Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD has been removed

457 replies

Flojoloco · 06/03/2024 00:24

DD is 15 with additional needs. Things have been getting progressively difficult. Today she told her social worker that I hit her and there is a bruise on her face so they removed her. There’s a strat meeting tomorrow and I’ve no idea if she’s coming home or not either way it’s a mess. I either lose my DD or she’s at home and I’m scared of her lies. She’s 5’8” and 14+ stone, she has massive temper tantrums/meltdowns and puts holes in doors etc. I have no doubt if I ever hit her she would paste me. She lives a charmed life but she’s not very happy at the moment and that’s impacting massively. I would never hit her. I’ve no idea where the bruise came from. If she bumped her head on something or deliberately smacked herself in her face. I haven’t seen her but the photo on SW phone didn’t look like a bruise, she just looked blotchy. Either way we need help.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
greyflannel · 09/03/2024 11:48

I also think the discussion of parental responsibility has become confused. Parental Responsibility relates to the power to make decisions in respect of the child.

greyflannel · 09/03/2024 11:48

I also think the discussion of parental responsibility has become confused. Parental Responsibility relates to the power to make decisions in respect of the child.

TheSquareMile · 09/03/2024 11:47

Flojoloco · 08/03/2024 20:10

Update - had a meeting today with everyone. It’s been NFA’d and I’m so relieved and hopefully we can begin to move on.
It’s going to be telling the next time DD kicks off. We have another meeting next week on exploring the function and what additional support might be useful

@Flojoloco

I would still explore the legal position vis-a-vis educational possibilities, OP.

You said that she is 15. Does this mean that she will be taking her GCSEs in 2025? What kind of school does she attend at the moment?

greyflannel · 09/03/2024 11:39

Withinthesewalls · 09/03/2024 11:27

But as far as services are aware it is a moments notice- they get a call from a teenager saying that their mum has hit them and left a bruise and they are scared- this is the first they know of it and they proceed on that basis.

They see a mark on a child who is insisting that their mum is violent- there isn’t any evidence immediately showing that to be untrue except the mum says she didn’t (which they all say), so they take the child for a night while they build a picture of the actual situation.

They do that because the alternative is to leave the child and not know whether there first job the next morning is going to be visiting intensive care because the mum has stabbed the child.

They keep the child safe, they speak to professionals who know the family, they speak to the kid and the mum again and they decide that this is a troubled child with a loving mum. So seeking to back up that belief with a medical, they then try and unite mother and child…

at which point mum says she doesn’t want her back, she does this, says that, mums frightened etc.

So, services suddenly have a much more complex situation than they previously thought and need to deal with it, but in the meantime they don’t have the right to remove the child, the mum doesn’t have the right to give up PR, they don’t have anywhere safe to send the child (because of the total underfunding of services) but they do have a legal duty to safeguard the child- so, with the mum that says she is loving, and evidence shows she probably is, is the best option available for the child in that moment.

Mum then shouts, swears, flip flops about allowing a medical and asks for engagement then refuses engagement and that adds a whole extra layer of complexity to the situation and that means it takes longer for mother or child to get any support.

Children’s social care have a legal duty towards children, and not to impinge or interfere with their parents rights unnecessarily- they don’t have that same duty towards the adults themselves.

That is because historically the focus has been on protecting vulnerable children from dangerous adults and making sure kids can’t be whisked off into care if the SW doesn’t like the look of their parenting style, or they are poor, or immigrants or have special needs or are disabled, all of which used to happen.

You have to bear in mind that the system is based on not repeating atrocities like the 1000’s of children wrongly sent to Australia by SS, and having as few ‘Baby P’ cases as possible.

And in a country where there is basically zero money available for SS, or any of the services that could have stopped the situation the op has escalating to this point, all services are targeted at what is statistically most likely to go badly, and far more children are murdered by their parents than parents are murdered by their children.

The child to parent violence dynamic IS a hole in service provision in all senses- research, statistics, practice guidance, legislation and crucially actual physical resources to access.

Just on your narrow question of statistics, I'd be interested to know whether more 15 year olds are killed or injured by their mothers, than mothers are killed or injured by their 15 year olds. I am not convinced the risks run in the way you suggest.

WhatNoRaisins · 09/03/2024 11:37

There is a real need for funding to keep these families safe. It bothers me as I have a close friend who knows that this is the situation she will inevitably find herself in despite seeking all the early intervention she can. Her child is still young and she's already sporting some painful injuries. Her mental health is going to shit in the meantime.

Withinthesewalls · 09/03/2024 11:27

WhatNoRaisins · 09/03/2024 10:52

It don't think these parents are just doing it at a moments notice, this is a last resort situation. In extreme cases I don't think it would be unreasonable for a parent to remove themself from a dangerous situation even if it is illegal.

But as far as services are aware it is a moments notice- they get a call from a teenager saying that their mum has hit them and left a bruise and they are scared- this is the first they know of it and they proceed on that basis.

They see a mark on a child who is insisting that their mum is violent- there isn’t any evidence immediately showing that to be untrue except the mum says she didn’t (which they all say), so they take the child for a night while they build a picture of the actual situation.

They do that because the alternative is to leave the child and not know whether there first job the next morning is going to be visiting intensive care because the mum has stabbed the child.

They keep the child safe, they speak to professionals who know the family, they speak to the kid and the mum again and they decide that this is a troubled child with a loving mum. So seeking to back up that belief with a medical, they then try and unite mother and child…

at which point mum says she doesn’t want her back, she does this, says that, mums frightened etc.

So, services suddenly have a much more complex situation than they previously thought and need to deal with it, but in the meantime they don’t have the right to remove the child, the mum doesn’t have the right to give up PR, they don’t have anywhere safe to send the child (because of the total underfunding of services) but they do have a legal duty to safeguard the child- so, with the mum that says she is loving, and evidence shows she probably is, is the best option available for the child in that moment.

Mum then shouts, swears, flip flops about allowing a medical and asks for engagement then refuses engagement and that adds a whole extra layer of complexity to the situation and that means it takes longer for mother or child to get any support.

Children’s social care have a legal duty towards children, and not to impinge or interfere with their parents rights unnecessarily- they don’t have that same duty towards the adults themselves.

That is because historically the focus has been on protecting vulnerable children from dangerous adults and making sure kids can’t be whisked off into care if the SW doesn’t like the look of their parenting style, or they are poor, or immigrants or have special needs or are disabled, all of which used to happen.

You have to bear in mind that the system is based on not repeating atrocities like the 1000’s of children wrongly sent to Australia by SS, and having as few ‘Baby P’ cases as possible.

And in a country where there is basically zero money available for SS, or any of the services that could have stopped the situation the op has escalating to this point, all services are targeted at what is statistically most likely to go badly, and far more children are murdered by their parents than parents are murdered by their children.

The child to parent violence dynamic IS a hole in service provision in all senses- research, statistics, practice guidance, legislation and crucially actual physical resources to access.

WhatNoRaisins · 09/03/2024 10:52

It don't think these parents are just doing it at a moments notice, this is a last resort situation. In extreme cases I don't think it would be unreasonable for a parent to remove themself from a dangerous situation even if it is illegal.

Withinthesewalls · 09/03/2024 10:41

WhatNoRaisins · 09/03/2024 07:31

It's sad given how far we've come at de-normalising intimate partner abuse that women (I know some fathers are involved but a lot of the time it seems to be women) are expected to just cope with the same verbal and physical aggression from their children.

It’s a different legal and moral position, so it requires a different approach.

You can’t just kick 15 year old disabled children out- it isn’t legally ok. It’s perfectly legal to kick an abusive partner out (or to leave yourself).

Someone HAS to have legal and moral responsibility for children. That is their parents in the first instance, as it should be.

Removing that responsibility/right is a big thing- it can only be done in court by a judge- even if a child is in foster care the parents share PR with the state.

There needs to be better and more understanding and support in situations where the child is showing abusive behaviour towards the parent, but there still has to be a process of getting to the bottom of the situation, and working out what is best for the whole family.

No one actually wants to live in a world where you can just give up PR at a moment’s notice (see- the millions of women enraged because feckless men behave as though they can), or where SS can just remove and terminate PR without going through very fastidious checks and balances, otherwise the system would be open to all sorts of abuses.

WhatNoRaisins · 09/03/2024 10:07

I don't think it's about blaming the child with the disability but recognising that it's not a safe and acceptable situation for the carer to be in. Agree that it's like these people are just seen as collateral rather than people.

FleurdeLiane · 09/03/2024 09:46

WhatNoRaisins · 09/03/2024 07:31

It's sad given how far we've come at de-normalising intimate partner abuse that women (I know some fathers are involved but a lot of the time it seems to be women) are expected to just cope with the same verbal and physical aggression from their children.

But the behaviour of children who don't have the developmental capacity to behave differently really is not the same, and I think we need to insist on this if our children are not to be grossly unfairly stigmatised and blamed.

What's not OK in the face of some families facing very significant challenges due to disability is the state saying to mothers, suck it up, you're on your own, rather than providing the myriad resources a civilised country would provide to support child development and ensure a decent quality of family life (including the quality of life of individual carers). Instead we are collateral.

WhatNoRaisins · 09/03/2024 07:31

It's sad given how far we've come at de-normalising intimate partner abuse that women (I know some fathers are involved but a lot of the time it seems to be women) are expected to just cope with the same verbal and physical aggression from their children.

Coshei · 09/03/2024 06:59

TotoroElla · 08/03/2024 22:30

Completely agree with this. These types of threads always get a tonne of posters who do not have a clue. They only know what they think 'should' happen which does not relate to reality atall.

Don’t forget about the ones who excuse everything because of additional needs and expect people seeking help to be martyrs and just accept their fate.

TotoroElla · 08/03/2024 22:30

FleurdeLiane · 08/03/2024 07:41

You are getting some terrible advice on this thread, OP. Please take lyour own egal advice.

Completely agree with this. These types of threads always get a tonne of posters who do not have a clue. They only know what they think 'should' happen which does not relate to reality atall.

TotoroElla · 08/03/2024 22:26

kittycloud · 08/03/2024 03:46

100% this. It's an abusive relationship. It must be extremely distressing for you not to have your daughter there at home with you, but long term this could be a better option for both of you, perhaps she will start to learn about consequences -and when SW see what she's actually like, you'll get the support you so desperately need. I'm hoping it all works out for you in the end 🙏

Her DD is at home with her. And thinking SW will 'see what she is actually like' and OP will get support is naive.

justasking111 · 08/03/2024 22:01

Flojoloco · 08/03/2024 20:10

Update - had a meeting today with everyone. It’s been NFA’d and I’m so relieved and hopefully we can begin to move on.
It’s going to be telling the next time DD kicks off. We have another meeting next week on exploring the function and what additional support might be useful

Excellent news

Flojoloco · 08/03/2024 20:10

Update - had a meeting today with everyone. It’s been NFA’d and I’m so relieved and hopefully we can begin to move on.
It’s going to be telling the next time DD kicks off. We have another meeting next week on exploring the function and what additional support might be useful

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 08/03/2024 19:43

Coshei · 08/03/2024 17:37

Which is the case with many people until they are hit with actual and significant consequences. But this is hardly relevant any more considering the OP’s latest updates so I don’t see how this quarrelling helps her.

If OP’s DD has ASD/ADHD she won’t magically understand consequences, no matter how significant. All that will happen is that the behaviour will escalate because she will be bewildered. Her behaviour is as a result of her needs not being met. The needs of an actual disability. The more you post, the more you demonstrate that you have no understanding of ND.

Coshei · 08/03/2024 17:37

TotoroElla · 08/03/2024 17:13

You clearly said that this situation may make her understand consequences when her mother has made it quite clear that her suspected autism means she does not understand consequences.

Which is the case with many people until they are hit with actual and significant consequences. But this is hardly relevant any more considering the OP’s latest updates so I don’t see how this quarrelling helps her.

TotoroElla · 08/03/2024 17:13

Coshei · 06/03/2024 23:32

@TotoroElla ”Oh this situation will cure her autism will it?” Again. I never said this, and I see no point in engaging any further with you if you decide to twist words around.

@Flojoloco I’m very sorry to read your update. I second what pp said and it might be good idea to record conversations with her without her noticing. Keep safe and please keep in mind that her nasty words are not true, and “just” an expression of her frustration. That doesn’t excuse them, but remember that you are doing a better job than most of us would.

You clearly said that this situation may make her understand consequences when her mother has made it quite clear that her suspected autism means she does not understand consequences.

FleurdeLiane · 08/03/2024 15:46

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 08/03/2024 14:20

@FleurdeLiane
I'm not sure the tag 'abuser' is accurate or helpful. It serves to judge and suggests a level of intent that may not actually be present. Better to describe concerning behaviours, unsafe behaviours etc, and/or to describe the impact upon OP.

I get what you're saying, but I think the issue is that being on the receiving end feels like being abused, even if you recognise that your child isn't deliberately being an abuser.

And you feel trauma from that and are told (in our case) to try mindfulness. Is there any other situation where someone is facing daily violence where that would be the response? Try taking ten minutes out of your day to practice mindfulness to cope with being beaten up and verbally abused.

@EilonwyWithRedGoldHair - jeez, I think there must be some awful course professionals are going on to regurgitate this. Had the exact same - try and stay mindfully in the moment whilst being attacked so you expand your tolerance and can come to accept it without feeling distressed. No thanks, I'd like you/your colleagues to work with us to help reduce the violence - which I appreciate may take more time and resources than me 'mindfully' accepting it...

Lavender14 · 08/03/2024 14:39

Ah op, this sounds incredibly difficult and it sounds like you're between a rock and a hard place.

I also work in supported accommodation and honestly, places are really limited. If your dd could get a place in somewhere similar that's very structured and supported it might not be a bad thing. You could continue to be her advocate and support and love her as her parent but you'd have a proper network around her that can help navigate the challenging parts. Ideally it would also mean she has somewhere secure to live as she starts to move into adult hood. I've worked with a lot of families who waited until their child was in their 20s (and they were too elderly to manage any longer at home) to try and move their child into their own place and it's 100x more difficult and at that point more emergent because they've made the decision at crisis point instead of before.

Your dd needs a secure network and things in her own name outside of you op incase anything ever happened to you. Would it be worth speaking with the social worker about what options are out there in terms of good supported accommodation and what the pathway into that would be and what waiting lists are like? It might give you more info to make a decision on.

In terms of the lie she's told, I have no real advice only a hand hold. But please make sure you're looking after yourself and maybe availing of a support network for parents in similar positions? You deserve to be heard and supported as well op because you're dealing with so much.

I really hope this works out to the best possible outcome for you and your dd.

Withinthesewalls · 08/03/2024 14:30

WhatNoRaisins · 08/03/2024 14:11

It does mean that I'd never take the risk of having a vulnerable family member live with me even temporarily. We no longer trust that if it wasn't working out for whatever reason that we would get any help even if the person wasn't safe. I don't think we should be abusive towards SWs but I completely get why people have to resort to difficult behaviour.

That’s a sensible decision.

Withinthesewalls · 08/03/2024 14:28

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 08/03/2024 14:20

@FleurdeLiane
I'm not sure the tag 'abuser' is accurate or helpful. It serves to judge and suggests a level of intent that may not actually be present. Better to describe concerning behaviours, unsafe behaviours etc, and/or to describe the impact upon OP.

I get what you're saying, but I think the issue is that being on the receiving end feels like being abused, even if you recognise that your child isn't deliberately being an abuser.

And you feel trauma from that and are told (in our case) to try mindfulness. Is there any other situation where someone is facing daily violence where that would be the response? Try taking ten minutes out of your day to practice mindfulness to cope with being beaten up and verbally abused.

It’s an incredibly difficult situation for everyone involved. The child in question will also be given similar (daft) advice because there isn’t enough actual help available.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 08/03/2024 14:20

@FleurdeLiane
I'm not sure the tag 'abuser' is accurate or helpful. It serves to judge and suggests a level of intent that may not actually be present. Better to describe concerning behaviours, unsafe behaviours etc, and/or to describe the impact upon OP.

I get what you're saying, but I think the issue is that being on the receiving end feels like being abused, even if you recognise that your child isn't deliberately being an abuser.

And you feel trauma from that and are told (in our case) to try mindfulness. Is there any other situation where someone is facing daily violence where that would be the response? Try taking ten minutes out of your day to practice mindfulness to cope with being beaten up and verbally abused.

WhatNoRaisins · 08/03/2024 14:11

It does mean that I'd never take the risk of having a vulnerable family member live with me even temporarily. We no longer trust that if it wasn't working out for whatever reason that we would get any help even if the person wasn't safe. I don't think we should be abusive towards SWs but I completely get why people have to resort to difficult behaviour.