Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assigned Female at Birth - AFAB

483 replies

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 08:36

AIBU to get the actual rage every time I see this written down? Often in reputable sources.

Obviously this has come about due to people differentiating between gender and sex - I understand needing clarity between those two when talking to or questioning people.

but every single bloody time I read it I can only think of the horrific female infanticide statistics. AIBU to think ‘assigned female at birth’ is fucking offensive to women, as so many of us are killed at birth ONLY because we are female. Nobody assigned those infants a female sex, they didn’t just randomly pick half of the babies and murder them.

can’t we agree as a society to call out AFAB and AMAB as being horrific and change it? Happy to hear alternatives. Observed female/male at birth sounds reasonable to me if you need to specify birth sex vs gender.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 10:12

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 10:08

I thought you didn’t like people bowing down to ideology

Yet you use it when convenient to your argument

One could ask why a womans religious ideology is more important than someone else’s gender ideology. Both are nonsense according to you?

Edited

If you think that religious minority women should be further repressed by males then I think that says quite a lot about what you think about women.

I don't have to believe in their religion to think that all women should have rights to spaces free from males.

Melroses · 05/03/2024 10:12

YANBU.

Total regressive nonsense.

Nobody is assigned anything at birth.

Birth certificates record the circumstances of a birth.

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 10:08

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 10:04

Of course, but vulnerable girls are more likely to be harmed by trans ideology. My daughter is autistic many of her peers are 'identifying' as boys/ non binary now at the risk of being infertile in the future due to wanting puberty blockers and radical double mastectomies at adulthood. Does that not concern you, it's fucking horrifying to me?

And I mentioned religious minorities in my last post. Women of religious minority are more impacted by trans ideology than other women. Some now have to self exclude because women's swimming sessions might include male bodied people and toilets are no longer single sex. Doesn't that bother you?

Think about who you are helping here, men are not and will never be a minority, no matter what gender feelings they claim to have.

Edited

I thought you didn’t like people bowing down to ideology

Yet you use it when convenient to your argument

One could ask why a womans religious ideology is more important than someone else’s gender ideology. Both are nonsense according to you?

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 05/03/2024 10:07

Nope, can’t spend my life hunting for reasons to kick off cos Trans. It’s a collection of letters fgs.

They ask other stuff but you don’t get your knickers in a twist about how many of them were murdered as a result of it?

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 10:06

Crabble · 05/03/2024 10:05

is that a serious comment or just glib nonsense to deflect so you don’t have to engage with the rest of the post?

It’s not deflection

Surely if you care so much about babies being killed for merely being born female, this movement would be music to your ears.

notsorighteousthesedays · 05/03/2024 10:06

Universalsnail · 05/03/2024 09:21

I don't see the point in being offended by it.
There are many nuanced areas of the clash between trans rights of inclusivity and women's rights to female only space. The only way to have calm helpful discussions about that is to meet each other respectfully and if the term AFAB helps some trans biologically female people to feel heard and therefore opens up the possibly for more nuanced discussion about far more important issues then fine.

I honestly think all the polarisation and toxicity around this subject is far more harmful then the term AFAB.
And it's funny to be talking about female people with actual problems like female infanticide whilst complaining about the term AFAB.

Edited

Funny? In what way?

Crabble · 05/03/2024 10:05

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 09:37

Well then if that’s the case surely you’d be pushing for this movement.

As if people have to wait until a child determines their gender before being killed a few less might die.

is that a serious comment or just glib nonsense to deflect so you don’t have to engage with the rest of the post?

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 10:04

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:58

Just one final response before I go to be productive… I would counter argue - do you believe disabled people (a minority) should have their needs met? Do you believe Jewish people (a minority) should have their needs met? Do you believe black people (a minority in this country) should have their needs met? You clearly believe women and children should which I applaud. Just because someone is a minority doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be listened to and accommodated.

Of course, but vulnerable girls are more likely to be harmed by trans ideology. My daughter is autistic many of her peers are 'identifying' as boys/ non binary now at the risk of being infertile in the future due to wanting puberty blockers and radical double mastectomies at adulthood. Does that not concern you, it's fucking horrifying to me?

And I mentioned religious minorities in my last post. Women of religious minority are more impacted by trans ideology than other women. Some now have to self exclude because women's swimming sessions might include male bodied people and toilets are no longer single sex. Doesn't that bother you?

Think about who you are helping here, men are not and will never be a minority, no matter what gender feelings they claim to have.

Naunet · 05/03/2024 10:03

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:58

Just one final response before I go to be productive… I would counter argue - do you believe disabled people (a minority) should have their needs met? Do you believe Jewish people (a minority) should have their needs met? Do you believe black people (a minority in this country) should have their needs met? You clearly believe women and children should which I applaud. Just because someone is a minority doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be listened to and accommodated.

Oh my god, are you seriously comparing things like wheelchair ramps which hurt no one and help someone access a supermarket for example, to some dipshit claiming their feelings are hurt by biological fact?! Well I guess schools better start teaching flat earth theory too then by that logic.

Crabble · 05/03/2024 10:03

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:58

Just one final response before I go to be productive… I would counter argue - do you believe disabled people (a minority) should have their needs met? Do you believe Jewish people (a minority) should have their needs met? Do you believe black people (a minority in this country) should have their needs met? You clearly believe women and children should which I applaud. Just because someone is a minority doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be listened to and accommodated.

Absolutely trans people should be accommodated. So should female people and sometimes that means we need to have a respectful conversation, and sometimes that means that something trans people would prefer won’t be possible (likewise with women).

The problem with AFAB is it completely disregards the feelings and needs of one group (natal women) in favour of the other, by pretending sex isn’t real or important.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 10:01

So I don’t really understand why treating people decently is so displeasing to so many people.

Pandering to trans ideology has led to -

Rapists in women's prisons.
Women and children being sexually assaulted in women's single sex spaces.
Women being displaced on sporting teams or beaten by males in sport.
Women not having single sex rape crisis care options.
Lesbians being called bigots for not accepting trans women in their dating pool.
Girls refusing school or to drink at school because boys have been in their toilet.
A woman raped on NHS single sex ward then gaslit by being told that was impossible because there was no man on the ward.
Religious minority women and sex assault victims / other vulnerable women withdrawing from society due to the fact that there are no longer single sex spaces.

This list is not exhaustive.

Changing the terminology in respect of the recording of the sex of babies born is part of the ideology that has led to these harms.

This is why it is displeasing to many.

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:58

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 09:55

So basically you think that it is right to pander to a minority rather than be accurate.

Even when you have seen the harms done to women and children as a result of society pandering to that minority?

As others have said they can believe what they want about themselves but forcing language on others and removing single sex spaces is harmful.

Just one final response before I go to be productive… I would counter argue - do you believe disabled people (a minority) should have their needs met? Do you believe Jewish people (a minority) should have their needs met? Do you believe black people (a minority in this country) should have their needs met? You clearly believe women and children should which I applaud. Just because someone is a minority doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be listened to and accommodated.

Codlingmoths · 05/03/2024 09:58

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:52

I was referring to people who are transgender. That is, later in life their feelings of only having been assigned a gender at birth are so central to their being. I don’t necessarily disagree that observed fe/male at birth would be a bad thing instead but I’d be interested to hear trans people comment too.

Transgender people should stop trying to conflate sex and gender then and maybe we could all get along. Sex is fixed and no amount of ‘feeling’ can change that.

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 09:57

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:52

I was referring to people who are transgender. That is, later in life their feelings of only having been assigned a gender at birth are so central to their being. I don’t necessarily disagree that observed fe/male at birth would be a bad thing instead but I’d be interested to hear trans people comment too.

I’d be interested if any of them objected to replacing the word “assigned” with observed instead. Because I can’t see why that isn’t a reasonable alternative.

OP posts:
OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:56

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:54

It’s assigned SEX at birth, not gender, so how does that impact trans people, who largely accept sex and gender are different?

My mistake I mistyped. Thanks for the correction.

Codlingmoths · 05/03/2024 09:55

HighonCatnip · 05/03/2024 08:48

It's a term used to emphasise that for many intersex individuals in the past, doctors who were unsure about what sex the baby was would pick one. Hence 'assigned'. It emphasises that the sex was assigned rather than inherent. You only have to read stores of people who grew up intersex and very much felt they were male when they'd been assigned female or vice versa. Couldn't get worked up over something like this.

I can because for 99,9% of babies born in the first world it’s just so wrong and really misleading. I knew my babies were boys or girls at 11 weeks pregnant through testing of their dna fragments in my blood. That’s reality. Whatever they are is fixed. And this language gives people the idea it’s not, language matters.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 09:55

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:52

I was referring to people who are transgender. That is, later in life their feelings of only having been assigned a gender at birth are so central to their being. I don’t necessarily disagree that observed fe/male at birth would be a bad thing instead but I’d be interested to hear trans people comment too.

So basically you think that it is right to pander to a minority rather than be accurate.

Even when you have seen the harms done to women and children as a result of society pandering to that minority?

As others have said they can believe what they want about themselves but forcing language on others and removing single sex spaces is harmful.

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:55

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:50

And why would we try a way that has very little track record of working? Do you know a secret history doesn’t?

Im not interesting in sitting down and discussing with ‘sides’ anyway, I’m not sure many people are, they can tell themselves whatever lies they want, they’re entitled to their beliefs. My issue is with professional institutions adopting this ideological language.

Well I would also argue that history shows us that arguments, battles, wars (whatever level of disagreement) never pan out well. So I don’t really understand why treating people decently is so displeasing to so many people.

Anyway I have to get back to work so I shall leave you all to your discussion. Hope everyone has a lovely day ☺️

Musomama1 · 05/03/2024 09:54

I'm with you OP and your reasoning is interesting.

For me, my reasoning is that it's ideological language thrust on 'disbelievers'. The earth is round, not flat, sex is observed, not assigned.

We know this language really has nothing to do with the rare occurences of difficulty in observing sex (although medical professionals can do a simple cheek swab now so no observation is needed). Of course it's to do with modern gender identity politics.

It's bollocks and I call it out on the forms by ticking 'other, then stating that myself or my children's sex was not assigned.

Keep resisting, once that Overtons Window gets moved, this shit will be normalized.

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:54

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:52

I was referring to people who are transgender. That is, later in life their feelings of only having been assigned a gender at birth are so central to their being. I don’t necessarily disagree that observed fe/male at birth would be a bad thing instead but I’d be interested to hear trans people comment too.

It’s assigned SEX at birth, not gender, so how does that impact trans people, who largely accept sex and gender are different?

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:52

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 09:49

But that argument makes no sense in respect of babies being born.

Babies are born with a sex not a gender identity. Saying the sex is assigned rather than observed has nothing to do with the babies.

Every human has a sex which is observed and noted at birth.

I was referring to people who are transgender. That is, later in life their feelings of only having been assigned a gender at birth are so central to their being. I don’t necessarily disagree that observed fe/male at birth would be a bad thing instead but I’d be interested to hear trans people comment too.

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:50

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:48

I’m not discussing history. I’m suggesting a way forward.

And why would we try a way that has very little track record of working? Do you know a secret history doesn’t?

Im not interesting in sitting down and discussing with ‘sides’ anyway, I’m not sure many people are, they can tell themselves whatever lies they want, they’re entitled to their beliefs. My issue is with professional institutions adopting this ideological language.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 09:49

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:47

That is a valid point (the flat earthers bit). I suppose my argument centres around the fact that we are talking about something that is so intrinsic to a person and their sense of self rather than a belief outside of themselves. I don’t think I’m expressing that well but I do feel there is a difference. It’s almost that their experiences are self-reported I suppose.

But that argument makes no sense in respect of babies being born.

Babies are born with a sex not a gender identity. Saying the sex is assigned rather than observed has nothing to do with the babies.

Every human has a sex which is observed and noted at birth.

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 09:49

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 09:46

Why is it problematic on forms?

The poster literally says it in the following sentence 🤯

They really did not

If it’s so rare for it to be an issue why kick up a stink

Some people’s arguments here are very odd

apparently AFAB on forms isn’t necessary because so few people align to that term

but in the next breath say how it shouldn’t be used on a form because a tiny portion of those who were misasigned at birth might have issues with the form.

either a small group of people matter or not

OldManSign · 05/03/2024 09:48

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:44

I’m not saying that at all. I am saying to treat them with respect. You catch more flies with honey than with vinegar

Im sorry, but history proves you very wrong

I’m not discussing history. I’m suggesting a way forward.