Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New baby after SIL lost hers

87 replies

TrishMB · 05/03/2024 15:18

Hi, first time poster here. My SIL and I were pregnant at the same time, sadly she lost her baby. When she lost her baby, DH and I were very respectful, not discussing our pregnancy, not posting any scans/updates into family Wattsapp group, except on the day she was born, didn’t post anything on social media etc.
Since then the MIL has shut us out, had family dinners without inviting us and ignoring our baby. She even refused to hold her at one stage. It’s now been 3 months since she seen us and our children and we had a very close relationship, she even childminded our kids during the week while we worked. She’s blaming grief but I’m finding that hard to accept as I feel it’s unfair she’s punishing us for having our baby. Ignoring our other children is also unfair. Am I being unreasonable to not be understanding?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bloom15 · 05/03/2024 22:07

Namenamchange · 05/03/2024 15:59

I think it’s absolutely shocking that a grandmother won’t hold her grandchild, and no longer sees her 2year old grand daughter. Personally, I’d leave her to it, and have minimal contact in the future, . I wouldn’t invest a huge amount of energy in the relationship, and I’d keep it very casual in the future.

Agreed.

I could understand if this was the SIL but the MIL is bizarre and cruel to the OP's eldest child. I wouldn't foster any other kind of relationship with her and certainly not her and my children

VampireWeekday · 05/03/2024 21:15

Don't let her back into your daughter's life.

skyfalldown · 05/03/2024 20:15

Sounds like MIL is a grief vulture. She doesn't really care about the loss, she only wants to centre her own feelings.

Tryingmybestadhd · 05/03/2024 20:10

I lost a baby last year and know to well how much it hurts , 2 of my Mils went on to have a baby and one about to have a baby in a few weeks and I admit it hurts , but there is no way I hell I would ever not wish them all the best , buy presents for the babies and not be there for them . It’s not your fault , at some stage this will come up and you need to let her know her behaviour is wrong .

DaveOnTheTrain · 05/03/2024 20:07

Maybe the MIL didn't want to hold your baby in front of her daughter, who'd lost hers.
Must have been quite painful for you, but equally hard for the SIL to watch her mum with a grandchild she'd wished to have given her as well.
Perhaps in her mind it was best to refuse at that time.

Zyq · 05/03/2024 19:56

TrishMB · 05/03/2024 16:02

yes we asked, her response was she was grieving.

Did she ignore SIL's children when you had similar losses?

Silvers11 · 05/03/2024 19:54

I’m on Mat leave so didn’t need her to look after 2yo. Although she was taking her 1 day a week up until Xmas. She would text me on a Sunday to tell me what days she could do that week. She stopped doing this. We spent Xmas at theirs with all the family, including the SIL and it was very awkward. That’s when MiL refused to hold baby. I haven’t heard from SIL since and we were close.

@TrishMB So, seems to me, reading your posts, that something else also actually happened, at Xmas. Can't you think of anything that was said/done which has caused MIL to pull back? Where, exactly, did the awkwardness come in? Obviously SIL would have known that you were bringing the baby and thought she could handle it, but it does sound like there is more to this reaction by MIL than you are saying?

Soubriquet · 05/03/2024 19:29

[embarassed] yes. Not my uncle, my brother!

Chonk · 05/03/2024 19:22

Soubriquet · 05/03/2024 16:51

My mother was pregnant at the same time as I was. I found out, called her and she called me back later saying she was too. She felt weird so did a test.

I lost mine a few weeks later whilst she went on to have a healthy pregnancy. I got pregnant again 3 months later. There’s a 6 month gap between my dd and my uncle.

I gave her full congrats and what not because it wasn’t her fault I lost my baby. Yes I was upset and it took me a couple of weeks to grieve but it happened.

Your MiL is being unreasonable

@Soubriquet I'm sorry for your loss. Part of your post has confused me, do you mean there's a 6 month age gap between your daughter and HER uncle? Not your uncle?

HanaJane · 05/03/2024 19:22

Actually I think MIL and SIL are being unreasonable now. I was pregnant at the same time as a good friend, I had a miscarriage at 9 weeks and she went on to have a healthy baby. Yes it was hard but I was also happy for my friend and wouldn't have dreamt of punishing her for being the one who had a baby! Similarly my SIL had a miscarriage while I was pregnant with DD, must have been awful for her but she was still happy for us when DD was born, came to visit etc.
Sometimes life is hard and unfair but you have to deal with it and do the right thing. these two sound very self centered

fruity81 · 05/03/2024 19:06

2mummies1baby · 05/03/2024 18:25

If you think she's a narcissist and she creates that much drama, why do you trust her to look after your child?

i’ve asked a few times… no response 🤷

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 05/03/2024 19:04

Did SIL or MIL ever send you a gift or anything like that?

I would guess that jealousy is at play here. MIL is jealous that everything is going well for you while her own DD is having a really hard time, and she can't stand it. She can't stand to see someone else happy while her own DD is struggling. And she probably has zero boundaries and is quite self centred (I think we overuse the word narcissist) so feels all the feelings as though they are her own.

It's not rational and it's not acceptable behaviour, but I would guess that's why she's behaving the way she is.

It's very hurtful, and it's really sad that you anticipated a support network who have failed to show up for you. MIL won't get that time back with baby grandchild and your relationship will never be the same. Sorry, OP. I hope you start to build your village elsewhere.

2mummies1baby · 05/03/2024 18:25

TrishMB · 05/03/2024 16:18

😂😂 it actually is!! But yes, there is always drama in this family, and always caused by the MiL. She’s a narcissist for sure, and you wouldn’t believe half the things she’s done on her own kids and grandkids! She’s fallen out with everyone of her kids at once stage due to them not “doing what they’re told” 🙄

If you think she's a narcissist and she creates that much drama, why do you trust her to look after your child?

dapsnotplimsolls · 05/03/2024 18:22

MIL is being an absolute arse. Take this as an opportunity to be shot of her and her dramatics forever.

mummyh2016 · 05/03/2024 18:12

They're both being unreasonable. MIL is being ridiculous. SIL I get it would be painful to see you but there is nothing stopping her dropping you a text. I'm not saying weekly but once a month maybe wouldn't hurt anyone. You sound like you've been considerate since her loss so it isn't as though you're going to start sending her pictures and updates of your baby. It's a shame if you were close before like you say.
I'd keep my distance. I'm not saying go NC but I honestly wouldn't bother making the effort at any point in the future.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 05/03/2024 18:12

💐 it's hard, I understand you. Someone you have previously had a good relationship has just ghosted you.

But, could this be a case of loyalty?
She might feel awkward if she goes and sees baby and actually find some joy in having this grand child.

Best is to get DH on board, get him to talk to his mum and sister. Get him to take the 2y old for a spontaneous visit... MIL will soon relise what she's missing!

I was in your SIL situation. Our due dates were only a few weeks apart and seeing this child, is a constant reminder of what I have lost. Even though I have had a my own beautiful baby 18 months later...

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 05/03/2024 18:07

Are you sure they're not using SIL's loss as an excuse and that something else actually happened?

Redglitter · 05/03/2024 18:02

I think they're both behaving badly. I appreciate the SIL has had a miscarriage & that's sad but life does go on. She can't keep taking her loss out on other people.

As for the MIL she should be ashamed. Yes her daughter miscarried but her son has a new baby she's ignoring. She's grieving for a baby she never knew rather than enjoying the new one in her family

Does she always make things about her

SauronsArsehole · 05/03/2024 17:59

TrishMB · 05/03/2024 16:16

14 weeks and this would have been her 6th, she has 5 already

14 weeks is still miscarriage territory. Late miscarriage but not a still birth.

this isn’t to diminish how she is feeling. I’ve had 6 losses from 8 - 16 weeks for all of them and the grieving was the same. The process very similar (one needed a D&C)

but it wasn’t a stillbirth. Stillbirth is very very different as you have to go through Labour and birth iyswim.

when I read your op I did think ouch yes that’s bad as you held a living baby and she held her still born and I’d get the pushing away. But not with this having been there myself.

this is just …. Odd

i think your best bet is to accept life without the in-laws. Discuss with your DH how he is feeling about this and make an active decision about contact not a passive one where you’re being pushed out.

Devilshands · 05/03/2024 17:57

TrishMB · 05/03/2024 16:16

14 weeks and this would have been her 6th, she has 5 already

I don’t know if I am the only one but I find this sort of comment (and previous ones you’ve made) a bit vulgar.

A loss is a loss, regardless of how many children you have. I imagine if you’ve conveyed that thought to MiL it’s not surprising she doesn’t want to see you ATM.

Everyone reacts to a loss differently and this isn’t about you - it’s about SIL who is experiencing her first loss.

britneyisfree · 05/03/2024 17:32

I think they've done you a favour. Be glad you're rid of them both before your two year old is hurt by mil since she upsets everyone.
Sort out childcare for when/if you return to work and be done with it.

Noseybookworm · 05/03/2024 17:32

You can't change your MIL and SIL feelings or reactions. People do grieve differently and the fact that she has other children won't make this loss any less painful. You don't seem to like or have a particularly good relationship with your MIL anyway so I would just concentrate on your own little family and leave them to grieve in their own way. Ultimately, it's their loss if they don't end up having a close relationship with your children.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 05/03/2024 17:19

I would completely ignore your MIL.
Reach out to your SIL and ask her how she is doing [she's got to be busy with 5 kids already]. Tell her your DD is missing her cousin and would she be up for a playdate at yours or a meet up somewhere? That's it's also an opportunity to introduce her to baby X if she feels ready. That you understand from your own experience how hard it can be and if she's not ready yet, that's fine. Reach out when she'd like to catch up. Perhaps over the Easter holidays if it ever stops raining.

Then leave it. No-one can say later that you haven't tried. Move on with life in your own small family.

Beepboops · 05/03/2024 17:02

What @SerenityNowInsanityLater said.

Your MIL shouldn't be making your new baby and 2 year old suffer for her inability to manage her emotions.

It's not your fault that your SIL miscarried yet she seems to think it is.

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 05/03/2024 16:59

How unkind to your little baby who is brand new in the world and already bearing the brunt of a ridiculous, ego-driven, drawn out tantrum carried out by adults who are emotionally inept. I’m so sorry for you OP.
What a joyful arrival. You now have 2 blessings and this is the response? Unbelievable!

I understand grief. Big time. I’ve had miscarriages and a stillborn daughter, so yes, of course it’s sensitive and all the rest. But this isn’t grief. This beyond that. This is cruel. And at this stage, it’s unforgivable. It’s such a powerful message to you on your in law’s part. Be wise and never forget this.

What hurts your SIL is also what will heal her: Life moves on.
And that’s just straight up truth.
She will heal. But at what cost?

Your children should not carry adults’ hostility. I’d give nanny the big swerve. This isn’t love on her part.