Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask parents/carers to control toddlers in shops?

161 replies

TheOtherMrs · 05/03/2024 13:33

Just been to do a quick shop with DH. A small child came running around a corner straight in to DHs legs. The child's mother went ballistic, screaming into DHs face about looking where he was going and threatening to hit him - she hadnt even seen what had happened!. Fortunately the child was fine and a shop assistant calmed her down, stating that DH wasn't in the wrong and that perhaps using the child seat in the trolley for the child, rather than bread, was the way forward.

It surely not too much to ask that children be properly looked after in busy shops?

OP posts:
Springtimesunshinesun · 07/03/2024 13:29

What am I missing? Unless you were both going like Usain Bolt and the child stopped suddenly.

K0OLA1D · 07/03/2024 13:23

Springtimesunshinesun · 07/03/2024 13:13

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius Re vulnerable people honestly being knocked down by rampaging toddlers though? I know that looks really sarky written down - it isn’t meant to be but it’s a bit like dog threads where dogs are running amok up and down the country and ruining picnics and terrifying small children - these things do get a bit daft where a running two year old suddenly becomes a thing to be feared and avoided at all costs.

And no one is advocating strapping them in for their own safety, it’s to stop them getting out.

My DN aged 2, stopped directly in front of my DM the other day. DM fell forwards and fell ontop of DN. Thankfully they were both OK as DM held her weight off her. If that was me, the kid would have had all 12.5 stone of my full weight on top of them. So it's not just for my safety

Springtimesunshinesun · 07/03/2024 13:13

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius Re vulnerable people honestly being knocked down by rampaging toddlers though? I know that looks really sarky written down - it isn’t meant to be but it’s a bit like dog threads where dogs are running amok up and down the country and ruining picnics and terrifying small children - these things do get a bit daft where a running two year old suddenly becomes a thing to be feared and avoided at all costs.

And no one is advocating strapping them in for their own safety, it’s to stop them getting out.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/03/2024 12:16

If a child is in the buggy, I'd expect them to be strapped in, for safety reasons, @Springtimesunshinesun - so as long as they aren't being left in the buggy all day/most of the time, I don't see the problem with them being strapped into it in the supermarket.

And it isn't the only option available for parents to stop their children running amok in the shops - they can use the child seat on the trolley, or reins, or hold their child's hand, or insist they hold onto the trolley. They can involve the child in the shopping, whilst making sure they aren't running around bashing into other shoppers or risking hurting themselves on the corners of shelves, trolleys or baskets.

Surely that is a reasonable compromise that allows parents to go shopping with their children and vulnerable people to shop without the risk of being knocked over and potentially badly hurt.

Springtimesunshinesun · 07/03/2024 12:00

Well, normal life isn’t being strapped into a buggy!

I do sometimes wonder what the ‘strap them into a buggy’ parents do long term. My DS is 3 and hasn’t been in a buggy since last summer and that was only because I was heavily pregnant at the time .

AllesAusLiebe · 07/03/2024 10:30

Oh dear, there are some embarrassing responses on this thread. "If I strap my child into the trolley, they'll scream", "he hates the buggy", "she likes to wander around".

FFS just do your shopping and go about your business. If darling child hates shopping and/or being kept safe and out of other people's way - tough! They're kids and have to learn to integrate into normal life. Don't inconvenience other people because of your weird desire to pander to your kid's every whim and be their best mate.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 07/03/2024 09:05

mathanxiety · 06/03/2024 18:12

What about a buggy?

He was in a pushchair a lot. But the other side was I wanted him to walk in the hope he'd nap at a sensible time. If I didn't wear him out he'd stubbornly stay awake until 4pm then sleep until 7pm and then bedtime was screwed.

Plus he was running around like that until he was about 7. Eventually turned out he's autistic, and very, very sensory seeking.

K0OLA1D · 06/03/2024 18:38

Moglet4 · 06/03/2024 14:26

I do have old, frail people in my life and if a 2 year old toddling into them would cause them such serious injury then yes, I would advise they avoid supermarkets because guess what? Children are part of society too. I am not referring to screeching, scooting 6 year olds who of course shouldn’t be behaving like that in a supermarket; the lady who the vitriol was directed at also had a tottering 2 year old so the reaction towards her imo was extreme and hyperbolic. I don’t even recognise most of the behaviour described on here - if this sort of thing happened in the supermarkets around me, it would be a notable one off. Maybe I’m just lucky or maybe some of the people on these threads are just descended from Dahl’s witches!

Cool. As a 33 year old, (if a 2 yo ran into the backs of my legs and I fell over, would cause me serious injury) I'll just stop going into morrisons in case some knob head can't control their kids

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 06/03/2024 18:33

@Moglet4 - my FIL values the social interactions he gets when he goes shopping - and I’m sure he is not alone. By saying vulnerable or frail people should not go out to the shops, you will be increasing their isolation and loneliness, and this is a killer for people.

I think it is perfectly reasonable to expect parents and carers to make sure their children don’t run around in supermarkets and treat them as playgrounds. It is hazardous for them and for other people. I don’t expect children to behave perfectly, nor do I expect parents to have them under perfect control all of the time - we are all only human, after all - but everyone has a right to be able to use shops/supermarkets safely.

The solution to having both frail or vulnerable people and parents with kids in supermarkets is a bit of tolerance and understanding on BOTH sides. Those of us without young children need to understand that children won’t behave perfectly all the time so we need to keep an eye out for the odd running toddler, but the parents of young children need to do their best to stop their kids treating the supermarket like a playground. Heaven forbid, but some of them might have to tell their little darling that they can’t ride their scooter or bike in the shops, and that running around everywhere is not a good idea.

mathanxiety · 06/03/2024 18:17

Coldsore · 05/03/2024 20:54

Men can be Karens too. But it’s women mostly complaining on this thread, I would hazard a guess. In fact most people in my day to day life I see complaining are women. There was a thread on MN last week about men hating women but in reality it seems to be women hating women always.

again, I wouldn’t let my children do this. They hold hands or they are carried/strapped in. I just think this thread is totally crazy and some of the comments have made me laugh.

people here are so sensitive and understanding about literally any ailment or age, except for children and toddlers. It’s hilarious!

A lot of us have done our time in the trenches and we have little patience for people who have no regard for the safety of their own toddlers or small children.

Also, it's the term Karen that's problematic, not the fact that it's applied to women. Saying men can also be Karens doesn't make it less offensive.

mathanxiety · 06/03/2024 18:14

SausageRoll58 · 06/03/2024 13:33

I also hate seeing kids actually sitting in the supermarket trolleys with their dirty shoes and sticky hands. GET YOUR KIDS OUT OF THE TROLLEY AND MAKE THEM WALK! It's a food trolley, not a buggy!

But the food is packaged, and the trollies are often parked outside where birds can poop on them and rodents can run all over them.

mathanxiety · 06/03/2024 18:12

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 06/03/2024 14:54

DS used to be a nightmare in our small Tesco's - no full sized trolley to strap him into or I would have. Luckily he never ran into anyone, but a quick trip to get a few essentials would be so stressful.

And he was like that everywhere, he never stopped. Local cafe - running around. Toddler group - when the other children were sitting down singing he was doing laps of the hall.

What about a buggy?

MissyB1 · 06/03/2024 16:17

Moglet4 · 06/03/2024 14:26

I do have old, frail people in my life and if a 2 year old toddling into them would cause them such serious injury then yes, I would advise they avoid supermarkets because guess what? Children are part of society too. I am not referring to screeching, scooting 6 year olds who of course shouldn’t be behaving like that in a supermarket; the lady who the vitriol was directed at also had a tottering 2 year old so the reaction towards her imo was extreme and hyperbolic. I don’t even recognise most of the behaviour described on here - if this sort of thing happened in the supermarkets around me, it would be a notable one off. Maybe I’m just lucky or maybe some of the people on these threads are just descended from Dahl’s witches!

2 year olds don’t always “toddle” they often run - very fast!

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 06/03/2024 14:54

mathanxiety · 06/03/2024 04:28

Accidents like that only happen when toddlers are not firmly buckled into a trolley. They're predictable and completely avoidable.

DS used to be a nightmare in our small Tesco's - no full sized trolley to strap him into or I would have. Luckily he never ran into anyone, but a quick trip to get a few essentials would be so stressful.

And he was like that everywhere, he never stopped. Local cafe - running around. Toddler group - when the other children were sitting down singing he was doing laps of the hall.

Moglet4 · 06/03/2024 14:26

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 06/03/2024 13:11

One day you, or someone you love, might be elderly and/or vulnerable, @Moglet4, and I am sure you will want them or you to be able to carry on living a normal life. Why should my elderly FIL have to shut himself away from everyone, and take away the social contact that he has (and that makes life worth living) so that parents don't have to stop their children running round in a supermarket?

Are you honestly suggesting that all elderly, frail or vulnerable people should be shut away from normal life, so that children can be allowed to run riot wherever they are?

In the OP, @TheOtherMrs says the child was running round the corner - not just pottering over to collect some fruit for their mum, so that is very different to what you do with your child.

Also, as other posters have said - what about the risks to the child? Places like supermarkets are not designed to be children's playgrounds - there are lots of sharp corners, and things that, if a child knocked into them, could hurt the child. Clearly this does not apply to your gently pottering child, but the child in the OP could have run round the corner smack dab into the corner of a shopping trolley, which would have hurt!!

I do have old, frail people in my life and if a 2 year old toddling into them would cause them such serious injury then yes, I would advise they avoid supermarkets because guess what? Children are part of society too. I am not referring to screeching, scooting 6 year olds who of course shouldn’t be behaving like that in a supermarket; the lady who the vitriol was directed at also had a tottering 2 year old so the reaction towards her imo was extreme and hyperbolic. I don’t even recognise most of the behaviour described on here - if this sort of thing happened in the supermarkets around me, it would be a notable one off. Maybe I’m just lucky or maybe some of the people on these threads are just descended from Dahl’s witches!

SausageRoll58 · 06/03/2024 13:33

I also hate seeing kids actually sitting in the supermarket trolleys with their dirty shoes and sticky hands. GET YOUR KIDS OUT OF THE TROLLEY AND MAKE THEM WALK! It's a food trolley, not a buggy!

SausageRoll58 · 06/03/2024 13:32

I'm physically disabled with leg and feet problems among other things and get sick of kids uncontrolled using shops as playgrounds. They bang into my legs, which physically hurts me, and the ''parents'' blame me for daring to be in the same room with their brats.

I've had kids knock my walking stick/crutches out of my hand and run into my Rollator.

I hate them and their me-myself-and-I attitude.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 06/03/2024 13:11

Moglet4 · 05/03/2024 22:52

For goodness’ sake! I don’t think the woman is talking about an 8 year old, or indeed a 3 year old running riot. My 2 year old hates sitting in the trolley so to avoid screaming I usually let her walk. She loves finding the different fruit and veg we’re shopping for. She’s 2 so she pitter patters over to them. I watch her and mostly hold ger hand but on occasion she has got free and bumped or nearly bumped into someone’s legs. Aside from the fact that it hurts about as much as a teddy bear, you’re probably more likely to be hit by someone’s trolley as her. These things are accidents and are just part of living in a society. If someone being bumped by a toddler is going to cause serious injury then that person should be taking precautions and getting their food delivered!

One day you, or someone you love, might be elderly and/or vulnerable, @Moglet4, and I am sure you will want them or you to be able to carry on living a normal life. Why should my elderly FIL have to shut himself away from everyone, and take away the social contact that he has (and that makes life worth living) so that parents don't have to stop their children running round in a supermarket?

Are you honestly suggesting that all elderly, frail or vulnerable people should be shut away from normal life, so that children can be allowed to run riot wherever they are?

In the OP, @TheOtherMrs says the child was running round the corner - not just pottering over to collect some fruit for their mum, so that is very different to what you do with your child.

Also, as other posters have said - what about the risks to the child? Places like supermarkets are not designed to be children's playgrounds - there are lots of sharp corners, and things that, if a child knocked into them, could hurt the child. Clearly this does not apply to your gently pottering child, but the child in the OP could have run round the corner smack dab into the corner of a shopping trolley, which would have hurt!!

SoOutingWhoCares · 06/03/2024 11:52

Springtimesunshinesun · 06/03/2024 11:29

Key words there are ‘I remember.’ And as was once very famously said, recollections may vary! If you remember it chances are it happened after you were five, certainly not before three.

People always say this but it's not my experience at all and there must be others like me.

My first memory is from 18 months and I have plenty after that well before 5. I can remember being sneaked into my Mum's old workplace to meet her friends, (at a long since demolished forensic pyschiatry unit) where she only worked for 6 months after returning from maternity leave; I can see her colleagues, the decor, where my Dad parked, the smell, how to get from the ward to the staff canteen through a staff corridor etc. I can remember lots about nursery, play groups, family weddings, big events and holidays etc. We didn't have a camcorder and my mother hated photos when I was a kid so it's not that I've "seen" this stuff some other way and attributed it to memory.

We're Asian and I didn't meet my paternal grandparents or aunties, uncles and cousins until I was 3 and we went to the country my family are originally from for a month. My memories of that time period are clear as day right down to things we ate, where shops were in the village, the layout of the houses on the dirt road they lived on. What the temples looked like. The insects I encountered. Being taught new local slang phrases. Our whole family waiting at the airport for us, crying and passing me from person to person. I'm 40 now and I've never been back there
since but I could tell you how to get to the hotcake shop or the beach on foot from grandma's house and where the creepy "black magic" lady lived and how to avoid passing her house on her way to the main town.

I always find it really weird when people say you can't remember things pre 5! I'm sure I'm not some sort of medical marvel, maybe it's uncommon but it's certainly not impossible.

Springtimesunshinesun · 06/03/2024 11:29

GasPanic · 06/03/2024 10:44

I remember being a kid in supermarkets and never once eating stuff or grabbing stuff that my parents told me not to. I may have knocked some stuff off shelves very rarely, but to be fair I do that as an adult too. Always got a chocolate bar at the end though.

Supermarkets are not great places to let small kids run around, because they are full of sharp corners and hard things like shelving and racks. People moving around them are focusing on buying food, not on the three year old running round the corner flat out into a trolley that can hardly be seen.

I tend to shop late that way you can avoid most of the people and also the worst kids behaviour. If I had my way I would not allow kids in supermarkets past 20:00 - to be fair there are not normally that many around at that time anyway.

Key words there are ‘I remember.’ And as was once very famously said, recollections may vary! If you remember it chances are it happened after you were five, certainly not before three.

KimberleyClark · 06/03/2024 10:58

What gets me at airports is seeing tiny children/toddlers pulling little suitcases along behind them. Surprised they don’t cause more accidents.

Rosiiee · 06/03/2024 10:54

God the number of times my DS who is 2 has walked into people! It’s always the other person who apologises to me though when it was very clearly my DS who just wasn’t looking.

I try to keep him in the pram with a snack while i do my shopping but as hes getting older he's starting to fight the pram 😩

GasPanic · 06/03/2024 10:44

BasiliskStare · 06/03/2024 04:40

I read this once and it made me laugh ( & I speak as one who has a scar on ankle from scooting toddler in the supermarket - not mine )but recall taking young DS to supermarket - with in the trolley or reins ( do people still do this )

Anyway - here

Test 8: Grocery Shopping
Go to the local supermarket. Take with you the nearest thing you can find to a pre-school child -- a fully grown goat is excellent. If you intend to have more than one child, take more than one goat.
Buy your weekly groceries without letting the goat(s) out of your sight.
Pay for everything the goat eats or destroys.
Until you can easily accomplish this, do not even contemplate having children.

I remember being a kid in supermarkets and never once eating stuff or grabbing stuff that my parents told me not to. I may have knocked some stuff off shelves very rarely, but to be fair I do that as an adult too. Always got a chocolate bar at the end though.

Supermarkets are not great places to let small kids run around, because they are full of sharp corners and hard things like shelving and racks. People moving around them are focusing on buying food, not on the three year old running round the corner flat out into a trolley that can hardly be seen.

I tend to shop late that way you can avoid most of the people and also the worst kids behaviour. If I had my way I would not allow kids in supermarkets past 20:00 - to be fair there are not normally that many around at that time anyway.

Springtimesunshinesun · 06/03/2024 09:40

A six year old in Nottingham.

The ambulance did not get there before his mother either: he was next to her when the accident happened.

Toddlerteaplease · 06/03/2024 09:01

@Springtimesunshinesun I thought he was about 3