Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stat maternity pay should be relative to earnings

131 replies

nappyvalley2024 · 06/03/2024 06:21

Why is statutory maternity leave a flat rate after the initial 6 weeks?

It would be fairer to have it linked to earnings for 3-6 months. Families in higher incomes will find the drop in pay more significant than those on lower incomes and would have been paying more NI.

This leads to higher earning women having to take shorter mat leaves than those on lower incomes.

OP posts:
Sawitch · 06/03/2024 08:15

plantlover34 · 06/03/2024 06:33

I'm not sure about linking it to earnings, but I do agree that it's shockingly low. Who can possibly live on £700 a month?

I think SMP should be raised in line with other benefits or possibly closer to minimum wage.

It would cost a lot less than a 2p cut in NI, and would actually make a lot of sense from a government that says it wants to raise the birth rate - pay mothers better for the work they do!

Slightly off thread, but there are many single/widowed pensioners who are expected to live on this kind of monthly income!

TheFairyCaravan · 06/03/2024 08:11

DDIL is on maternity leave. Both she and DS2, they’re both nurses, picked up extra shifts while she was pregnant to save for when they had a drop in income. He’s just started his Masters, as well as having a newborn and a full time job, but if they need the money he will do over time shifts, too.

There comes a time when you have to take responsibility for yourself and your own actions. A baby takes nine months to grow, so even if it’s not planned you do have time to save, especially if you’re a high earner.

Pepsimaxedout · 06/03/2024 08:04

Oh and most higher earners would be eligible for a tax refund on Sat Mat pay. I was getting £500 back on tax every month on SMP.

mummyh2016 · 06/03/2024 08:03

@Bookmark1111 not necessarily if the partner is a low earner.

Pepsimaxedout · 06/03/2024 08:03

MississippiAF · 06/03/2024 06:25

Nope, find better employers to fund mat leave, not taxpayers

This. More high earning women will have a decent employer who will top up sat mat pay than those on minimum wage/zero hours contracts.

Women should be paying attention to stuff like this when they choose an employer. Yet still so many have no idea what their employers maternity policy is until they are 26 weeks pregnant!

High earning women also have more opportunities to save prior to the baby being born.

Elmo230885 · 06/03/2024 08:01

How dare people on low incomes have children... the nerve of it all!

Surely higher earners notice the drop more as they live to their means and would generally have higher outgoings? Forward planning is key, saving up a bit. As other posters have said maternity packages as a whole tend to be better for better earners.

I've had two 12 month maternity spells as a middle earner with middling outgoings. We had savings and I was fortunate to have reasonable maternity packages.

Toomanyemails · 06/03/2024 07:59

duende · 06/03/2024 06:40

I had both my kids in the UK and each time I had to save up for a year to top up my stat mat pay. I was the higher earner.

It is not the norm in most European countries where mat leave is proportionate to your average earnings in the months/ year pre mat leave. In Poland for example you get 80% of your average pay, for 12! months.

Germany is about 70%
Spain is 100%.

Women should not be financially screwed for years for taking time off to give birth.

This but it's usually capped in European countries, ie 80-100% of your pay up to a certain amount (somewhere around the average salary, usually a bit above). This is the case in the European countries I'm familiar with, though individual companies might top up mat pay further. I'm extremely in favour of this kind of system and have seen the positive effects! It doesn't tend to come at an extra cost for the state, because the higher employment levels of women bring a net benefit.

The main point surely is that our statutory mat pay is woeful for everyone.
I really hope this becomes a major policy issue in the UK. It's shocking how far behind we are on this.

user1984778379202 · 06/03/2024 07:58

nappyvalley2024 · 06/03/2024 07:41

Presumably their costs would be lower. It's all relative isn't it.

If your earning £1300 a month and statutory maternity is £700 it's not much difference. It's a huge drop in income between £700pm and £3000pm.

If you’re earning 3k a month when you get pregnant you have scope to save to top up your maternity pay. A woman on low income won’t have that ability.

Calculuses · 06/03/2024 07:58

You think the state should pay higher benefits to those who earn most?

Mumoftwo1312 · 06/03/2024 07:57

It is possible to disagree with the op (I do) without saying vile things like "churning out kids". Ffs internalised misogyny much. Giving birth is hard and we have a plummeting birth rate in the uk, significantly lower than replacement level. Even if you're OK with that, there's no need to use such disrespectful words for motherhood. You're on mumsnet, go hate mothers somewhere else.

I personally think the base rate should be higher but I don't think it should be based on income.

mitogoshi · 06/03/2024 07:56

Flip it around- why should I the tax payer subsidise higher earners more than lower earners?

I actually think flat rate of state support is right, but increasing this is more important, for all

mummyh2016 · 06/03/2024 07:56

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/03/2024 07:31

It’s not jealousy to say people who earn well should pay their own living costs including funding their own children.

Everyone should be able to pay their own living costs and for their own children. Have what you can afford.

WoodBurningStov · 06/03/2024 07:55

My moral compass tell me that you should save for a child and not expect any help from the gov for time off after they baby. But in reality, I was the higher earner when I had my dd and the mat leave from my company was brilliant. 90% of my salary for 9 months. I felt very lucky and because dd wasn't planned, I'd have been screwed if I'd only got SMP.

I think employers should fill the gap, but if we did this then it would be another reason not to employ child bearing age women. Illegal or not, employers would indirectly discriminate again. I think it would be a step back for women in the workplace.

Lifebeganat50 · 06/03/2024 07:53

nappyvalley2024 · 06/03/2024 07:41

Presumably their costs would be lower. It's all relative isn't it.

If your earning £1300 a month and statutory maternity is £700 it's not much difference. It's a huge drop in income between £700pm and £3000pm.

Do you also think that high earners who become unemployed should receive more in benefits than lower earners who become unemployed?😂

WithACatLikeTread · 06/03/2024 07:52

There is a huge difference in money to someone on a low income.

buzzlightyearsaway · 06/03/2024 07:51

I saved hard for my mat leave

It's a shitty provision

WithACatLikeTread · 06/03/2024 07:50

nappyvalley2024 · 06/03/2024 07:41

Presumably their costs would be lower. It's all relative isn't it.

If your earning £1300 a month and statutory maternity is £700 it's not much difference. It's a huge drop in income between £700pm and £3000pm.

I am not sure the costs will be lower? If you rent you are more likely to paying more than mortgage. More likely to formula feed than wealthier parents etc.

SecondUsername4me · 06/03/2024 07:49

I started a thread a few years back to suggest that the minimum mat pay should be your contracted hours × NMW for at least the first 6m. I was flamed. "Who will pay for it? / people shouldn't have more kids than they can afford / people should save for it"

About 3m ago a thread was started saying that the 30 funded hours should be available to those earning over 100k as how ridiculous was it that someone earning 120k had to pay for their childcare for their 3 kids.

Well, posters were tripping over themselves to agree. Of course people on 120k shouldn't have to pay for their childcare for the kids they chose to have. Completely ignorant of the fact that they should have not had more kids than they can afford / should save for costs etc.

Fucking irony.

SomethingDifferentt · 06/03/2024 07:48

If your earning £1300 a month and statutory maternity is £700 it's not much difference. It's a huge drop in income between £700pm and £3000pm

Someone earning £3k a month has more capacity to save for mat leave. And for someone earning £1300 a month with reduced capacity to save, the drop to £700 can be catastrophic.

In what world do you boldly state the difference from £1300 to £700 is 'not much? It's £600 a month. The difference between paying your rent or not for some.

ElderMillenials · 06/03/2024 07:44

In an ideal world people would have savings to cover the drop. But in the current climate there is a huge amount of people earning what should be a good wage but it's impossible to save enough because of increased everything. These are the people earning too much for state assistance but not enough to be well off and even a fairly common package is a significant drop.
I do think employers should offer better maternity and paternity leave though rather than the government funding.

From personal experience, dc1 I earned 22k and mat pay was 100% for 6 weeks, 90% 6 weeks then 50% to 6 months and statutory after that. Dc2 earned 30k, 100% 6 weeks, 90% to 3 months and 50% to 6 months then statutory. Both times I'd saved 3-5 months worth of pay through luck and scrimping.
Now on 45k (not that there will be mat leave!) it would be much harder to save that much because everything costs more, mortgage has increased, bills, food, insurance... all higher.

And that's not even including unplanned pregnancy.

Now someone on UC isn't going to have that drop or need to save.

On the flip side though, people working are more likely to have better standards of living or better prospects of bettering.

Lillers · 06/03/2024 07:43

There seem to be a lot of assumptions on this thread that a higher earning mother is on a par with her partner - I’m the higher earning between me and DH. I’m in a public sector organisation that tops up mat pay to 50% of my salary after the 6 week drop off, but only for an additional 12 weeks, then it’s statutory all the way. DH earns half what I do, so this is a huge dent to our household income.

However, I don’t think that I should be getting more statutory mat pay than anyone else. Yes I pay more in tax etc, but I don’t get upset when a less well off person gets hospital treatment or goes to a decent school, so why would I be upset that they get the same entitlement to mat pay as I do?

Ultimately the issue is that mat pay is crap for everyone. I wish my employer enhanced mine by more, but they don’t. I wish my husband earned more, but he doesn’t. I wish I’d be able to take a full year off when I have my baby, but I won’t be able to and that’s just how it is. At least I’m not worrying about how to afford to feed my family.

nappyvalley2024 · 06/03/2024 07:41

WithACatLikeTread · 06/03/2024 07:37

Does this mean low income mothers would have to go back to work earlier than high income mothers?

Presumably their costs would be lower. It's all relative isn't it.

If your earning £1300 a month and statutory maternity is £700 it's not much difference. It's a huge drop in income between £700pm and £3000pm.

OP posts:
JC89 · 06/03/2024 07:38

BlueThursday · 06/03/2024 06:24

My own view is a higher earner is more likely to have an enhanced package from their employer or more of an opportunity to save prior to the leave

Nailed it.

WithACatLikeTread · 06/03/2024 07:37

Does this mean low income mothers would have to go back to work earlier than high income mothers?

OurfriendsintheNE · 06/03/2024 07:36

Families on higher incomes should be more able to save than those on low incomes. Richer people don’t deserve more money for having babies than poor people do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread