Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fleeting comments that still sting years later

708 replies

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 08:29

I was early 30's and single. Dating, but having zero luck and wondering if I'd die alone at the bottom of the stairs with my cat eating my big toe.

I confided in my best friend at the time, I was feeling low about myself and sad. Fed up of the dating world.

She said, her partner had told her that "if I lost a bit of weight I could have anyone I wanted".

Was it a back handed compliment? Meant to hurt me? Meant to make me feel better? Why would she say that? I had no idea.

Years later, it still pops up in my head like that unexpected morning pimple.

I've always carried a few extra pounds, I love my food! But, I was by no means what you'd describe as "big".

Anyway, it stung. A lot. And certainly didn't make me feel better.

It made me wonder if anyone else had a carefree passing comment, that probably meant nothing to the person who said it, yet hit you to the core and stayed with you years later?

OP posts:
NotestoSelf · 06/03/2024 09:50

Excited101 · 06/03/2024 09:42

Thanks @NotestoSelf for making me feel even shitter about something that’s haunted me for the last 17 years, that’s great.

Honestly, @Excited101 -- I'm sure it's happened to large numbers of people at some point, especially those who were working comparatively young and had undiagnosed conditions!

I can imagine you were taken aback and upset at the time, but having your performance commented on negatively on by your manager aged 21 isn't something that should have 'haunted' you for the best part of two decades, unless he/she was spectacularly cruel and tactless about it. We've probably all under-performed at some point.

My HoD in my first job tried to get me fired out of the blue at the end of my probation period, after professing satisfaction with my work all along -- he just came out with something he had literally never mentioned as an issue at an extremely formal meeting that usually operated as a mechanism for confirming someone in post. It was pure spite, as I discovered later he hadn't wanted me, he'd had another candidate in mind. It was publicly humiliating and upsetting at the time, but it hasn't 'haunted'me.

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 09:47

Simplesalmon · 06/03/2024 09:11

Let it go, really just do.

Your friend may have been trying to be helpful or maybe even cruel. You will never know but just leave it in the past.

I can honestly say I don't think of it on purpose, nor dwell. When I'm feeling a bit down though it pops automatically to the front of my mind, like self sabotage to reinforce my negative thoughts.
I don't doubt that she probably has no clue her comment had a lasting impact on my self esteem. I don't remember it daily and am generally an upbeat person, but we all have our bad days, and that's when negative comments from the past seem to re-emerge. I wish they didn't!

OP posts:
Raspberryjamsandwich · 06/03/2024 09:45

A lot of these are really sad and upsetting. The words were designed to sting.
I remember after my school formal, the pictures from the night were printed in the paper. I was in one of the pictures. A few days later a woman told me she had seen my picture and I "looked really well". I was pleased with the comment till she added "you must've had a lot of make up on." I'm fairly sure that comment was meant to be cruel

Here's one that I think was an innocent comment that meant no harm but still stung.
I sent a greetings card to woman I knew for a big milestone birthday. A few weeks later I bumped into her in town. She said to thank my dd (8 years old) for writing her such a lovely card. "It was so nice that she had written it herself."That was my hand writing. Something I've always been self conscious of but no mater how hard I try my hand writing never looks good.Blush

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/03/2024 09:45

Simplesalmon · 06/03/2024 09:11

Let it go, really just do.

Your friend may have been trying to be helpful or maybe even cruel. You will never know but just leave it in the past.

But sometimes the really stinging comments do stay with you. And a lot of times people just don't think.

Many years ago, not quite along this line, we had family friends who lived near us and would take me and my DB out and invite us round (they had dogs) and also a friend of theirs who was an antiques dealer took us out too. Later on they moved and had children. I used to sometimes visit them when they moved because they'd y moved near my grandad which was a 30 minute bus ride away and he was tutoring me in French (he was dual national French/German). One day they both suggested I shouldn't call round again as it was eating into their family time. It was the way this was said, quite aggressive and in the street. I was about 16 and a bit shy. So I came back to my parents and suggested we cut off this friendship, which we did. There's no need to speak to a 16 year old that way. The woman tried to be friendly years afterwards, when she was divorced and I ignored her. Her DH was always much nicer than she was, more friendly and tactful. The other friend, the antiques dealer, was still friends with them but then they limited contact with her too, for some reason, we still stayed friends with the antiques dealer who was/is lovely.

BobbyBiscuits · 06/03/2024 09:45

There are a few that stick in my mind.

One was my cousin's wife, we were at a restaurant and I had just lost my Dad, I was 13 and a bit overweight, a big size 12. I reached for a second piece of bread as the food hadn't arrived yet, and she leaned over and snapped my hand away from it and said, "don't be so greedy'.
She was naturally slim and tall, and 12 years older so I looked up to her.

The other was my uncle, again round the same sort of time, he told me, unprovoked, that his wife weighed 7.5 stone, and that's what I should be weighing? That one led me to go to the edge of hell with bulimia for 20 years.

I don't blame them for my (ongoing) ED, but those comments still stick in my head as if they were yesterday.

SoOutingWhoCares · 06/03/2024 09:44

Motherofpearlxoxo · 06/03/2024 09:08

My best friend said my bottom teeth were crowded as a passing comment and asked if it was because of wisdom teeth. It had never bothered me before but I then went on to have £3700 worth of Invisalign treatment.

He would be so upset if he knew it was because of his comment!

This has reminded me...

A nasty elderly woman in a cafe...she'd already said something nasty about my looks ("you look awful! Baby kept you up all night?!"...I was 20 and didn't have a baby) when she piped up to a girl nearby, "haven't you got BEAUTIFUL teeth!!! They are lovely and small and white...not like HER (me)." Turned to me with absolute venom in her eyes and said "yours are BIG. Like HORSE teeth." then cackled like a witch for what seemed like ages.

When I got home, I took a nail file to my teeth and filed loads of them off 😥

HoorayFriday · 06/03/2024 09:43

Motherofpearlxoxo · 06/03/2024 09:08

My best friend said my bottom teeth were crowded as a passing comment and asked if it was because of wisdom teeth. It had never bothered me before but I then went on to have £3700 worth of Invisalign treatment.

He would be so upset if he knew it was because of his comment!

I'm guessing a lot of people just don't realise the impact their comments have on others. I've probably mentioned things to others unknowingly. Just the slightest comments can really jar and manifest.

OP posts:
Excited101 · 06/03/2024 09:42

Thanks @NotestoSelf for making me feel even shitter about something that’s haunted me for the last 17 years, that’s great.

NotestoSelf · 06/03/2024 09:39

SoOutingWhoCares · 06/03/2024 09:23

When I was 12 we were getting a professional photo shoot done at a local studio.

The photographer asked if he could take some indvidual shots of me. My Mum seemed unsure (probably worried about money).

When we were viewing the pictures back, he stopped on one of me.

He said something like,

"Now, look at this...the thing about your daughter is, she's not pretty. I think we can all agree she can't be described as pretty..."

And my mother replied, very honestly,
"No, she's not pretty."

Before he finished,

"She's BEAUTIFUL. Absolutely stunning..."

And went on to give this ridiculous effusive praise of my apparent "looks". Which I can't remember, because all I can remember is my mum saying, in a really truthful manner, "No. She's not pretty." and how humiliated and embarassed the whole situation made me feel. I remember my face going red and burning and feeling so ashamed.

The man was a neggy, creepy arsehole and I was already mortified by his initial comments (and I didn't believe his final comments anyway).

But my MUM, man?

She should have whacked him over the head with her handbag the minute he started, or yanked me out of there and said "I'm not subjecting my daughter to your stupid comments, you nasty man!" or even just "How dare you! She's TWELVE!"

but no...

she just said, "No. She's NOT pretty."

And it hurt like hell. Because at 12, as a girl in the 90s, "pretty" was EVERYTHING.

My mother thinks that being complimented gives you 'notions', AND that men should always be deferred to and agreed with, so regardless of whether she thought I was a raving beauty or not, she would have agreed with the photographer that I was Quasimodo.

(I realise this does not make it any the less stinging. My own grandmother was a prolific body shamer, and my mother is extremely critical of women who don't 'make the effort' and wear 'flattering' clothes.)

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/03/2024 09:37

A really nasty manager when I was about 23 said to me in an unpleasant tone of voice 'we can't all be oil paintings, can we Gonna?'. I'd never thought I was an oil painting (attractive). She said other nasty sniped comments and after I didn't do well (didn't fail it) at my 3 month probation I decided to leave. Evil woman.

dancinfeet · 06/03/2024 09:35

I’m embarrassed to be seen with you, when we go out walk a few steps behind me with the pram so people don’t know we’re together. My ex, a few weeks after I had given birth.

aLFIESMA · 06/03/2024 09:29

SoOuting Who Cares
Same Mum?
I was really little and my mum had her hands on my shoulders, faced me towards her and kindly explained that gran was lying!

aLFIESMA · 06/03/2024 09:24

"I know you gran tells you that you're pretty but you're not"
My mum.

SoOutingWhoCares · 06/03/2024 09:23

When I was 12 we were getting a professional photo shoot done at a local studio.

The photographer asked if he could take some indvidual shots of me. My Mum seemed unsure (probably worried about money).

When we were viewing the pictures back, he stopped on one of me.

He said something like,

"Now, look at this...the thing about your daughter is, she's not pretty. I think we can all agree she can't be described as pretty..."

And my mother replied, very honestly,
"No, she's not pretty."

Before he finished,

"She's BEAUTIFUL. Absolutely stunning..."

And went on to give this ridiculous effusive praise of my apparent "looks". Which I can't remember, because all I can remember is my mum saying, in a really truthful manner, "No. She's not pretty." and how humiliated and embarassed the whole situation made me feel. I remember my face going red and burning and feeling so ashamed.

The man was a neggy, creepy arsehole and I was already mortified by his initial comments (and I didn't believe his final comments anyway).

But my MUM, man?

She should have whacked him over the head with her handbag the minute he started, or yanked me out of there and said "I'm not subjecting my daughter to your stupid comments, you nasty man!" or even just "How dare you! She's TWELVE!"

but no...

she just said, "No. She's NOT pretty."

And it hurt like hell. Because at 12, as a girl in the 90s, "pretty" was EVERYTHING.

Judijudi · 06/03/2024 09:17

A few years ago went to GP for smear test while I was there she weighed me and told me I was obese (I’m small and size 12 and very muscular) I felt so humiliated that I didn’t go back for another smear test for several years and have refused to be weighed by anyone other than myself ever since

NotestoSelf · 06/03/2024 09:12

Excited101 · 06/03/2024 09:01

I had a manager pull me aside once, I thought it was to let me know it was to go to a different branch which I had been hopeful and excited for. But no, he told me he’d had reports of me not ‘pulling my weight’ by my colleagues. I was about 21 years old and had undiagnosed ADHD (only diagnosed at 36). I hadn’t fully been able to know quite what I was meant to be doing, and had thought I was doing fine. That phrase still haunts me regularly. It’s horrible.

I wouldn't have said that was a 'carefree passing comment', though -- it was a manager letting you know your work needed improvement. I can imagine you were upset by it if you thought you were doing fine, but presumably that's why you needed to be warned, especially if, as you say, you didn't know exactly what you were supposed to be doing, regardless of the reason.

Pickles2023 · 06/03/2024 09:12

Getting told by my Ex whole family that i wasn't good enough for their son..they then preceded to call my family saying i was violent, vile ect.

I think my family laughed because i was so shy and meek. So trying to imagine me hurling tea at at a room of people was most amusing. 😂😂

(I couldn't even do public speaking back then)

Cookiecrumblepie · 06/03/2024 09:12

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

readingmakesmehappy · 06/03/2024 09:11

Aged about 13 my grandmother told me that "men don't make passes at girls who wear glasses." I was desperately insecure about how I looked anyway. Not a coincidence that I didn't have my first serious boyfriend until I was 20.

sophi1995 · 06/03/2024 09:11

JacquesHarlow · 06/03/2024 08:50

what is the “AIBU” dilemna? I don’t get this post

What don't you get? It's extremely clear.

Would you be happier if she had a posted the typical "AIBU to ask if you have ever....."?

Simplesalmon · 06/03/2024 09:11

Let it go, really just do.

Your friend may have been trying to be helpful or maybe even cruel. You will never know but just leave it in the past.

Thrivenotsurvive · 06/03/2024 09:10

I was very insecure in a past relationship due to his behaviour and if I ever brought up something that bothered me he would call me a joke, an embarrassment, pathetic - you get the jist

still haunts me today whenever I have to speak up about something that bothers me, even if it’s to a work colleague or a stranger in a shop

Motherofpearlxoxo · 06/03/2024 09:08

My best friend said my bottom teeth were crowded as a passing comment and asked if it was because of wisdom teeth. It had never bothered me before but I then went on to have £3700 worth of Invisalign treatment.

He would be so upset if he knew it was because of his comment!

DontWasteMyTime · 06/03/2024 09:05

bravotango · 06/03/2024 09:00

When I was 20 I was at a house party and was trying to leave through the front door, but there was a guy stood in the way smoking. I said 'excuse me' and sort of tried to squeeze past and he squared up to me and said 'you fat, ugly cunt' and I was absolutely mortified and terrified and totally overwhelmed. It's been years and years since it happened but I vividly remember it and noone has ever been so vicious to me since

That's terrible.

DontWasteMyTime · 06/03/2024 09:05

My late MIL to me -

You'd be a lot better without all that make-up (I was very self-conscious about my Rosacea)
You're barrel-shaped
You care about that cat more than you do your kids
You're like your dad - broad and short
You could be attractive if you tried

To be fair, she was a twat about most people, but I was always the main target