Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assigned Female at Birth - AFAB

483 replies

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 08:36

AIBU to get the actual rage every time I see this written down? Often in reputable sources.

Obviously this has come about due to people differentiating between gender and sex - I understand needing clarity between those two when talking to or questioning people.

but every single bloody time I read it I can only think of the horrific female infanticide statistics. AIBU to think ‘assigned female at birth’ is fucking offensive to women, as so many of us are killed at birth ONLY because we are female. Nobody assigned those infants a female sex, they didn’t just randomly pick half of the babies and murder them.

can’t we agree as a society to call out AFAB and AMAB as being horrific and change it? Happy to hear alternatives. Observed female/male at birth sounds reasonable to me if you need to specify birth sex vs gender.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 17:01

Would you refuse to use a person's chosen name if usually belonged a gender different to their sex at birth? Would you refuse to refer to them by their preferred gender if you were discussing them with a third party?

I'll bite. No one has to participate in a lie/pseudo reality/ideology they don't believe in (especially ones that are harmful to women and children) if they don't want to.

I'd probably have full sympathy to whatever struggles they were facing as result of their gender dysphoria and would hope they were treated with kindness and compassion, like most non cunty people, but feelings don't trump reality, or my right not to be a liar.

Why should I be a liar to save someone's feelings?

izimbra · 05/03/2024 16:59

'Women's rights are under attack'

Can you explain the mechanics of how accepting trans women as women might strip me of my right to maternity leave, equal pay etc.

izimbra · 05/03/2024 16:56

Sounds like you don't actually know any trans people.

Is that correct?

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 16:50

izimbra · 05/03/2024 16:35

So the transphobes here who are adamant that no human being should 'be allowed to live a lie' - how does this impact on your interaction with trans people?

Assuming you know any trans people?

Would you refuse to use a person's chosen name if usually belonged a gender different to their sex at birth? Would you refuse to refer to them by their preferred gender if you were discussing them with a third party?

Would it be the same for friends or family? Even if you knew it was deeply hurtful to the person and was experienced as bullying?

Really interested to know how your fanaticism on this issue impacts on your relationships with trans people. I imagine it's very similar to how homophobes behave - you know the sort of people who object to homosexuals on the grounds that 'it's just not natural', or that homosexuality is a threat to the family unit.

Firstly, you have a lot of questions to answer on this thread. Any updates on that.

Secondly - names are one thing. They can be legally changed, aren't necessarily sexed. I would honour a name change.

Anything else is a lie, supporting an illusion that sex can be changed. It can't. Nothing kind, respectful or loving about facilitating lies.

Toseland · 05/03/2024 16:47

I find it amazing that for 0.02% of the population and to the detriment of women (51%) words around pregnancy and childbirth have been changed at all.

OldManSign · Today 09:04
Honestly with issues like this you need both sides to sit down and have a calm and respectful discussion and reach a consensus.
LOL and where exactly was the calm and respectful discussion when they introduced this language?! There wasn't one! Women have been told that the language is changing and if they don't like it they are transphobic bigots and need to loose their jobs!

No. Women's language needs to be restored to what it was. You can't come in, change the language making the majority less safe and then when people complain say "oh both sides..."

No - women's rights are under attack, we are NOT negotiating with these colonisers.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 16:47

izimbra · 05/03/2024 16:40

"I don’t know why they don’t just call it legal sex."

If you have a gender recognition certificate you are legally recognised as your preferred gender. Birth & marriage & death certificate & passport in your preferred gender.

And that's legal fiction. Everyone knows it. Stupid and dangerous.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 16:46

izimbra · 05/03/2024 16:35

So the transphobes here who are adamant that no human being should 'be allowed to live a lie' - how does this impact on your interaction with trans people?

Assuming you know any trans people?

Would you refuse to use a person's chosen name if usually belonged a gender different to their sex at birth? Would you refuse to refer to them by their preferred gender if you were discussing them with a third party?

Would it be the same for friends or family? Even if you knew it was deeply hurtful to the person and was experienced as bullying?

Really interested to know how your fanaticism on this issue impacts on your relationships with trans people. I imagine it's very similar to how homophobes behave - you know the sort of people who object to homosexuals on the grounds that 'it's just not natural', or that homosexuality is a threat to the family unit.

How about you attempt to answer some of the questions put to you, and then you might get something back in return from the big transphobes.

Naunet · 05/03/2024 16:45

izimbra · 05/03/2024 16:35

So the transphobes here who are adamant that no human being should 'be allowed to live a lie' - how does this impact on your interaction with trans people?

Assuming you know any trans people?

Would you refuse to use a person's chosen name if usually belonged a gender different to their sex at birth? Would you refuse to refer to them by their preferred gender if you were discussing them with a third party?

Would it be the same for friends or family? Even if you knew it was deeply hurtful to the person and was experienced as bullying?

Really interested to know how your fanaticism on this issue impacts on your relationships with trans people. I imagine it's very similar to how homophobes behave - you know the sort of people who object to homosexuals on the grounds that 'it's just not natural', or that homosexuality is a threat to the family unit.

If you want an honest discussion, maybe don’t start it by calling people names. Just a basic life skill tip for you there.

izimbra · 05/03/2024 16:40

"I don’t know why they don’t just call it legal sex."

If you have a gender recognition certificate you are legally recognised as your preferred gender. Birth & marriage & death certificate & passport in your preferred gender.

izimbra · 05/03/2024 16:35

So the transphobes here who are adamant that no human being should 'be allowed to live a lie' - how does this impact on your interaction with trans people?

Assuming you know any trans people?

Would you refuse to use a person's chosen name if usually belonged a gender different to their sex at birth? Would you refuse to refer to them by their preferred gender if you were discussing them with a third party?

Would it be the same for friends or family? Even if you knew it was deeply hurtful to the person and was experienced as bullying?

Really interested to know how your fanaticism on this issue impacts on your relationships with trans people. I imagine it's very similar to how homophobes behave - you know the sort of people who object to homosexuals on the grounds that 'it's just not natural', or that homosexuality is a threat to the family unit.

Lion400 · 05/03/2024 16:31

Ohhbaby · 05/03/2024 15:48

Yeah it doesn't work like that though. "You consider it a fact, others do not". Some things are objectively true mate
-He drove under the influence .

  • The sun is hot
-The baby has blue eyes. -The baby is a girl

You can't make up your own facts."oh no I don't feel like I was under the influence" You can feel any way you like but it doesn't change facts

But remember…

‘War is peace. Freedom is slavery. Ignorance is strength.' - ‘1984’ Fiction book about fiction

‘Males are Females if that’s what they claim be’ - 2024 dystopian bullshit spouted by scientific fact denyers.

Ohnoooooooo · 05/03/2024 16:29

I don’t know why they don’t just call it legal sex.

Waitingfordoggo · 05/03/2024 16:25

YOU consider it a fact, others do not.

If you don’t believe it’s a fact, then you presumably think it’s an opinion.

You think whether or not sex exists is a matter of opinion?

Did you miss the bit of the KS3 English syllabus which covers the difference between fact and opinion?

Ohhbaby · 05/03/2024 15:48

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:08

I was alluding to the fact that a more neutral term may benefit both parties. All you’ve done is prove my point that some of you can’t actually have a reasonable discussion and consider both sides. YOU consider it a fact, others do not. You need to be respectful of their viewpoint to get anywhere with this. You don’t have to agree with them but you need to listen and stop being so needlessly aggressive with your tone.

Yeah it doesn't work like that though. "You consider it a fact, others do not". Some things are objectively true mate
-He drove under the influence .

  • The sun is hot
-The baby has blue eyes. -The baby is a girl

You can't make up your own facts."oh no I don't feel like I was under the influence" You can feel any way you like but it doesn't change facts

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 15:41

izimbra · 05/03/2024 14:57

Can we be clear - when you say 'men in female spaces' are you referring to trans women?

Can you explain to me what the difference is between a trans woman and any other man?

And why that difference means they should have the right to be treated as the opposite sex in relation to single sex spaces?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 15:37

izimbra · 05/03/2024 14:57

Can we be clear - when you say 'men in female spaces' are you referring to trans women?

Yes. As they are men. You can't be one without the other.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 15:34

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 13:59

and when that safety is meaningfully impacted people will listen

So a woman raped by a male (transwoman) in an NHS single sex ward then being told that that could not have happened because there was no man on the ward has not meaningfully impacted the safety of the woman who has been raped?

And that's just one example.

Do you know what your views disgust me. I've got a fair idea that no amount of harm to women & children will be 'meaningful' to you.

inamarina · 05/03/2024 15:33

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 10:54

Then surely you should be championing this movement?

Bringing the concept of assigned gender to the Middle East to prevent deaths.

I think you could win a Nobel prize for that

Oh ffs, you can’t be serious?
So the men who currently oppress women in Afghanistan would stop doing it if those women declared themselves male? 🙄

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 05/03/2024 15:32

DreamyCritic
I am still wondering how many women & children need to be harmed before Dutch deems it a meaningful impact.

These are EXACTLY the same arguments used by the far right to stop migration to the UK from Pakistan & India.

////
Except they are based on the belief that humans can change sex. Which isn't AT ALL ridiculous 

Treeper22 · 05/03/2024 15:32

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 15:04

Or unspecified feelings in heads

😁 that's what I was alluding to....😉 but it looks like Izimbra has nothing....

Cattenberg · 05/03/2024 15:21

I can respect your religion up to a point. I will use your preferred name and pronouns (as a courtesy) in almost all circumstances. But I shouldn’t feel pressured to practise your religion. I’m not going to pretend that it’s possible to really change sex, or that there aren’t situations where sex really does matter.

DreamyCritic · 05/03/2024 15:16

I don't respect liars or those that bully others in yo accepting their lies.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 15:14

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 05/03/2024 15:13

You don’t have to respect the outcome just the viewpoint.

//

It's quite difficult to respect the opinion that humans can change sex.

Exactly. I don't respect the position of flat earthers either.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 05/03/2024 15:13

You don’t have to respect the outcome just the viewpoint.

//

It's quite difficult to respect the opinion that humans can change sex.

ErrolTheDragon · 05/03/2024 15:10

'Can we be clear' is a pertinent question on a thread where women are being told words matter. It's hard to be clear when people play Humpty Dumpty with words and use them to mean whatever they want.

It's not us who are deliberately attempting to change words from simple, clearly understood meanings.

Male and female - sex. Biological fact. But there are now those who'll claim these words can be used for 'gender' - XY individuals, no DSDs claiming to be 'female'.

Man and woman. Specific terms meaning adult human males and females. Necessary words.

There's no good reason to subvert these to describe 'gender' as that has its own terms 'masculine and feminine'.

'Assigned' ... you can assign the value of a variable, you can assign a task - you can't 'assign' an immutable property such as sex.

Words matter. We can't communicate properly otherwise, and there are real consequences to these changes if laws have been written with the long-existing meanings and then are (mis)interpreted using new ones.