Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stat maternity pay should be relative to earnings

131 replies

nappyvalley2024 · 06/03/2024 06:21

Why is statutory maternity leave a flat rate after the initial 6 weeks?

It would be fairer to have it linked to earnings for 3-6 months. Families in higher incomes will find the drop in pay more significant than those on lower incomes and would have been paying more NI.

This leads to higher earning women having to take shorter mat leaves than those on lower incomes.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Simonjt · 06/03/2024 20:34

Where we live you receive 80% of your income upto a maximum of around £65 per day for 390 days, the final 90 days are then paid a low fixed rate of around £14 per day.

In the UK higher earners are more likely to have savings, a partner who is a higher earner and access to a fairly decent work based maternity package. Lower earners are the ones who suffer as often there is less ability to save, its likely a partner has a fairly similar income and maternity packages are likely to be statutory and nothing more. I do think SMP should be increased in the UK, I do also think we need to look at women being able to move over to sick pay (often more generous) after a certain amount of time if they have a complex recovery. At the moment there will be lower earning women going back to work before they are physically fit to do so, where as under normal circumstances they would be eligble to be signed off on sick leave.

TwylaSands · 06/03/2024 18:53

DottieMoon · 06/03/2024 13:31

Don't be ridiculous. Why would you presume pensioners don't have to worry about housing costs? Not everyone owns their own property.

What bubble do you live in?

Even if you own a house, housing costs are still a factor. My gran has a pension and a mortgage free house. She has still had to find money to pay for a new roof and maintanance costs.

ironorchids · 06/03/2024 16:34

If people want to be able to retire in old age and society to function, then they want women to have children.

The birth rate in the UK is not high enough to keep up with the cost of people retiring, so we clearly need to do more to facilitate families having children and not incentivise women to put off having children until they're too old to have the number of children they want to have or to avoid it altogether if they actually want children but feel they can't afford it at all.

Mat pat should be higher all round.

DottieMoon · 06/03/2024 13:31

nappyvalley2024 · 06/03/2024 08:20

"Slightly off thread, but there are many single/widowed pensioners who are expected to live on this kind of monthly income!"

Presumably they don't have housing costs though.

Don't be ridiculous. Why would you presume pensioners don't have to worry about housing costs? Not everyone owns their own property.

What bubble do you live in?

MillshakePickle · 06/03/2024 12:00

I really must be quite dim. There are ways to boost your stat mat pay. I'm following this thread with interest as I'm on mat leave myself and posted above. For others, if they qualify, they can get UC top ups. The pay isn't ideal and should be higher, but it isn't unworkable with a bit of common sense if you've laid some previous groundwork.

If you're earning above NWM when you go on mat leave even at statutory (I'm on stat pay and have been the whole time) it's not just the £700 you get there's also tax rebates. I don't earn enough to pay the higher rate of tax but earn just under it, and each month, I have had a nominal amount of tax back. Ie. Taking just under £800. This helps massively. Also, there are kit days available. I have worked some especially around Christmas or if I know I have something coming up that needs a bit cash and to keep on top of my role for when I return.

I completely understand that there will be many much, much worse off but if you're earning at least the median national wage it is doable. Tight and hard but manageable. Sacrifices need to made in most cases. And, is it fair? Yes it is because ultimately we have the choice. There are many who won't be able to bitch about mat leave pay due to pregnancy loss and infertility. Which will most often cost them money. I think there are some very insensitive opinions being presented here.

While I think it's good to raise awareness about poor pay it should be raised in all areas where it's simply not good enough to meet a basic standard of living. I feel with mat pay you can offset the temporary loss. And if you're a higher earner you should be able to get back on your feet quicker.

Also, we as a while begrudge taxes and paying more. The system as it is can barely support itself without raising taxes and national insurance (don't even get me started on the autumn or today's upcoming budget) it simply cannot happen unless there's more going into the system. And, to be frank other areas need to addressed before stat mat pay.

SevenSeasOfRhye · 06/03/2024 11:29

SMP should be increased but this should be across the board. You are being paid a higher salary for your specialist skills and experience - but if you are having a baby and looking after it, you are doing the same 'job' as someone on minimum wage, so there is no reason for your 'salary' to be different. It's for your employer to decide if your specialist skills warrant employer-enhanced maternity pay, but this shouldn't fall on the state.

Zaxi · 06/03/2024 11:28

GreenPalmyr · 06/03/2024 08:24

Not necessarily - their household running costs such as mortgage is likely to be higher. Just because someone earns ‘more’ doesn’t mean they’re not down to their final few quid in the last week of the month.

Yeah possibly, but, you shouldnt live to the ends of your means though

Flowersandforests · 06/03/2024 11:28

I completely agree with you Op - I think lots of people here forget that higher earners generally have higher outgoings…. For example mortgages. It’s easy to save they can save, but someone on £100k could have the same left over at the end of the month as someone on £30k after bills.

You can’t plan your whole life around being on maternity leave so you do have to struggle through.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 06/03/2024 11:18

Bushmillsbabe · 06/03/2024 10:29

There is lots of comments that employers should pay better mat leave, which is absolutely true. But this then has knock on effects.
I'm an NHS team lead,team of 10, this year 3 people on mat leave so a third of the team. We can't employ any cover until they get 6 months into mat leave and drop to SMP as still paying them, we dont get any extra budget when someone on mat leave. They then leads to already overworked staff taking on 50% more work, now 1 is off long term with stress, 1 on extended parental leave, and we have 5 people doing 10 peoples work - impossible. And if wait list goes up we get fined and even less money for staff.
But no one wants to pay more tax for the government to pay for better mat leave.
So its not an easy one

Edited

I agree and it's a similar story where I am (not NHS but public sector).

Pipp223 · 06/03/2024 11:18

Would it be typical for a high earner to rely upon SMP? I would expect high earners to be considerably more likely to recieve enhanced maternity pay from their employer (mine was full pay for 6 months, 75% for the next 3).

Bushmillsbabe · 06/03/2024 11:12

Many saying those with higher incomes can make cuts more easily, but this isn't always true. I can't just tell my mortgage company (£1500 a month) or council tax (£400 a month) that am going to 'cut' their payments, it doesn't quite work like that. Those on very low incomes may have lower outgoings (cheaper council housing, council tax reductions, free prescriptions, subsidised childcare on UC) but we need to stop this race to the bottom mentality, the 'you can't moan as I think I'm worse off than you' and support all new mums

I do agree with comments that SMP should last a year, no 9 month old baby should be in full-time nursery because their primary carer can't afford to not return to work. Evidence shows that children have the most secure long term mental health outcomes when with primary carer until 18-24 months old, but few can easily afford to be off even 12 months.

blushroses6 · 06/03/2024 11:11

SMP should absolutely be higher than it is, £700 a month doesn’t even cover half of mortgage/bills for most people now. I don’t believe it should be tied to earnings though, those on higher salaries should have been able to save or at least save a portion from the moment they found out they were pregnant every month, at least. I was able to save around £500 a month while I was pregnant for the first time so I had some spending money while on MAT leave. I do laugh at posters who suggest that the state should not be paying at all though, we already have a declining birth rate, someone else’s children will likely be caring for you in your old age.

Nosleepforthismum · 06/03/2024 11:07

I don’t think you can expect the state to pay SMP that matches your salary. It unfairly penalises women who do NMW jobs (which are often undervalued but incredibly important). I understand you have paid more in tax but it’s like saying high earners must take priority for NHS services as they have contributed more than the lower earners.

As a higher earner, you have the privilege of choosing to live well within your means where others have no other option but to literally live hand to mouth each week. It’s not the states responsibility to pay for your large mortgage and multiple outgoings when you choose to have a child.

WithACatLikeTread · 06/03/2024 10:57

Also those on low incomes on maternity allowance find that claiming MA means they take it off the UC and you are worse off.

Cheesetoastiees · 06/03/2024 10:43

Not really those with higher incomes have more opportunities to prepare for it and find ways to make cuts than those on lower incomes where every penny counts. I just think it should be at least minimum wage and last the full year.

Bushmillsbabe · 06/03/2024 10:29

There is lots of comments that employers should pay better mat leave, which is absolutely true. But this then has knock on effects.
I'm an NHS team lead,team of 10, this year 3 people on mat leave so a third of the team. We can't employ any cover until they get 6 months into mat leave and drop to SMP as still paying them, we dont get any extra budget when someone on mat leave. They then leads to already overworked staff taking on 50% more work, now 1 is off long term with stress, 1 on extended parental leave, and we have 5 people doing 10 peoples work - impossible. And if wait list goes up we get fined and even less money for staff.
But no one wants to pay more tax for the government to pay for better mat leave.
So its not an easy one

Tohaveandtohold · 06/03/2024 10:27

I agree that SMP or maternity allowance is quite small especially for someone who normally earns like 4 times of that however, I don’t think it’s the state’s responsibility to keep paying for people’s choices really. People also need to plan before all these major life changes.
I’m lucky that when I had my 3rd, I got full pay for 6 months but we planned ahead for the 3 months of SMP and I went back to work after as for us, it didn’t make financial sense to have 3 months unpaid. Everyone should also plan this way rather than expecting the govt to keep paying.

DodoTired · 06/03/2024 10:26

@PheobeBebe

higher earners pay more taxes so contribute much more. What “entitlement” are you talking about??

BodenCardiganNot · 06/03/2024 10:22

*Bagwyllydiart · Today 06:28

The state should not have to pay for your children*

We need women to have children. If the birth rate declines then there will be serious issues down the line. South Korea for example is facing a national emergency because of the declining birth rate. Earlier this year, France, alarmed by the lowest birth rate in almost three decades in 2023 — at 1.68 compared with South Korea’s 0.72 — announced a major reform to its parental leave system.
So yes, the state should support families and that includes 'paying for children'.

ZiriForGood · 06/03/2024 10:22

I'm in central Europe and it works like that here - we understand sick pay, maternity leave, jobs seakers allowance and pension as state governed insurance (so the pay is proportionate to income, of course with some reductions and cappings).

We actually see it as more fair, because all employees and employers pay % to the pot as a part of general taxation and than everyone gets better support when they needed, not only those with the best employers with extra benefits.

DragonFly98 · 06/03/2024 10:20

plantlover34 · 06/03/2024 06:33

I'm not sure about linking it to earnings, but I do agree that it's shockingly low. Who can possibly live on £700 a month?

I think SMP should be raised in line with other benefits or possibly closer to minimum wage.

It would cost a lot less than a 2p cut in NI, and would actually make a lot of sense from a government that says it wants to raise the birth rate - pay mothers better for the work they do!

It's much more generous than UC many people live on less than £700 a month.

Woollyewe · 06/03/2024 10:19

Garlicking · 06/03/2024 06:47

I quickly looked up the German info:

The maternity allowance amount is always determined by the salary of the last cleared calendar months before the beginning of the maternity period. It is a maximum of EUR 13 per day. The employer pays the difference between the maternity allowance amount and your previous salary.

You don't need the state to pay you to be pregnant, you need employers to.

Its such a difficult one because not every business can afford these costs. Im lucky, i work for a big bank and got 6 months full pay but i think small businesses would be out if business in lots of cases if they had to match these packages.

loudbatperson · 06/03/2024 10:18

I agree with previous posters, as a higher earner I am in a fortunate position to be able to save to cover the drop in income for maternity leave, and I also have an enhanced maternity package from my employer which is less common, although does exist, in the bottom end of the pay scale.

Nurserygreed · 06/03/2024 10:18

Bagwyllydiart · 06/03/2024 06:28

The state should not have to pay for your children

Those children will be filling the coffers for your future pension…

BIossomtoes · 06/03/2024 10:15

user1471552329 · 06/03/2024 10:02

In Scandic countries this is standard. Together with subsidised child care women work full time and can afford to leave abusing relationships! It’s vital for women to have their own income.

Trouble is this OP wants Scandinavian services and benefits on UAE tax rates.