Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think friend should be doing better by now? It's been two years

63 replies

VividPeachFawn · 05/03/2024 15:52

NC for this one. I've got a friend who's been pouring her heart out for a solid two years about her ex partner leaving her. It was genuinely heart-wrenching for her, and to make matters more complicated, he's now dating AP. From what I've gathered, he told AP he was in an open relationship before getting involved with AP, so I primarily hold him responsible, but AP also shares some part of the blame. The situation is far from ideal.

Dear friend has been keeping a close eye on her ex's new girlfriend online based on the information she's gathered and I believe she's been messaging her. It comes across as a bit obsessive, and I can't help but feel a touch sorry for both of the women. The whole situation is just disheartening.

Dear friend can't seem to stop talking about it. After a full 24 months of hearing the same narrative, we're all quite drained. She pops round now and then to lend a hand, but the conversations inevitably turn into extensive rants about exp and AP. Even over phone/text it often seems she's fishing for comments about how horrible exp is. It's very one-sided, and despite our own work, family, and life troubles, she appears somewhat insensitive to our experiences. She's a SAHM, and he pays her a decent sum, yet she insists there's no time in the day while we're all struggling too. She claims to be in counseling, but it's hard to see any progress. We've offered endless support, and she goes on and on about how hard things are for her but she has never had to work for anything aside from being a mum, which is not a paid job for the rest of us and she gets a full salary from him from what I understand. I believe her bills are paid by him as well.

I'm at a loss for how to help. She's adamant about portraying herself as the victim, but her approach seems to hinder any progress. Frankly, she was always a bit rude about him, even before the separation. I'm torn – should she be in a better state by now, or am I being overly critical? We as her friends can't be the only ones trying to help her forward but if we should be providing more support I would like to.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fordian · 07/03/2024 18:05

Read half, jumped to the end.

A friend of mine's DH left her 16 years ago.

That event still clouds everything about her life; even more traumatic than breast cancer.

She went on and on and on and on about it. We (me plus other friend) got heartily sick if it, especially as she ignored all our well meant advice about things like family finance. She dies at least now admit she'd listened to us a bit more.

He, of course, had OW, now married to her.

But it is exhausting listening to it month after month.

FajitaFajita · 06/03/2024 19:01

I understand this and sympathise - I've been going through something similar with a friend. The difference is she's the one who had the affair and it soon became apparent that her AP was and still is emotionally abusive towards her. She can't leave, her whole life is a mess and it's all I ever hear about from her. She never asks about me or my life. It's a very one sided relationship and I find it very draining. I did tell her a year ago that I couldn't listen to it any more as I felt I had nothing more to add and it was affecting my own mental health. It helped for a while and she stopped talking to me about it but inevitably the topic will still come up. I practice the grey rock method a lot!!
I think you need to be honest with her but in a kind and supportive way.

MissChristie · 06/03/2024 18:47

Hccvrdg · 06/03/2024 09:35

Going against the grain here but I think the info about him paying all her bills etc IS relevant... perhaps if she had to go out to work she'd have less time to sit and obsess about the ex and get herself so worked up!

Agree.

MissChristie · 06/03/2024 18:46

She sounds very stuck and would benefit from trying to propel her own life forward in some way with new experiences, challenges and opportunities. I’d find it all very draining and would distance myself.

HomeIsHardToFind · 06/03/2024 18:39

She needs to get a job or volunteer to fill her time.
Her finances are taken care of and it sounds like she just has too much time on her hands to mope.
Thankfully she is not my friend as I wouldn't have put up with this level of communication about a break up for two years!

Humptydumptybounced · 06/03/2024 18:21

You could buy this book for her ;- https://www.amazon.co.uk/Win-Your-Breakup-That-Away-ebook/dp/B09NCDR3X3

Prawncow · 06/03/2024 18:15

It sounds like she’s stuck in a pattern of venting to you and it’s causing you to resent her. It’s become a very unbalanced relationship. Your role is to listen to her rants and agree. You’ve said it’s draining and it sounds it.

I'm at a loss for how to help

You can’t. You’re not her therapist. Providing an audience for her ‘extensive rants’ isn’t helping her either. It might have been useful 2 years ago, right after it happened. Now it’s become a really bad habit.

Spana20 · 06/03/2024 17:43

She may be depressed or neurodivergent and may need support with her mental health before she can move on?

Caroparo52 · 06/03/2024 10:57

She sounds like a record on repeat and a complete drain on your emotional energy. I would be honest and say that the dialogue between you has to change or you will regretably be taking steps to protect your own mental health by seeing her less.
Think of the situation as a lifeguard who cannot rescue the drowning person who threatens to drown them both.

OrionStridesIn · 06/03/2024 10:17

It's really hard when you have children and therefore a link to the person who treated you so badly. You can't just completely distance yourself from this person who caused so much pain. It's still horrible of course but when there are no children involved you can have a clean break and not need to know anything about the other person's life.

I think it's entirely understandable that only two years on, she still has a lot of anger and pain. And the jealousy on display over the money he is giving her- she is bringing up their child so she is entitled to something, surely? Although by not working in paid employment she is putting herself in a precarious position should he pull the plug on that arrangement.

I totally get as a friend that it's draining and you've a right to say enough and not want to deal with it to this extent. It's unusual for her to be venting to this degree at this stage. But she's not wrong to feel the way she feels. She would be better off trying to move on and build a better life for herself now though.

stopthinkingaboutit · 06/03/2024 09:37

It's a VERY different scenario, but your post reminded me of the end of this clip.

Sometimes you just have to say that enough is enough!

https://youtube.com/shorts/0GdG0nLC56I?si=kbLjJLnSBNSvR6_l

Hccvrdg · 06/03/2024 09:35

Going against the grain here but I think the info about him paying all her bills etc IS relevant... perhaps if she had to go out to work she'd have less time to sit and obsess about the ex and get herself so worked up!

winterplumage · 06/03/2024 09:31

BibbleandSqwauk · 05/03/2024 18:42

One thing I always point out when "bitter" ex wives are brought up on here us that if you've been left with the day to day care of the kids, that's new every day. That didn't happen in the past and is over with. The other parent's absence is a reality every day, every issue where you need to be in two or three places at once, every time you have to bundle the kids in the car to get milk cos you can't leave them at home, every time one of them has a problem and you have to advocate for them or figure out the best approach. Whether it's two years, five or ten that won't change. It's not bitterness to be massively fucked off by that.
Having said that, I do agree that there can be boundaries about how long you vent for and to whom and there's nothing wrong with gently suggesting that she focus on aspects of the situation she does have control over.

I agree with this, also, that it can be traumatic breaking up, especially when cheating was involved. It can take many years to adjust to a new reality.

So, although yes it's getting too much for you, I'd say whatever you decide to say with empathy, emphasise that you understand and care, but feel it would help her as well as you to have set times for venting, but more times for distraction and fun!

WandaWonder · 06/03/2024 09:27

She's obsessed, I couldn't keep up being friends there is only so much understanding people can take

Frazzledatfifty · 06/03/2024 09:24

I agree with everyone advising that you should gently (but firmly) tell her that it is time to move on, and time to change the dynamic of your friendship back to a more equal and jointly supportive footing! And - I wonder if she could do with some CBT therapy/training if she hasn’t had some already - so good for finding coping mechanisms and positive ways of moving forward. Sounds like she could really do with other things to focus on - maybe a challenge of some sort… a sporting event or some charity work if she doesn’t want an actual job. Sounds like she needs to be busier and have more positive things in her life that she can be excited about…

Previousreligion · 06/03/2024 09:22

Well I was still crying at least once a week over my ex after two years. So I don't think it's too long. I grieved for ten years.

On the other hand I wasn't stalking him on Facebook and had no knowledge of his life.

I think I'd tell her bluntly she's really just continuing to harm herself this way. Maybe she doesn't really want to heal at the moment - maybe she feels like this is all she has left to cling to.

I'd encourage her in new hobbies too.

LoreleiG · 06/03/2024 08:22

Your poor friend having a MN thread about her continuing sadness. If you find it boring you don’t have to engage but she can’t just switch off her feelings of grief - it sounds like she can’t cut the guy out of her life either so it’s always there. If only there were grief support sessions for break ups.

I agree with @scribblyscribbles work out what you can change about you rather than trying to change her.

scribblyscribbles · 06/03/2024 08:14

I doubt it will work if you try to have some kind of big chat about this. I’d focus on the one person you can control: you. Tighten up your boundaries. Stop being a willing and satisfying audience. Change the subject every time she brings it up.

DonutHead · 06/03/2024 07:50

Is it a “full salary and all her bills” or is it child maintenance and him paying the mortgage (on a house that he still owns half of and needs to pay towards anyway) and the bills to keep a roof over his DC’s head, while his ex brings them up?

After he had an affair and left her, after she’d made herself financially vulnerable by being a SAHM (which I presume benefited both of them) and she is still providing full-time childcare (that makes his life easier).

Your wording is a hit strange, that’s all.

Notamum12345577 · 06/03/2024 07:31

onemoremile · 06/03/2024 07:14

How can you possibly say it would have been easier if he'd died? That is a dreadful thing to say and incredibly belittling to widows.

My dad, widowed reasonably young, said the same thing (that a marriage breakdown can be harder).

ViciousCurrentBun · 06/03/2024 07:20

I am supporting a friend who is divorcing and it’s coming up to two years, also as her DH had an affair. We do talk about it but not all the time but she has other things jn her life, being a FT secondary school teacher being one of them. She needs somethung else in her life and you need to tell her. I do not mean dating either.

onemoremile · 06/03/2024 07:14

Isthisexpected · 05/03/2024 18:32

This is such a horrible read. There's no time limit on grief and she's still processing everything that happened. If he'd died it actually would have been easier but instead the heartache goes on because he's very much living his new life.

She definitely needs therapy for support to move forward and heal but telling her to get a grip as has been suggested is cold and thoughtless.

How can you possibly say it would have been easier if he'd died? That is a dreadful thing to say and incredibly belittling to widows.

RubiesandRose · 06/03/2024 07:13

My friend was cheated on by her husband repeatedly and it split their marriage up over 25 years ago. At the time she had 2 young kids and was devastated. The devastation became anger and it consumed her. Hating her ex DH and ensuring her kids hated him too was her main focus.

Her diatribes about what he said/did never lessened and it tough to listen to, there was no reasoning with her.

She was a lovely woman, aside of this, funny, loving and kind but as the kids grew up, she found solace in the bottle and then total oblivion, finally passing away 6 years ago.

On reflection I wish I had been tougher and more honest with her instead of hoping a listening ear would allow her to vent it all away. She needed to be told as your friend does to not let him determine her future and to focus on the new life she can create.

FluffyToesMeow · 06/03/2024 06:47

NotestoSelf · 05/03/2024 16:17

Her income/its source etc is irrelevant, and I think you should deal with your own obvious emotions about that. Also, you can't make her move on in her head. What you absolutely can do is tell her that you've heard enough, you feel your relationship has become lopsided from so much listening and empathising, and that you want to return to meetings on a more even footing, where you both take it in turns to talk about your lives.

Really would you honestly say this to a friend?

Livelovebehappy · 05/03/2024 22:11

Tbh, 2 years post separation is no time at all, and most women who’ve been left by their dh are not fully over it in this time frame. It’s hugely traumatic, and some never really heal. But, I would say that your friend should read the audience, and pick who she wants to lean on for support with care. When my dh left me, I got an idea as time went on who I could sometimes rant to when feeling down. Maybe you should just tell her that you’re not really interested in listening to it now. If you vocalise that you’re fed up of hearing about it all now she’s two years down the line, she will then learn not to mention it around you.