Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask parents/carers to control toddlers in shops?

161 replies

TheOtherMrs · 05/03/2024 13:33

Just been to do a quick shop with DH. A small child came running around a corner straight in to DHs legs. The child's mother went ballistic, screaming into DHs face about looking where he was going and threatening to hit him - she hadnt even seen what had happened!. Fortunately the child was fine and a shop assistant calmed her down, stating that DH wasn't in the wrong and that perhaps using the child seat in the trolley for the child, rather than bread, was the way forward.

It surely not too much to ask that children be properly looked after in busy shops?

OP posts:
VivaVivaa · 05/03/2024 20:02

iverpickle · 05/03/2024 19:42

Somewhere along the line parents seem to have been taught that physical touch is almost always inferior to spoken language.
A parent should ask with words, but ultimately cannot physically move their child because this is a violation of the child's bodily autonomy.

The idea that parents make some decisions, and toddlers go along with them, even if they are explaining what is happening to their child at the time, is now seen as wrong.
It doesn't matter that a toddler can't comprehend, as long as a parent doesn't physically make a child do anything they appear not to want to do.

Some parents go so far as to feel sorry for children who aren't free to fully express themselves, moving in the space, lying on the floor, touching the objects that surround them. They feel that it's their right to experience the world around them, without limits.

I've seen a parent sitting down on the floor of the supermarket in the middle of an aisle, asking whether her toddler, who was doing a sort of snow angel, thought it was time to go home yet.
These parents feel that if they upset their child in any way that they are bad parents, and it's a shame, because little toddlers should be allowed to cry to express their upset and unhappiness and yes, lack of understanding of a complex world, just as they did a few months back when they were tired and hungry babies in arms.

This narrative stinks. Yeah, some parents are too permissive and their children need to be better controlled. This isn’t some new phenomena, there were parents/kids like this when I was growing up in the 80s/90s. The majority of current parents haven’t changed and are more than prepared to physically remove their small children from dangerous/annoying/inconvenient situations. The small minority of parents who are too permissive have just been given a bigger platform, and likewise the people who complain about these parents have also been given a bigger platform. Of the 10s and 10s of parents I come across weekly with pre schoolers, the vast majority are more likely to pick up and carry out their snow angel-ing 2 yo then barter with them.

BCBird · 05/03/2024 20:01

A supermarket is not a playground

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 05/03/2024 19:59

Once again parents failing to parent or teach children the appropriate behaviour. If a child cannot behave in public because the parents cannot be arsed to teach or supervise them then tough shit if the child gets hurt.

SarahAndQuack · 05/03/2024 19:46

Oh, come on.

It was just an accident.

The mum was being daft, but honestly, with this thread, so are you.

Thehonestbadger · 05/03/2024 19:45

My 2.5yo loves to run around with me shopping BUT I go at quiet off peak times and I’m always very apologetic if she does cross paths with anyone. I’m a ‘I’m so sorry, DD look where you are going you almost ran into that person’ type of mum.

Ultimately kids needs to learn to negotiate life and they don’t do that being constantly restrained. My mother is an academic in the field of early childhood development and frequently comments on how ‘consistently physically restrained’ small children are in modern society verses when she was a child. It’s much less acceptable to have small children in day to day life now than it was then.

Don’t get me wrong, the parents letting a 1yo scan stuff on a self check out at midday on a Saturday are douchebags but 10am on a Wednesday or 6pm on a Monday…that’s fine. It’s like being a learner driver, maybe avoid rush hour but everyone has to learn 😂😬

iverpickle · 05/03/2024 19:42

Somewhere along the line parents seem to have been taught that physical touch is almost always inferior to spoken language.
A parent should ask with words, but ultimately cannot physically move their child because this is a violation of the child's bodily autonomy.

The idea that parents make some decisions, and toddlers go along with them, even if they are explaining what is happening to their child at the time, is now seen as wrong.
It doesn't matter that a toddler can't comprehend, as long as a parent doesn't physically make a child do anything they appear not to want to do.

Some parents go so far as to feel sorry for children who aren't free to fully express themselves, moving in the space, lying on the floor, touching the objects that surround them. They feel that it's their right to experience the world around them, without limits.

I've seen a parent sitting down on the floor of the supermarket in the middle of an aisle, asking whether her toddler, who was doing a sort of snow angel, thought it was time to go home yet.
These parents feel that if they upset their child in any way that they are bad parents, and it's a shame, because little toddlers should be allowed to cry to express their upset and unhappiness and yes, lack of understanding of a complex world, just as they did a few months back when they were tired and hungry babies in arms.

Daisymae55 · 05/03/2024 19:38

My dd loves a wonder around the supermarket. But if she was at the point of charging off and into people she’d absolutely be in the trolley. But the fact this woman yelled at your DH is ridiculous. I’d be mortified and apologising like crazy if my 2 year old charged into someone. Woman sounds horrible

Wellhellooooodear · 05/03/2024 19:37

You've had a one off incident with a dick parent. Let's not tar everyone with the same brush eh.

onawave · 05/03/2024 19:35

Mine have 2 choices, they walk properly and I get them to help getting what we need or they go in the trolley and they can complain as much as they want, so I have been the woman in Tesco with 2 wailing banshees strapped in a trolley. I would be mortified if they were tearing about the place and knocked someone over.
Or, I do the shopping while they are at nursery then slop off to Costa for a coffee in peace at the same time.

lazyarse123 · 05/03/2024 19:32

I work in a small supermarket and we have stupid flag things hanging from the ceiling, no danger to anyone unless they're nearly 7 foot tall. But I had a boy of about 10 running and jumping trying to grab them while his dad stood there oblivious. I eventually asked his dad to stop him because we have a lot of elderly customers. We got the usual "Tarquin please don't do that the lady wants you to stop" wtf is wrong with people. Control your brats it's not a playground.

Maray1967 · 05/03/2024 19:31

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 05/03/2024 15:46

If a running child bumped into my FIL’s legs, where he has bone cancer that is weakening the bones, he could well end up with a fracture that would never heal, and would put him in a wheelchair, and he wouldn’t live long after that.

If they run into an elderly person who has a fall, that could cause a hip fracture, requiring surgery and a long stay in hospital, and could well result in a previously independent person having to have a lot of care and support.

There are plenty of places for children to run around and have fun, but in my opinion, a supermarket/shop is not one of those places.

Well said.

To those posters who are saying that they kept an eye on their toddlers who
love to wander around - Tesco is not the park. Put them in the trolley or strap them in reins so they are right next to you. You should be absolutely certain that they are not able to run into someone. Neither of mine were allowed to go wandering around the supermarket. It is not a playground.

TheOtherMrs · 05/03/2024 19:31

LlynTegid · 05/03/2024 19:25

Children can misbehave, it happens. What is not OK is a parent not being prepared to accept that something unacceptable has happened and seeking to blame others.

This. It wasn't the child running into DH that was the problem, it was his mother's reaction. The accident could have been avoided if she'd held his hand or used the child seat in the trolley.

OP posts:
VivaVivaa · 05/03/2024 19:29

Ive seen small kids run in public places and DS1 has done a handful of times before I could grab him and put him in trolley/put reins on. I think that’s part and parcel of small children and, whilst annoying, can happen to any parent.

What’s clearly abnormal in this situation is the mother’s reaction. Surely that’s where your anger should be? If DS1 has ran into your DH I’d be mortified and apologise, which I reckon (maybe hope?) 99% of the population would do!

Catsmere · 05/03/2024 19:29

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 05/03/2024 15:46

If a running child bumped into my FIL’s legs, where he has bone cancer that is weakening the bones, he could well end up with a fracture that would never heal, and would put him in a wheelchair, and he wouldn’t live long after that.

If they run into an elderly person who has a fall, that could cause a hip fracture, requiring surgery and a long stay in hospital, and could well result in a previously independent person having to have a lot of care and support.

There are plenty of places for children to run around and have fun, but in my opinion, a supermarket/shop is not one of those places.

This is what pisses me off when visitors let their kids run around the retirement village I live in. Most of the people here are unwell or unsteady enough to use walking sticks or walkers, the paths are very narrow, but there are some family members who seem to think it's a playground.

Motheroffourdragons · 05/03/2024 19:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on behalf of the poster.

TheOtherMrs · 05/03/2024 19:26

Allfur · 05/03/2024 19:06

Hou could always get your shopping delivered

Yep. Next time we run out of butter I'll bear that in mind.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 05/03/2024 19:25

Children can misbehave, it happens. What is not OK is a parent not being prepared to accept that something unacceptable has happened and seeking to blame others.

TheOtherMrs · 05/03/2024 19:23

Coldsore · 05/03/2024 19:00

It’s one of those:

I always hold my toddler/children’s hands, and this isn’t something that happens to me but

the Uk is so child intolerant and some of these comments are stupid. I never let my children walk on low down walls as I think it’s inconsiderate but I remember the joy of doing it as a child and wonder if social conditioning to respond to Karens means my children are missing out on small pleasures. If a child (not mine) bumped into me in the supermarket I can’t think I would mind at all.

I stopped reading as soon as you mentioned "Karens".

OP posts:
JSMill · 05/03/2024 19:23

I can't believe how many parents allow their children to run around supermarkets. I have recently recovered from a trapped nerve and when I was poorly, sudden movements caused a lot of pain. Therefore when I had to move quickly out of the way of children running around, it caused me a lot of pain. It made me think of how it must be for old people who suffer from various aches and pains and have to worry about children running into them.

thefallen · 05/03/2024 19:22

Allfur · 05/03/2024 19:06

Hou could always get your shopping delivered

That's right, just don't leave your house rather than expecting parents to hold their children's hands or otherwise stop their kids running riot.

OP YANBU.

TheOtherMrs · 05/03/2024 19:20

PotterHead1985 · 05/03/2024 16:47

Whilst yes anything can happen at any time and we take calculated risks (assuming you don't know you have a condition that causes you to faint) this is not the same. A stationery shoe rack isn't likely to suddenly grow legs and come flying round a corner and into the surprised legs of someone else.

If a child did that to my elderly mother and her walker she would be flat on her back, most likely injured and definitely carted off to hospital (blood thinners). Are you saying my poor mother should never leave the house again, just so some lazy person can decide NOT to parent their child and use the supermarket as a playground whilst she babies her loaf of bread in the child seat of the trolley?

And to the OP your hubs is a very decent man because I'd have been right back in that stupid cows face if it had been me she was screaming at and threatening to hit.

DH has the patience of a Saint! I think both of us were too shocked to react at the time but we were both shaken by the incident.

OP posts:
TheOtherMrs · 05/03/2024 19:13

DysmalRadius · 05/03/2024 13:40

Sounds like the parent was the problem, not the toddler.

Yep, she seemed to have a loose connection somewhere!

OP posts:
IgoogledYOLO · 05/03/2024 19:11

I can't physically lift my (young) 3 yo into the trolley. I'm vertically challenged and they are getting too big now.

Agree with pp, the kid might not have been a problem but the mum was for sure.

If the child is known to be wild then yes, they should be in trolley/harness. Otherwise, they are still learning and blips happen.

Axcis · 05/03/2024 19:08

My toddler used to grab onto any man's leg. Sometimes headbutting the nads. But it was early 2000s and we both would laugh it off.

Allfur · 05/03/2024 19:07

*you