Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fleeting comments that still sting years later

708 replies

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 08:29

I was early 30's and single. Dating, but having zero luck and wondering if I'd die alone at the bottom of the stairs with my cat eating my big toe.

I confided in my best friend at the time, I was feeling low about myself and sad. Fed up of the dating world.

She said, her partner had told her that "if I lost a bit of weight I could have anyone I wanted".

Was it a back handed compliment? Meant to hurt me? Meant to make me feel better? Why would she say that? I had no idea.

Years later, it still pops up in my head like that unexpected morning pimple.

I've always carried a few extra pounds, I love my food! But, I was by no means what you'd describe as "big".

Anyway, it stung. A lot. And certainly didn't make me feel better.

It made me wonder if anyone else had a carefree passing comment, that probably meant nothing to the person who said it, yet hit you to the core and stayed with you years later?

OP posts:
Calliopespa · 08/03/2024 06:20

TheMessiahIsMySister · 07/03/2024 18:02

BMI is a blunt instrument.

But it’s pretty obvious on first glance if someone is overweight because they’re a bodybuilder or an All Black prop, or they’re obese.

DH is tall and broad shouldered but lean and not particularly muscular beyond what men are ( so more than me but not so you’d gawp/ even comment and certainly not a bodybuilder.) He has always been “obese” yet looks quite a tall thin person.

Meanwhile I am of average to above average height, small hips, wrists etc but always have had shape st the top of my thighs, calves etc ( basically where you have storage fat) yet until last dc was always “ underweight.” Yet DH and I - obese and underweight - were probably very similar in terms of “ obesity.” Obviously it works in the broadest sense that if you put in weight you will move up thd bmi index ( am now well within “normal” 🤨 not underweight as of old !) but I really was fine when it said underweight just what once would have been called “fine build.” Meanwhile the notion DH is obese is just silly. So I think some builds can stretch the sensible application of it without being rugby prop extreme.

QuizzlyBears · 08/03/2024 02:39

Someone at work recently suggested someone else was ‘taking one for the team’ by sitting next to me. They don’t know I heard.

Ulysees · 08/03/2024 00:24

@Happilyobtuse that's interesting I didn't know that.

Pinkmoose · 07/03/2024 23:33

MuchTooTired · 07/03/2024 19:09

My friends were singing nursery rhymes for some reason, and I couldn’t remember the words. Upon telling them that, one said to me that it’s just as well I don’t have kids, I’d make a terrible mother. I’d been struggling with infertility for years, she knew it, and just stuck the boot in.

More recently, ‘D’H shouted at me that I’m fucking fat, a shit wife and utterly shit in bed, that I fuck everything up and told our DD that he loves her and he’s sure that I love her in my own way. The last one stabbed me through the heart, the idea of my little girl being told that and potentially remembering that.

Your daughter will know you love her. My own father used to say stuff like this to my mother and everyone thought he was so nice.
She did get fat because he wore her confidence down to nothing and she'd eat to get over the pain.
I get people say things in anger but how are you dealing with it? It's hard to talk to friends as well as once it's in the open people will see him differently.

Happilyobtuse · 07/03/2024 22:20

Ulysees · 07/03/2024 17:53

@Happilyobtuse you don't sound very big at all and BMI is good??

I am not big visibly and no one has ever called me overweight or obese but I have been told by the GP that for health reasons I need to get my BMI below 23 as I am of asian heritage. Once my BMI is below 23, chances are that my insulin resistance will improve and I will move to normal blood sugar rather than pre-diabetic range. So yes, you can be overweight and not look it at all.

JohnSt1 · 07/03/2024 19:47

When I was in college, there was a woman (we were both mature students) who liked to tell me how sexually unattractive I was. She was otherwise very nice to me, and I thought we were friends. 🙄

This happened several times. I never behaved in a sexual manner towards her, or commented on her appearance.

MuchTooTired · 07/03/2024 19:20

@TheMessiahIsMySister I hope to. It’s bloody ridiculous, but classic abuse starts in pregnancy (my DTs are 6) and I’m terrified of leaving. Not because he’ll hurt me, but I can’t keep them safe from his shitty temper if I’m not there, I’m scared leaving will fuck the kids up and scared staying will too. I’m quietly collecting evidence of his behaviour so I’m ready to provide ‘proof’ otherwise he’ll just paint me as mentally ill. But yes, in time I will do. Until then I try to remind myself that I’m not what he says I am, and that even if I do eventually argue back on occasion I’m not abusive, a bully or gaslighting him like he says I am/do.

TheMessiahIsMySister · 07/03/2024 19:12

Please tell me you’re leaving that man, @MuchTooTired

MuchTooTired · 07/03/2024 19:09

My friends were singing nursery rhymes for some reason, and I couldn’t remember the words. Upon telling them that, one said to me that it’s just as well I don’t have kids, I’d make a terrible mother. I’d been struggling with infertility for years, she knew it, and just stuck the boot in.

More recently, ‘D’H shouted at me that I’m fucking fat, a shit wife and utterly shit in bed, that I fuck everything up and told our DD that he loves her and he’s sure that I love her in my own way. The last one stabbed me through the heart, the idea of my little girl being told that and potentially remembering that.

MonkeyPlywoodViolin · 07/03/2024 18:20

Aged about 14, my male friend said that his mate had referred to me as “the elephant woman”.

At a similar age, my mum used to take me shopping and when I had tried on a few things and they didn’t fit / look flattering, insisted on my looking in the maternity section. I will never, ever forget it. I was slightly puppy fatty but a size 12. 😰

SevenSeasOfRhye · 07/03/2024 18:05

NoraLuka · 07/03/2024 12:10

I agree with PPs that worrying about image and these kinds of comments isn’t new, if anyone has read Anne of Green Gables (I know it’s fiction but still) Marilla remembers a comment made to her as a child so people were thinking about these things way back in 1880 or whenever it was set.

Yes, someone remarked that Marilla was 'homely' and it took 50 years for the sting to go away. Perhaps a similar thing had happened to the author.

TheMessiahIsMySister · 07/03/2024 18:02

Calliopespa · 07/03/2024 15:02

BMI is acknowledged to be a very rough estimate of overweight/ obesity. There are lots of things it cannot factor in like muscle.

BMI is a blunt instrument.

But it’s pretty obvious on first glance if someone is overweight because they’re a bodybuilder or an All Black prop, or they’re obese.

CantFindTheBeat · 07/03/2024 18:00

RosesAndHellebores · 06/03/2024 20:21

I've said many times on here before, after many miscarriages and the birth of ds2 with a heart malformation incompatible with life, MIL "It's such a shame you can't perform". It was decades ago now. I have still never forgiven her. She's now a very old lady, but it doesn't mean she isn't an utter cow.

What a hideous, hideous thing to say. There's just no excuses are there 💕💕💕

Ulysees · 07/03/2024 17:53

@Happilyobtuse you don't sound very big at all and BMI is good??

Ulysees · 07/03/2024 17:52

@PineapplePomPom thank goodness for that ❤️

PineapplePomPom · 07/03/2024 16:39

@Ulysees No I didn't, it was all very rushed as they needed to get me to hospital quickly. In hindsight, I don't think it was malicious, it was all very rushed and DH was trying to arrange childcare for other DC. I can't remember what they did put my baby in to take to hospital. (It certainly wasn't a bucket or carrier bag) The hospital staff were lovely though, they washed him and put him in a tiny basket and took Polaroids and hand and footprints. It was just a very careless and crass question from the paramedic at the time.

Happilyobtuse · 07/03/2024 16:38

Calliopespa · 07/03/2024 15:02

BMI is acknowledged to be a very rough estimate of overweight/ obesity. There are lots of things it cannot factor in like muscle.

Agreed, but BMI is still a pretty good estimate for most people by and large except professional athletes, body builders etc. Also I am 10.5 stone, 5 ft 6”, don’t really look unfit but I am overweight for ppl of asian heritage, my BMI is 23.8 and I am still in the pre-diabetic range. I walk 5-6 miles daily and work out for half an hour with weights and also run a few days a week. I have now been told to lose more weight by my GP. So I am taking it seriously.

Ulysees · 07/03/2024 16:28

@PineapplePomPom did you or anyone report the paramedic?
I had to report a midwife when a workmate MC. It was during COVID and the girl was alone. She was made to feel like shit. The girl's DM didn't make much fuss but I was fuming.

GN637 · 07/03/2024 16:28

@Calliopespa no professional athletes or bodybuilders were patients of mine. No extra muscle. Just overweight/obese.

HoorayFriday · 07/03/2024 15:30

PineapplePomPom · 07/03/2024 14:09

1996, 5 months pregnant with my 3rd child (a boy) Sadly I miscarried at home, he was very tiny but fully formed. Paramedic to me "Do you have a bucket or carrier bag to put IT in?" meaning my baby 😥 I was bleeding heavily and in shock. Just absolutely awful.

I have no words for this. I can't begin to imagine how that felt 💐

OP posts:
PineapplePomPom · 07/03/2024 15:29

@SwoopingIsBad Thank you 🫶 It was almost 30 years ago but I'll never forget that remark. I'd like to think health professionals are more aware of language used around miscarriage/baby loss.

SwoopingIsBad · 07/03/2024 15:09

PineapplePomPom · 07/03/2024 14:09

1996, 5 months pregnant with my 3rd child (a boy) Sadly I miscarried at home, he was very tiny but fully formed. Paramedic to me "Do you have a bucket or carrier bag to put IT in?" meaning my baby 😥 I was bleeding heavily and in shock. Just absolutely awful.

That was such an inconsiderate thing for them to say when you were going through something so devastating. I'm so sorry 💐

Calliopespa · 07/03/2024 15:02

GN637 · 07/03/2024 13:08

@Happilyobtuse when I was a practice nurse we'd do BMI as part of various things. I was often surprised when the measurements showed someone to be obese when to my eye they were just a bit chunky, solid or other similar description. You read it on here all the time with those who are 3 stone overweight as being cuddly, chunky, well-built etc when in reality (depending on height) then at 3 stone overweight they are likely to be obese or pushing obese.

This thread was a sad read last night. So many nasty comments made to people that have affected lives.

BMI is acknowledged to be a very rough estimate of overweight/ obesity. There are lots of things it cannot factor in like muscle.

PineapplePomPom · 07/03/2024 14:09

1996, 5 months pregnant with my 3rd child (a boy) Sadly I miscarried at home, he was very tiny but fully formed. Paramedic to me "Do you have a bucket or carrier bag to put IT in?" meaning my baby 😥 I was bleeding heavily and in shock. Just absolutely awful.

Happilyobtuse · 07/03/2024 14:00

GN637 · 07/03/2024 13:08

@Happilyobtuse when I was a practice nurse we'd do BMI as part of various things. I was often surprised when the measurements showed someone to be obese when to my eye they were just a bit chunky, solid or other similar description. You read it on here all the time with those who are 3 stone overweight as being cuddly, chunky, well-built etc when in reality (depending on height) then at 3 stone overweight they are likely to be obese or pushing obese.

This thread was a sad read last night. So many nasty comments made to people that have affected lives.

Exactly my point. I would never ever make a comment about anyone’s weight or looks etc. But when you go to a health professional and they state a fact, I would accept it and work on it and not take it personally.

My mum told me long ago that when someone says something which hurts your feelings, it is ok to feel sad. But always think about what was said and see if there is any truth to it, if it is something you need to work on then work on that and if not, just let it go, like water off a ducks back. I have lived by that and it has always made me respond sensibly even when I don’t like what is being said.