Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assigned Female at Birth - AFAB

483 replies

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 08:36

AIBU to get the actual rage every time I see this written down? Often in reputable sources.

Obviously this has come about due to people differentiating between gender and sex - I understand needing clarity between those two when talking to or questioning people.

but every single bloody time I read it I can only think of the horrific female infanticide statistics. AIBU to think ‘assigned female at birth’ is fucking offensive to women, as so many of us are killed at birth ONLY because we are female. Nobody assigned those infants a female sex, they didn’t just randomly pick half of the babies and murder them.

can’t we agree as a society to call out AFAB and AMAB as being horrific and change it? Happy to hear alternatives. Observed female/male at birth sounds reasonable to me if you need to specify birth sex vs gender.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:47

Treeper22 · 05/03/2024 09:38

That's like saying some people think the earth is round but others don't and we need to sit down and find a compromise around language to accommodate the beliefs of flat earthers. No, Sorry. Beliefs can be respected, sure, but that doesn't mean language that has developed from rigorous scientific study has to be adjusted to accommodate them.

That is a valid point (the flat earthers bit). I suppose my argument centres around the fact that we are talking about something that is so intrinsic to a person and their sense of self rather than a belief outside of themselves. I don’t think I’m expressing that well but I do feel there is a difference. It’s almost that their experiences are self-reported I suppose.

CecilyP · 05/03/2024 09:46

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 09:18

@OldManSign there is no debate to be had. It's like 2+2=4 and someone coming along and saying, is it though, can't we have a reasonable debate about it?

Eh no. 2+2=4. End of.

Well quite! The phrase just sounds ridiculous. Like a group of midwives might say, ‘we’ve had a lot of boys today, let’s assign the next baby female!’ Or even like the babies are coming off some kind of factory production line!

I’ve never made any connection with infanticide, and while we’re being factually correct, killing a baby because it is female is not actually infanticide.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 09:46

Why is it problematic on forms?

The poster literally says it in the following sentence 🤯

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:44

I’m not saying that at all. I am saying to treat them with respect. You catch more flies with honey than with vinegar

Im sorry, but history proves you very wrong

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 09:44

ErrolTheDragon · 05/03/2024 09:43

But I have no issue with people using AFAB or AMAB if they so wish

I also don’t believe in god but don’t go around shitting on people coming out of church

If people want to use inaccurate terms about themselves, that's fine.
It's the use on forms etc which is problematic, rather than simply asking for sex. It's somewhat akin to being asked which religion you belong to with no possibility of not having one.

The co-option of the phrase from its valid use for a small number of people with DSDs who were mistakenly 'assigned' the wrong sex at birth (probably vanishingly small number in developed countries now) shows the complete disregard for them. In those rare cases, the appropriate information is not the sex they were (mis)assigned at birth, but rather the actual sex subsequently identified.

Why is it problematic on forms?

ErrolTheDragon · 05/03/2024 09:43

But I have no issue with people using AFAB or AMAB if they so wish

I also don’t believe in god but don’t go around shitting on people coming out of church

If people want to use inaccurate terms about themselves, that's fine.
It's the use on forms etc which is problematic, rather than simply asking for sex. It's somewhat akin to being asked which religion you belong to with no possibility of not having one.

The co-option of the phrase from its valid use for a small number of people with DSDs who were mistakenly 'assigned' the wrong sex at birth (probably vanishingly small number in developed countries now) shows the complete disregard for them. In those rare cases, the appropriate information is not the sex they were (mis)assigned at birth, but rather the actual sex subsequently identified.

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:42

DreamyCritic · 05/03/2024 09:37

So far "respect" has got us in yo a situation where women & girls have no access to single sex provisions, they like employment, are arrested and denied equal opportunity in sport and representation in politics. What about that should be respected?

You don’t have to respect the outcome just the viewpoint. All I am saying is to talk to people with more respect and you much more are likely to have your viewpoint heard and considered.

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 09:41

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:37

So if you know it’s inaccurate ideology, why do you take issue with people being annoyed at places like the NHS using it? Do you think people don’t have a right to be angry by misleading language coming from professional institutions?
The church isn’t forcing it’s language on medical institutions, it keeps itself within the church, just as this ideology should be doing. Would you be ok with, for example, having to pray and thank god in every restaurant before eating, to keep Christian’s happy?

If I went to a restaurant and there were loads of Christian’s eating in there and the request was made, of course I wouldn’t mind.

I don’t think people have a right to be angry about the NHS or any other organisation asking a pretty simple question.

Universalsnail · 05/03/2024 09:41

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 09:29

I understand that some people would prefer to use the term AFAB, does that mean it’s fair that wider society should also use it in case they ask someone who considers themselves AFAB?

I don’t wish to badger people who say they are AFAB - but when it’s written in the news or in medical questionnaires etc it upsets me.

Edited

Meant kindly but i honestly think if there was a sliding scale of problems with 10 being the most serious and 1 being really not serious then magazines printing the term AFAB is a 1. I just don't think it's anything worth getting upset over even when discussing trans v women's issues.

EasternStandard · 05/03/2024 09:40

izimbra · 05/03/2024 09:32

Yes. You've got a bee in your bonnet about trans women. Stop thinking about it. It doesn't affect you.

It doesn't affect you.

I think if the inaccessible gender based language was dropped that would be the case

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 09:40

Were the people who wanted this change to unscientific language, also being overly sensitive?

Exactly.

MagpiePi · 05/03/2024 09:40

Universalsnail · 05/03/2024 09:21

I don't see the point in being offended by it.
There are many nuanced areas of the clash between trans rights of inclusivity and women's rights to female only space. The only way to have calm helpful discussions about that is to meet each other respectfully and if the term AFAB helps some trans biologically female people to feel heard and therefore opens up the possibly for more nuanced discussion about far more important issues then fine.

I honestly think all the polarisation and toxicity around this subject is far more harmful then the term AFAB.
And it's funny to be talking about female people with actual problems like female infanticide whilst complaining about the term AFAB.

Edited

So if the term AFAB offends 50% of the population then they should just suck it up?
This tiptoeing around language because a very small, vocal minority choose to ignore reality has turned into a proper shitshow.

Rosesanddaisies1 · 05/03/2024 09:40

Why not focus your anger on the actual issue, i.e. sex selective abortion or actual female infanticide. Who cares about some terminology.

DreamyCritic · 05/03/2024 09:39

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:36

I would just say I disagreed personally. I don’t need to give it a descriptor. If I called your strongly held views nonsense I’m sure you would get riled up. That’s all I’m pointing out is happening to people.

If my beliefs are nonsense I would have to accept people saying so.
Why are people so scared of being honest?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 09:39

It's fine to say something is nonsensical when it is. Like I said previously, I don't care if a flat earther reeeaaallly believes the earth is flat. It's not.

If they get offended by that then that's on them. I don't care. We don't have to have a respectful, reasonable, polite, calm, lovely discussion about it. I'm not up for debating crazy beliefs.

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:39

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 09:32

But why does it upset you?

You being overly sensitive is the issue here

Were the people who wanted this change to unscientific language, also being overly sensitive?

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 09:38

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:33

I didn’t say it should be perpetuated at all. I just mean to say that their reality and lived experience is just as valid as yours and worthy of being listened to. You could probably also argue that there’s indisputable evidence that trans people are harmed by our current language (I’d need to read up on that to have a solid argument). I’m not stating you are wrong or they are wrong, I just mean the current methods of talking about this are just not working and perhaps being more tactful would get people further.

Their reality is not real though.

I mean, no human can change sex.

Why should society change based on a persons perception of 'gender'? What even is gender? How does a man live as a woman if it is not to do with stereotypes of what he believes a woman is? Why should that give him the right to single sex spaces for women?

Why should his gender feelings trump the safety and dignity of women in single sex spaces?

And before you ask well what has this got to do with assigned female at birth? It has everything to do with it. It is all part of the same push to 'identity' based politics and the people it harms most are women and children. If you use this language you are perpetuating this belief and that does harm women and children.

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 09:38

izimbra · 05/03/2024 09:32

Yes. You've got a bee in your bonnet about trans women. Stop thinking about it. It doesn't affect you.

This has got nothing to do with trans women. It’s nationwide terminology.

In fact, whenever I see anyone referring to themselves as AFAB/AMAB - it’s mostly in the context of trans men calling themselves AFAB.

My issue is with everyone else using the term assigned male/female at birth when they want to specify sex rather than gender.

OP posts:
Treeper22 · 05/03/2024 09:38

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:08

I was alluding to the fact that a more neutral term may benefit both parties. All you’ve done is prove my point that some of you can’t actually have a reasonable discussion and consider both sides. YOU consider it a fact, others do not. You need to be respectful of their viewpoint to get anywhere with this. You don’t have to agree with them but you need to listen and stop being so needlessly aggressive with your tone.

That's like saying some people think the earth is round but others don't and we need to sit down and find a compromise around language to accommodate the beliefs of flat earthers. No, Sorry. Beliefs can be respected, sure, but that doesn't mean language that has developed from rigorous scientific study has to be adjusted to accommodate them.

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 09:37

Crabble · 05/03/2024 09:35

The point is that sex is innate. It is an objective reality which exists, independently of someone gender identity. There are consequences to someone’s sex - an absolute fuckton of them. Female infanticide is one example.

The reason AFAB is offensive is is implies sex isn’t an objective reality but a decision made by humans as to what sex someone is. It conflates sex and gender identity in the wider context of people trying to minimise the importance of sex in female oppression. OP’s point about infanticide is no one checks female babies gender identity before killing them.

Out of interest why can’t we use the phrase “born female” or “observed to be female” instead of “assigned female”? What would be your complaint about that?

Well then if that’s the case surely you’d be pushing for this movement.

As if people have to wait until a child determines their gender before being killed a few less might die.

DreamyCritic · 05/03/2024 09:37

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:34

I’m not saying that at all. I am saying to treat them with respect. You catch more flies with honey than with vinegar. I really do believe there is some middle ground to be found with these issues. Unfortunately there are people on both sides who just can’t be respectful long enough to find it. The type of language I often see online is just alienating the other parties.

So far "respect" has got us in yo a situation where women & girls have no access to single sex provisions, they like employment, are arrested and denied equal opportunity in sport and representation in politics. What about that should be respected?

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:37

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 09:31

Nope

But I have no issue with people using AFAB or AMAB if they so wish

I also don’t believe in god but don’t go around shitting on people coming out of church

So if you know it’s inaccurate ideology, why do you take issue with people being annoyed at places like the NHS using it? Do you think people don’t have a right to be angry by misleading language coming from professional institutions?
The church isn’t forcing it’s language on medical institutions, it keeps itself within the church, just as this ideology should be doing. Would you be ok with, for example, having to pray and thank god in every restaurant before eating, to keep Christian’s happy?

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:36

DreamyCritic · 05/03/2024 09:34

What other word to describe nonsense would you suggest which is more respectful in your view?

I would just say I disagreed personally. I don’t need to give it a descriptor. If I called your strongly held views nonsense I’m sure you would get riled up. That’s all I’m pointing out is happening to people.

Crabble · 05/03/2024 09:35

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 09:12

So then what’s the link to female infanticide

If you don’t believe sex is assigned at birth, then why link it to poor babies that have been killed

its really quite abhorrent to try and link the two

The point is that sex is innate. It is an objective reality which exists, independently of someone gender identity. There are consequences to someone’s sex - an absolute fuckton of them. Female infanticide is one example.

The reason AFAB is offensive is is implies sex isn’t an objective reality but a decision made by humans as to what sex someone is. It conflates sex and gender identity in the wider context of people trying to minimise the importance of sex in female oppression. OP’s point about infanticide is no one checks female babies gender identity before killing them.

Out of interest why can’t we use the phrase “born female” or “observed to be female” instead of “assigned female”? What would be your complaint about that?

DreamyCritic · 05/03/2024 09:35

izimbra · 05/03/2024 09:32

Yes. You've got a bee in your bonnet about trans women. Stop thinking about it. It doesn't affect you.

AFAB actually describes transmen not transwomen.