfriend broke up with me I was 18. I was in bits- first heartbreak and all that- and my mum said: well you have put on some weight.
This was true- I had gained maybe 1-1.5 stone during the relationship but I was no bigger than a12-14 at 5'10. Anyway, 20 years later I still remember those words and they still make me feel ashamed and upset and angry at her.

waitingforautumn · 06/03/2024 21:45

JamesPringle · 06/03/2024 08:39

Dad, when I was about 14, told me I was "very overweight." I was 5"11 and a size 12. He seemed angry and disappointed with me.
This and other comments/putdowns has led to a lifetime of disordered eating. Same for my siblings. He was equally disappointed and pissed off when I lost the weight.

Similar here. I've had my fair share of stings from friends, acquaintances etc but the dad ones have hurt the most!

Whatayear2023 · 06/03/2024 21:44

Like another poster I was spoken to by a manager at a top car insurance company only 19 at time I was told that there was numerous complaints about me by females due to my looks and clothing. That many are couples in the office and the way I look and dress is causing friction between many couples. She gave me an official warning and called the recruitment agency to complain. I left at lunch and cried my heart out never went back and spent around 3 months home sick with anxiety over what I looked like and people talking about me

Calliopespa · 06/03/2024 21:43

CaramelMac · 06/03/2024 21:25

Said to me by a shop assistant “do you find it hard to get shoes for your massive feet?” My feet are size 7, I’m 5’10” so I’m well aware I’m much bigger than most other women, but it’s never nice to have it pointed out to you.

Next time: “ and do you find it hard to keep friends with your massive mouth?”

Beansandneedles · 06/03/2024 21:42

Whatthechicken · 06/03/2024 21:16

I know! I just can't fathom it. My kids are adopted, so I have to be incredibly honest with them - about everything. It took me years to get my daughter to trust me to take care of her (I was another mum figure at first, mum had let her down, so why should she trust me). My mum knows how hard we have had to work, and yet sometimes, my mum, seems too go out of her way to undermine me and get my daughter to question me...but she will say she was joking, she didn't think. It's like she's in some weird competition with me that I want no part of. When I got my degree, first in the family - she had to get a diploma...If I mention the way I do things in my own home - I'm having a go at her, 'bullying' her...It's just exhausting.

It is. I'm so sorry you're dealing with it. The degree thing is crazy. It makes me feel sad for them on many levels. There's some extremely poor self esteem going on there.

My mum still refers to "our gcse's" as she helped me study. I'm 37 tomorrow. I wouldn't think about gcse's at all if she wasn't bringing them up. Mental! But I'm trying to be kind whilst maintaining boundaries and self respect for myself and the children. She's the product of her upbringing and education. Mostly I think she can't help it. Doesn't affect me the way it used to since I've had therapy. Water off a ducks back mostly now. Been interesting to watch her adapt since her comments no longer provoke the reactions she's used to.

Calliopespa · 06/03/2024 21:41

Neverletgosince · 06/03/2024 19:59

I have two that have had lasting impressions on my sex life and both happened about 25 years ago when I was at uni. I think 1998. I think it is relevant to say that I was quite sheltered when I was young, strict Catholic family and I’m not a rebel.

One, a male friend and I were discussing oral sex (I’d never done it although that wasn’t actually part of the conversation) and he said how much he liked it “but she’s got to be clean. It’s gross if she’s not clean”. Since then I’ve always been paranoid and never really felt comfortable receiving or liked giving.

I had a crush on a regular customer at a bar I worked at. One night he came round with a group of friends and all got rather drunk. we ended up making out in my room. I was totally into it when all of a sudden, he stopped and said “oh, you’ve pissed on me”. I said “no I haven’t” and he replied “you did. Feel my back, it’s soaking”. It just felt sweaty, the bed wasn’t wet or anything. He didn’t seem totally horrified but the mood was ruined so we stopped and he left. To this day, I have never fully let myself go in bed again because, despite the bed not being noticeably wet, I’m not confident that i didn’t thus I won’t pee when I’m totally letting go. He probably doesn’t even remember me. The impact that comment has had on my sex life to this day has been really sad. I feel for my husband of 20 years but I just can’t fully immerse myself because of that comment.

Silly thing is he probably only said it cos he had an insecurity about how sweaty he was getting !

MaMisled · 06/03/2024 21:40

I was told I was "great fun but certainly not marriage material!"