Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My DH has hidden his true income from me... but why?!

433 replies

PurpleTrees123 · 05/03/2024 14:25

Together 15 years, married 10 years, 2 kids. we are happy. Name changed but regular mnetter.

Short version:
DH salary is £42.5k.
His commission bumped his income up to £97k last year, but he has never mentioned this.
AIBU to think he should have mentioned this at some point?

Long version:
DH basic salary is currently £42.5k. his monthly income only just covers his share
of the bills, so he rarely has any more left to add to savings pots, pay off
the mortgage etc.

My salary is more than DH's. I am a good saver, so I set aside my savings first,
and then decide what to do with the left over. I might save some more, I might
spend.

We have separate finances (I know this divides opinions on here!) We get paid into our own bank accounts, and then transfer a set amount each month to a joint account. All bills are paid from the joint account. We are then left with our
own pots of money to do as we wish.

Generally this has worked well for both of us as I am a good saver, so despite the fact I earn more, I also will save for big ticket items and pay for those.... new
boiler, holiday, big days out, family meals, theatre tickets etc.

I feel confident that this has been an even split over the years. And for many
years, DH took home more than I did.

Today, the post has been delivered and there are several letters in there. As I went through them, there are 3 letters from the Inland Revenue. 2 letters are in small brown envelopes, nothing unusual.

One of the letters was bigger and had a large window where the name and address is. Through the window, I could instantly see the words, Income: £97,000

I can’t unsee this. I didn’t go looking for this. It’s actually shocking how it is so clear. I guess it’s the way the letter has been drafted and folded, and this info just happened to end up in the window and be so visible.

Now I don’t know what to do… only yesterday we were talking about job hunting and he was saying that he needs to earn more money as he doesn’t like feeling like he always owes me money for things (I just paid for a big holiday out of the savings).

He has potential to earn commission in his role, but at no point has he ever alluded to the fact he has doubled his basic income. All this time I am thinking he earns much less than me, and I have been paying for things out of the savings to make things fairer. His car needed a full service and work done recently and I even offered to pay for that. He didn’t take me up.

I can’t think what he has spent his money on. We have 2 nice cars – we pay for these monthly and I know how much this costs. Our children do lots of activities, but again this is all out of the joint account so I know how much these cost.

We hardly eat out. He doesn’t have a shopping habit, we don’t belong to expensive clubs. We both WFH mostly, and spend all weekends together.

If I can save money each month, then how has he ended up with not enough to even contribute to joint holidays, and say he needs a better paid job?!

I recognise we are financially comfortable, and I am not here for a debate on
WHAT we spend our money on. We both pay into pensions.

AIBU in thinking he should have told me his whole income, rather than let me think he only earns his basic salary. I feel a bit of a mug to be honest.

Or is it none of my business? He hasn’t actually lied… I’ve never asked him what he took home last year. But at the same time, I had no idea his earning potential was that high!

OP posts:
Daisyblue77 · 07/03/2024 21:38

MassageForLife · 05/03/2024 14:38

I bet if a woman posted saying that she earns £42.5k, but for whatever reason that only just covers half the bills, and that her husband earns more, should she tell him about her bonus - she would get a very different response on here.

She would be advised to have her own savings account.

Its not about having savings, its about lying ans making the other partner pay for all big things, the boiler , holidays ect;

Blondeshavemorefun · 07/03/2024 18:10

Not good he lied about commission

But I would want to know what the other debts were that he paid off

WoodBurningStov · 07/03/2024 16:32

I'd absolutely have it out with him. I'd be wanted to know why he's happy for your to pay all the big ticket items when he's earning about the same as you.

MassageForLife · 07/03/2024 16:26

Tokenmale56 · 07/03/2024 16:24

I can't bear the suspense. I need to know if he's hiding money or it's just a scam letter or whatever.

There is an easy solution to that.

RTFT. Just the ops posts will do.

Tokenmale56 · 07/03/2024 16:24

I can't bear the suspense. I need to know if he's hiding money or it's just a scam letter or whatever.

WineThirty · 07/03/2024 16:08

I agree that the lack of transparency is a huge problem and that you need to discuss this in much more detail.
In a scenario where bills are covered and you both earn enough to cover optional spending at a level you are both happy with and you are saving overall, I don't see a problem with having separate bank accounts, so long as there is transparency and all money is treated as family money even if technically some is in accounts in one name, some in the other and some in joint.

After all, ISAs and pensions can only be in one name, so i am not sure why it should be different for other savings. In fact, it is better to spread savings between different banks and different names to ensure maximum protection under government deposit protection scheme in a financial crisis and maximise access to good deals etc.

Like you, DH and I started off earning similar amounts. When we bought a house together (pre marriage), we set up a joint account for bills but kept our own accounts. After we got married and my earnings started increasing relative to his, I offered that we put everything into a joint account but he did not see a reason for that. I also suggested that a few more times over the years but he has never seen the need.
Over time he reduced his hours so he was there more for the DCs and so we agreed he would stop his payment to the joint account and I increased mine. I also paid mortgage (after a house move), childcare and most other costs relating to the DC directly and funded ISA and pension contributions for both of us (or enabled him to contribute more to his own pension by picking up other stuff). I also have a couple of savings accounts but he knows how much I earn and if he is falling short for some reason, he spends from the joint account or asks me to transfer him some money. i transfer money to him or into the joint account periodically anyway (not least because it is easier for him to book holidays and pay tradesmen etc because he is around more). I know that if we were to divorce he could be entitled to half of everything but in fact because i have made some investments in his name and house is jointly owned etc, we are not far off 50:50 of assets anyway. The idea that he is financially abused or that we are not a partnership is laughable.

I can, though, see that it is not the same for everyone, particularly where people are struggling even to cover bills or where one does not have much left once the bill are are paid but the other does and does not share it in some way. Clearly the scenario that needs to be avoided is where one has a lifestyle which involves buying designer clothes and the other one cant afford any new clothes - I can see that a joint account helps avoid that, although frankly someone selfish enough to do that probably would not agree to a joint account anyway. But DH and I enjoy the same lifestyle without needing all money to be in one account.

LouDeLou · 07/03/2024 13:55

This just stinks to high heaven. You know it. No one doubles their salary and not tell their wife...no one!

NonPlayerCharacter · 07/03/2024 12:25

Pushtart · 07/03/2024 12:15

you don't have to merge finances completely, but to most people I know marriage is a partnership, shared costs is part of it and obviously in a divorce everybody gets half pretty much so it seems like its a good way to organise things when actually married too. I think hiding anything, is not a sign of a good partnership, especially if it's finances. Honestly I get annoyed if my partner hides chocolate for himself!

Well legally it's a contract to merge finances and assets and it gives you rights to that end that aren't fully reproducible in any other way.

So if you don't want to merge your money and indeed can't see why anyone would be so "obsessed" as to do it (not your words, I know), the question is why you'd get married!

Pushtart · 07/03/2024 12:15

you don't have to merge finances completely, but to most people I know marriage is a partnership, shared costs is part of it and obviously in a divorce everybody gets half pretty much so it seems like its a good way to organise things when actually married too. I think hiding anything, is not a sign of a good partnership, especially if it's finances. Honestly I get annoyed if my partner hides chocolate for himself!

NonPlayerCharacter · 07/03/2024 11:12

ThatCheekyKoala · 07/03/2024 10:53

Why are people so obsessed with completely merging finances when you get married? I earn more than my husband (neither of us high earners though) and we both contribute the same towards joint account where all bills come from. The rest stays in our own accounts. Because I have more money left after bills than DH, I pay for the vast majority of kids stuff: clothes including school uniform, shoes, activities, presents, birthday parties, presents for friends, etc. If we go out for a meal sometimes I’ll pay, sometimes my husband will, sometimes we’ll use the joint account.

For the most part I think it’s perfectly fair, but neither of us really has much money left once everything is said and done, if one of us had loads of money left I guess that would be unfair. But alas, we don’t 😂 The only thing that annoys me is that DH seems to have no clue how much all these kid related things cost and always acts surprised if I say I can’t afford to pay for something because I spent all my money on the kids 🙄 I guess if he knew how much kids actually cost we wouldn’t have had 3 though, and I quite like them all so I’m glad he was clueless 😂

Why are people so obsessed with completely merging finances when you get married?

Do you know what marriage is?

ThatCheekyKoala · 07/03/2024 10:53

Why are people so obsessed with completely merging finances when you get married? I earn more than my husband (neither of us high earners though) and we both contribute the same towards joint account where all bills come from. The rest stays in our own accounts. Because I have more money left after bills than DH, I pay for the vast majority of kids stuff: clothes including school uniform, shoes, activities, presents, birthday parties, presents for friends, etc. If we go out for a meal sometimes I’ll pay, sometimes my husband will, sometimes we’ll use the joint account.

For the most part I think it’s perfectly fair, but neither of us really has much money left once everything is said and done, if one of us had loads of money left I guess that would be unfair. But alas, we don’t 😂 The only thing that annoys me is that DH seems to have no clue how much all these kid related things cost and always acts surprised if I say I can’t afford to pay for something because I spent all my money on the kids 🙄 I guess if he knew how much kids actually cost we wouldn’t have had 3 though, and I quite like them all so I’m glad he was clueless 😂

Mrsgreen100 · 07/03/2024 10:33

Omg this is what my ex did , I covered all holidays school fees groceries etc for 20 years , I was also lied to
in my experience it’s the tip of the ice burgh
hes basically stealing your wealth
i would want to see all his earnings history since being together, betting his got huge pension and secret savings to boot .
he is a liar
and has been using you
awful you need to sort this and see everything
mot would be game over for me

Beautiful3 · 07/03/2024 10:05

If you're married, just put your money together. Then you can see what you have, and what's left over.

drxyz · 07/03/2024 10:03

I guess this is what happens when you have separate bank accounts in a marriage.

Sounds very odd though that income was actually visible through an envelope.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 07/03/2024 09:55

His take home pay after taxes and no is £65,487. You fell into the trap of you have your money and I have mine. If you want to avoid arguments you put it together.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 07/03/2024 09:48

supercalafragilisticexpealidocious · 07/03/2024 07:42

You must be reading the wrong thread. That's precisely the opposite of what she did. She had savings in her name but all savings were for her family to cover holidays and pay for extras. She believed she was doing this because she was the higher earner. Bills and normal outgoings were split equally. What has actually happened is that her husband earned the same as her but has been lying to her that he earned far less and has been letting her spend her extra money on him and the family. His extra money seems to have disappeared into a black hole.

More fool her then for agreeing to that set up.

SpatulaSpatula · 07/03/2024 09:20

I don't think you've been abusive, but I've recently started earning a lot more and it has made me rethink things. Previously I only earned a little more and it seemed fine to organise our finances as you do. But now I've realised it means my partner is always pushed to the limits of his income by decisions I make. Like, will we buy on the vine tomatoes or classic salad tomatoes, but across ever single decision. Especially with things like holidays, where I'm treating us to something extra nice, when maybe he would feel more comfortable spending less on the holiday and more on replacing his dead elastic boxers or simply more towards the mortgage. It's controlling without meaning to be and I think would be seen differently if the genders were reversed. It can't be nice to feel as though you can't contribute to your family, that everything from the children's clothes to summer holidays are just mummy's treats, and actually if cheaper choices were made, maybe he could. (We plan to change our set up once my finances are a bit more predictable, and in the meantime I'm just paying a bit extra into our shared account and trying to be more frugal.)

Your partner has been really dishonest. Maybe he was feeling controlled, maybe, for the first time, he was going to get his head above water and he's been ashamed about his situation, but whatever it is, you have to press him on it. That's double his salary, and it can't just disappear on small debts. They'd have to be big debts. If they were, why didn't you know about them? Does he think paying for shared costs just isn't his responsibility? Where has all that money gone? It sounds like his sneakiness might be hiding real incompetence with money, and in fact your arrangement might have to continue to protect your family money, but with greater openness and more input from him about what he thinks are reasonable expenses.

MarlenaGru · 07/03/2024 09:15

one thing to be aware of is even if your savings are split he’s entitled to half if you divorce. Slightly frustrating when one of your spends all your money on the kids, a pension pot or saving for the family and the other buys things for himself. The pots all get shared and the things are worthless.

alanet · 07/03/2024 09:14

This doesn't make sense, you say you have separate finances but pay bills from a joint account. You also say that everything is split 50/50 but then lots of other things, cars, holidays, raising children, all come from your savings account that only you contribute to, this doesn't sound very 50/50 to me. What were his small debts he paid off?

Not splitting everything 50/50 makes sense when earnings are unequal but it seems unfair to be concealing income then offering to pay for some things, saying you're unable to contribute to others, whilst your partner has no idea how much you've actually made.

Firethehorse · 07/03/2024 08:56

To answer your question OP your husband has been lying to you so that he can keep a significant amount of money without your knowledge. He has done this so that you will pay for his holidays, his share of any significant outgoings and his share of your children’s large presents etc. I think you are an intelligent woman and I think you do know this but quite rightly it’s a bitter pill to swallow after 15 years and two children. Now your eyes have been opened, but only courtesy of HMRC, it must be clear to you that he will not have earned zero commission ever, so has been lying to you for a long time and had absolutely no intention of changing this deceitful arrangement. ‘A chat’ can not be relied on, he has lied to you by omission for at least two years and probably much, much longer. If you choose to stay with someone who has treated you this way you would be wise to consider setting down rules where he shows you pay slips etc ongoing. Personally I could not look at my husband in the same way after this. Do not downplay this or laugh it off as him being a bad saver. He is a grown man with a wife and children; his behaviour has been disgraceful and he was not going to tell you, he simply got found out.

CeriseMix · 07/03/2024 08:45

The OP ask us “Why?” in her opening post. The problem is that no one can answer that - except OP and DH. 15 pages of wasted contributions really …

gamerchick · 07/03/2024 08:14

decionsdecisions62 · 07/03/2024 04:30

I don't know why people act so surprised when they find these things out if they have separate bank accounts in a marriage. It seems to me that there is a problem from the very beginning if you don't want to share the finances.

The first thing is you haven't seen the whole letter. You are speculating. Try good old fashioned straightforward communication and transparency.

When you've spent many years visitng places like Mumsnet you soon realise you would have to be a total fool to completely share finances like that. Always retain a little bit of independence because things can go tits up no matter how many years in you are. Who in their right mind wouldn't keep a bank account of their own?

It doesn't mean there's an issue. It's just common sense.

rainydays03 · 07/03/2024 07:53

decionsdecisions62 · 07/03/2024 04:30

I don't know why people act so surprised when they find these things out if they have separate bank accounts in a marriage. It seems to me that there is a problem from the very beginning if you don't want to share the finances.

The first thing is you haven't seen the whole letter. You are speculating. Try good old fashioned straightforward communication and transparency.

Why does there have to be a problem from
the beginning if you don’t have only a joint bank account?

supercalafragilisticexpealidocious · 07/03/2024 07:42

Carpediemmakeitcount · 07/03/2024 07:29

I am torn before you didn't want to share extra money but as soon as you find out he has more your eyes widen.

You must be reading the wrong thread. That's precisely the opposite of what she did. She had savings in her name but all savings were for her family to cover holidays and pay for extras. She believed she was doing this because she was the higher earner. Bills and normal outgoings were split equally. What has actually happened is that her husband earned the same as her but has been lying to her that he earned far less and has been letting her spend her extra money on him and the family. His extra money seems to have disappeared into a black hole.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 07/03/2024 07:29

I am torn before you didn't want to share extra money but as soon as you find out he has more your eyes widen.