Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fleeting comments that still sting years later

708 replies

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 08:29

I was early 30's and single. Dating, but having zero luck and wondering if I'd die alone at the bottom of the stairs with my cat eating my big toe.

I confided in my best friend at the time, I was feeling low about myself and sad. Fed up of the dating world.

She said, her partner had told her that "if I lost a bit of weight I could have anyone I wanted".

Was it a back handed compliment? Meant to hurt me? Meant to make me feel better? Why would she say that? I had no idea.

Years later, it still pops up in my head like that unexpected morning pimple.

I've always carried a few extra pounds, I love my food! But, I was by no means what you'd describe as "big".

Anyway, it stung. A lot. And certainly didn't make me feel better.

It made me wonder if anyone else had a carefree passing comment, that probably meant nothing to the person who said it, yet hit you to the core and stayed with you years later?

OP posts:
EnglishHamlet · 06/03/2024 23:23

Oh God, so many.
Being 16, feeling really self conscious about having an outbreak of pimples on my face. Walking out of the door of a chain store, to 3 boys a couple of years older, all eyeing me up and down, when 1 of them said "She'd be alright and I'd shag her if it wasn't for that fucking ugly acne!" Then all 3 of them creased over with loud laughter whilst pointing at me as they walked past. I felt ugly from that day on.
Being 11 and my dad marching me in to a chemist to order me to be weighed on the chemist scales. When he saw the weight, he exclaimed loudly "Well if you're that heavy now, after losing weight from having your brace fitted and not being able to eat, God knows what you bloody weighed before!" I died in front of all the other customers. He then walked behind me down the street. I dared to turn and look at him, only to see him looking at me in absolute disgust. Cue a lifetime of disordered eating. I've seen photos of myself at age 11 and I just look a normal size/weight.
Being 18 and my boyfriend's older sister getting married. His mum showing me the dress and saying "In a few years when you marry my boy, you can wear this dress but I'll have to let the seams out and add extra panels in because you're very big, dear". I was a size 10 - 12 at 5ft 8. His sister was a size 6 - 8 at 5 ft. I shrank inside when she said this. I cried afterwards as I felt demeaned. Boyfriend went and told his mum she'd upset me. She came to me and said "Now why are you crying about being so big, you silly thing."
Being 28 and showing a different, later boyfriend a photo of me on my friend's hen do, him laughing out loud and saying "You look like a hippo dropped down to earth from outer space!". I mean, I was wearing size 12 trousers!! I wasn't a hippo! And even if I was, who says that in response to being shown a happy photo from a fun night out? I felt really self conscious about my body after that.
Being 8 and my nan telling her milkman I wanted to be a ballet dancer when I grew up, whilst I stood proudly beside her in my tutu and ballet shoes after having just finished my lesson. Him looking at me and saying "Naaah, they'd never have her, she'll go no-where" dead seriously. And my nan didn't say anything to him! I gave up ballet soon after that.
Being 45 at a summer works party, and having an older male colleague stare blankly at me whilst I was explaining something to him, only for him to reply "Why.........do........you.........talk........sooooo.........slooooooowlyyyyy......." Then walking off leaving our conversation unfinished. I didn't tell him it's because I have dyslexia and sometimes have to fight really hard mentally to find the words I'm searching for in my brain due to dyslexia causing a processing delay and sometimes that means I pause slightly in between sentences. I'd always thought I'd masked it quite well up until he said that to me. I didn't speak to anyone at the party after that, and left early.
I mean, I have dozens more to tell.......
A lifetime of receiving insensitive comments!

UnbelievablySelfish · 06/03/2024 23:21

When I say “they are glad it’s not them” I mean being targeted.

UnbelievablySelfish · 06/03/2024 23:20

@Sam0207 Oh Sam, I could cry for you too. My DD is going through similar. My heart breaks for her.
It’s my belief that it only takes one very strong but very dark personality to influence a whole group. The others just want to keep in with the Leader and are scared of her. They’re glad it’s not them.
I’m sure they didn’t all dislike you.

I do feel sorry for nose-picker too. Would she have been on her own if you hadn’t been made to share?
<over invested>

trytopullyoursocksup · 06/03/2024 23:12

When I was about 12, I used to go to a dance class. There was another girl my age there and she was prettier than me and very very slim - skinny really, like a lot of girls were in the early 80s but is more unusual now. I was stocky, I wouldn't look at all out of place in a year 7 class now but back then I was conscious that I was heavier than a lot of girls. I wasn't tall; I had a tiny waist and visible ribs (believe me I knew exactly what my body looked like) but a big bum and thick legs. I always tried to hide my body as much as possible and tried to distract attention by having pretty hair or whatever else I could do.

The dance teacher's friend was trying to sell her (horrible) handmade clothes for children and asked the teacher for models. Without asking me, the teacher told her friend that she could "have" me, and the other girl, J. I was horrified - no way was I prepared to get up and parade in lumpy handmade clothes that would make me look even worse than I always did anyway. I was trying to compose some polite excuse in my head and while I was standing there silently the teacher confirmed it - "That works, doesn't it? J to be the pretty one, Try to be the dumpy one".

TheMessiahIsMySister · 06/03/2024 23:12

ChishiyaBat · 06/03/2024 23:04

No you don't have to convince me of anything. I am simply just giving my opinion. Of course losing weight makes a difference to people, but it's perception rather than reality is my point. Most people feel better when they lose weight so they think they look better and will usually have more confidence. Plus people just love to comment even if someone has put on a very small amount of weight, even if you aren't overweight people still call people fat and that shapes how people think and see themselves and others. It makes no difference to me because I am not pretty/attractive/good looking or whatever, so I don't have to worry, but I do understand how people will feel more beautiful if they lose weight because of how orhers treat them.

Those of us impacted by this are not talking about feelings and perception, or being socially conditioned to see slim as more attractive.

Those things are true enough, but I look like CZJ when the weight is off, and like a jowly, hamster-cheeked frump when I’m carrying extra weight. I can see it in the mirror and in photos.

It’s no biggie - because I know I’m attractive when my face is slim, so I don’t lose sleep over it when it isn’t. It’s not perception, or all in my mind. It’s reality!

FYI - I *don’t have great facial bone structure - no cheek bones!

What I do have, is a perfectly oval face, large brown eyes and a small nose. Great slim - not when the heavy cheeks are dragging everything down! Grin

Marellaspirit · 06/03/2024 23:09

A few years ago I needed a haircut and my usual hairdresser was on maternity leave so my mum suggested I go to the one she used.

I hate having my hair cut and don't really like being in the salon, looking in the mirror while making small talk. My usual hairdresser was mobile so came to my house and I'd known her for years so felt very comfortable with her. She had trained and worked for several years with a well known national chain and won several awards for her work.

New hairdresser dismissively pulled at my hair, curled her nose up and absolutely slated the style (basically a layered, shoulder length bob) telling me it was awful, and said it was like I had two hairstyles on my head while laughing and pointing it out to her colleagues. I was mortified, I wanted the ground to open up and swallow me whole!

Boomboxio · 06/03/2024 23:08

A relative commented on my big hips at around 11 years old

Around the same time a boy at school that I fancied told me I was a weird shape.

Some others commented on my shape and weight too, one saying I was getting chunky.

Looking back at photos of the time I had an amazing figure, like hourglass, I was a size 8.

These comments and some others set me off on an over-two decade battle with anorexia. I was hospitalised at one point and almost died.

I've been recovered a good while now and it makes me so angry and sad that some stupid comments caused me to damage myself so much.

And...

I've recently been told I have nothing going for me 🙃 but I'm past the point of caring what others think of me now.

ChishiyaBat · 06/03/2024 23:04

TheMessiahIsMySister · 06/03/2024 22:53

With all due respect (genuinely!), we don’t need to convince you of anything.

We all know our own reality. Weight on / weight off makes a big difference for some people.

No you don't have to convince me of anything. I am simply just giving my opinion. Of course losing weight makes a difference to people, but it's perception rather than reality is my point. Most people feel better when they lose weight so they think they look better and will usually have more confidence. Plus people just love to comment even if someone has put on a very small amount of weight, even if you aren't overweight people still call people fat and that shapes how people think and see themselves and others. It makes no difference to me because I am not pretty/attractive/good looking or whatever, so I don't have to worry, but I do understand how people will feel more beautiful if they lose weight because of how orhers treat them.

All2Well · 06/03/2024 23:03

TheMessiahIsMySister · 06/03/2024 22:53

With all due respect (genuinely!), we don’t need to convince you of anything.

We all know our own reality. Weight on / weight off makes a big difference for some people.

THIS!

StringTheory1 · 06/03/2024 23:01

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 22:48

Oh my life, this is just utterly awful.
I can feel your pain with this.
I hope you realise that we all have wobbly bits and that a decent loving person sees beyond this into our soul. He was no man. A weak pathetic pile of nastiness that you are well rid of! 💞

That’s so kind. Thank you. It was 20yrs ago now. We went on to marry, have two lovely kids, and divorce amicably. We barely had sex thoigh, as I knew I wasn’t attractive to him.
I’m fat these days, but have ten times more sex! 😆

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 22:53

localnotail · 06/03/2024 22:16

OP, I don't think you friend meant anything else apart from what she meant...

I hope I'm not going to get slaughtered for this, please note this is my personal opinion only! So here it goes:

I'm not massively overweight myself but I know I would look much more attractive if I lose that extra 10-12 pounds... I know I will look good because I only put on weight recently, because of peri/ stress/ etc and I was thinner and better looking before. The thing is, I don't really care what I look like as dating is not on my list at all and I'm very happy and content the way I am, I might try to get fitter and more active but my looks are fine to me whatever. But, IF I wanted to date, I would probably try to lose weight to increase my chances. That's how life is I'm afraid! You might meet someone who would love you for you, but this definitely is not going to happen on OLD.

Edited

I'm thankfully now married to a lovely man, who sees beyond a few wobbly bits and loves me for who I am. Thank God I didn't end up with the type of man who is obsessed with what I look like. Looks fade. We all get older. Most will gain weight. We are best friends and together for life, regardless of wrinkles and rolls.

OP posts:
TheMessiahIsMySister · 06/03/2024 22:53

ChishiyaBat · 06/03/2024 22:50

I do have good bone structure, but nothing will convince me that you are not pretty if you are fat, but magically are when you are thin.

With all due respect (genuinely!), we don’t need to convince you of anything.

We all know our own reality. Weight on / weight off makes a big difference for some people.

ChishiyaBat · 06/03/2024 22:50

Happilyobtuse · 06/03/2024 22:12

Ah I guess you are one of the lucky ones whose face is not affected by weight gain. I am definitely not one of those lucky people. I go from super attractive/ pretty to fat faced. I tend to gain weight on my face first. But similarly when I lose weight my facial features are really enhanced. So losing weight definitely makes me more attractive.

I do have good bone structure, but nothing will convince me that you are not pretty if you are fat, but magically are when you are thin.

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 22:48

StringTheory1 · 06/03/2024 22:41

Ex-H: “I’m afraid I can’t have sex with you these days because your tummy overhangs a little and I don’t like that in women, Im sorry”.

(In hindsight I was 25, slim, tall, fit & healthy). But I believed him, and was so miserable, lonely and appalled at myself that I attempted suicide.

Oh my life, this is just utterly awful.
I can feel your pain with this.
I hope you realise that we all have wobbly bits and that a decent loving person sees beyond this into our soul. He was no man. A weak pathetic pile of nastiness that you are well rid of! 💞

OP posts:
TheMessiahIsMySister · 06/03/2024 22:46

God this thread is so depressing. So many awful comments, that would be forgotten by the perpetrator seconds after they left their mouth, but will stay with the recipient forever and affect them in all sorts of way.

I agree that the comment almost always says more about the person saying it.

Whether it’s because they’re a loser incel-type man with their own deep insecurities lashing out at the world, other women/bosses/feiends/family members projecting their own insecurities, or seriously dysfunctional parents - again dealing with their own unresolved issues and insecurities.

In response to the OP, I am another one whose weight goes straight to their face. I look great when slim (being honest on an anonymous forum, although as a middle-aged 50YO, I am obviously invisible now!), but the minute I put on any weight, I look frumpy because it’s gone straight to my face.

I have had that thought - she’d be so gorgeous if she lost a bit of weight - (very much internally and never expressed!) about people. It’s totally my own issue though - I’m thinking about myself and projecting.

Any comment that is a judgement is always about the person expressing it. And again, happy / content people don’t say mean things to others. They don’t deliberately hurt people. So although they may pass-remark and instantly forget it, they’re also going through life with a bit of a black hole inside, so it can’t be much fun being them.

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 22:45

SheerLucks · 06/03/2024 20:47

She said her partner had told* her that "if I lost a bit of weight I could have anyone I wanted". *

Maybe I'm a glass half full person, but I would have definitely jumped on the good bits from this!

So he was basically saying that you were attractive enough to attract anyone if you just lost a bit of weight.

I would have actually said that was a massive backhanded compliment!

Of course, but as humans, generally the default position is to straight to the negative. All my ears heard were 'she's fat'. I was feeling low, so this just made me think my disastrous dating life was all down to me being overweight.
Luckily, I'm happily married now to the loveliest man in the world who always raises me up 🥰

OP posts:
StringTheory1 · 06/03/2024 22:41

Ex-H: “I’m afraid I can’t have sex with you these days because your tummy overhangs a little and I don’t like that in women, Im sorry”.

(In hindsight I was 25, slim, tall, fit & healthy). But I believed him, and was so miserable, lonely and appalled at myself that I attempted suicide.

PurpleRobe · 06/03/2024 22:35

I was 10 years old when my dad died and my BIL (aged about 28 at the time) said at the wake:

"stop crying, you look ugly when you cry"

I've never told my sister what he said

morningsnig · 06/03/2024 22:31

It was more a projection of his own thoughts on himself

This is a good takeaway

Ramalangadingdong · 06/03/2024 22:30

Happilyobtuse · 06/03/2024 21:46

People are nasty and making mean comments are totally unnecessary.

But if you look at people who are obese and then they lose weight, there are literally 1000’s of videos on social media, nearly all of them go from very ordinary to super attractive,beautiful, pretty etc.

I have this experience personally also, when I am thin I am very attractive ( have been a model) , when I gain weight I just look fat faced with a double chin. It is super hard to keep the weight off as I love eating but I am finally seeing some success with combo workouts with weights.

Some people are very attractive fat or thin. I am one of those people who just looks very different when fat. I look far better when I am slim.

Herethere123 · 06/03/2024 22:30

'Your breasts are your only redeeming feature.'

I've breastfed two babies since then so they certainly aren't anymore.

Remembered this periodically over 25 years in a 'what a twat' sort of way. But sometimes now, when it's a low ebb day, I look in the mirror and this memory stings.

TravellingSpoon · 06/03/2024 22:30

Ex-MIL told me that I was very lucky to have DS, who have severe autism and learning disabilities, as he would never leave me like her son had done (by moving out to Uni).

I am very lucky to have my DS, he is brilliant. But I would give everything I ever had for life to be easier for him.

ilovesushi · 06/03/2024 22:29

Pookerrod · 06/03/2024 16:58

My DM one Christmas Day evening.

I was 6 weeks postpartum, had PND, and had an over-tired, hyper 2 year old having tantrums at the drop of a hat.

I had spent all day trying to “act normal”, juggle kids, presents, Christmas lunch and host my parents. It was all too much so I took myself off to my room for half an hour after I’d put the kids down for a little cry and lay down.

Anyway, DM marches into my room and hisses at me that “no wonder my children are a nightmare with a miserable mother like me” and walks out again.

My relationship with my DM has never recovered from that little comment she made and it comes back to me every time my kids play up, even now that they are teens.

That is awful. My DM has come out with similar comments in the past usually when I was really struggling. We live close to each other now and see quite a lot of each other but I always hold her a little bit at arm's length emotionally. Not sure if it is me who is poor at forgiveness or it is a bit of self preservation. I don't think she has any idea I feel that way.

Xmasdaft2023 · 06/03/2024 22:27

There’s two that spring to mind..

  1. place I’d worked from 16-19 - boss told me on a Xmas night out “you’re problem is you never know when to just say nothing” HOWEVER it wasn’t the comment that stung because I knew it was true, it was the person saying it that annoyed me! She should’ve known better and said nothing on a night out fuelled by alcohol.

  2. an uncle “you need to put on weight, are you sure you have no disorder, it’s not normal to be that skinny”… I’m still the same size 20+ yrs later. Problem with the comment is - he had zero idea if I was or not, if I had been then it would never have helped and though I didn’t/don’t it could’ve easily sent me in a spiral!

pleased to say I’m zero contact with either person, I still say what I think and I’m still lucky enough to be skinny 😉 unfortunate really that both comments have stuck around!

BoogalooBoo · 06/03/2024 22:24

In my late 20s I went from a size 10 to a size 12. Out for coffee with my dad he asked how I was, I said that I should probably make time to exercise a bit more and he said, 'yeah you can see all the weight on your face'. I had honestly never thought about weight on my face?!

Another was at school aged 14, I put my hair in a ponytail and someone - I can't even remember who - said 'oh coz your hairs greasy?' I've religiously washed my hair every 2 days ever since and I'm nearly 40!

Swipe left for the next trending thread