Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD has been removed

457 replies

Flojoloco · 06/03/2024 00:24

DD is 15 with additional needs. Things have been getting progressively difficult. Today she told her social worker that I hit her and there is a bruise on her face so they removed her. There’s a strat meeting tomorrow and I’ve no idea if she’s coming home or not either way it’s a mess. I either lose my DD or she’s at home and I’m scared of her lies. She’s 5’8” and 14+ stone, she has massive temper tantrums/meltdowns and puts holes in doors etc. I have no doubt if I ever hit her she would paste me. She lives a charmed life but she’s not very happy at the moment and that’s impacting massively. I would never hit her. I’ve no idea where the bruise came from. If she bumped her head on something or deliberately smacked herself in her face. I haven’t seen her but the photo on SW phone didn’t look like a bruise, she just looked blotchy. Either way we need help.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
happyhippo24 · 06/03/2024 13:34

pam290358 · 06/03/2024 10:56

Could we please stop with the ‘actions have consequences’ lectures. It’s been pointed out ad nauseam that ND conditions can and do render the person unable to link their actions with the consequences. It’s not bad behaviour for the sake of it, a free pass to be an arsehole, enjoying the attention, or any of the other equally vile suggestions here from people who clearly have no understanding of neurodiversity.

ND typically robs the person of the understanding of socially acceptable behaviour and the resulting behavioural issues are symptoms, not bad behaviour to be punished - any more than you would punish a wheelchair user for the inability to walk. It’s a medical condition - a disability if you want to think of it that way. And as such, the person is deserving of the same understanding and support as is given to other disabled people.

Thank you for saying this

justasking111 · 06/03/2024 13:32

A friend works at a SEN school, 3 to 18 years. She has also run a SEN club for 18 to 25 years for over 20 years.

At the club she runs DofE for the youngsters tootles off in a minibus at lakes mountains. It works well.

Whereas at the SEN school the pupils are mollycoddled, allowed to do what they want for 15 years, then they're thrown back to the parents.

The rules put in place for a healthy child ie no you can't do that, please use a knife, fork, spoon, you don't bite others . If you're non verbal use the signs. All bad behaviour is excused by parents and the school. Friend says that the mollycoddling by the school is a disservice to the child and parent.

There's a mountain of guilt put on the parents by the state.

Todaywasbetter · 06/03/2024 13:28

You have the right to live in a home without fears for your safety, without being beaten and bruised and battered. It’s totally irrelevant whether your daughter wishes you harm or has control over her behaviour. I admire you.

GetBackIntoBedGerald · 06/03/2024 13:23

Flojoloco · 06/03/2024 10:45

She kept saying but you’re her mum, you have PR. I told her that counts for f all when they are having strat meetings behind my back.
I told her I want her seen by a medic and her ‘injury’ assessed as well as the rest of her.

I was crying and shouting and swearing. They have never seen me like that. Maybe they will think I do lose my temper but I was just so frustrated.

It sounds to me like the SW's arse has been handed to her in whatever meetings have been had, and she has been told to backtrack.

She is trying to save face and saying the "You have PR, she is your responsibility" and putting the "blame" on you (not that you have any blame!!)

SummerFeverVenice · 06/03/2024 13:21

Coshei · 06/03/2024 12:19

To be honest I feel for the OP, not her daughter.
We could spend all day debating and disagreeing but at the end of the day the OP is the person suffering some unacceptable behaviour in her own home.
This was not a little lie she dished out, and I thoroughly hope that the OP now gets support for herself in this situation. If the daughter behaves in such ways then she is not fit to live in the family unit at everyone else’s expense and health.

At the end of the day EVERYONE in the home is suffering. OP, DD, all siblings.

You are implying the DD to be institutionalised somewhere like a young offenders prison by saying “If the daughter behaves in such ways, then she is not fit to live in the family unit..”

SummerFeverVenice · 06/03/2024 13:18

@formerspedtherapist
People with ADHD are not unable to comprehend and crucially, extrapolate future consequences. Rather, they legitimately struggle with impulse control whilst intellectually being capable of comprehending such consequences.

Yes, but add the lack of impulse control and difficulty in focussing/forgetfulness of ADHD to Autism that prevents you from reading social cues, understanding social rules, and complete lack of awareness of the reaction to your own behaviour, then you have a potent mix that increases the likelihood you will be among the 25% of autistic persons that literally cannot fathom consequences, especially in socio-behavioural situations.

The DD has both ASD and ADHD.

Rosscameasdoody · 06/03/2024 13:17

Abeona · 06/03/2024 13:04

The disability needs to be diagnosed and treated, as with any other. Not punished.

This is a serious question, because perhaps I've missed something — new developments in this field, maybe. What treatment for ASD do you have in mind?

I ask because I have an adult cousin never formally diagnosed with ASD but very clearly ND and in special education from 6 until 16. Now in his 50s and widely interpreted by HCPs as being ASD but never offered treatment.

There is no one standard treatment but appropriate specialist education, speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, physiotherapy and behaviour management all play a part, but most of these are in conjunction with early intervention, as are various medications. But without a diagnosis I imagine these things would be difficult to access. Below is a link to the National Autistic Society website which you may find useful.

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwi6i_m729-EAxU9ZEEAHTbHD2kQFnoECBwQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.autism.org.uk%2Fadvice-and-guidance%2Ftopics%2Fmental-health%2Fseeking-help&usg=AOvVaw286PQH0m9Dy3W1cUOcWfXv&opi=89978449

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwi6i_m729-EAxU9ZEEAHTbHD2kQFnoECBwQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.autism.org.uk%2Fadvice-and-guidance%2Ftopics%2Fmental-health%2Fseeking-help&usg=AOvVaw286PQH0m9Dy3W1cUOcWfXv&opi=89978449

Mumofoneandone · 06/03/2024 13:17

Is there any way you can get some legal advice as to where you stand? Sounds a nightmare situation and very mixed information.
Good luck

SummerFeverVenice · 06/03/2024 13:15

pootlin · 06/03/2024 12:25

None of this will help OP when she's lying hurt at the hands of her dd.

A support package that includes SEN specialist support for autistic children struggling with challenging behaviour to help reduce it won’t help?

OP understanding that her DD isn’t trying to or deliberately hurting her, won’t help?

A support package that includes carer visits and respitr breaks, won’t help?

A support package that includes psychosocial therapy for the DD, won’t help?

A support package that includes counselling for the siblings, won’t help?

Access to parents of ASD children support groups and classes on ND parenting techniques that work with ASD children, won’t help?

Not worth giving it a go?

TheCloisters · 06/03/2024 13:15

TheCloisters · 06/03/2024 07:50

My sister was like this. Sounds very similar to the OPs child.
One of four girls, a twin, loving home and no trauma has ever been disclosed. She’s been to a lot of therapy and never disclosed anything in family therapy or informally at any other time.
She has additional needs and a diagnosised personality disorder. She was violent towards siblings as a young child even, my mum didn’t shout or smack her. She was understood, loved and supported. They tried to meet needs, get support.
By her teens she was dangerous. I moved out and so did my siblings pretty young. The police often got involved and my parents were ruled by her for years.
He came to a head when she was sectioned for violent behaviour in public. My parents refused to have her back. The pressure on them to was enormous. Social workers said awful things to them, they were guilt tripped so many times. My sisters narrative of being pushed out was fed back. They didn’t wash their hands of her, went to therapy, advocated for her, went to every meeting. It was awful.
It’s actually been the best thing for her, removing the facilitation of her behaviour. She with support for a flat eventually and lives independently, even has a job. I honestly don’t think she could have done this with my parents enabling her to have zero responsibility long term.
Whilst I’m in contact with her it was a massive impact on my childhood. I have actual scars, I had no focus on me and spent a lot of teenage years wandering the streets and staying out to avoid the house. It centred around her. I even missed a major exam once as the police demanded I take her home as a teen.
I hoenstly thing she was more a source of trauma , than the one with the trauma. She had everything she needed and more, and as I said- even she in therapy has only expressed demands and expectations or threats.

I’m going to share my experience again for those coming later and with the view that ND needs omniscient always be understood.
It is quite possible the dd has unmet needs AND is abusive towards her mother. I’m writing this as someone with three false teeth and a facial scar from a sibling with a similar presentation in their teens. It’s not as simple as people are making out, just meeting needs and all behaviours stopping.

OP. Channel your anger first into an email. Get it in writing, and communication in writing rather than the phone. When I took over my sisters care contact for a while this was vital. I was many many times told what I wanted to hear on the phone. It was then denied later. When she was discharged it was amazing what wasn’t recorded, I was gaslit once it was evident they wanted me to take her to my house.

Start by just emailing a summary of events so far as a record, and then state in bullet points why you cannot have her today. If you wish, what would need to be in place for this to happen.

I have no advice apart from being very stubborn, and stating everything in writing. Even if they call you, summarise the conversation and your points and email it. Expect to repeat yourself. I am not safe, she is not safe. Bullet point any questions you have as numbered points. Avoid generalising commentary.

AmethystSparkles · 06/03/2024 13:12

Controversial but people with ASD tend to not be manipulative because our cognitive empathy isn’t very well developed. (Cognitive empathy means we don't understand people’s motives - it isn’t the same as emotional empathy.)

Personality disorders can’t be diagnosed before the age of 18 so they all get diagnosed with ASD instead from what I can see. It’s so insulting for those of us with ASD who absolutely do not seek out drama and attention. We’re usually the victims of people with personality disorders so it kind of stings.

That said, I’m sorry for this situation and am no stranger to abuse. I wish that abuse from child to parent wasn’t ignored but it is.

Beingboredisgoodforyou · 06/03/2024 13:11

I don't understand the legal process followed by the sw for removing your child.
It reads as though she just took her with her when she left. Did the police remove her using their powers of protection? Did the sw apply for an Emergency Protection Order? Did you just agree that she could leave with the sw? If the last one then you have already entered into a s.20 voluntary arrangement because I can't see any other way the sw could legally have removed her except without your voluntary consent. The sw has also been negligent in not arranging for a medical to document the alleged injury. Bruises fade so it's important they're documented by a paediatrician. A sw taking a photo is not evidence. Did you consent to the photo being taken? Get yourself some legal advice.

LeoTheLeopard · 06/03/2024 13:10

hattie43 · 06/03/2024 06:02

I wouldn't want her back . She's nearing an adult age and all you're experiencing will get worse . What if she really hurts you or ramps up the lies saying you've historically abused her , you could end up in prison.

Be grateful to have a breather and really think about your future . Do you want one .

I also agree with this, she obviously is not able to restrain herself either emotionally or physically and I don’t think you should put yourself in harms way.

my strongest advice would be to not have her back until it is safe for you to be around her.

formerspedtherapist · 06/03/2024 13:07

pam290358 · 06/03/2024 12:37

In this one post you’ve demonstrated that you have absolutely no concept of what we’re talking about here, despite the nature of ND being explained and expanded on by people who have experienced similar to the OP.

I’ll have one more go on behalf of everyone you’ve likely offended here with your judgement and lack of understanding. DD absolutely does enjoy the attention her behaviour brings. That is in no way connected with her ability to understand that actions have consequences, because the attention she receives as a result of her behaviour is not a consequence. It’s an effect - instant gratification.

And that’s all she sees. As has already been pointed out, the actual consequence of her behaviour is yet to come - the most likely being her eventual removal from the home. When that comes DD won’t have any idea of why, because her thinking is in terms of ‘if I do x (action) I’ll get y (immediate gratification)’,, not, as you seem to think ‘if I do x (action) I’ll get y (instant gratification)but eventually z (actual consequence of behaviour adversely affecting others)will happen so I’d better stop.

ND conditions typically affect the ability to recognise socially unacceptable behaviours. The behavioural issues are not simply ‘bad behaviour’ but a symptom of the disability and of needs which are as yet undiagnosed and unmet. Until they are and she receives the support she needs, the behaviour will continue. There is no free pass. There is no ‘wake up’ call. Any more than you can issue a wake up call to a physical disability. You treat it and hope for the best outcome to improve quality of life. ND is a disability, and should be treated as such, not punished.

What you're describing correlates more to intellectual disability (low IQ). The students I teach with ID tend to be completely unable to comprehend and extrapolate consequences apart from what is physically in front of them. This is a genuine issue that requires a lot of very specific conditioning.

As for ADHD, there's not much documented link with intellectual deficiency. In fact, students with ADHD can be incredibly perceptive and clever.

People with ADHD are not unable to comprehend and crucially, extrapolate future consequences. Rather, they legitimately struggle with impulse control whilst intellectually being capable of comprehending such consequences.

In my experience as a SPED therapist and someone with ADHD myself, witnessing natural consequences (with a safety net, NOT to a traumatic extent) can actually help with emotionally internalising causal links/consequences.

Rosscameasdoody · 06/03/2024 13:06

Beingboredisgoodforyou · 06/03/2024 12:50

She's 15. It's against the law to place a child in a hostel/supported accommodation.

And yet social services can and do place 14 and 15 year olds in ‘unregulated accommodation’ including hostels. They tend to be children who have high needs and have exhausted the options for other forms of care - residential providers are often unwilling to take in children with these complex needs and local authorities are forced to turn to the unregulated sector as a result. OP’s DD would likely fall into this category if no other placement is found.

Abeona · 06/03/2024 13:04

The disability needs to be diagnosed and treated, as with any other. Not punished.

This is a serious question, because perhaps I've missed something — new developments in this field, maybe. What treatment for ASD do you have in mind?

I ask because I have an adult cousin never formally diagnosed with ASD but very clearly ND and in special education from 6 until 16. Now in his 50s and widely interpreted by HCPs as being ASD but never offered treatment.

Boopydoo · 06/03/2024 13:04

I think you need to make it clear to SW that you are in carer breakdown, you are no longer well enough to care for her.
How soon is your daughter 16, which then means she comes under Adult Social Care?
I am a fellow Mum who last year put her 26 year old into assisted living through being totally worn out. We parents are the easy and cheap option to provide long term care, they will try and not do anything to help at every turn.,

Coshei · 06/03/2024 13:01

Rosscameasdoody · 06/03/2024 12:53

So we should lock away those who are ND, who have learning disabilities or other mental health conditions then ? Yes, the behaviour is unacceptable, but you seem intent on believing that DD has some control over it, when the whole crux of the thread is that if she is ND it’s a symptom of the condition. She’s disabled. The disability needs to be diagnosed and treated, as with any other. Not punished.

Where did I ask for her be locked away? No where.
Maybe consider the OP posting here because her feelings and mental health are as important as her daughters.
As I said hopefully this will initiate some additional support because the current living arrangement is unsustainable in the long run.

Iwasafool · 06/03/2024 12:56

pam290358 · 06/03/2024 10:56

Could we please stop with the ‘actions have consequences’ lectures. It’s been pointed out ad nauseam that ND conditions can and do render the person unable to link their actions with the consequences. It’s not bad behaviour for the sake of it, a free pass to be an arsehole, enjoying the attention, or any of the other equally vile suggestions here from people who clearly have no understanding of neurodiversity.

ND typically robs the person of the understanding of socially acceptable behaviour and the resulting behavioural issues are symptoms, not bad behaviour to be punished - any more than you would punish a wheelchair user for the inability to walk. It’s a medical condition - a disability if you want to think of it that way. And as such, the person is deserving of the same understanding and support as is given to other disabled people.

Consequences don't have to be punishments. If she breaks something e.g. her phone the consequence is she doesn't have a working phone. No one is punishing her it is just a fact.

It is also a fact that her mother also has needs and if their needs are incompatible something has to change. She sounds like she is being violent and intimidating her mother and the OP does not have to just accept that abuse because her daughter can't help it.

I do have experience of working with teenagers with similar problems who were in residential care.

pandarific · 06/03/2024 12:56

wow this thread is triggery for me. Love to hear how people with ND can’t possibly be abusive and, you know, just handwave abuse if it happens to you at their hands?

I’m NC with my sister because she is massively abusive - lying, aggressive, manipulative - you would not believe some of the things she has said and done. She is ALSO ND and traumatised and all the rest - but, so am I, and I’m not an arsehole. Some ND people, like some NT people, are arseholes, and imo if high functioning enough to learn, then ND cannot be used as a free pass for vile behaviour.

I hope op gets the best outcome for her and her daughter.

Rosscameasdoody · 06/03/2024 12:53

Coshei · 06/03/2024 12:19

To be honest I feel for the OP, not her daughter.
We could spend all day debating and disagreeing but at the end of the day the OP is the person suffering some unacceptable behaviour in her own home.
This was not a little lie she dished out, and I thoroughly hope that the OP now gets support for herself in this situation. If the daughter behaves in such ways then she is not fit to live in the family unit at everyone else’s expense and health.

So we should lock away those who are ND, who have learning disabilities or other mental health conditions then ? Yes, the behaviour is unacceptable, but you seem intent on believing that DD has some control over it, when the whole crux of the thread is that if she is ND it’s a symptom of the condition. She’s disabled. The disability needs to be diagnosed and treated, as with any other. Not punished.

Beingboredisgoodforyou · 06/03/2024 12:50

Withinthesewalls · 06/03/2024 08:14

Having undiagnosed additional needs , particularly things like asd/ADHD is very traumatic.

So @Soontobe60 is correct- this is a traumatised child.

I think a lot of posters have a very rose tinted view of how the system works- you can’t just decide you don’t want your 15 year old back and they go and find a lovely residential school/therapeutic foster home for them.

That’s unlikely even if they are removed because you have been abusing them. It costs a fortune, and there are barely any available.

If SS are forced to accommodate them it is nearly always in hostels, or as a first resort with family/ friends.

She's 15. It's against the law to place a child in a hostel/supported accommodation.

IncompleteSenten · 06/03/2024 12:49

They need to put in writing what returning her to you will involve.

Ask them if they are saying that you are a risk to your child then why are they insisting she comes back to you.

Point out they can't have it both ways. Either she's at risk in which case it is irresponsible of them to return her as they have a duty of care to her or they are saying she is not at risk in which case you need that in writing as well as them confirming they have no concerns and will not be involved.

Because what it seems like they're planning to do is return her to you and make you jump through hoops and follow plans and justify yourself because it's cheaper for them to do that than to provide care for her.

cactidream · 06/03/2024 12:45

massive hugs- I had a similar story in my close circle.
the only answer was to let the child go - and for her to see how the life looks like

I know it feels empty, but try to find some entertainment to take your mind out of this situation

she needs to learn the hard way

Rosscameasdoody · 06/03/2024 12:43

pootlin · 06/03/2024 12:25

None of this will help OP when she's lying hurt at the hands of her dd.

That doesn’t make it any the less true, and you can’t fulfil the needs of one person by ignoring the needs of another. It will help in terms of OP understanding that her DD’s behaviour is a symptom of her condition and not deliberate, but I agree, OP needs practical help because she is potentially in harms’ way. Unfortunately it looks as though it’s going to be a long road to access any help if the attitude of the SW is anything to go by.