Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assigned Female at Birth - AFAB

483 replies

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 08:36

AIBU to get the actual rage every time I see this written down? Often in reputable sources.

Obviously this has come about due to people differentiating between gender and sex - I understand needing clarity between those two when talking to or questioning people.

but every single bloody time I read it I can only think of the horrific female infanticide statistics. AIBU to think ‘assigned female at birth’ is fucking offensive to women, as so many of us are killed at birth ONLY because we are female. Nobody assigned those infants a female sex, they didn’t just randomly pick half of the babies and murder them.

can’t we agree as a society to call out AFAB and AMAB as being horrific and change it? Happy to hear alternatives. Observed female/male at birth sounds reasonable to me if you need to specify birth sex vs gender.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 13:30

Remeniss · 05/03/2024 13:26

Sticking a picture on a door is hardly safeguarding.

It's representative of a social contract. Which people understand and uphold in various ways.

Yet you want to dismantle this and make women less safe. Same question for you then. How many women do you consider to be acceptable collateral damage here. Let's have that number?

99victoria · 05/03/2024 13:27

@Remeniss well if you don't think it's worthy of a serious discussion, go away and don't discuss it. Leave it to those of us who realise it is a very serious subject

Crabble · 05/03/2024 13:27

@Remeniss do you think it is accurate to say sex is assigned at birth, in other words that choice comes into it?

Naunet · 05/03/2024 13:26

Naunet · 05/03/2024 12:21

Then why are sexual assaults more common in mixed sex changing rooms compared to single sex?

https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/women/sexual-assault-unisex-changing-rooms-sunday-times-women-risk-a8519086.html

Any explanation for this @Remeniss? I’m really interested to hear why you think this happens.

Remeniss · 05/03/2024 13:26

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 12:21

Ah so women will be harmed anyway so we should stop all safeguarding???

You might be burgled anyway so do you leave your front door open or unlocked?

Sticking a picture on a door is hardly safeguarding.

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 13:26

What is wrong with changing the term

Assigned Female at Birth

to saying either

Observed female at Birth or Recorded Sex at Birth was Female ?

Could there be an issue with this?

OP posts:
Remeniss · 05/03/2024 13:23

Ratsoffasinkingsauage · 05/03/2024 12:35

@Remeniss Good to see you’ve resorted to insults.

I never said trans people didn’t exist. They obviously do. Gender expression- true freedom to wear what you like and be who you are is a valuable thing. Everyone should be able to dress and express themselves how ever they feel comfortable without fear of violence or discrimination.

But wearing dresses or liking make up = being a woman is a deeply regressive gender norm and part of the historic oppression of women. In a truly free society women could talk about this without being labelled as ‘transphobic’.

In the same way that women should be able to discuss miscarriage, infertility and child birth without having to centre men in that experience. Women are the only group of people not allowed to define themselves and their experiences without reference to others. That is sexism.

It how is someone describing themselves as afab asking you to Center men at a childbirth discussion???

the vast majority of comments on this thread are highly theoretical and exceedingly dramatised.

trans people responsible for the potential eradication of FGM, Jesus wept.

men donning skirts to enter women’s toilets to perpetrate abuse because they wouldn’t dare do that with a moustache and a pair of trousers on. It’s hard to take such a discussion seriously.

MsRosley · 05/03/2024 13:02

There's no such thing as gender. There's only sex, personality and dysphoria in some individuals around their sex. That is the ground rock of reality.

Ratsoffasinkingsauage · 05/03/2024 12:35

@Remeniss Good to see you’ve resorted to insults.

I never said trans people didn’t exist. They obviously do. Gender expression- true freedom to wear what you like and be who you are is a valuable thing. Everyone should be able to dress and express themselves how ever they feel comfortable without fear of violence or discrimination.

But wearing dresses or liking make up = being a woman is a deeply regressive gender norm and part of the historic oppression of women. In a truly free society women could talk about this without being labelled as ‘transphobic’.

In the same way that women should be able to discuss miscarriage, infertility and child birth without having to centre men in that experience. Women are the only group of people not allowed to define themselves and their experiences without reference to others. That is sexism.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 05/03/2024 12:31

YANBU

No one is “assigned” anything at birth.

Even for the small amount of people with a DSD where the incorrect sex may be recorded they are not “assigned” anything

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 12:31

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 10:42

unless you are a baby who was killed due to being born female, of the mother of one this isn’t going to be a kick in the teeth

It’s incredibly shitty to use dead children as an argument for your weird vendetta.

For clarification’s sake. This isn’t a vendetta.

There is plenty of context in language but I would assume there are words/terms that you have an immediate response to because of the deeper understanding you have. I won’t list slurs but there are many.

When hear “assigned male or female at birth” the image springs to mind of a doctor randomly choosing who gets to be born boys or girls. I think of all those girls who have suffered immense pain, violence and torture because of their sex. No one assigned them to a life of violence and torture- they are murdered raped and disfigured because they are female. Their femaleness is inherent, not gendered. Only a sadist would inflict those choices on an infant.

i hear assigned female at birth and I wish so many births had been assigned male instead.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 12:30

Yes @TheKeatingFive I think this is important, as is pointing out that we don't want to exclude trans women from women's single sex spaces because they are trans but because they are male.

Women are at risk from all males.

This is nothing to do with not believing that trans people exist it is believing that women should be safeguarded from the risk that is posed by males.

And that children should not be put on harmful pathways.

AFAB & AMAB are all part of the problem.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 12:30

Being trans is how a person feels so you can't tell can you? Or are you being transphobic?

Exactly. I thought that anyone who says their trans should be believed. No exceptions. So that sounds like a very transphobic position according to TRA principles.

TheKeatingFive · 05/03/2024 12:26

So the argument isn't 'trans women are a significant threat to all women' - because statistically they can't be: only 0.3% of the population are trans women, and the vast majority of them don't engage in predatory behaviour. Which makes the real issue predatory cis gender men pretending to be trans in large enough numbers that you think it's a meaningful threat that we all need to worry about.

Women have already been harmed by men accessing their spaces on the grounds of 'I'm really a woman, honest'

Whether you'd consider these men to be 'truly' trans or not, I don't know. I'm not sure it matters. I thought the only criteria of relevance is the person declaring themselves to be a woman. Or do you have another criteria that could be applied? If so, do share.

Ultimately this comes down to a simple question. How many women have to be harmed for you to consider this to be unacceptable. Please bear in mind this number is already greater than zero.

So let's have it. What's that number?

Remeniss · 05/03/2024 12:26

Ratsoffasinkingsauage · 05/03/2024 12:20

@Remeniss Care to address anything I said to you?

Not really, it’s would be like responding to that chicken in Moana that keeps throwing itself into the water.

whether you agree or not, trans people do actually exist and whether you think it’s right or not, they can call themselves whatever the hell they want.

baubletits · 05/03/2024 12:25

It irks me as well. We don't pick the baby's sex from the Sorting Hat, aside from a small % of babies born with DSDs, sex is not assigned.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 12:23

@izimbra I find your 'not really trans' argument interesting.

How do you know this man isn't really trans?

Being trans is how a person feels so you can't tell can you? Or are you being transphobic?

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 12:21

Remeniss · 05/03/2024 12:17

Ummm but when did having women’s only spaces protect women and children? I’m pretty sure peeping Tom’s and toilet rapists have never been stopped by a picture of a stick figure in a dress on a door.

Ah so women will be harmed anyway so we should stop all safeguarding???

You might be burgled anyway so do you leave your front door open or unlocked?

Naunet · 05/03/2024 12:21

Remeniss · 05/03/2024 12:17

Ummm but when did having women’s only spaces protect women and children? I’m pretty sure peeping Tom’s and toilet rapists have never been stopped by a picture of a stick figure in a dress on a door.

Then why are sexual assaults more common in mixed sex changing rooms compared to single sex?

https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/women/sexual-assault-unisex-changing-rooms-sunday-times-women-risk-a8519086.html

Unisex changing rooms put women at danger of sexual assault, data reveals

The vast majority of reported sexual assaults at public swimming pools in the UK take place in unisex changing rooms, new statistics reveal.

https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/women/sexual-assault-unisex-changing-rooms-sunday-times-women-risk-a8519086.html

Ratsoffasinkingsauage · 05/03/2024 12:20

@Remeniss Care to address anything I said to you?

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 12:20

Dutchairfryer · 05/03/2024 12:16

My men’s rights activism? Behave

You were the one to bring up someone being arrested and claiming to be a woman. I’m merely stating they can claim what they like it doesn’t make a difference

So you think that that person who was convicted of harming women in a single sex spaces isn't trans then, how can you tell?

What IS a trans woman if it is not a man who declares that he is a woman? Why don't you believe this man when he says he is a woman?

How can we tell who is a 'genuine' trans woman and who is a man trying to get into single sex spaces to sexually assault or to masturbate or all of the other vile reasons that men want to abuse women?

Naunet · 05/03/2024 12:19

izimbra · 05/03/2024 12:16

So the argument isn't 'trans women are a significant threat to all women' - because statistically they can't be: only 0.3% of the population are trans women, and the vast majority of them don't engage in predatory behaviour. Which makes the real issue predatory cis gender men pretending to be trans in large enough numbers that you think it's a meaningful threat that we all need to worry about. And to that purpose you fossick about on Google looking for news stories about cis gender men pretending to be trans (or occasionally a story about a predatory trans women) share it all over social media and shout 'look! trans women are a threat to all our safety'.

And I wonder what makes you different from the Tommy Robinsons of this world campaigning for a halt to immigration under the banner of 'Asian grooming gangs mean that all Asian men are a threat to our children'? Hmm

How do you know they’re pretending?! Sounds very transphobic.

ShugarTits · 05/03/2024 12:17

Remeniss · 05/03/2024 11:43

wtaf

If doctors assign sex - it implies they can do so arbitrarily.

if infants are killed because they are assigned female at birth - shouldn’t the doctors just start assigning all babies to be male? We can avoid all this slaughter.

OP posts:
Remeniss · 05/03/2024 12:17

lifeturnsonadime · 05/03/2024 12:11

Dutchairfryer

Your men's rights activism is astonishing. More women and children ARE harmed by the fact that we no longer have single sex spaces.

You are saying we should be fine with it because they can be arrested after the event ignoring the fact that women were safer before some males made unreasonable demands.

How about we go back to the original status quo where women and children weren't harmed because of the demands of a subset of males.

Ummm but when did having women’s only spaces protect women and children? I’m pretty sure peeping Tom’s and toilet rapists have never been stopped by a picture of a stick figure in a dress on a door.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 05/03/2024 12:17

Observed. It is observed. You are not assigned your sex at birth.

Ignore anybody trying to tell you that their are bigger problems in the world. This one is massive and it is the posters who shout you down who either have an agenda or are too stupid to know that there is one.