Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fleeting comments that still sting years later

708 replies

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 08:29

I was early 30's and single. Dating, but having zero luck and wondering if I'd die alone at the bottom of the stairs with my cat eating my big toe.

I confided in my best friend at the time, I was feeling low about myself and sad. Fed up of the dating world.

She said, her partner had told her that "if I lost a bit of weight I could have anyone I wanted".

Was it a back handed compliment? Meant to hurt me? Meant to make me feel better? Why would she say that? I had no idea.

Years later, it still pops up in my head like that unexpected morning pimple.

I've always carried a few extra pounds, I love my food! But, I was by no means what you'd describe as "big".

Anyway, it stung. A lot. And certainly didn't make me feel better.

It made me wonder if anyone else had a carefree passing comment, that probably meant nothing to the person who said it, yet hit you to the core and stayed with you years later?

OP posts:
DreamTheMoors · 07/03/2024 02:59

My mum was beautiful. Startlingly beautiful.
When she was 12, they added captions underneath all the photos in the yearbook. Under Mum’s, they wrote, “pleasingly plump.”
At 95, she was still affected by that, still telling me how offended she was by those two words. How they all thought she was “fat.”
She died a year later.
I honestly don’t think they wrote it out of malice, but it followed her her entire life.

Sam0207 · 07/03/2024 02:45

UnbelievablySelfish · 06/03/2024 23:20

@Sam0207 Oh Sam, I could cry for you too. My DD is going through similar. My heart breaks for her.
It’s my belief that it only takes one very strong but very dark personality to influence a whole group. The others just want to keep in with the Leader and are scared of her. They’re glad it’s not them.
I’m sure they didn’t all dislike you.

I do feel sorry for nose-picker too. Would she have been on her own if you hadn’t been made to share?
<over invested>

They all pretty much didn't like me. I was the weird kid with divorced parents, shite clothes and who had no clue how to integrate socially. I thought they were my friends, but they really weren't. Found my tribe (for a while) outside of school.

It left me with decades long anxiety around "fitting in" and socialising. I struggled right up until I went to a 12 step fellowship and someone told me (not in relation to this) the "Not everyone has to like me, just as I don't have to like everyone - and thats ok!"

So sorry this is happening to your daughter, the only advice I can give, well two bits really..

  1. help her to find her tribe - might mean some out of the box ideas on clubs etc.
  2. keep building her self esteem, the more she can recognise the good qualities in herself, the less other peoples opinions matter.

And tell her, I said that weirdo/uncool friends are the best!

Oh, nose-picker, I presume someone who hadn't been picked as the 3 bestie names would have been put in with her. I kinda felt sorry for her myself at the time.

Danfromdownunder · 07/03/2024 02:36

Whenever I took seconds at dinner or a sweet biscuit for my coffee my Dad would say to me “There you go piggy”. He’s dead now and I’m 51 and I still want to smash his face in for that.

JaneFarrier · 07/03/2024 01:34

@user1492757084 while you're right about attitudes changing, I don't think this is entirely a generational thing - I recall my mother (1950s childhood) and my great-aunt (1930s/40s childhood) both remembered and told me about comments which had cut them deeply. Neither is/was a particularly fragile soul.

My great-aunt was told she would never find a husband as she had unrealistically romantic ideas for a plain girl!

user1492757084 · 07/03/2024 01:20

Yes, I agree that my mother's generation and older were very against people thinking too highly of themselves.
Don't worry what you look like, you are clean and kind - Who's looking at you?
I remember a story about the late Queen, about how her own grandmother told her she was acting pompous in a shop and how, upon reflection, she had been thinking of herself as an enormously pleasing princess.

Pride comes before a fall.

Posing in the mirror was not on.
My father once said my skirt was as short as the skirts worn by the girls drumming for business down on the corner.
It was true.

It was amoral to think oneself beautiful or above one's station or better than the next person. Being a good looser and a non boastful winner were of equal importance.
Finding and making use of your talents for the benefit of others was what was admired.
Self depricating humour was rife and normal. My mother would repeat the "Girls in glasses don't get passes" too. She wore glasses.
People laughed at themselves.
They got through the war years and coped with little.

I think we have all been the brunt of a shocking criticism but perhaps today's youngsters are too image focused and thus could be marred for life by hearing a negative comment. Whereas I think I gained character and humility, hearing that I was not the centre of the universe.

TheMessiahIsMySister · 07/03/2024 01:19

JaneFarrier · 07/03/2024 00:56

Frog eyes unite! It was girls at high school that said this to me, but yes, large, green, and probably one of my better features whatever they said.

Large green eyes are my absolute dream!

JaneFarrier · 07/03/2024 01:15

MagicCastle · 06/03/2024 18:39

When I was 10 years old, I went swimming with a group of friends and one of their mothers to the local pool. I jumped off the diving board and when I came back to the group, one of the other girls told me that my "friend" had said "When Magic Castle landed in the pool the whole world shook" and her mother had laughed and said "Yeah I bet it did"

I was humiliated! I was already bigger than the other girls as I started puberty early. Was by no means obese or actually even fat, I was just a foot taller than everyone else. But I'm 40 now and those words have stayed with me for the last 30 odd years! Bit silly to still feel ashamed about it but those childhood feelings of embarrassment have never gone away and I've felt like the fat one in the group my whole life :(

This kind of thing regularly happened to me and I so much fear it happening to my daughter, who is also the class tall kid, which is not surprising as she's one of the oldest in the yeargroup as well as having an early growth spurt ans puberty (as I did). I've never criticised my body in her hearing and CERTAINLY never passed any judgement on hers, but I've no control over what stupid things others may say. And I think they sometimes do, from hints I'm picking up. It's a hard balance to tread. I'm hoping in another few years the other girls will have caught up.

JaneFarrier · 07/03/2024 00:56

Meowandthen · 06/03/2024 20:46

A man that a friend was dating once said I had eyes like a frog.

They are quite large and green. I’ve been complimented on them many times but that comment still bothers me, some 35 years later.

Daft but still… 🤷🏻‍♀️

Frog eyes unite! It was girls at high school that said this to me, but yes, large, green, and probably one of my better features whatever they said.

SpiritOfEcstasy · 07/03/2024 00:45

@Whatthechicken I read a really interesting book recently about inherited trauma https://www.easons.com/it-didnt-start-with-you-mark-wolynn-9781785044380?gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAiAxaCvBhBaEiwAvsLmWKrvT6yCvYlnQFDFJEYgN7MBgWjfnJaoSLqjSx3ZQYVDkiGi_pRJfBoCR5kQAvD_BwE
I had one of those lightbulb moments a few years back where I realised some of my actions/behaviours weren’t wholly my own and that they had been unconsciously internalised in my relationship with my mother. She had internalised them from hers and so forth …we absolutely can stop the rot.

RosesAndHellebores · 07/03/2024 00:41

Oh @SoOutingWhoCares - your story brought back a memory. When I was a little girl, pink was for pretty girls, so I didn't have it. Even my glasses were blue.

When I was 30 I had enough money to fit a brand new, German kitchen. So I got it in pink. It matched my pink carpets and pink curtains. It was more tasteful than it sounds.

At 63 pink is still my favourite colour. DD had as much pink as she wanted. She didn't want much of it. Probably because she could have it.

Foodfoodfoodfood · 07/03/2024 00:24

Throughout primary a classmate of mine said many horrible things.. some in fleeting comments but others more thought out. It did haunt me but then I moved away and didn’t think much of him for 15 years or so. Moved back to our old hometown and soon after he dies, won’t say exactly from what but he was intoxicated and unhappy. Only 32, he never really got his life on track. Going to his funeral was heartbreaking, but not only did I mourn him as someone I had know my whole childhood but I also realised there can be so much misery for those that speak unkind words. Not really sure where I’m going with this, but I hope those who have had these comments now realise it’s not about them at all ♥️

Tezza1 · 07/03/2024 00:13

SoOutingWhoCares · 06/03/2024 09:23

When I was 12 we were getting a professional photo shoot done at a local studio.

The photographer asked if he could take some indvidual shots of me. My Mum seemed unsure (probably worried about money).

When we were viewing the pictures back, he stopped on one of me.

He said something like,

"Now, look at this...the thing about your daughter is, she's not pretty. I think we can all agree she can't be described as pretty..."

And my mother replied, very honestly,
"No, she's not pretty."

Before he finished,

"She's BEAUTIFUL. Absolutely stunning..."

And went on to give this ridiculous effusive praise of my apparent "looks". Which I can't remember, because all I can remember is my mum saying, in a really truthful manner, "No. She's not pretty." and how humiliated and embarassed the whole situation made me feel. I remember my face going red and burning and feeling so ashamed.

The man was a neggy, creepy arsehole and I was already mortified by his initial comments (and I didn't believe his final comments anyway).

But my MUM, man?

She should have whacked him over the head with her handbag the minute he started, or yanked me out of there and said "I'm not subjecting my daughter to your stupid comments, you nasty man!" or even just "How dare you! She's TWELVE!"

but no...

she just said, "No. She's NOT pretty."

And it hurt like hell. Because at 12, as a girl in the 90s, "pretty" was EVERYTHING.

I must have been about 14, in the late 70s when my mum said that everyone has one outstanding feature (I now know that is rubbish). Simperingly, I asked her what mine might be. I assumed she would say excellent skin, because at that time I did have good skin. She considered me for a moment, and said "eyebrows". I mean, eyebrows of all things! Especially as I have pale, almost invisible sparse eyebrows. To this day I hardly ever plucked or darkened my eyebrows.

Thanks a heap, mum.

Thursa · 07/03/2024 00:08

Unfortunately I was “blessed” with big boobs. So I’ve heard some nasty shit over the years. One that sticks in my mind was walking past two young lads and one said to the other “look at the tits on that”! That. Not even her. That.

what the hell is wrong with some men?

XenoBitch · 07/03/2024 00:02

Another... Sad

Back in school, the teacher had us say one nice thing about our selves. I said I was kind... the whole class laughed at me.

XenoBitch · 07/03/2024 00:00

Someone who I thought was a friend gave me a hug, and whispered "just because I am hugging you, does not mean I like you".

Also, my own DM. My DP bought a posh digital camera, so I said I might sign up to a college course on how to use it. She said "what it the point? It wont get you a job" (I am unable to work due to MH issues). I never enrolled on the course.

Ruthietuthie · 06/03/2024 23:56

I was about 14. I was going out to a nice restaurant and was dressed up. I felt beautiful in a new dress. My Dad looked at me and said, "How much are you charging? You look like you should be standing on the street corner."

hellsBells246 · 06/03/2024 23:53

Aye. My mum, when I was 13 and stunning, told me I'd look better without that 'roll of fat' on my back.

And she told me I looked 'fine' on my wedding day.

I tell my dc they are beautiful all the time. They are.

maybebaby2023 · 06/03/2024 23:49

I didn’t wear makeup to high school one day. I usually would wear a little but not overkill though on this morning I didn’t have time.

A boy in my year said I looked like Cheryl Cole, but with cancer.

Years later, it still bothers me.

loropianalover · 06/03/2024 23:45

Ugh, really stomach churning to read some of these posts… I have one that’s stuck out to me, from when I was in a pub in Amsterdam in my early 20s. In the smoking area just chatting casually with lots of different people, got talking to one guy about music, can’t really remember the specifics but we liked a few of the same bands. My friend and I were just passing through the pub, wasn’t interested in having anything happen with this guy and gave no signs that I wanted anything.

Mid conversation he just kind of leaned back and said ‘you know, it’s really great that someone like you can still go out and… be so confident’ while just gesturing to me as if to say I was so repulsive but it’s great I’m still living life.

He said it so matter of fact and with such a cheerful tone that I really thought he must be right. Never mind self esteem, all my self worth went out the door that night & I’ve never been the same. I know he probably never thought about it again.

ChishiyaBat · 06/03/2024 23:39

TheMessiahIsMySister · 06/03/2024 23:12

Those of us impacted by this are not talking about feelings and perception, or being socially conditioned to see slim as more attractive.

Those things are true enough, but I look like CZJ when the weight is off, and like a jowly, hamster-cheeked frump when I’m carrying extra weight. I can see it in the mirror and in photos.

It’s no biggie - because I know I’m attractive when my face is slim, so I don’t lose sleep over it when it isn’t. It’s not perception, or all in my mind. It’s reality!

FYI - I *don’t have great facial bone structure - no cheek bones!

What I do have, is a perfectly oval face, large brown eyes and a small nose. Great slim - not when the heavy cheeks are dragging everything down! Grin

Guess i'm lucky i'm ugly then and I don't have to worry about being pretty when i'm thin and not when i'm not so thin, although i've never been thin thin thanks to my body shape and height, i'm a 4foot 10inch chubby dwarf who wouldn't look out of place down the silver mines with the rest of my clan, my lack of beard would be a problem though😂.

allaloneandlost · 06/03/2024 23:38

Hundreds.

"Stupid, useless and will never amount to anything"
"F@@@@@g fat ugly crackpot"
"Not welcome here as you're not a local"
"Who'd date that?" Said by two 'men' pointing at me on a train.

Snide comments about my weight ALL the time. Either too heavy or too thin.

No wonder I prefer to be alone even though it's horrible.

Bringtheweatherwithyou · 06/03/2024 23:35

NeedToChangeName · 06/03/2024 10:46

Some awful comments on here

I don't know what the solution is. Perhaps to support our children's self esteem in the hope that they are resilient enough not to be shaken by cruel and unwarranted comments? (in addition to the obvious, teach our children to be kind and considerate adults)

But how to teach resilience?

Can it even be taught?

I pile compliments onto my kids but my eldest child dismisses them immediately. Also sees any constructive remark as a criticism and dwells on it so much that DC1 becomes very difficult to help.

Picklewicklepickle · 06/03/2024 23:33

Ah yes the Dad comments. My dad always called me moon face as a child, it took me until my 30s to realise that actually my face shape isn’t even round but I still avoid photos at all costs because all I can see is my big fat face and I hate it.

My dad didn’t mean it with malice and he still defends it as in his eyes it’s a factual comment, he sees nothing wrong with commenting negatively on people’s weight/appearance because to him it’s true so they can’t be hurt. My poor mum got told off for being fat when she put on a little weight after having children then for being too thin when she was run ragged with 3 under 5.

I also had comments about being stuck up/too solemn when actually I was extremely shy and my parents did nothing to help build my confidence/ be more outgoing.

I have DDs and I never want them to suffer with crippling low self esteem like I did/do, this thread has reminded me to think extra carefully about the affect a thoughtless comment can have.

So many truly terrible things mentioned above, I’m sorry for all of you that are still affected

EatingTillIDie · 06/03/2024 23:31

Just remembered a comment to my 4 year old daughter at a birthday party a few weeks ago. Made by a 4 year old boy. "You are no good at anything."
She cried her eyes out. They certainly start young. I wanted to scratch that little kids eyes out 😅

Moonside · 06/03/2024 23:24

Ah a few come to mind...

In middle school a friend randomly decided to 'ask out' a boy on my behalf. I didn't even have a crush on him. He looked horrified, looked at me then back at her and said "urgh, no way, she's so UGLY" (emphasis his).

Wearing a slightly cropped top at around 12, my mum said "I can't let you go out like that with your gut hanging out". She'd often worry about me getting "chubby" and have us all start "eating healthily" but I've yet to see a picture of me as a child or teenager where I look even remotely overweight.

There's others but those came into mind quickly.

Throw in both my biological and adopted dad dropping me and I have quite a lot of insecurity and fear of abandonment. DH insists he loves how I look but I think pretty much every other woman is more attractive and it's only a matter of time before he wants to sleep with someone more in his league. I can sometimes hardly bear talking to people as they have to look at my face and I think it must be awful for them (I work in a job that requires long face to face conversations too!). Plus I developed such disordered eating I am actually overweight now so fat AND ugly. Other people say I'm not but they have to be kind don't they. I'd love to be beautiful.