Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not send a birthday card to someone with advanced dementia?

117 replies

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 05/03/2024 10:47

FIL is in a home and is sadly now unable to recognise any of us, doesn't speak, is unable to feed himself. Sleeps most of the time. We saw him recently but won't be there on the day. They are likely to have a little celebration but I doubt very much he'll know what's going on. DH doesn't think it's worth sending a card, but WWYD?
YABU - just send one, to show you care
YANBU - don't bother
Thanks

OP posts:
ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 05/03/2024 14:53

Care home staff are mostly really good about celebrating birthdays with a cake and singing happy birthday to the resident . They may buy a little present too (as in the care home funds this rather than staff themselves).

DappledOliveGroves · 05/03/2024 14:52

Honestly, some of the replies here really piss me off. The idea that a card can "brighten" someone's day, or make them smile. The last few Christmasses and birthdays that my mother had, she had no clue what was happening. I took my 1-month old baby in to "meet" her - she had no idea that DD was there, she couldn't focus, couldn't see (cataracts), had no speech, no comprehension. Nothing. Writing a card for her just highlighted what we'd lost and how the person had long disappeared.

Yes - sometimes people might be lucid. My grandmother's dementia wasn't so severe and she might have noticed or understood the idea of a card. But my mother had no clue whatsoever as to what was going on. We spent the last few years praying for her to die, which she finally did in January.

Writing and taking a card or a present was a complete sham. And the idea she might have liked some chocolate? She couldn't eat - she was aspirating mushed food and choking, because she'd lost the ability to swallow.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 05/03/2024 14:51

Absolutely send one .

My mum had dementia and even though she might not have understood why she was receiving the cards or remember the person that had sent them, she loved receiving them and having them up in her room. Flowers too.

When someone has dementia it's about finding anyway you can into the person that is there now. IMO people who go on about their relatives not recognising them are focusing on themselves rather than their relative .

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 05/03/2024 14:50

I would send a card with a note for the staff to read to him. I would also send some bulbs in a pot or something visual to cheer up his bedside table.
So he opens his eyes and sees a happy birthday card and a pot of diffs every few hours, and it's new every time. What's not to like.
I'd also send some sweets for the staff.

saraclara · 05/03/2024 14:47

saraclara · 05/03/2024 14:37

I sent cards right up to my wonderful MIL's death. Not to do so would feel like denying her existence as a person.

Also, my DD used to send her Grandma a random card with a message and chat inside it, and a photo of the great granddaughter that MIL had never met* about once a month.

None of us had any idea whether MIL was remotely aware of what the carers were reading to her and showing her, but DD wanted to show her love, and the carers told us how they loved to see an envelope arrive in the post with DD's writing on and to share her message and news with MIL. They displayed the cards on the wall by MIL's favourite chair in the lounge.

*DD lived three hours away so visits with the baby weren't really an option.

crumpet · 05/03/2024 14:46

GalileoHumpkins · 05/03/2024 10:56

This has properly made my blood boil, send a card because he's loved and you want to celebrate him. The staff will read it to him.

this. And even if he wouldn’t know he didn’t get a card, he may still be pleased to receive a card. It’s nothing to you and may have a benefit to him.

also the idea of old photos is nice - you could find some of his younger self and put them into a moonpig card

MereDintofPandiculation · 05/03/2024 14:42

Even if he doesn't know who he card is from, it adds to the overall number of cards, and that is worth doing.

WittyMotherhoodRelatedPun · 05/03/2024 14:40

Hakunatomato · 05/03/2024 10:53

Just get on moonpig and it will take you 5 minutes to send a card.

Exactly. Worst case, that’s £5 you’ll never see again.

Even it gave him 2 seconds of joy to see a colourful picture, surely it would be worth the effort.

saraclara · 05/03/2024 14:37

I sent cards right up to my wonderful MIL's death. Not to do so would feel like denying her existence as a person.

BobbyBiscuits · 05/03/2024 14:35

Yeah, maybe you could send some other things from his past, like find his record collection (or some of it at least) on youtube and ask the carers to play it for him? There are other things apart from the card.
But the card is good enough. It's hard to know what to do when people have dementia, it can be upsetting for everyone.

Sharptonguedwoman · 05/03/2024 14:26

Herdinggoats · 05/03/2024 10:52

Send one. Pictures from years and years ago are good as well. Even in the most advanced state my grandfather could still recognise people in pictures from the 1950’s and before. (Nothing recent though).

I think it’s also good for the staff to be aware that there are family who care lurking around.

This, absolutely this. The care home staff will be doing their best with your FIL and it's good for them to know there is someone who cares and pays attention. They do gently monitor who comes and goes. When I moved mum onto County Council funding, I was asked in the interview how often visits were made.

BobbyBiscuits · 05/03/2024 14:24

I get told there's no point sending stuff to MiL as she has pretty severe dementia, can't recognise anyone etc. I always want to send flowers. I feel why not send the card, the carers can read it out to him and show it to him, and say 'oh look these lovely people sent you this nice card, it has a picture of x on it, etc" He may get little out of it but surely it will sound positive and caring to those around him as well. Is he able to eat chocolates, or some sort of treat if fed by carers? Something that he always likes? You could send some of that? It's a nice thing to do and no harm done but it's kind.

DancingOctopus · 05/03/2024 14:23

This reminds me of a story that I read- a man spent all day everyday with his wife in her nursing home. Someone asked him why he did because " she doesn't remember you". He replied " but I know and remember her".
For that reason, I would send a card.
There will be many birthdays after the relative has sadly passed away when your husband will wish that he could send a card.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 05/03/2024 14:18

Of course a card gets sent - a total of what ? £2.50 including a stamp if someone is really that skint/mean.

MitchellMummy · 05/03/2024 14:17

Why not do a Moonpig one with a full face picture of (say) his wife in her younger days? Takes a few minutes and could brighten up his day.

Yummymummy2020 · 05/03/2024 14:15

Send a card op. It’s such a simple gesture. I find it so sad when some residents in homes have rooms with cards and some have nothing. Whether he is aware or not it is a kind thing to do and he might not be around much longer so you won’t have the chance (or chore as it sounds for dh) to do it In the future.

Chunkycookie · 05/03/2024 14:14

My dad died in January. His last birthday was in August.

It was just horrendous, actually. At that point he was just varying between staring ahead and talking nonsense.

The care home made a cake, the children made cards. He didn’t know what was going on. The only but that made me laugh was when I was handed a bit of cake and he turned to dh and said, “I don’t know that fat cow over there is, but she could do without eating that.” That was the only coherent thing I’d heard him say in months.

I cried for days before abs after. I actually hated that there he was, his third birthday trapped in a living hell, in an even worse state than the year before. I went to church the next day and prayed to god that it would be his last one. I hated it for him.

Dementia is just awful. But what’s worse is people judging family for how they handle it. You would have thought I was the coldest harted bitch over the last three years, but it was a combination of exhaustion for fighting for his care over the tiniest thing and complete and utter grief and sorrow on how that proud, capable man ended up. Ultimately, self preservation had to take over or I wouldn’t be here either right now.

I haven’t read a lot of these replies but I bet some are along the lines of how selfish not to send a card. Sickening, really. I wouldn’t wish having a loved one succumbing to dementia on my worst enemy.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 05/03/2024 14:13

Keepingittogetherstepbystep · 05/03/2024 13:59

Try to add photos to your newsletter if possible, it gives him something to focus on.

My dad spent his last birthday in hospital, his dementia wasn't as advanced as some people's but he was hurt at not being acknowledged by some of his family.

I had thought of adding photos. I am getting some printed this afternoon. Thank you. Sorry about your dad. It's so hard to know what's going on in FIL's head.

OP posts:
MenopauseSucks · 05/03/2024 14:09

Of course you should send him a card! And maybe some chocolates/something he can eat on his birthday.
Doesn't matter if he has advanced dementia, doesn't know who you are & might not be able to process it, it may still interest him & he might get some pleasure from it.

I used to make a big fuss of my Mum's birthdays even though she didn't have a clue who I was. She used to enjoy the card, found the balloons hilarious & the cake was always well received!
I guess deep down I was making a big celebration of her birthday & Xmas for me rather than her.

caringcarer · 05/03/2024 14:04

Beryls · 05/03/2024 10:49

I'd send one, it's a couple of quid and shows you care even if he won't realise it.

This.

Keepingittogetherstepbystep · 05/03/2024 13:59

Try to add photos to your newsletter if possible, it gives him something to focus on.

My dad spent his last birthday in hospital, his dementia wasn't as advanced as some people's but he was hurt at not being acknowledged by some of his family.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 05/03/2024 13:58

SoOutingWhoCares · 05/03/2024 12:01

Heartbreaking.

Are people really this lazy/stingy?!

Yes. Send the poor man a nice bright colourful card with sweet words that a care assistant can read out. He doesn't deserve to be completely forgotten about.

This post has made me so angry I actually can't even write what I want to about my own experience with dementis sufferers. Anyway needless to say yabvvvvvu.

Um, it's not about being lazy or stingy, but whether it's pointless. Which is why I posted - for thoughts. And kind posters have made me realise that we should send one. Actually I think the thought of writing the card is upsetting for DH. But if you read my updates you'll see we will definitely be sending a card and a letter with news that can be read out to him.

OP posts:
JoWawa · 05/03/2024 13:57

And the carers will know you care. I think that is important.

Anneinavan · 05/03/2024 13:56

I also think you should send a card.

  1. it reminds the care staff of the human being and the life that existed before the disease
  2. it may bring a small (even if fast forgotten) spark to his day
  3. It let’s any other visitors know that he is still a lived member of the family who is not forgotten
and those things seem worth the price of a card and a stamp.
Ofcourseshecan · 05/03/2024 13:51

I'm so glad you are sending a card and letter, OP. Don't write off someone while they're still alive. He's still a human being, and someone you love. You have no idea what he may be able to experience.

I've read research showing that people with dementia may be aware for some time afterwards that something nice (or bad) happened to them, even without necessarily having seemed aware of what was happening at the time.

And anyway -- for heavens sake, the cost of a card! Why wouldn't you send it even if you thought there was only a 1% chance he'd enjoy it?