Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assigned Female at Birth - AFAB

483 replies

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 08:36

AIBU to get the actual rage every time I see this written down? Often in reputable sources.

Obviously this has come about due to people differentiating between gender and sex - I understand needing clarity between those two when talking to or questioning people.

but every single bloody time I read it I can only think of the horrific female infanticide statistics. AIBU to think ‘assigned female at birth’ is fucking offensive to women, as so many of us are killed at birth ONLY because we are female. Nobody assigned those infants a female sex, they didn’t just randomly pick half of the babies and murder them.

can’t we agree as a society to call out AFAB and AMAB as being horrific and change it? Happy to hear alternatives. Observed female/male at birth sounds reasonable to me if you need to specify birth sex vs gender.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
inamarina · 05/03/2024 11:53

Naunet · 05/03/2024 09:07

No, we just need to stick with facts, sex is not assigned at birth. There is zero reason to pretend it is.

Exactly, why can’t we just stick with facts?
Do we need calm and respectful discussion with people who claim the earth is flat too? I mean, stay respectful by all means, but facts are facts.

endofthelinefinally · 05/03/2024 11:53

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 11:43

Until you can show me how a form giving an option for AFAB or AMAB has harmed women I’ll just let you shout into the sky

It gives credence to a movement which has moved on to locking up convicted rapists in women's prisons, sterilising and mutilating vulnerable children, removing single sex services for female victims of rape and violence, amongst other things. Once you insist that everyone bows to this new belief, you can't pick and choose the bits of the whole that you think are ok.
Read "Time to Think" by Hannah Barnes and "Trans" by Helen Joyce. Well researched and accessible.

Remeniss · 05/03/2024 11:50

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 09:01

I do, truly.

It’s an odd phrase, so every time I read it or hear it, it sticks out like a sore thumb. Then the physical reaction comes because it’s repugnant to pretend we get to choose who is a girl or who is a boy considering the horrendous violence against women and girls globally.

people don’t get their clitoris removed because someone decided at birth they were a girl. They don’t get abandoned at birth on the whim of a doctors decision over whether he assigned them one sex or another. Women don’t get raped because someone chose us to be women.

i can’t get past it - so yes it distresses me. Like it does when I hear many slurs.

How does any of that change whether someone’s sex is observed or their gender assigned??? It’s literally the same outcome. What a weird thing to be fixated on

Devonshiregal · 05/03/2024 11:46

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 09:01

I do, truly.

It’s an odd phrase, so every time I read it or hear it, it sticks out like a sore thumb. Then the physical reaction comes because it’s repugnant to pretend we get to choose who is a girl or who is a boy considering the horrendous violence against women and girls globally.

people don’t get their clitoris removed because someone decided at birth they were a girl. They don’t get abandoned at birth on the whim of a doctors decision over whether he assigned them one sex or another. Women don’t get raped because someone chose us to be women.

i can’t get past it - so yes it distresses me. Like it does when I hear many slurs.

That’s exactly what all this shit is. Bigoted. Women are not. They just are…not. Not real. Not a thing. Not worthy. Just whittery idiots who think we are victimised.

all this gender is different from sex shit is stupid too. It IS based on sex.

case and point - how can a male have gender reassignment and have a vagina “made”, claim they are now WOMEN but then say oh gender is nothing to do with sex? Well then you’re not transgender your transex and therefore believe that sex ‘matters’ and that female “gendered” clothes etc are related to your sex.

SO trans people are by the very nature fundamentally opposed to gender isn’t associated with sex-ers (non binary for instance)

this is all so stupid. People are acting as though someone came along and arbitrarily slapped the terms man and women onto people. They didn’t. It is observable at birth and has been for fucking millions of years.

and the intersex argument is ridiculous. If all trans people were actually intersex, that would make sense. If their biology/genes showed us that they were actually more male than female or vice versa, then what we would have is a bunch of people who were mis-assigned at birth. But we don’t. They aren’t. We have a small number of people who sadly have congenital differences who were raised under strict gender stereotypes but whose biology associates more with the sex which doesn’t adhere to those stereotypes. And yet trans are appropriating these people’s congenital disorders (because that’s what it is) and using them as an argument to support their mental illness and perusal of gender stereotypes.

honestly it’s as stupid as if someone said ATLAB -Assigned Two Legs At Birth. No. You were born with two legs. Anyone born without a leg has a congenital disorder. Ffs.

or ABAB - assigned black at birth.

all the while women are still being raped. Still being abused. Still being treated like second class citizens simply because we ARE female. And there’s nothing you can do to blind people to reality, no matter how hard some people stomp their feet and scream that we should pretend we can’t tell who is female or not!

you are so right op. We don’t get to CHOOSE how we are born or how we are treated.

Ratsoffasinkingsauage · 05/03/2024 11:46

@Dutchairfryer Did you read my post?

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 11:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

inamarina · 05/03/2024 11:44

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 08:47

Oh give over

Do you actually think about female infanticide every time you see 4 little letters written down?

If so I’d ask yourself why. Especially since in the countries where it’s an issue, they don’t tend to align with the AFAB movement either

Doesn’t really matter if she thinks about female infanticide every time she sees those letters.
Fact is those babies are killed because they’re female. They don’t get the chance to identify out of it.

Remeniss · 05/03/2024 11:43

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 08:50

Did you read my post? You don’t think it’s offensive to the millions of babies who you must believe had their sex ‘assigned’ and died because of it?

wtaf

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 11:43

endofthelinefinally · 05/03/2024 11:41

My point is that the whole concept of "assigned at birth" is ridiculous and is part of a recent ideological movement that is extremely harmful to women and children. Sex is immutable and cannot be assigned or changed. The vast majority of people know this.

Until you can show me how a form giving an option for AFAB or AMAB has harmed women I’ll just let you shout into the sky

endofthelinefinally · 05/03/2024 11:43

Ratsoffasinkingsauage · 05/03/2024 11:39

@Dutchairfryer

I completely understand the OPs point and since you don’t will have a go at explaining.

The concept that sex is assigned by a doctor at north suggests that your sex is chosen for you by someone else.

Since women have been discriminated against in the basis of sex for the last several millennia (in the context of the western world) then the notion of being ‘assigned’ a sex at birth suggests that someone else is putting you into a disadvantaged grouping based on their own observations and not because of inherently who you are. Female infanticide is often based in the value of female infants in that society (often low because girls are seen as costly and a poor investment for the family vs boys). This is sex based oppression. You rightly point out that these societies do not recognise different gender expressions but have not carried that through to understand that gender expression and sex are two separate things.

The suggestion is that any woman at any time can identify out of her oppression by simply choosing not to identify as a woman.

This then suggests that women are identifying into their own oppression- essentially buying into the limitations society places on them.

It is victim blaming at its worst. Being born female and then expressing your gender outside of the narrow confines of social gender norms does not make your any less female. It doesn’t stop you from being raped, or getting pregnant, dying in childbirth, being treated as crazy for having hormone problems or from getting breast, uterine or cervical cancer. The idea that it does is stupid and dangerous and wishful thinking.

I suspect many women would like to opt out of those things but that’s not how bodies or reality works. And it is ultimate in luxury, priviledged thinking to suggest that it could. I’m sure the child brides of Yemen would love the freedom to identify out of their forced marriages.

You put it so much better than me. Hopefully you won't get a sarcastic reply.

endofthelinefinally · 05/03/2024 11:41

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 10:54

Then surely you should be championing this movement?

Bringing the concept of assigned gender to the Middle East to prevent deaths.

I think you could win a Nobel prize for that

My point is that the whole concept of "assigned at birth" is ridiculous and is part of a recent ideological movement that is extremely harmful to women and children. Sex is immutable and cannot be assigned or changed. The vast majority of people know this.

Ratsoffasinkingsauage · 05/03/2024 11:39

@Dutchairfryer

I completely understand the OPs point and since you don’t will have a go at explaining.

The concept that sex is assigned by a doctor at north suggests that your sex is chosen for you by someone else.

Since women have been discriminated against in the basis of sex for the last several millennia (in the context of the western world) then the notion of being ‘assigned’ a sex at birth suggests that someone else is putting you into a disadvantaged grouping based on their own observations and not because of inherently who you are. Female infanticide is often based in the value of female infants in that society (often low because girls are seen as costly and a poor investment for the family vs boys). This is sex based oppression. You rightly point out that these societies do not recognise different gender expressions but have not carried that through to understand that gender expression and sex are two separate things.

The suggestion is that any woman at any time can identify out of her oppression by simply choosing not to identify as a woman.

This then suggests that women are identifying into their own oppression- essentially buying into the limitations society places on them.

It is victim blaming at its worst. Being born female and then expressing your gender outside of the narrow confines of social gender norms does not make your any less female. It doesn’t stop you from being raped, or getting pregnant, dying in childbirth, being treated as crazy for having hormone problems or from getting breast, uterine or cervical cancer. The idea that it does is stupid and dangerous and wishful thinking.

I suspect many women would like to opt out of those things but that’s not how bodies or reality works. And it is ultimate in luxury, priviledged thinking to suggest that it could. I’m sure the child brides of Yemen would love the freedom to identify out of their forced marriages.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 11:25

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 11:25

@TheKeatingFive you and I keep cross posting.

You are right, it is so dramatic.

Perhaps if the trans community showed even a modicum of concern over the fact that women and children are being harmed we could have a sensible conversation about this.

But it's all about them. As ever.

Exactly

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 11:25

@TheKeatingFive you and I keep cross posting.

You are right, it is so dramatic.

Perhaps if the trans community showed even a modicum of concern over the fact that women and children are being harmed we could have a sensible conversation about this.

But it's all about them. As ever.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 11:24

izimbra · 05/03/2024 11:19

FACTS! FACTS! FACTS!

Imagination, feelings, identity are as nothing. They're irrelevant to our sense of ourselves and the way we move through the world, at least according to the multitudes of angry Gradgrinds here on Mumsnet, most of whom have never met a trans person but are practically incontinent with anger at the thought of their existence, or of anyone actually accepting trans people on their own terms.

I'm not angry at the existence of trans people.

I'm angry that their demands to be treated in all circumstances as the opposite sex harms women.

I am angry that transactivist say that pointing this out makes a woman a transphobe.

Perhaps if trans women could use their imaginations better they could come up with solutions to their identities that didn't involve women and children being collateral damage. Because women are not acceptable collateral damage and the days of silencing us over it are over.

Enough damage to women and children has been done.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/03/2024 11:23

izimbra · 05/03/2024 11:19

FACTS! FACTS! FACTS!

Imagination, feelings, identity are as nothing. They're irrelevant to our sense of ourselves and the way we move through the world, at least according to the multitudes of angry Gradgrinds here on Mumsnet, most of whom have never met a trans person but are practically incontinent with anger at the thought of their existence, or of anyone actually accepting trans people on their own terms.

You sound like a toddler having a tantrum.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 11:22

izimbra · 05/03/2024 11:19

FACTS! FACTS! FACTS!

Imagination, feelings, identity are as nothing. They're irrelevant to our sense of ourselves and the way we move through the world, at least according to the multitudes of angry Gradgrinds here on Mumsnet, most of whom have never met a trans person but are practically incontinent with anger at the thought of their existence, or of anyone actually accepting trans people on their own terms.

Quit all the DRAMA we're all sick of it.

People can express themselves however they want and no one is objecting to anyone else's existence.

Just stay out of spaces that don't belong to you. Very simple.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 11:20

That the truth is 'transphobic' is not the fault of women.

Exactly. It's reality that these people have an issue with. Don't shoot those of us who refuse to deny basic facts.

izimbra · 05/03/2024 11:19

FACTS! FACTS! FACTS!

Imagination, feelings, identity are as nothing. They're irrelevant to our sense of ourselves and the way we move through the world, at least according to the multitudes of angry Gradgrinds here on Mumsnet, most of whom have never met a trans person but are practically incontinent with anger at the thought of their existence, or of anyone actually accepting trans people on their own terms.

Whiskyinajar · 05/03/2024 11:19

Ex midwife here, I never assigned sex at birth. They were born male or female....thats it.

It's a boy or a girl. Apart from v v rare intersex births. Never saw one in 20 years.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 11:18

izimbra · 05/03/2024 11:06

<Transphobes metaphorically screaming into the faces of trans women> YOU'RE A MAN! Angry YOU'RE A MAN! Angry YOU'RE A MAN! Angry

That's what Mumsnet's for. Do you feel better now?

But the only way a person can be a trans woman is by being a man.

That the truth is 'transphobic' is not the fault of women.

Perhaps if trans women respected that women need single sex spaces for safety and dignity and stopped demanding access then we wouldn't need to point out the bleeding obvious.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 11:15

izimbra · 05/03/2024 11:06

<Transphobes metaphorically screaming into the faces of trans women> YOU'RE A MAN! Angry YOU'RE A MAN! Angry YOU'RE A MAN! Angry

That's what Mumsnet's for. Do you feel better now?

Well this wouldn't be required if 'transwomen' weren't claiming women's spaces and services and asking to be treated the same as biological women. It's all on them.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 11:14

I haven't read the whole thread, but it's obviously nonsense.

I wonder why the medical profession are objecting to this kind of fuckwittery. Surely they hold their expertise in higher regard than this.

Alchemistress · 05/03/2024 11:13

izimbra · 05/03/2024 11:02

Out of interest - I know transphobes aren't all religious, but for those of you who are - God is referred to repeatedly in the Bible as a male, but has no corporeal body. Why is there an absolute conviction that god is male normal among people who believe that gender is always and only determined by biology?

Shaktism specifically believes God to be a woman.

The trinity in Western culture regards God as male because Jesus is God's corporeal form and I'm pretty sure that it's accepted that he was a man.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 05/03/2024 11:12

izimbra · 05/03/2024 11:02

Out of interest - I know transphobes aren't all religious, but for those of you who are - God is referred to repeatedly in the Bible as a male, but has no corporeal body. Why is there an absolute conviction that god is male normal among people who believe that gender is always and only determined by biology?

Religious leanings are one thing but believing in pretend facts is scientifically bizarre. Hence, men are not female and vice versa, cats are not dogs, the tooth fairy doesn't exist but in the myth the tooth fairy is a female. I'm sure plenty MRA's would love the opportunity to embed further untruths in any way possible, sex clown/drag 'queen' nursery story time brainwash anyone?

Swipe left for the next trending thread