Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like DD loves her nanny-housekeeper more than me

382 replies

bringpositivitea · 04/03/2024 20:11

My DD is 2, I'm a SAHM and we have a housekeeper / nanny who comes daily 9-3 on weekdays - she does all the cleaning, laundry, ironing, cooking lunch etc. The only thing I do is cooking dinner. So essentially I'm with my daughter all day, I try to plan really fun things for her like playdates, go to various playgrounds, soft play, feed the ducks, ride her bike, go to kid friendly museums etc. However if I have a doctors appointment or need to get something done (around 1-2 times per week when I'm gone for 3-4 hours) my daughter will stay with this nanny / housekeeper until I get back (they usually just go to the park).

It feels like my daughter loves the nanny / housekeeper (call her NH for short) more than me and I can't understand why. If NH is home when we are, she will prefer to play with NH over me and actively tell me "go away mummy" if I walk into the room they are playing in. If I'm dressing her for the walk she will request that NH does it instead. I don't stop them and it's now turned into them playing together just after her nap because if I ask whether she wants to go outside, DD will say no she wants to play at home with NH rather than go with me to the park or do anything with me...

OP posts:
Delatron · 06/03/2024 08:40

This shouldn’t be up for discussion- whether the housekeeper has enough work. But let’s be honest a house doesn’t require ‘occasional’ cleaning.

There’s quite a bit, every day. I must do at least 2 hours - including making and cleaning up after breakfast, washing, putting away washing (I don’t iron but that takes a while) tidying up everybody’s shit that is in the wrong place. Making beds and tidying all the rooms (I don’t do this but it’s a job), then lunch -
cook and tidy up after lunch. You could vacuum. dust, etc etc. Then dinner rince and repeat (I work so this is fit in between that and kids stuff as most people do). My house never feels spotless and sorted.

I don’t do the extra stuff but I can see how a housekeeper in a large house with a small child would have enough to do. Then a bit of childcare on top.

Kwasi · 06/03/2024 07:58

MrsSamR · 04/03/2024 20:19

Bit confused as to how you're a SAHM but have a nanny 5 days a week 9-3?

I was a SAHM and would have done anything for someone to come in and take care of the house, especially as I suffer with a chronic illness.

OP mentions regular doctors appointments of 3-4 hours a week, which suggests to me she may have some health issues. Even if she doesn’t, it’s fine for her to have help.

Herewegoagain84 · 06/03/2024 07:48

I would be pleased. Of course a nanny will never replace a parent / be preferred. It’s a novelty / something different / she finds it fun. Parents who are jealous of childcare are weird tbh. And asking whether you’re doing something wrong because your DD seems to like her…?! 😵‍💫

Karmaisagod · 06/03/2024 07:39

This is brilliant. OP's last post was on Monday and is on page 2. 36 hours later there are NINE more pages of people still arguing over whether she deserves a housekeeper, what the required levels of cleanliness are for a family of 3, repeated histrionic mentions of slavery (!!!)... Bravo, Mumsnet. Some posters' sheer determination to mask their bog standard jealousy and envy as superiority and social concern never ceases to amaze.

T0AD · 06/03/2024 07:37

Why do you think people are jealous? Why would you want someone hanging out in your house all day who's not your pal or partner ??

Bo1978 · 06/03/2024 07:08

MrsSamR · 04/03/2024 20:19

Bit confused as to how you're a SAHM but have a nanny 5 days a week 9-3?

Why are you confused? She’s been very very clear! The fact she has a nanny and is also at home is your issue, but that isn’t what she’s asking. Nothing to do with us and if some of us are honest, we are just jealous she can afford to do that 😂

Sjh15 · 05/03/2024 22:30

MrsSamR · 04/03/2024 21:16

I'm genuinely not jealous. I just don't understand how there is 6 hours of housework to be done in a day in a house of 3 people.

Don’t worry. I’m baffled too.
I have a 2 yo son. I work very part time, good hourly rate, I’m baffled at how someone can have enough to do in 6 hours around your house in the day, when sometimes at home with my 2 yo, I feel bored, especially when he’s taking a long nap.
the laundry for 3 people isn’t loads. I’m not jealous, just baffled why it’s needed.

altho when DS was a newborn I would have LOVED this

Fossilteacher · 05/03/2024 22:30

bringpositivitea · 04/03/2024 20:11

My DD is 2, I'm a SAHM and we have a housekeeper / nanny who comes daily 9-3 on weekdays - she does all the cleaning, laundry, ironing, cooking lunch etc. The only thing I do is cooking dinner. So essentially I'm with my daughter all day, I try to plan really fun things for her like playdates, go to various playgrounds, soft play, feed the ducks, ride her bike, go to kid friendly museums etc. However if I have a doctors appointment or need to get something done (around 1-2 times per week when I'm gone for 3-4 hours) my daughter will stay with this nanny / housekeeper until I get back (they usually just go to the park).

It feels like my daughter loves the nanny / housekeeper (call her NH for short) more than me and I can't understand why. If NH is home when we are, she will prefer to play with NH over me and actively tell me "go away mummy" if I walk into the room they are playing in. If I'm dressing her for the walk she will request that NH does it instead. I don't stop them and it's now turned into them playing together just after her nap because if I ask whether she wants to go outside, DD will say no she wants to play at home with NH rather than go with me to the park or do anything with me...

This is a joke, right?

Aubree17 · 05/03/2024 18:56

It's great she has such a good relationship with your care giver.

Don't give it a second thought. Your her mum and irreplaceable. I guarantee in 20 years time you will look back and wonder why you ever worried.

TomeTome · 05/03/2024 17:48

I didn’t read op say she can’t afford ivf but since we’ve no idea how much that would cost or what the risks are for her I’m not sure why that’s lead you to decide her housekeeper is a slave. As for knowing children brought up with domestic staff, that’s a large proportion of the world. You sound a little tunnel visioned.

hangingonfordearlife1 · 05/03/2024 17:35

@TomeTome nope it's not. she's saying she can't afford ivf treatment but can afford a full time housekeeper.... and then is worried her kid loves the housekeeper more. i see so many of these mothers disconnected from their kids because of these poor staff raising them. she doesn't need to employ a slave

spriots · 05/03/2024 17:33

And also as a PP pointed out - children somehow know when someone really wants to engage with them and can be a bit contrary about it. One of mine went through a phase of that with a grandparent.

spriots · 05/03/2024 17:25

Lalupalina · 05/03/2024 17:23

I think it's open to debate whether the OP does sound happy in her life.

@spriots It's most definitely not up for debate. It also has nothing to do with the op's question.

I think it does though?

I think it may make her magnify the problem

LovelyTheresa · 05/03/2024 17:25

Nanny0gg · 05/03/2024 17:17

How much do you think most hairdressers get paid?

Cleaning can be equally lucrative and you don't have to talk to annoying clients!

Snap! I think that people think of 'cleaners' as some sort of nineteenth century charwoman. While I'm not denying that some employers are exploitative, that isn't limited to the domestic realm. I wonder if all the people who are so smug about how they do their own cleaning so they don't 'contribute to exploitation' are as diligent about avoiding restaurants just in case the staff are exploited, or bother about where they buy their clothes in case the garment workers are exploited. When it comes to the latter, a lot of them will cry poor and claim to be only able to afford Primark or Matalan. Also, the real reason that they don't have a cleaner is that they can't afford one.

Lalupalina · 05/03/2024 17:23

I think it's open to debate whether the OP does sound happy in her life.

@spriots It's most definitely not up for debate. It also has nothing to do with the op's question.

LovelyTheresa · 05/03/2024 17:21

T0AD · 05/03/2024 14:51

That was to the posters saying it's really fine to live in a society where people pay women crap money to clean up after them

Where did I say it was 'ok to pay women crap money'? My cleaner is on 18.00 per hour!

Nanny0gg · 05/03/2024 17:17

T0AD · 05/03/2024 14:50

🤣😂 come on. Look how much they get paid compared to the people who's house they're cleaning.

I don't know how to do plumbing or how to cut my own hair, it's difficult. I can clean my own bathroom and kitchen.

How much do you think most hairdressers get paid?

Cleaning can be equally lucrative and you don't have to talk to annoying clients!

TomeTome · 05/03/2024 17:17

I’m not sure we need to comment on OPs levels of happiness or how worthwhile we feel her life is FFS

spriots · 05/03/2024 17:16

Nanny0gg · 05/03/2024 17:12

~Who knows?

Maybe she sits on her arse and eat bonbons!

Yes, it's good to do something 'useful' if you don't need to work to earn, but on the other hand, if you're happy in your life not working isn't that a great place to be?

I think it's open to debate whether the OP does sound happy in her life.

To me - she sounds a bit fixated on her DD because she has nothing else to do. And actually I also think that having your mother's totally undivided attention - no other children or chores - might be smothering for some children.

But it's totally subjective - maybe to others she sounds very happy.

I have no issues with buying in help - I do it myself, not to this tune obviously

TomeTome · 05/03/2024 17:14

hangingonfordearlife1 · 05/03/2024 16:25

kind of because it's actually modern day slavery in the middle east and has links to people trafficking. in uk we pay at least a living wage to anyone providing services. We don't pay $10 and withhold passports

Domestic staff are used throughout the world. Some people exploit people from poorer countries and some pay them a fair wage for their labour. Some employers confiscate or “hold” people’s passports and some don’t. There are slaves in the uk. OPs thread is not about any of that though is it? She’s asking about her child’s emotional attachment to a paid carer. Your personal (odd) objection to her paying for domestic help to is irrelevant.

Nanny0gg · 05/03/2024 17:12

ilovebreadsauce · 05/03/2024 13:59

I have 5 children as it goes!
When they were all young , yes I could have used the hell, but with one 2 year old? I don't think it is particularly good fir a child to have a dedicated adult whose remit is solely to entertain them.I certainly wouldn't feel comfortable with fulltime housekeeper hanging round all the time. And wtf dies she do all day with only one adult and one child in the house and another in the evening.Yes, I get there are occasional cleaning jobs that need to be done, but they only need doing, you know, occasionally!

~Who knows?

Maybe she sits on her arse and eat bonbons!

Yes, it's good to do something 'useful' if you don't need to work to earn, but on the other hand, if you're happy in your life not working isn't that a great place to be?

MrsKintner · 05/03/2024 17:00

T0AD · 05/03/2024 14:51

That was to the posters saying it's really fine to live in a society where people pay women crap money to clean up after them

Housekeepers often get paid more than teachers and nurses in this country.

hangingonfordearlife1 · 05/03/2024 16:25

TomeTome · 05/03/2024 15:57

Why does it matter where the OP lives? There are plenty of people in the uk who have cleaners. There are plenty who call a plumber or donors when their toilet is blocked and some who pay others to groom them (hairdressers, waxers, masseuse, manicurists). What IS all this nonsense?

kind of because it's actually modern day slavery in the middle east and has links to people trafficking. in uk we pay at least a living wage to anyone providing services. We don't pay $10 and withhold passports

TomeTome · 05/03/2024 15:57

Why does it matter where the OP lives? There are plenty of people in the uk who have cleaners. There are plenty who call a plumber or donors when their toilet is blocked and some who pay others to groom them (hairdressers, waxers, masseuse, manicurists). What IS all this nonsense?

Lalupalina · 05/03/2024 15:50

hangingonfordearlife1 · 05/03/2024 14:58

@ilovebreadsauce
this woman can't afford ivf but can afford a housekeeper- this says to me she's in the middle east and paying a pittance for slave labour

But how is your 'detective' work is relevant to the op's question? Confused