Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reacted to a hair dye patch test, AIBU to be confused about my hairdresser’s response was wrong?

32 replies

justwantnicehair · 04/03/2024 23:32

My previous hair stylist has moved to Australia, so I had my first appointment with another stylist at the same salon who is highly recommended. I had a consultation and had a patch test done behind my ear. The next day the whole area behind my ear was red with dry, itchy and flakey skin which is something I’ve not experienced before. I rang the hairdressers to ask for their advice and they said I could still go ahead with it but it’s ‘my decision’. I feel lost as I’m not sure if a bit of redness and skin dryness is ‘normal’ and to be expected (I do generally have sensitive skin and can get eczema), or whether it’s a sign of an allergy which puts me at risk of anaphylaxis.

I told the hairdresser I didn’t want to risk going ahead with it and I then asked if there any any alternative formulas I could be patch tested for which I am. My hairdresser didn’t really explain much about whether ths kind of thing is common and whether any other formulas may be suitable or whether it’s likely I’ll react to all of them, they just kept reiterating it was my decision. I’m now quite nervous about trusting them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bookteafag · 06/03/2024 08:50

listen to your body.
I dyed my hair for years and it always itched but i was ok until one day i was not.
Same old hair dye but this time my head felt like it was on fire i washed it out after 5 mins and my head was blistering.
I thought quickly and got the shavers out and went bald emergency GP appointment.
She told me i was lucky my head could have swelled up.
I shaved my head every week for 4 weeks i mean bald.
I was itching sore blisters red contact dermatitis and hives all over my face & body i looked like a freddy krueger for months.
Its been a year now and my hair has grown back lovely and natural it took a year for my head and skin & scalp to heal.
My scalp still itches but not like it did and i dont look like freddy krueger any more.
I would never use hair dye again.
I have a few grays but i like them and it could have been much worse.

SmileyClare · 06/03/2024 08:26

swayingpalmtree · 06/03/2024 06:29

She didn't even see the reaction for herself. I'm not sure why you now don't trust her

Most decent stylists won't dye someone's hair if they've had a reaction- thats why. They won't go near it because it could be potentially dangerous to the client. They should care more about the health of their clients than getting money for a dye job. I wouldnt trust them either after that.

Quite.

A qualified hairdresser is trained in the legal requirements of patch tests and the importance of avoiding dye should ANY reaction present itself in the 48 hours after.

Any reaction to hair dye indicates an allergy to an ingredient and it’s likely to result in a far more serious reaction if the dye is used again on a larger skin surface just days later.

Some clients are alarmed if the patch test has dyed the skin a bit red but op is describing skin irritation.

The hairdresser did not even ask for a photo or ask op to show her the rash before telling her she can go ahead with huge amounts of chemicals; not just dye but bleach and a toner too.

This hairdresser does not take the well being of her clients seriously: avoid.

Sourisblanche · 06/03/2024 06:45

https://amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2011/nov/28/could-hair-dye-kill-you

An old article but shows the potential dangers of hair dye. There is also some info on the NHS website.

I didn’t know any of this until it happened to me last year. I used to get half head blonde highlights twice a year. The time before my patch test, I remember thinking wow my head is burning and I was really relieved when my hairdresser took the foils off and rinsed my hair but I still wasn’t thinking allergy at that stage.

Could your hair dye kill you? | Health & wellbeing | The Guardian

<p>Recent severe reactions to hair colouring have prompted the question: why is the likely culprit – PPD – still being used, when it's banned in makeup</p>

https://amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2011/nov/28/could-hair-dye-kill-you

Sourisblanche · 06/03/2024 06:37

The patch test is a H&S stylist legal requirement if a client hasn’t had hair dyed for more than 5 months. I’ve been using the same salon for 12 years and it happened to me last year. My hairdresser said they are seeing increasing amounts of hair dye allergies which could be related to having had Covid or starting menopause.

Anyway, I had to go to the local walk in because my lips swelled up a little bit and the nurse told me the allergy gets worse each time you are exposed to the chemicals so don’t be tempted to try again. I am quite gutted really because my hair looks dull now and my hairdresser was my friend and I enjoyed going in and hearing her news.

pootlin · 06/03/2024 06:37

Hahahe · 05/03/2024 18:37

I don't think it's up to the hairdresser to give advice about the reaction you had. She didn't even see the reaction for herself. I'm not sure why you now don't trust her.

Because she knows she will be causing OP’s ENTIRE head to get ‘red with dry, itchy and flakey skin’ but doesn’t care.

pootlin · 06/03/2024 06:34

Sounds like a shit hairdresser. Do NOT trust them, go elsewhere.

swayingpalmtree · 06/03/2024 06:29

She didn't even see the reaction for herself. I'm not sure why you now don't trust her

Most decent stylists won't dye someone's hair if they've had a reaction- thats why. They won't go near it because it could be potentially dangerous to the client. They should care more about the health of their clients than getting money for a dye job. I wouldnt trust them either after that.

swayingpalmtree · 06/03/2024 06:26

I’m wondering if bleach and toners are safe?

You'll need a patch test for the toner for sure. Regarding bleach for highlights- that usually doesn't touch the scalp (in foils) so should be ok but if your hair is fine or fragile, I'd get a strand test done to see how your hair takes it. It can be quite damaging so test it first.

Hahahe · 05/03/2024 18:37

I don't think it's up to the hairdresser to give advice about the reaction you had. She didn't even see the reaction for herself. I'm not sure why you now don't trust her.

TempName247 · 05/03/2024 16:04

Kevin Murphy has toluenediamine as well 🙁

TempName247 · 05/03/2024 15:57

Wherehaveallthepopchipsgone · 05/03/2024 14:19

@TempName247 Josh Wood colour is PPD free and also excellent! Obviously you would still need to do a patch test but worth a try!

joshwoodcolour.com/collections/ppd-free-hair-colour

Aw thank you, this was actually one that I used for a while but then reacted to as it has toluenediamine, it is used instead of PPD as is less aggressive but unfortunately I can’t use anything now with either chemical.

Wherehaveallthepopchipsgone · 05/03/2024 14:19

@TempName247 Josh Wood colour is PPD free and also excellent! Obviously you would still need to do a patch test but worth a try!

joshwoodcolour.com/collections/ppd-free-hair-colour

TempName247 · 05/03/2024 14:07

I was dying my hair for years before I developed the ppd allergy, the first time it was a mild itchy scalp which I didn’t realise was an allergic reaction, the next time my whole scalp and neck were burning and itching for days. I was able to use another dye which was ppd free but I then became sensitive to another ingredient (toluenediamine).

In all the years of going to the hairdresser, many different ones in different cities, they NEVER did a patch test.

all of you who use these dyes, you can develop the allergy at any time even if you have been using the same dye. It is so important to patch test every time.

I am stuck using non permanent dyes now so if anyone knows of a good ppd free permanent dye, please let me know! My greys are showing!!

Londontown12 · 05/03/2024 13:48

Bleach is ok because it will be in the foil but again she should patch test the toner as well x

FlabMonsterIsDietingAgain · 05/03/2024 11:38

justwantnicehair · 05/03/2024 10:29

Thanks all, it was a patch test for the root colour which is light brown. I was also due to get a full head of highlights and low lights.

I’m wondering if bleach and toners are safe?

You'll need to patch test the bleach and toners.

I'd hazard a guess that bleach you'd be ok with but that you may react to the toner. That then leaves you with the decision of whether the bleach alone will get you the colour you want.

justwantnicehair · 05/03/2024 10:29

Thanks all, it was a patch test for the root colour which is light brown. I was also due to get a full head of highlights and low lights.

I’m wondering if bleach and toners are safe?

OP posts:
Londontown12 · 05/03/2024 09:05

Yes you can certainly react !
Had a client for years who had dark dye monthly and all of a sudden a reaction !
Did lists of patch tests to different brands and reaction everytime !
Never did her hair again !
I would step away from this stylist she obviously has never experienced someone reacting to colour she obviously not that interested in that part of being a hairdresser !
A good hairdresser will be knowledgeable about these things and only want the best for their clients !
Goodluck it’s a minefield! I myself have struggled to find a hairdresser as a hairdresser with the same intregrity as myself !!

Airdustmoon · 05/03/2024 07:24

You might not react to all dyes OP. I had a bad reaction to a patch test and the hairdresser was similarly blasé about it, even though my skin was raw! I still have the scar behind my ear and it was over 2 years ago now. I did not go back. I found a new hairdresser and she uses Kevin Murphy products which do not contain PPD. No problems at all.

swayingpalmtree · 05/03/2024 07:24

Your hairdresser is dangerously wrong. What's the point of doing a patch test if you're going to ignore the results? allergic reactions to hair dye get worse with each consecutive use so do not go ahead with this. Your entire face could swell up and you'd need steroids and anti histamines.

I cant believe they are advising this- it's awful. My hair stylist tested my hair for bleach and refused to give me highlights because the patch test on a sample of my hair showed my hair couldn't take it- it broke apart. They cared more about my hair and health than the money they'd get from highlights- that shows true care and I trust them. Never get your hair done by someone who you don't trust.

FlabMonsterIsDietingAgain · 05/03/2024 07:20

@Devonshiregal the only thing I've been allergic to is dyes, that does include the ones used for brows and lashes as well so I don't use those, risking an itchy head is one thing, risking blindness is a whole other ball game and mascara works fine. You do have to be very careful to read the packaging on dyes though, lots say things like 'gentle', 'organic', 'all natural ingredients' but they're as full of PPDs as the ones that say 'vibrant', 'intense' and 'shocking colour'.

Catza · 05/03/2024 07:13

Mummyoflittledragon · 05/03/2024 05:18

I am confused. There should be notes stating what brand of product and colour the old stylist used. Didn’t the stylist look these up? If they did, why the need for the patch test? I would be wanting to find this out first, then to make sure I hadn’t recently become allergic, patch test the product the old stylist used.

If it is the same product as before, maybe go to another hairdresser.

You are supposed to have a patch test if you last colour appointment was longer than 6 months ago. Also if the stylist was self-employed renting a chair, she is technically a separate business and needs to have her own test records.

solarised · 05/03/2024 05:41

CharSiu · 04/03/2024 23:43

I am allergic to hair dye.

I would be switching hair salons as she isn’t taking it seriously.

This. She could kill you

Mummyoflittledragon · 05/03/2024 05:18

I am confused. There should be notes stating what brand of product and colour the old stylist used. Didn’t the stylist look these up? If they did, why the need for the patch test? I would be wanting to find this out first, then to make sure I hadn’t recently become allergic, patch test the product the old stylist used.

If it is the same product as before, maybe go to another hairdresser.

Snozzlemaid · 05/03/2024 03:11

I started getting reactions a couple of hours after having mine coloured so decided I couldn't risk it anymore.
My hairdresser moved away so I found a new salon. On my first cut I explained I was going to grow out the colour and why, the new hairdresser couldn't believe I'd suddenly started reacting and didn't think it would be an issue at all.
She said she'd never heard of anyone suddenly becoming allergic to it. I'm not a hairdresser but I know you can develop this type of allergy at any time.
Surely that's why they do the test? Sounds crazy to do it and then ignore the result.
Op I would not be risking it personally. There's some horrific stories out there of bad reactions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread