Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assigned Female at Birth - AFAB

483 replies

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 08:36

AIBU to get the actual rage every time I see this written down? Often in reputable sources.

Obviously this has come about due to people differentiating between gender and sex - I understand needing clarity between those two when talking to or questioning people.

but every single bloody time I read it I can only think of the horrific female infanticide statistics. AIBU to think ‘assigned female at birth’ is fucking offensive to women, as so many of us are killed at birth ONLY because we are female. Nobody assigned those infants a female sex, they didn’t just randomly pick half of the babies and murder them.

can’t we agree as a society to call out AFAB and AMAB as being horrific and change it? Happy to hear alternatives. Observed female/male at birth sounds reasonable to me if you need to specify birth sex vs gender.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
fiftysevenorangepumpkins · 12/03/2024 21:11

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 08:36

AIBU to get the actual rage every time I see this written down? Often in reputable sources.

Obviously this has come about due to people differentiating between gender and sex - I understand needing clarity between those two when talking to or questioning people.

but every single bloody time I read it I can only think of the horrific female infanticide statistics. AIBU to think ‘assigned female at birth’ is fucking offensive to women, as so many of us are killed at birth ONLY because we are female. Nobody assigned those infants a female sex, they didn’t just randomly pick half of the babies and murder them.

can’t we agree as a society to call out AFAB and AMAB as being horrific and change it? Happy to hear alternatives. Observed female/male at birth sounds reasonable to me if you need to specify birth sex vs gender.

No, you are not the only one, I always wonder what they mean by that

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 12/03/2024 21:08

The message is directed at women and also people who are transgender and who may not associate themselves with being female despite having female reproductive organs - eg trans men. It’s just an inclusive bit of wording.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 12/03/2024 21:08

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 12/03/2024 20:59

What exactly is the problem with that ?

It's factually incorrect.

IGoWalkingAfterMidnight · 12/03/2024 21:01

Well, the clue is in the thread title.

Sex is not 'assigned' at birth, it is observed. You would hope that a science based health organisation would know that.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 12/03/2024 20:59

What exactly is the problem with that ?

IGoWalkingAfterMidnight · 12/03/2024 20:40

This from my local health board today...

How can they write this in all seriousness?

Edited to add that I'm sitting on my hands to stop me typing a response - I have several family members working for the Trust.

Assigned Female at Birth - AFAB
ShugarTits · 10/03/2024 20:29

Look who also agrees with 83% of the votes here Brew

Assigned Female at Birth - AFAB
OP posts:
endofthelinefinally · 10/03/2024 07:48

WaterWeasel · 09/03/2024 11:42

When the balance of domestic abuse/sexual assault/rapes are committed by trans women than males living as males, I will agree that’s an issue

TW are over represented in the figures for sexual offences when compared with other men. Check your facts!

According to the prison service's own statistics, male prisoners who identify as women are 8 times more likely to be convicted sex offenders than the rest of the male prison population. This should be widely publicised as it is a very worrying piece of information. The figures have been linked many times on this board.

WaterWeasel · 09/03/2024 11:42

When the balance of domestic abuse/sexual assault/rapes are committed by trans women than males living as males, I will agree that’s an issue

TW are over represented in the figures for sexual offences when compared with other men. Check your facts!

Catiette · 06/03/2024 15:23

It does actually work really well as an analogy. I may use it in future (while being very clear that it, rather wonderfully, presents all humans indiscriminately as bins of different varieties 😂, & that this was first suggested by someone arguing from a TRA perspective).

The phrase "semantic label" is spot-on as an expression of what we find so distressing: the wealth of female experience, with its potential, glory and unspeakable suffering reduced to a semantic label - a label that, what's more, has been imposed with the stated intent of advancing the offensive idea that these experiences are, in fact, wholly arbitrary.

On that basis, I, personally, refuse (geddit?) to condone AFAB & cis-.

RufustheFactualReindeer · 06/03/2024 12:50

Excellent post catiette

🗑️

RufustheFactualReindeer · 06/03/2024 12:47

WaterWeasel · 05/03/2024 20:26

I think that they were trying to support your bizarro opinions. 😂

They were and it went straight over that posters head 😀

i did like the story of the little green bin that could…

lifeturnsonadime · 06/03/2024 08:19

@Catiette

Jennifer Lopez Applause GIF by NBC World Of Dance
Catiette · 06/03/2024 07:09

PS

The SFTRBB has asked me to clarify in light of the above:

In defending the status of the black bin in society, the SFTRBB are often accused of "bin essentialism" and find this infuriatingly disingenuous. They point out that black bins have, for many years, presented and found fulfilment in a multitude of ways (graffiti-ed, half-painted, welcoming being filled with glass, compost and occasionally drunken teenagers...) This never changed their proud membership of the community of black bins and the prejudice they faced because of it...

...Until that community's very existence was denied.

Catiette · 06/03/2024 06:47

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 05/03/2024 18:01

I saw a green wheelie bin today, and somebody had stuck an A4 paper to the side of it and written “black bin” on it. To the casual observer the bin was quite clearly green. It was a “scientifically” green bin.

But the label stuck to it, which stated it identified as a black bin was intended to make it clear to the waste collectors that despite appearances, the bin was filled with regular household rubbish and not garden waste.

That plucky little green bin wanted to fulfil the role of a black bin, and be treated the same as a black bin and not be ignored or even penalised for externally appearing green.

And while not technically a black bin, it used that semantic label to help others understand how it fits into society.

A little story about bins there.

And very soon, all the little black bins began to be told that they weren’t black bins after all… unless they stuck that same ragged piece of paper to themselves declaring it. They’d been so proud of their true nature and purpose as a black bin, and now, suddenly, it had been replaced by a label they didn’t want!

The SFTRBB (Society For The Rights Of Black Bins) was especially concerned. Black bins had struggled for years with green bins calling them worthless because of their function - „You’re full of rubbish! Look at us - we make a useful contribution to society, with our worthwhile contents! You’re just trash!“ - and the Society had evolved to combat this view. It was an important issue, as black bins were often abused for what they were, physically attacked, destroyed! But, now, the Society could no longer explain why this was and could no longer speak for all black bins.

Because black bins were no longer recognised as existing in their own right, existing as who they felt they truly were. They were being told that any abuse was because of that little piece of paper they had to choose to stick on to be seen.

And it wasn’t because of that at all.

hyperbolicnonsense · 05/03/2024 23:05

Megifer · 05/03/2024 18:56

I genuinely have no idea what assigned female/male at birth means.

How does that work with sex scans for pg women? Is that assigned female/male at scan?

I think perhaps those people just have to write N/A when asked whether they were AFAB or AMAB.

hyperbolicnonsense · 05/03/2024 22:53

It's offensive because it introduces the misogynistic idea that people can change sex. The pretence that people can change sex is being used to attack hard-won women's rights. There's no need to use the 'at birth' or the 'assigned' bit because sex doesn't change. Hence male at birth, male forever - better captured by saying just 'male'. Male is about body and not an identity statement so no need to get offended.

DreamyCritic · 05/03/2024 22:23

What am I meant to do when a very butch appearing female is in the ladies loo when I am?

Nothing.
As you say they are a butch FEMALE in tbe ladies loo. You already know it's OK for them to be there.

Annalouisa · 05/03/2024 22:19

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:08

I was alluding to the fact that a more neutral term may benefit both parties. All you’ve done is prove my point that some of you can’t actually have a reasonable discussion and consider both sides. YOU consider it a fact, others do not. You need to be respectful of their viewpoint to get anywhere with this. You don’t have to agree with them but you need to listen and stop being so needlessly aggressive with your tone.

Please do tell anyone who uses AFAB that they need to sit down and listen, too, and that they need to be more respectful of women who were born female, and are thus WOMEN.

The real problem, in my view, is that AFAB tries to redefine people who don't want to be re-defined. If you want to talk about yourself as AFAB for some reason, go ahead, but don't expect us all to follow and contort ourselves into thinking being a woman is just some random thing a doctor wrote on a notepad. That really is denying reality, and it's actually disrespectful to deny other people's reality. Walk a thousand miles etc.

No one is obliged to sit down and listen to someone who denies their existence and belittles a defining characteristic as a random thing that's mainly in their head. Sex is real. Gender is a societal expectation. Chromosomes don't lie.

Signed: Assigned female through DNA at conception, not after birth through an administrative error.

Bonus question: if sex is assigned at birth, do the doctors give out penises and vaginas? How do they stick them on? 😜

endofthelinefinally · 05/03/2024 22:02

ThinWomansBrain · 05/03/2024 20:48

In the early 80's a friend was training as a nurse at Gt Ormond Street - I can still recall her astonishment at the first intersex new born that she worked with - 40+years on.
Admittedly most of the patients were transferred there, but it turned out to be far from unusual.

There is no such thing as intersex.
DSDs have nothing to do with gender ideology.
DSDs are all specific to either male or female sex.
People who have DSD have asked repeatedly to not be used and exploited in this way.
I wish people would stop repeating this misinformation about a tiny minority of people who are born with a genetic condition.
I hope your friend was better informed by the time they qualified.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 21:55

When the balance of domestic abuse/sexual assault/rapes are committed by trans women than males living as males, I will agree that’s an issue

Eh so you expect the less that 1% of males (who identify as women) to commit MORE crimes against women than the 99% of males who do not identify as trans before you will think that trans women are a risk to women, whilst ignoring the fact that statistically this is not going to happen and ignoring the evidence that shows that trans women commit offences against women at at least the same rate as any other man?

@DontLeanOnTheKeyboard it is male crime that is the problem. Males who have special women identities are no less likely to commit crimes against women than any other male. In fact proportionately more trans women who are in prison are in there for sexual crimes than other males.

We want single sex spaces for women because ALL males are a risk, including trans women. It is not because they are trans it is because they are male.

If a woman identifies as a trans man then given she is female she can use the spaces she sees fit. If she feels uncomfortable in women's spaces that is not really the problem of women to fix.

maddening · 05/03/2024 21:07

Gender was only assigned when it was not clear - this was less than 0.01% of births - stolen medical language 🙄

PurpleBugz · 05/03/2024 21:05

YANBU

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 20:59

Instead of directing your ire at trans women, direct it at males, and society’s attitude to them that allows some of them to commit atrocities against women. Or other men. And let’s address domestic abuse within same sex relationships. I bet they’re pretending to be lesbian/gay to get access to people they can control.

Trans women are males. That risk doesn't change because they put a dress on. When you find a magical way of females being able to tell the bad males from the good males (trans women in your opinion) then please, let us know.

In the meantime all males, regardless of how they identify, can stay out of women's spaces.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 20:55

Instead of directing your ire at trans women, direct it at males, and society’s attitude to them that allows some of them to commit atrocities against women. Or other men. And let’s address domestic abuse within same sex relationships. I bet they’re pretending to be lesbian/gay to get access to people they can control.

Transwomen are males. They offend against women at the same rate, if not higher, than other males.

Why would any woman want to compromise their safety by letting them access their spaces. Why should women make themselves less safe because of some totally unscientific, unverifiable idea in a man's head?

And fundamentally, according to self id, this is inviting ANY man who likes into women's spaces. All they have to do is say they 'feel like a woman' 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread