Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fleeting comments that still sting years later

708 replies

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 08:29

I was early 30's and single. Dating, but having zero luck and wondering if I'd die alone at the bottom of the stairs with my cat eating my big toe.

I confided in my best friend at the time, I was feeling low about myself and sad. Fed up of the dating world.

She said, her partner had told her that "if I lost a bit of weight I could have anyone I wanted".

Was it a back handed compliment? Meant to hurt me? Meant to make me feel better? Why would she say that? I had no idea.

Years later, it still pops up in my head like that unexpected morning pimple.

I've always carried a few extra pounds, I love my food! But, I was by no means what you'd describe as "big".

Anyway, it stung. A lot. And certainly didn't make me feel better.

It made me wonder if anyone else had a carefree passing comment, that probably meant nothing to the person who said it, yet hit you to the core and stayed with you years later?

OP posts:
Happilyobtuse · 07/03/2024 09:28

As a kid I played a lot of basketball and was quite tanned. Each time we visited my relatives in my home country I would be told I was so dark and should avoid the sun! 🤣Fast forward and now I am told I am too pale! With some people you can’t win! 😂

ilikemethewayiam · 07/03/2024 09:06

My ex and I lived in a bit of rough area at the time. At the end of our road was a rough pub and there was sometimes fights at kicking out time. My ex was a huge guy who worked on night club doors for extra money sometimes. We were sitting watching a film late one night around pub out time, and I just fancied a little bit of Chocolate. I asked him if wouldn’t mind popping over the little late night shop which was across the main road just behind the houses facing. No biggy if he didn’t want to, I was just asking. He huffed and puffed and asked why couldn’t I go myself. I just looked at him with incredulity and said ‘seriously!’, he said ‘What? you think someone would want to rape you? Why on earth would anyone want to rape YOU!’. If ever I look back and wonder if we could have worked it out. I remember those words!

ClareBlue · 07/03/2024 08:51

If ever there was a thread that supports the old adage that if you haven't got anything positive to say about someone, don't say anything.
Some are probably not meant to hurt but some of these comments made to people are just vindictive and nasty.

BetterWithPockets · 07/03/2024 08:26

This is a fascinating thread, OP — all those things that people say that stay with us, even years later.
The thing that amazes me is that even on a thread like this, you get some posters with (hopefully throwaway rather than designed to hurt) comments like ‘I just don’t understand why anyone would let themselves be affected by that; I wouldn’t.’ Well, no, perhaps not, and you’re clearly superior (or think you are!) but everyone’s different…
The thread does make me worry, though, about things I’ve said that might have had a lasting impact on someone. I don’t make a habit of it, at least not intentionally, but I do remember a good friend meeting a boyfriend of mine for the first time and he sided with her about something (can’t remember what now). The next time I saw her, she kept gloating about how he’d ’chosen’ her over me, and in the end, I snapped, and told her what he’d said about her after she left (which wasn’t positive). I apologised later but still feel bad about it. We’ve remained friends though. But there must be other occasions I’ve said things — unwittingly — and hurt people.
The one thing that stays with me is me asking my DM if she thought I was creative; her looking at me and saying of course not; you’ve never created anything. Even now if people suggest I’m creative, I think no I’m not… It’s not bad by the standards of many things on this thread — but it’s certainly stayed with me.

AHalfWarmedFish · 07/03/2024 08:18

Excited101 · 06/03/2024 09:01

I had a manager pull me aside once, I thought it was to let me know it was to go to a different branch which I had been hopeful and excited for. But no, he told me he’d had reports of me not ‘pulling my weight’ by my colleagues. I was about 21 years old and had undiagnosed ADHD (only diagnosed at 36). I hadn’t fully been able to know quite what I was meant to be doing, and had thought I was doing fine. That phrase still haunts me regularly. It’s horrible.

My boss (a consultant rheumatologist) once told me (then a junior doctor) in front of the whole ward round that I was “as thick as pig shit” and needed to “stop being so useless”. I also had undiagnosed ADHD, I was trying my absolute best and it was never good enough. It does stay with you

Poltershighclimb99 · 07/03/2024 08:01

It is funny how little comments can haunt you. I was always self conscious of my body as a teenager. I was very skinny, I had no shape and no boobs. I was never bullied but kids at school would ask if I was anorexic, I really was tiny despite eating plenty. My cousin who is a year younger (we were around 14/15) had really big boobs and I overheard my mum and auntie talking downstairs. My aunt said she was worried my cousins boobs were too big for her age, my mum said ‘at least she has boobs, polters hasn’t got any’ then they laughed. My mum is not a cruel person at all and I’d say that’s the only thing I ever heard her say about me negatively but I felt so embarrassed and upset. She’d be devastated if she knew!!

NeedToChangeName · 07/03/2024 07:59

Bringtheweatherwithyou · 06/03/2024 23:35

But how to teach resilience?

Can it even be taught?

I pile compliments onto my kids but my eldest child dismisses them immediately. Also sees any constructive remark as a criticism and dwells on it so much that DC1 becomes very difficult to help.

I think it can be taught eg abseiling teaches us to be brave, football teaches us to lose gracefully and play again next week, watching a parent change career after redundancy teaches flexible thinking

Best to focus on effort, not achievement eg if we encourage children to study for an A, they may feel they failed if they get a B. If we encourage them to work hard to achieve their potential, they may be delighted with a B, if that was the best result they could have hoped for

But, horrible people will still say awful things and it's difficult to completely protect against that. All we can hope for is to minimise the impact

Battytriker · 07/03/2024 07:54

One or two years into my marriage (over 20 years ago) my MIL told me I looked better with my glasses on. I don't think she meant it how it sounded but I've worn them all day, everyday ever since even though I don't actually need to.

Another one involving my own DM this time, again 20ish years ago. A year or so after having my youngest we met up with family friends for lunch. One of the friends also had a young child, at the time she wore nice fitted jeans and fitted t - shirts (nothing wrong with this) which meant you could see the change in her body shape. I was always conscious of wanting to hide my shape so wore looser clothing. When we were standing in the car park saying goodbye she looked at me and said “oh you haven't got a muffin top, that's not fair”. Immediately my mum piped up saying “oh she has ”! I was gobsmacked that she would say such a thing. I would imagine it was more to make the friend feel better rather than make me feel bad but still. 🙄

SevenSeasOfRhye · 07/03/2024 07:53

I have numerous examples of random men in the street calling me ugly, making dog howling/barking noises in my direction and so on. It happened so often when I was younger (I'm now middle aged and blessedly invisible) that I came to expect it; I would tense up if I was passing a group of men, bracing myself for any comments.

Along with others on this thread, I also have a dad one. I was complaining to my dad about being bullied in school when I was in my early teens - I was relentlessly bullied, name-calling and being slapped/shoved in corridors. My dad impatiently said "What's the problem; you're bigger than most of them, aren't you?"

Firstly, I wasn't particularly big, I was a 1980s size 12, and as a second year about 5' tall, certainly not bigger in any sense than the group of fifth years who had singled me out. But what he said conjured up this horrible image of an enormous version of myself lumbering around like a tank shoving my assailants out of the way while they sneered at me. In no sense would it have helped my cause to be 'bigger' than anyone.

I suppose he might have been thinking of his own days at a boys' grammar school in the 1950s when physical size/strength might have been seen as an advantage.

But for me, the comment added insult to injury. It was never any use complaining about bullying in those days; even if you were taken seriously you were expected just to 'ignore' it or 'stay out of their way' (as if you'd seek them out!).

Calliopespa · 07/03/2024 07:50

Foodfoodfoodfood · 07/03/2024 00:24

Throughout primary a classmate of mine said many horrible things.. some in fleeting comments but others more thought out. It did haunt me but then I moved away and didn’t think much of him for 15 years or so. Moved back to our old hometown and soon after he dies, won’t say exactly from what but he was intoxicated and unhappy. Only 32, he never really got his life on track. Going to his funeral was heartbreaking, but not only did I mourn him as someone I had know my whole childhood but I also realised there can be so much misery for those that speak unkind words. Not really sure where I’m going with this, but I hope those who have had these comments now realise it’s not about them at all ♥️

I think that’s really true and , while it doesn’t ease the hurt of a nasty comment, I really don’t think people who truly feel good in themselves make nasty comments. I think a lot of people hurt a lot. 🥺

Happilyobtuse · 07/03/2024 07:12

TheMessiahIsMySister · 06/03/2024 23:12

Those of us impacted by this are not talking about feelings and perception, or being socially conditioned to see slim as more attractive.

Those things are true enough, but I look like CZJ when the weight is off, and like a jowly, hamster-cheeked frump when I’m carrying extra weight. I can see it in the mirror and in photos.

It’s no biggie - because I know I’m attractive when my face is slim, so I don’t lose sleep over it when it isn’t. It’s not perception, or all in my mind. It’s reality!

FYI - I *don’t have great facial bone structure - no cheek bones!

What I do have, is a perfectly oval face, large brown eyes and a small nose. Great slim - not when the heavy cheeks are dragging everything down! Grin

Hahaha! So true! My mum always says I look like CZJ when I am thin. With the weight on, you have described it perfectly! We could be twins! 😂🤣

CatMadam · 07/03/2024 07:10

HollyKnight · 06/03/2024 13:52

I think your friend did the MN equivalent of "I asked my DP, and he said..."

For me, my mum did the "I love you, but I don't like you" thing some mums think is fine to say to their troubled children. I have never forgotten that or forgiven it.

My mum said the same thing when I was struggling as an undiagnosed autistic teenager, and acting out because of it. I was already convinced that no one liked me, so to hear my mum say that broke my heart and it still weighs on my mind decades later. It’s really such an unpleasant thing to say to anyone, let alone your own child!

localnotail · 07/03/2024 07:05

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 22:53

I'm thankfully now married to a lovely man, who sees beyond a few wobbly bits and loves me for who I am. Thank God I didn't end up with the type of man who is obsessed with what I look like. Looks fade. We all get older. Most will gain weight. We are best friends and together for life, regardless of wrinkles and rolls.

That's great, but then why are you still bothered by this comment? I have a lot of "you need to loose weight, you need facelift, you need whatever" from my family - but I literally could not care less. For some people looks are the most important thing ever, and your friend simply reiterated this. You, and I, know its great to be good looking but its not the end of the world if you are not perfect. Just laugh it of, stand your ground and hold your head high! x

BetiYeti · 07/03/2024 06:53

I had been unwell for a few weeks, but was feeling much better and meeting up with a friend. I had done my hair, make up and dressed nicely, I was feeling good. As soon as friend saw me, she said, “You’re not right still, are you, you don’t look well and your eyes are red”. I checked in the mirror and my eyes weren’t red at all, I don’t know why she said it and everytime I see her now I feel anxious that she is going to say something about my appearance again.

Froggy99 · 07/03/2024 06:43

White van men shouting to my ex when we were together “I don’t fancy yours much” they thought it hilarious so did my ex.
I was in early pregnancy and felt like shit as it was so that really helped 😏

Beepbeep18 · 07/03/2024 06:31

Not a fleeting comment but when I was 19 I was on the bus alone going into my local town for a night out. Some boys I’d gone to school with relentlessly ripped the shit out of me for being fat, ugly, weird (yes, I am probably on the side of unconventional looking but still). I never got over it and years later my friend ended up dating a friend of the boys and saw the main one and told him what he’d done. He was mortified and apologised so much - but why you’d do it in the first place is beyond me

Fitz1987 · 07/03/2024 06:20

After having DD I had friends and family over visiting to see DD. I heard someone ask a friend, who was holding DD, do you think she's cute". The friend responded no she's not cute. I felt so heartbroken for my DD as she was holding her and I didn't stick up for her or take my DD from her. I promised myself going forward I will always stick up for my DD and cried for days after that I never stuck up for her.

Plumtop11 · 07/03/2024 05:50

I had it more recently with a friend who was making lots of passive comments every time we saw one another. She ended up going on a huge rant at me, told me I'd changed and she didn't like the person I was now and then ghosted me and we didn't speak for 2 years.

She was my oldest friend and i was devastated. Flip to now and she came grovelling. Told me she was going through a hard time at home and was projecting. Looking back I was always the underdog in our relationship; poor family, smaller house, had to work through school and college etc yet I was the one who has a successful career and my DH is a high earner and we have 3 DC. I think she felt uncomfortable with the change to circumstances for us and it made her resentful.

We're still not the same and won't ever be unfortunately. Too much was said and done.

pootlin · 07/03/2024 05:46

user1492757084 · 07/03/2024 01:20

Yes, I agree that my mother's generation and older were very against people thinking too highly of themselves.
Don't worry what you look like, you are clean and kind - Who's looking at you?
I remember a story about the late Queen, about how her own grandmother told her she was acting pompous in a shop and how, upon reflection, she had been thinking of herself as an enormously pleasing princess.

Pride comes before a fall.

Posing in the mirror was not on.
My father once said my skirt was as short as the skirts worn by the girls drumming for business down on the corner.
It was true.

It was amoral to think oneself beautiful or above one's station or better than the next person. Being a good looser and a non boastful winner were of equal importance.
Finding and making use of your talents for the benefit of others was what was admired.
Self depricating humour was rife and normal. My mother would repeat the "Girls in glasses don't get passes" too. She wore glasses.
People laughed at themselves.
They got through the war years and coped with little.

I think we have all been the brunt of a shocking criticism but perhaps today's youngsters are too image focused and thus could be marred for life by hearing a negative comment. Whereas I think I gained character and humility, hearing that I was not the centre of the universe.

I’d rather today’s youngsters be image conscience than hear the sexist crap you seem to be advocating for in your post. Funny how it’s all directed at women, not men, eh?

My father once said my skirt was as short as the skirts worn by the girls drumming for business down on the corner.
It was true.

Your father’s comment was vile.

As was @Danfromdownunder ’s father’s comment. She’s 51 not a ‘youngster’ but still hurt by her father saying ‘there you go piggy’ when she ate a biscuit.

Fluffybagel · 07/03/2024 05:27

In my early 20s on a night out a random man was vile to me (for no reason) and I can’t remember any of the other abuse except he called me Santa as I was wearing a black belt on a red dress - sounds funny typing it out now, but it made me sooo paranoid about my tummy! 🤣 I was a slim 10/12!

Also another one - when it recently engaged and showing a “friend” my engagement ring - her comment was “oh I thought it would be bigger” pretty sure this was jealousy as she so wanted her OH to propose but he didn’t for years!

Downunderduchess · 07/03/2024 05:23

Happilyobtuse · 06/03/2024 20:23

Sorry to hear you were offended, but your GP’s job is to tell you if you are unhealthy. Size 12 doesn’t mean you can’t be obese. If you are short and carry weight around your middle you can still be obese. You should take it seriously and lose weight. This is not a flippant comment, the GP weighed you and only stated a fact. And definitely don’t ignore a smear test for any reason. The GP is trying to help, not hurt your feelings.

Username tracks…

Makemineadecafplease · 07/03/2024 04:45

SoOutingWhoCares · 06/03/2024 09:44

This has reminded me...

A nasty elderly woman in a cafe...she'd already said something nasty about my looks ("you look awful! Baby kept you up all night?!"...I was 20 and didn't have a baby) when she piped up to a girl nearby, "haven't you got BEAUTIFUL teeth!!! They are lovely and small and white...not like HER (me)." Turned to me with absolute venom in her eyes and said "yours are BIG. Like HORSE teeth." then cackled like a witch for what seemed like ages.

When I got home, I took a nail file to my teeth and filed loads of them off 😥

You should have asked why she laughs like a witch. Annoying woman.

ThatPeachSnake · 07/03/2024 03:44

Also had a dreadful time at school, lots of shit at home to deal with and bad mental health problems meant I had poor attendance. My friends knew this.

I miraculously got into uni and was absolutely ecstatic that my life was about to change. Instead of saying congratulations, one of my friends said ‘you’ll have to go to classes now you’re paying for them’ with a smug look. I’m sure it was nothing, but it stuck with me

ThatPeachSnake · 07/03/2024 03:41

My ex partners dad used to tell me ‘you could have a good body if you did more exercise’ - baring in mind, I was a size 6 at that point 🙃 (he used to say it in-front of everyone, around the dinner table too)

Acheyelbows · 07/03/2024 03:03

When I announced the news that I had gotten engaged and showed my ring to my parents, my father said.."Oh at least this one might stick around!"

I had chosen to leave my ex partner five years earlier and I had no other failed relationships.

When I got an eyebrow ring as a 17 year old in college, he said I looked like "an innercity slut".

I have forgiven him but the words still sting.

As a young teenager on a nightout I was told by an older guy I would be nearly ok without glasses, have hated wearing them ever since. Can barely try them on in the opticians when I have to get new ones and wear contacts to work or socialising. I know it's ridiculous as I love glasses on other people, I just see myself as disgusting when I look in the mirror.