Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like DD loves her nanny-housekeeper more than me

382 replies

bringpositivitea · 04/03/2024 20:11

My DD is 2, I'm a SAHM and we have a housekeeper / nanny who comes daily 9-3 on weekdays - she does all the cleaning, laundry, ironing, cooking lunch etc. The only thing I do is cooking dinner. So essentially I'm with my daughter all day, I try to plan really fun things for her like playdates, go to various playgrounds, soft play, feed the ducks, ride her bike, go to kid friendly museums etc. However if I have a doctors appointment or need to get something done (around 1-2 times per week when I'm gone for 3-4 hours) my daughter will stay with this nanny / housekeeper until I get back (they usually just go to the park).

It feels like my daughter loves the nanny / housekeeper (call her NH for short) more than me and I can't understand why. If NH is home when we are, she will prefer to play with NH over me and actively tell me "go away mummy" if I walk into the room they are playing in. If I'm dressing her for the walk she will request that NH does it instead. I don't stop them and it's now turned into them playing together just after her nap because if I ask whether she wants to go outside, DD will say no she wants to play at home with NH rather than go with me to the park or do anything with me...

OP posts:
HarrietStyles · 06/03/2024 11:16

I worked as a Nanny 8am-7pm Mon-Fri for a family with one child. They also had another weekend Nanny, a Housekeeper, a Chef and a Driver. It’s not uncommon in central London. Liked to call herself a SAHM but essentially hung out with her son for one hour in the morning and then tucked him into bed at night, I did everything in between.

There was a day when we were in the hall of the house getting ready to leave, Mum had come to say goodbye to us, little boy fell over and Mum and I were an equal distance away from him. He ran to me sobbing and arms up for a cuddle. His Mum fell to pieces, burst into tears, grabbed him out of my arms asking why he had run to me and not her. I mean I think we all know why 🤷🏼‍♀️ I was essentially his primary caregiver.

The point of my story is that this is not at all what is happening with you! I think you confused people by calling her a Nanny/Housekeeper. She is a Housekeeper and you look after your child as a SAHM while she does all the housework. Occasionally she babysits your child for a couple of hours while you go to an appointment. She is therefore a cool Aunt or Grandparent figure who plays with your child occasionally without having to tell them off or bargain with them to eat their peas. Please don’t be upset that your child thinks they are awesome, of course they love you more and I’m sure 100% in the scenario I described above your child would run to you for comfort.

And let’s face it if we could afford it, all SAHMs would love a Housekeeper 9-3 every day, while we could just enjoy lovely time with our children. And do none of the boring jobs. And have them occasionally watch the kids while we popped to an appointment. I certainly would!

FluffyFlufferson · 06/03/2024 11:08

Lexiconifer · 06/03/2024 10:51

Thank you for being on of the maybe .01% of women on this thread who aren’t completely out of touch with real people’s lives.

I don’t think anyone thinks this situation is the norm. But does that mean it cannot be a legitimate worry?

Lexiconifer · 06/03/2024 10:51

MrsSamR · 04/03/2024 20:19

Bit confused as to how you're a SAHM but have a nanny 5 days a week 9-3?

Thank you for being on of the maybe .01% of women on this thread who aren’t completely out of touch with real people’s lives.

SamPoodle123 · 06/03/2024 10:44

I would just enjoy the freedom it gives you. It is probably because she spends more time with you. All dc are different. My older two preferred me to DH and nanny. But my youngest prefers DH to me, but me before nanny. She says it is because she does not see her daddy as often (he works long hours). If your dc is happy with your nanny/housekeeper, then that is great.

Zanatdy · 06/03/2024 10:42

Sjh15 · 05/03/2024 22:30

Don’t worry. I’m baffled too.
I have a 2 yo son. I work very part time, good hourly rate, I’m baffled at how someone can have enough to do in 6 hours around your house in the day, when sometimes at home with my 2 yo, I feel bored, especially when he’s taking a long nap.
the laundry for 3 people isn’t loads. I’m not jealous, just baffled why it’s needed.

altho when DS was a newborn I would have LOVED this

Go for a drive around your local area, have a look at all the houses. Are they all the same size of yours? There are some absolutely huge houses in my area. My friend is a cleaner and she could easily spend 6hrs a day in some of her clients homes. They aren’t all 2 up 2 down semi’s

Zanatdy · 06/03/2024 10:41

Ourlittletalks · 06/03/2024 09:28

This has to be a wind up? If not, it’s so out of touch with reality it’s painful to read. As a
SAHM, your job is all of the things NH is doing. I can understand having a cleaner come by a couple of times a week for a couple of hours, but 30 hours a week? That’s just laziness on your part.

Why a wind up? The post isn’t asking anything about whether there’s enough cleaning for a housekeeper. Perhaps it’s a huge house, I mean there are plenty of them in the U.K. To call someone lazy when you know nothing about them, their situation, their health issues is completely out of order. Should wealth people not post on MN for non wealthy / money related questions incase someone is offended as they’ve got more than them? Everyone in life has different circumstances and if you think it’s justifiable to go around attacking anyone that has more than you, then you need to give your head a wobble.

Poster is asking about her little girl being attached to the housekeeper. That can be answered without any reference to money.

raspberryjuiceandpompoms · 06/03/2024 10:28

I think some children crave a lot of attention from different people, not only their primary caregivers. My girl is a bit like that. I know she loves me but the minute she gets to have someone else’s company- she’s all over it. Won’t cry when I leave but she will give me the biggest hug.

I imagine that your daughter is so secure in knowing that you’re there for her that she’s happy to go out and explore on her own. So if anything, you’re doing a great job 👏

GreenButterBlackBean · 06/03/2024 10:27

Notamum12345577 · 04/03/2024 20:20

I’m glad someone asked! I would guess more ‘lady of leisure’ than SAHM?

Oh come on. I too am jealous. But she’s clearly just lucky enough to get to just dedicate her day to the mum part of SAHM rather than also having to juggle the house etc. incredibly lucky but you don’t have to be a dick to her for it…

IncompleteSenten · 06/03/2024 10:26

A sahm job is whatever she and her partner agree it is.

SophieinParis · 06/03/2024 10:26

Don’t worry, I’m a sahm but when my Dh gets home or the older siblings are their I’m bottom of the pile! And I do loads of nice thing as well.
you aren’t really bottom of the pile. You are her entire world. The other people are exciting extras.
Thats what I like to think anyway!

CleaningAngel · 06/03/2024 10:22

MrsSamR · 04/03/2024 20:19

Bit confused as to how you're a SAHM but have a nanny 5 days a week 9-3?

Exactly this!! Entitled or what !

TomeTome · 06/03/2024 10:01

Ourlittletalks · 06/03/2024 09:28

This has to be a wind up? If not, it’s so out of touch with reality it’s painful to read. As a
SAHM, your job is all of the things NH is doing. I can understand having a cleaner come by a couple of times a week for a couple of hours, but 30 hours a week? That’s just laziness on your part.

As a
SAHM, your job is all of the things NH is doing.
and here lies the problem. That really isn’t what a SAHM’s job is.

Everythinggreen · 06/03/2024 09:52

Bennettsister · 04/03/2024 22:09

If I had this set up I think I’d love the nanny housekeeper more than anyone else too.

Hahaha agreed! They would immediately be ranked my MVP in the house 🤣 I hate chores!!

FluffyFlufferson · 06/03/2024 09:49

JMSA · 05/03/2024 00:58

It actually sounds like she's a slave.

But hey, the OP makes the dinner so it's all good Confused

It sound like she is paid to do a household job. Why would you say she is a slave? Would you say someone who worked in a large royal household doing a similar role is a slave? Hotel housekeeping staff? What makes it slavery?

There are a lot of odd martyrish and jealous sounding posts on this thread.

Delatron · 06/03/2024 09:45

So if people had all the money in the world they’d still spend hours doing housework? I bloody wouldn’t! It’s soo dull. There are many other things I’d rather be doing. I’d happily pay someone to do about 2 hours in my house every day if I had the cash. Maybe not 6 but I don’t have a huge house.

Ramalangadingdong · 06/03/2024 09:38

MonsteraMama · 04/03/2024 20:25

My daughter definitely liked my older sister better than me when she was little! Cool Auntie with the green hair and amazing imaginary games was definitely more fun than mum with all her rules and discipline and "eat your broccoli please". You're still her one and only mum though. It's good that she has such a good relationship with someone who will be looking after her!

It is refreshing to hear a mum who understands this. I was close to the children of a couple of friends’ dc. It was difficult to see that they obviously felt a bit miffed that the kids sometimes seemed to prefer me, but I knew that was absolutely not the case. No one can oust mum - unless she is abusive and even then many kids remain loyal to birth Parent. Some mums are just a little insecure but what they also don’t realise is that the kids often seemed to adore me because they were picking up on and reflecting their mum’s trust and affection for me.

Cleo09 · 06/03/2024 09:35

MrsSamR · 04/03/2024 21:16

I'm genuinely not jealous. I just don't understand how there is 6 hours of housework to be done in a day in a house of 3 people.

Absolutely this! Who had a cleaner/housekeeper for 6 hours a day?!

Ourlittletalks · 06/03/2024 09:28

This has to be a wind up? If not, it’s so out of touch with reality it’s painful to read. As a
SAHM, your job is all of the things NH is doing. I can understand having a cleaner come by a couple of times a week for a couple of hours, but 30 hours a week? That’s just laziness on your part.

Illberidingshotgun · 06/03/2024 09:27

It honestly sounds like she just wants to stay home more, and that when you're with her, you're understandably trying to take her out lots and do things, and she's actually enjoying the time that she's at home with the other person.

I think in most families a SAHP would be busy at least part of the day with the cooking, cleaning, washing etc, and thus children have more time at home, gradually learning to play and occupy themselves, which is a vital skill.

You mention medical issues which suggest that you have needed to bring this extra support into the house, to enable you to cope day to day? Even when you're at home do not feel that you need to occupy your DD all the time, or take her out continually. Leave her to play whilst you get on with other things, even occasionally.

TomeTome · 06/03/2024 09:18

marmaduke12 · 06/03/2024 08:52

No. I never said that, but I don't know what this OP has over you guys but it is a very weird thread.
Generally, if dad doesn't do any cooking and cleaning he is a total shite.
If mum does nothing but cook dinner she is lying around doing nothing.
This OP - total opposite.
Leaving it with you.

I think maybe you have forgotten you are responding to individuals rather than some Borg MNetter.

Victoria3010 · 06/03/2024 09:15

Also, for everyone baffled at the housekeeper, I live in the cotswolds and loads of people (not us we can't afford it and our house isnt big enough) do this. The house will be large enough to warrant it (many bathrooms and huge immaculate kitchens), the clothes will be beautiful and everything folded beautifully and organised perfectly, my friends bathrooms all have individual rolled up small hand towels like a hotel to try your hands on and the housekeeper takes them away and replaces them. It's wonderful, if you take time to imagine it all, I'm not jealous and I'd 100% do it if we won the lottery! It's just a different approach and it's hard to imagine it until you see it. Fair play OP, I bet your home is beautiful

MrsZargon · 06/03/2024 09:14

bringpositivitea · 04/03/2024 20:11

My DD is 2, I'm a SAHM and we have a housekeeper / nanny who comes daily 9-3 on weekdays - she does all the cleaning, laundry, ironing, cooking lunch etc. The only thing I do is cooking dinner. So essentially I'm with my daughter all day, I try to plan really fun things for her like playdates, go to various playgrounds, soft play, feed the ducks, ride her bike, go to kid friendly museums etc. However if I have a doctors appointment or need to get something done (around 1-2 times per week when I'm gone for 3-4 hours) my daughter will stay with this nanny / housekeeper until I get back (they usually just go to the park).

It feels like my daughter loves the nanny / housekeeper (call her NH for short) more than me and I can't understand why. If NH is home when we are, she will prefer to play with NH over me and actively tell me "go away mummy" if I walk into the room they are playing in. If I'm dressing her for the walk she will request that NH does it instead. I don't stop them and it's now turned into them playing together just after her nap because if I ask whether she wants to go outside, DD will say no she wants to play at home with NH rather than go with me to the park or do anything with me...

Honestly this post is coming across to me like NH does all the graft and caregiving, and your role is more like old fashioned upper class mums who had the children brought to them for playtime. Maybe that isn’t the case so if not I apologise. But honestly I think children bond better with those doing things for them (washing, feeding, etc) rather than those that are essentially just there to play where it could seem a bit forced?
The joy of being a SAHM in my opinion is that you are totally immersed with the children and they do everything with you, including the rubbish jobs like cooking and cleaning. You say you go out to appointments or to get things done a couple of times a week, but a SAHM with no housekeeper would be taking the child with them for all of those things too. Maybe your daughter just feels a bit distant from you? Maybe you could try to rebalance things a bit - next time you need to pop out to the shops, dentist, nail salon whatever take her with you and let her just enjoy your company. At home, maybe get her involved with making the dinner with you, get her to set the table etc.
Lastly, enjoy having your NH, she sounds lovely and it must be so nice to not feel swamped with housework all the time x

Victoria3010 · 06/03/2024 09:09

You're not doing anything wrong, I think this is being a mum! Our children love us but we are never the most exciting/funnist/coolest person, its just how it is. Fun aunts, other peoples mums, babysitters, teachers - they're all better. It's even worse once they're teenagers, because they'll tell you why you're not the funnest....
I remember as a teenager thinking my friends mum was so awesome, with her nice clothes and her sports car. Ear wigged on her telling my mum that her daughter was always complaining she wasn't "mumsy" enough and how everyone else's mum dressed normally and spent time doing mum things and it wasn't fair. You can't win sadly. Get a puppy maybe, my labrador absolutely adores me.

marmaduke12 · 06/03/2024 08:52

TomeTome · 05/03/2024 07:48

So if you nip out for McDonald’s or go to a friends house for a meal are they parenting your child (or you)?

No. I never said that, but I don't know what this OP has over you guys but it is a very weird thread.
Generally, if dad doesn't do any cooking and cleaning he is a total shite.
If mum does nothing but cook dinner she is lying around doing nothing.
This OP - total opposite.
Leaving it with you.

theduchessofspork · 06/03/2024 08:52

T0AD · 05/03/2024 11:13

Why would you want to do all the housework if you didn't have to??
I'm amazed anyone would choose to do all the cooking and cleaning if it wasn't necessary. Surely no one loves cleaning toilets that much

I don't think people really understand. Personally I wouldn't want someone else to have to clean my toilet or clean up after me generally. I'd feel very uncomfortable with it. But I am a socialist and would like to live in an equal society where everyone has enough. Not where some do and some really don't and have to clean other people's shit up after them.

Most people understand fine. There’s a lot of fake bafflement going on.

It’s always traditionally female work that people are derogatory about. Always house cleaners not bin men.

The OP’s housekeeper is unlikely to be cleaning up her shit. The OP, if she is anything like most people who have housekeepers in the UK, probably has a big house, entertains a lot, has a wardrobe that needs looking after and all the errands and shopping that come with a big house and entertaining.

Housekeepers in the UK can earn a good salary. There’s nothing in the OP’s post to indicate she’s an exploitive employer.

Being a domestic worker doesn’t mean you don’t have ‘enough’. Domestic work can be an a positive choice because of the flexible hours. Home workers should certainly be better regulated but many employers behave well of their own accord - having home employees doesn’t make you exploitative. Choosing to have help when you are a SAHP doesn’t make you less than someone who works.