Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like DD loves her nanny-housekeeper more than me

382 replies

bringpositivitea · 04/03/2024 20:11

My DD is 2, I'm a SAHM and we have a housekeeper / nanny who comes daily 9-3 on weekdays - she does all the cleaning, laundry, ironing, cooking lunch etc. The only thing I do is cooking dinner. So essentially I'm with my daughter all day, I try to plan really fun things for her like playdates, go to various playgrounds, soft play, feed the ducks, ride her bike, go to kid friendly museums etc. However if I have a doctors appointment or need to get something done (around 1-2 times per week when I'm gone for 3-4 hours) my daughter will stay with this nanny / housekeeper until I get back (they usually just go to the park).

It feels like my daughter loves the nanny / housekeeper (call her NH for short) more than me and I can't understand why. If NH is home when we are, she will prefer to play with NH over me and actively tell me "go away mummy" if I walk into the room they are playing in. If I'm dressing her for the walk she will request that NH does it instead. I don't stop them and it's now turned into them playing together just after her nap because if I ask whether she wants to go outside, DD will say no she wants to play at home with NH rather than go with me to the park or do anything with me...

OP posts:
hangingonfordearlife1 · 05/03/2024 14:58

@ilovebreadsauce
this woman can't afford ivf but can afford a housekeeper- this says to me she's in the middle east and paying a pittance for slave labour

fluffycatkins · 05/03/2024 14:58

T0AD · 05/03/2024 14:50

🤣😂 come on. Look how much they get paid compared to the people who's house they're cleaning.

I don't know how to do plumbing or how to cut my own hair, it's difficult. I can clean my own bathroom and kitchen.

There are many basic tasks that you could do that you won't be doing.
It is noticeable that it is tasks routinely done in the home and by women that get run down and devalued like this.

MrsKintner · 05/03/2024 14:53

ilovebreadsauce · 05/03/2024 13:59

I have 5 children as it goes!
When they were all young , yes I could have used the hell, but with one 2 year old? I don't think it is particularly good fir a child to have a dedicated adult whose remit is solely to entertain them.I certainly wouldn't feel comfortable with fulltime housekeeper hanging round all the time. And wtf dies she do all day with only one adult and one child in the house and another in the evening.Yes, I get there are occasional cleaning jobs that need to be done, but they only need doing, you know, occasionally!

So the OP just has a much cleaner (and probably bigger) house than you, better lunch, cleaner sheets, freshly ironed clothes and her child gets much more attention than yours did as she has the money to pay for it.
Whether you think those things are important or worth spending money on is up to personal choice.

T0AD · 05/03/2024 14:51

That was to the posters saying it's really fine to live in a society where people pay women crap money to clean up after them

T0AD · 05/03/2024 14:50

🤣😂 come on. Look how much they get paid compared to the people who's house they're cleaning.

I don't know how to do plumbing or how to cut my own hair, it's difficult. I can clean my own bathroom and kitchen.

potato57 · 05/03/2024 14:46

Maybe your kid just likes going to the park more than museums.

Sometimes kids just want to be kids and not be ferried around everywhere. When I was a kid I preferred going to the library with my aunt rather than my mum just because the library my aunt took me to had a book train you could sit in. It had nothing to do with which person I preferred more. It could be something at that park she just really likes. Kids also often like to do something over and over again, so if you're giving them a new experience every time it might not be something they naturally gravitate to or have strong good memories of.

It could also be this nanny knows how to play better with a kid. I have one friend who treats her kids like everything is a school or life lesson and feels awkward playing with toys - even going to the park is a lesson on the lifecycle of acorn trees. I have another friend who will sit for hours on the floor pretending to eat fake sandwiches and talking as though she's a doll with tons of made up stories. Guess who the kids prefer to hang out with.

TomeTome · 05/03/2024 14:26

ilovebreadsauce · 05/03/2024 13:59

I have 5 children as it goes!
When they were all young , yes I could have used the hell, but with one 2 year old? I don't think it is particularly good fir a child to have a dedicated adult whose remit is solely to entertain them.I certainly wouldn't feel comfortable with fulltime housekeeper hanging round all the time. And wtf dies she do all day with only one adult and one child in the house and another in the evening.Yes, I get there are occasional cleaning jobs that need to be done, but they only need doing, you know, occasionally!

Maybe they have higher standards than you? Perhaps they hoover or mop every floor, wipe all the surfaces, polish all the wood, change at least two beds and associated ironing and laundering, wash the clothes, clean windows or oven or washing machine or fridge, clean multiple bathrooms and toilets, make a light lunch, do the bins, and eat have a break. Sounds like 6 hours to me. I too have 5 children and think this is unremarkable.

ilovebreadsauce · 05/03/2024 13:59

MrsKintner · 05/03/2024 12:32

Do you have children?

Once you have a child you will realise that it is actually possible to spend a whole day doing stuff with your child!

Would you be confused about what a nanny does all day if they weren't contracted to do cooking and cleaning?

I have 5 children as it goes!
When they were all young , yes I could have used the hell, but with one 2 year old? I don't think it is particularly good fir a child to have a dedicated adult whose remit is solely to entertain them.I certainly wouldn't feel comfortable with fulltime housekeeper hanging round all the time. And wtf dies she do all day with only one adult and one child in the house and another in the evening.Yes, I get there are occasional cleaning jobs that need to be done, but they only need doing, you know, occasionally!

ilovebreadsauce · 05/03/2024 13:50

MrsKintner · 05/03/2024 12:36

Oh actually I think you meant what does the housekeeper do!
You can definitely spend 6 hours a day on housekeeping, especially in a big house.
Keeping everything sparkling clean.
Doing everything more often like bedding changes.
All those very occasional jobs like cleaning out fridges and washing skirting boards get done weekly.
Ironing everything!

Yeah but not every day!

randomusernam · 05/03/2024 13:35

When my son was 2 he did some very similar things. We don't have a nanny but every time my husband was around he would only want him to do everything. He will be 4 in a few months and it's completely changed again. Now he's all about mummy.

Let the housekeeper play and ask if you can join them. Even just being in the room with them would be good.

LovelyTheresa · 05/03/2024 13:22

TomeTome · 05/03/2024 13:14

I don't think people really understand. Personally I wouldn't want someone else to have to clean my toilet or clean up after me generally. I'd feel very uncomfortable with it. But I am a socialist

The issue is really not that you’re a socialist it’s that you’re a snob and think menial cleaning is demeaning. It isn’t and cleaning your toilet is no better or worse than cutting your hair or doing your tax return. Some of the attitudes being flaunted on this thread are truly revolting.

Exactly. People who say that they wouldn't employ a cleaner are merely doing someone out of honest work. They aren't being empowering. It is not exploitative to employ someone to clean anymore than it is to employ them to service your car. Conditions and pay can be exploitative, but occupations cannot (with a few exceptions, mineral mining being one. Funnily enough, the people who pride themselves on not employing 'menial staff' probably don't think twice about their I-phones)

TomeTome · 05/03/2024 13:14

I don't think people really understand. Personally I wouldn't want someone else to have to clean my toilet or clean up after me generally. I'd feel very uncomfortable with it. But I am a socialist

The issue is really not that you’re a socialist it’s that you’re a snob and think menial cleaning is demeaning. It isn’t and cleaning your toilet is no better or worse than cutting your hair or doing your tax return. Some of the attitudes being flaunted on this thread are truly revolting.

LovelyTheresa · 05/03/2024 13:07

Lalupalina · 05/03/2024 12:59

I don't think people really understand. Personally I wouldn't want someone else to have to clean my toilet or clean up after me generally. I'd feel very uncomfortable with it. But I am a socialist

Then perhaps you should consider moving to a Socialist or even Communist country.

Let the rest of us live in a free society where we can choose to pay others for services that involve looking after our house, garden or loved relatives.

Precisely. Although, most 'socialist' countries are absolute hellholes where the rich live high off the hog while the poor starve. I get so tired of this nonsense every time there is a thread about someone having household help. 'Clean your own house' 'Do your own cooking/gardening/etc'. Then you have a million threads about how awful men are for not appreciating women....women are the ones who shame other women for employing help. Nobody would say 'do it yourself' if you had a plumbing issue, why is household cleaning and housekeeping any different?

Lalupalina · 05/03/2024 12:59

I don't think people really understand. Personally I wouldn't want someone else to have to clean my toilet or clean up after me generally. I'd feel very uncomfortable with it. But I am a socialist

Then perhaps you should consider moving to a Socialist or even Communist country.

Let the rest of us live in a free society where we can choose to pay others for services that involve looking after our house, garden or loved relatives.

MrsKintner · 05/03/2024 12:51

Full time housekeepers in London (eg 9-5ish) are on around £45k.

CharlieCoCo · 05/03/2024 12:51

vodkaredbullgirl · 04/03/2024 20:14

Get rid of the nanny/housekeeper.

fire someone because their child likes them? and replace them with someone they dont?

Thereislightattheendofthetunnel · 05/03/2024 12:45

LovelyTheresa · 05/03/2024 10:12

How is that relevant to what the OP asked?

Not relevant at all. Just curious. I know in other countries they provide this kind of service and the cost is a joke compared to developed countries.

MrsKintner · 05/03/2024 12:36

MrsKintner · 05/03/2024 12:32

Do you have children?

Once you have a child you will realise that it is actually possible to spend a whole day doing stuff with your child!

Would you be confused about what a nanny does all day if they weren't contracted to do cooking and cleaning?

Oh actually I think you meant what does the housekeeper do!
You can definitely spend 6 hours a day on housekeeping, especially in a big house.
Keeping everything sparkling clean.
Doing everything more often like bedding changes.
All those very occasional jobs like cleaning out fridges and washing skirting boards get done weekly.
Ironing everything!

MrsKintner · 05/03/2024 12:32

ilovebreadsauce · 05/03/2024 11:26

I don't think people are jealous, just a bit baffled to what she dies all day everyday when there is only the 3 of you living there, and you make the dinner.I would hate to have someone hanging round all day invading my privacy!

Do you have children?

Once you have a child you will realise that it is actually possible to spend a whole day doing stuff with your child!

Would you be confused about what a nanny does all day if they weren't contracted to do cooking and cleaning?

MrsKintner · 05/03/2024 12:28

T0AD · 05/03/2024 11:13

Why would you want to do all the housework if you didn't have to??
I'm amazed anyone would choose to do all the cooking and cleaning if it wasn't necessary. Surely no one loves cleaning toilets that much

I don't think people really understand. Personally I wouldn't want someone else to have to clean my toilet or clean up after me generally. I'd feel very uncomfortable with it. But I am a socialist and would like to live in an equal society where everyone has enough. Not where some do and some really don't and have to clean other people's shit up after them.

Yep, absolutely - but we currently do live in a world where you can pay for someone else to do your cleaning, pick and deliver your shopping, cut your grass, clean your car, cook your food, look after your granny, walk your dog - and huge numbers of people choose to use those services when they can afford to

fluffycatkins · 05/03/2024 12:05

But I am a socialist and would like to live in an equal society where everyone has enough. Not where some do and some really don't and have to clean other people's shit up after them.

I find it very interesting that it is usually work done by females in the domestic space which is treated like this. Other tasks covered by men don't seem to get this treatment.

Do people who object to others handling our waste manage all of their own rubbish disposal and not use public sewers? Or is it just specifically within the house that these concerns arrive. Would you not use a plumber if your toilet broke?

An equal society is surely more based around people being able to access employment opportunities that suit them rather than deciding what is and is not lesser work.

CactusMactus · 05/03/2024 12:04

Maybe get a nanny-nanny to look after your daughter so the housekeeper-nanny can housekeep and you can SAHM in peace!

AvonleaHeart · 05/03/2024 11:52

ilovebreadsauce · 05/03/2024 11:26

I don't think people are jealous, just a bit baffled to what she dies all day everyday when there is only the 3 of you living there, and you make the dinner.I would hate to have someone hanging round all day invading my privacy!

She's looking after her child.

Housekeeping and childcare are not the same thing, despite both jobs being the reality for most.

She has already stated several times that the housekeeper looks after the baby when she is at appointments or sometimes for a little while during the day (very similar to people who get a babysitter).

It is absolutely jealousy or PP wouldn't have been quite so snide in their tones.

rainbowunicorn · 05/03/2024 11:27

marmaduke12 · 05/03/2024 07:15

SUre but don't be surprised when the kid prefers the person that actually looks after them whilst mum swans about doing I don't know what. If the OP is very unwell that is a massive dripfeed .

What a nasty thing to say.

ilovebreadsauce · 05/03/2024 11:26

AvonleaHeart · 04/03/2024 20:44

  1. Ignore the jealous commenters. You are very lucky to have the help, but it's not a bad reflection on you as a mother.
  2. I was a nanny and this happened a lot. It's purely novelty and also nannies are dedicated to ensuring the child likes them... It's a lot of pressure and VERY active playing.

Things totally balance out at around 6/7 years old in my experience.
When imaginative games are less of a focus.

Please don't worry, just enjoy :)

Edited

I don't think people are jealous, just a bit baffled to what she dies all day everyday when there is only the 3 of you living there, and you make the dinner.I would hate to have someone hanging round all day invading my privacy!