Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable? House renting, children - complicated!

78 replies

Houseone818 · 05/03/2024 10:33

I own another house to the one myself and DH live in and own together. It was my grandparents house and was left in trust for me. I inherited this before me and H married and it is very much my house and all protected etc etc.

Currently this house is rented out and my plan has always been that eventually when my DC has grown up, I will sell it and give the proceeds (or the majority at least) to them to give them a step up, the house is currently in a trust for DC in case anything happens to me but it still gives me full control / ability to sell etc.. DH knows this.

Me and DH also own a house together that we bought during our relationship and is the family home. Here there is me, DH, our child and my stepchildren, DHs older sons. The children are all too young currently for this to even be an issue right now but a hypothetical conversation stirred up a bit of a tiff between me and H last night.

Basically we were talking generally about young ones these days and how hard it can be and we got onto the conversation of wondering how long kids in general will end up living at home for nowadays (SC currently here about 30% of the week). DH then said well we could always let SC rent the other house when they want to move out and how nice it is to have a house there that means we can offer a home to the children at a lower cost and so on... for context SS's are 15 and 17 and our child is only 5 so it's obviously more likely to be SC living independently quite some time before our child.

Essentially I said well no? That house was already rented and it is there for benefit of DC, not to he used at a cheaper rate for SC, didn't say it quite so bluntly but that was the gist that basically it was DCs house, not a "family" house and that until DC needed it to either live in or sell for the proceeds it would be rented as normal.

This got a bit heated, but there are a few reasons I wouldn't be open to this suggestion and the main one is I think it's a slippery slope. So say we offered it to SC, bearing in mind still this is all entirely hypothetical, but say we did, and they or one of them lives there for many years paying minimal rent, I don't believe that it wouldn't begin to feel like a "shared" house, like we either had to continue to let whoever it were live there and not give it to DC as planned or we'd have to share the proceeds. I just think it opens it up to getting messy and I'd rather keep it simple and separate. It's DCs future, not a family house that can just be used by whoever.

I've suggested in the past that DH start thinking about putting together some sort of savings or whatever for SDC, he could as the money isn't the problem, but he never has.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsB74 · 07/03/2024 12:13

Some step parents split their estate between their step and bio children, some don’t. I’m splitting mine equally between them all because my step children have been in my life for over twenty years, but I know people who have decided to only look after their bio kids. It’s up to you and everyone feels differently, so it’s no one else’s place to tell you what to do, so don’t be railroaded.

He should be setting up savings for all his children if he can afford to (along with you for your joint child). His ex should be too.

Problemnumber99 · 06/03/2024 22:55

I just wish all this 'help the kids' was a thing when I left home! 😅

If you agree you'll resent him for making you feel like you had to. Any damage, late rent, unpaid bills, parties, angry neighbours...all the things youngsters will likely do, will just exacerbate the resentment. He might resent you temporarily when you say no, but then it's old news.

Like a PP said, if it was cash in the bank or jewellery, it wouldn't be a thing. Your grandparents left it to you, to benefit your children.

Winter2020 · 06/03/2024 22:53

If we imagine your rental property rents out for £1000 each month and so brings in £12k each year.
Then let's imagine your step children rent it for £400 each month - an amount you decide covers insurance, repairs, maintenance. That adds up to £4,800 and £7200 less than renting at market rate.

What would annoy me is that your step children's dad is no worse off for them getting a leg up with housing, their mum is no worse off. It is only you/your child that is worse off.

You would be better to say, for example, that if their father and mother would like to subsidise their rent when they move out you would match what they put in (if you want to help them) up to a maximum that you are comfortable with - maybe £100 or £200 each month. So for example then mum, dad and you paying £200 each towards their rent rather than you paying (by losing rental income) the full £600.

I often think this when people own a holiday property/caravan and a wide circle of family/friends/neighbours/colleagues think that they should be able to rent it for free or very cheap. You wouldn't go giving a cousin or neighbour a grand so why would you give them a week in your property in August that would rent for £1200 for £200? It reminds me of this because I don't think that they would ask you to pay to subsidise your step children's property to the tune of £600 each month while mum and dad paid nothing but the loss in your income is the same £600.

Personally I think help your step children as presumably you care about them as children of your household but also expect their mum and dad to help them. The rental house is a distraction and an easy way out for their mum and dad to look to you while not having to do anything themselves.

SemperIdem · 06/03/2024 11:45

I’m with you here.

My partner has 3 children, I have 1. Granted there’s no shared child nor is there likely to ever be.

I have been very clear there will be no “sharing as one of four” for my child from very early on. How we own our property, how our wills are written reflects that.

LoftyTurtle · 06/03/2024 11:35

If I was you I'd probably rent it out to the SC, assuming you have a good relationship and they aren't (to put it bluntly) the sort of people who you could forsee would take the piss in a few years. But also, if I was your DH or SC I wouldn't expect you to rent it out to me either. If you did I'd think, oh that's really nice, but I wouldn't be pissed if you didn't either!

I have two sets of step parents - if they had their own other properties like you do, I wouldn't expect them to have rented it out to me when I was a young adult. If they did, I'd have been super grateful, but it wouldn't ever have crossed my mind to ask/demand they do it...

Ohnoooooooo · 06/03/2024 11:23

Honestly, I think this would never happen so I would not argue about it too much.

The chance a 15 and a 17 year old will one day both want to rent a house together where this house is - is surely slim? Maybe one would want to rent but it would be unfair one has cheap rent....plus they could go anywhere when they want to do further education get jobs.

I do think your hubby is being cheeky raising this - I think he is testing the waters to how much you see this house as a shared thing in the future or how much he thinks you'll provide for stepchildren in your will etc.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 06/03/2024 10:04

Haydenn · 05/03/2024 11:07

I’d also be making sure whatever he does for his eldest children he does for the OPs to make sure he provides equally for all his kids, rather than using the fact that the OP is financially savvy to remove that from his plate and effectively have her subsidising the others.

It wasn't financial savvy that got the OP the house in trust, it was an inheritance.

Pheasantsmate · 06/03/2024 09:53

If his kids inherit from a maternal grandparent or aunt are they expected to share it with your child? Of course not.

Id actually be really careful that with his half of the house and estate he doesn’t cut out your child in a misguided attempt to make things more equitable. Just because you are financially sorted doesn’t absolve him of responsibility to your joint child.

SomeCatFromJapan · 06/03/2024 09:53

Don't do it OP! This is a good deed that you know you'll be horrendously punished for, you'll never hear the end about "kicking them out" when the time comes.

FinallyFeb · 06/03/2024 09:34

OP I’m with you on this one.
Your DH and his ex can give your step DC help.
You have a good plan.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/03/2024 09:31

Houseone818 · 06/03/2024 09:11

But do you not think it has the potential to be really messy?

I can picture the responses I'd get now in however many years time about chucking SC and potentially even their family out of "their home" so I could sell it and give the proceeds to our child (which has always been the plan).

Nevermind the fact that renting at a lower rate also lowers the savings for our DC too as the rent currently goes in an account for them.

No I don't tbh. We've done it before a couple of times. Never had an issue.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/03/2024 09:29

Yogatoga1 · 06/03/2024 09:19

No, I was referring to your circumstance re. Treating children differently and your dh treating your children like is own.

if the roles were flipped would you treat his children like your own? To the point your children would suffer financially because your assets, earned before you met dh, are now split between all children’s, step or biological.

To do what the o/p is suggesting is effectively taking money from o/p’s dc, and giving it to the stepsiblings. Would you do that?

would you leave your house to step dc as if they were your own?

just making the point that’s it’s easy to say you’d treat them all the same when it’s your kids that will benefit.

But that's not what this thread is about so you're derailing.

I answered based on what was asked not all kinds of theoretical situations. I have no issue at all with giving any children in the family a leg up by way of 'mates rates' for want of a better term. Kids these days need all the help they can get as it's a lot harder for them than it was when I bought my properties.

The kids in my immediate and extended family are treated equally.

sandyhappypeople · 06/03/2024 09:27

To be honest I don’t really see the problem with what DH has suggested, as long as it was an official arrangement and they paid market value (or slightly below if you choose). If the house is being rented until such time that it will be sold for your DC then why would it make a difference if it was rented to them?

They would obviously be fully aware that it is never going to be theirs and it is a temporary living solution (same as if they rented anywhere) as the long term plan is to sell it when you need to.

the only sticking point would be the rent, he’s unreasonable to expect them to rent it cheap as you’d then be losing out on that rental income, but if you take family ties and emotion out of it, it could easily work as a business arrangement with terms in place.

I’m in your position OP with a separate rental property earmarked for my DC, I’d be annoyed if I was your DH and you refused to even consider having them as tenants for the reasons you have given (slippery slope etc), especially as it’s just a hypothetical conversation at this point anyway, they may never want to live there!

user1492757084 · 06/03/2024 09:27

Stick to your original plan.

Speak like you are more than willing to be generous with your joint family home and welcome DSC living there for lower rent for a set number of years while they save.
Your DH should be putting aside a sum to help his children too, given that you are agreeable.

SuncreamAndIceCream · 06/03/2024 09:25

YANBU op.

It's your DC's property and any decisions regarding it have to be made in the best interest of DC to maximise the benefit from the asset. I think the rules of the Trust will be pretty clear what you can and cannot do anyway and I would be very surprised if renting at lower rate to family would be in it t!

Regardless of that I think your DH is displaying a bit of a lazy attitude to providing for his DC. If he wants to give them a leg up he should be saving, not assuming he can piggyback on your good fortune.

scoliworrier · 06/03/2024 09:20

Fortunately the rights and wrongs will be laid down in black and white so there'll be no need to debate the rights and wrongs. It'll be as it is!

Yogatoga1 · 06/03/2024 09:19

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/03/2024 08:59

I think you've misread the original post.

No one is talking about giving half a house away. It's about letting the step children rent a second property at less than market value. They will still be paying. I would be happy to do this for any child in my family and indeed extended family too.

No, I was referring to your circumstance re. Treating children differently and your dh treating your children like is own.

if the roles were flipped would you treat his children like your own? To the point your children would suffer financially because your assets, earned before you met dh, are now split between all children’s, step or biological.

To do what the o/p is suggesting is effectively taking money from o/p’s dc, and giving it to the stepsiblings. Would you do that?

would you leave your house to step dc as if they were your own?

just making the point that’s it’s easy to say you’d treat them all the same when it’s your kids that will benefit.

scoliworrier · 06/03/2024 09:12

The house is in trust for the benefit of your DC? And presumably you are a trustee? As such you have responsibilities to that beneficiary. I would sit your husband down with a solicitor to explain quite plainly why his plan would in all likelihood go against the terms of the trust. Which was presumably in place when you met. Or did he assume a trust was no big deal? In law it really is

Houseone818 · 06/03/2024 09:12

I think as PP suggested I'll go over the trust and check that we can't rent at lower rate anyway so it's a moot point then. Fingers crossed!

OP posts:
Houseone818 · 06/03/2024 09:11

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/03/2024 08:59

I think you've misread the original post.

No one is talking about giving half a house away. It's about letting the step children rent a second property at less than market value. They will still be paying. I would be happy to do this for any child in my family and indeed extended family too.

But do you not think it has the potential to be really messy?

I can picture the responses I'd get now in however many years time about chucking SC and potentially even their family out of "their home" so I could sell it and give the proceeds to our child (which has always been the plan).

Nevermind the fact that renting at a lower rate also lowers the savings for our DC too as the rent currently goes in an account for them.

OP posts:
Houseone818 · 06/03/2024 09:09

ohdamnitjanet · 06/03/2024 09:06

I see, thank you. But I’ll presume if you had children that weren’t his he might feel like you understandably do.

Yes I imagine so!

OP posts:
ohdamnitjanet · 06/03/2024 09:06

Houseone818 · 06/03/2024 08:53

Just to clarify, my child is also his child.

I see, thank you. But I’ll presume if you had children that weren’t his he might feel like you understandably do.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/03/2024 08:59

Yogatoga1 · 06/03/2024 07:28

Who owns your house? If it’s yours, and your dh did have children, would you be happy for them to get half?

it’s ok saying that when your children aren’t losing out - or are actually benefiting as if your dh doesn’t have kids they may inherit from him?

But if you owned that house before your dh came on the scene, you’d be more than happy to give half of it to his kids?

your choice to get remarried. That choice leads to your kids losing half their inheritance as well?

I think you've misread the original post.

No one is talking about giving half a house away. It's about letting the step children rent a second property at less than market value. They will still be paying. I would be happy to do this for any child in my family and indeed extended family too.

Houseone818 · 06/03/2024 08:55

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/03/2024 23:20

Silly comparison. Her stepchildrens relatives aren't anything to do with her. Her stepchildren though are part of her family.

I'm so glad my husband treats my children as his own. I couldn't be with someone who wouldn't.

My grandparents knew my step children even less than DSCs mum family knows my children as I didn't even know DH at the time!

OP posts:
Houseone818 · 06/03/2024 08:53

ohdamnitjanet · 06/03/2024 08:49

Every word! It’s nothing to do with him. And I’d say the same if it was the other way round and he was keeping it for his children. Bet he wouldn’t be giving your child a cut.

Just to clarify, my child is also his child.

OP posts: