Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do about new estate we’ve moved to?

229 replies

Applepastry · 04/03/2024 16:07

We’ve recently moved to a new build estate. It’s directly next door to a council estate (no issues with this as my mum was brought up on one and lots of my friends were and are from council estates. Everyone seems friendly enough.
My main concern is that all the kids play out in the street, I totally understand with the ones who are 7 or 8 +
However there are 4 and 5 year olds playing out alone, without any adult supervision at all. My DS is 5 and he doesn’t have older siblings. These children will often come and knock for him and he asks to play out with them when he sees them all out on the street. I have been going out with him, but he asks why I have to go, when none of the other parents do.
They all wander up towards the park which is around a corner and you can’t see it from the estate. When I’ve been up there, it extends quite far and joins on a stream and woodland. I’m not comfortable with my 5 year old going up there out of my sight.
Other parents don’t seem bothered and just say “Oh I wonder where G is…he must be at the park”

I’m not a helicopter parent, but AIBU about 4 and 5 year olds (one was 3) being out in the streets by themselves? Some wandering in and out of other houses and into the road?

I just don’t know what to do about my DS as he’s keen to be accepted in this new area and wants to play out with them. He’ll definitely stand out with me or his dad hanging around.

OP posts:
mydrivingisterrible · 04/03/2024 19:40

This is how my childhood was - I was 4 when I was allowed out to play and one of our group was 3.

So I guess I'm normalized to this and thought it's normal? We never got into any trouble and got lots of exercise.

If you're really uncomfortable with it then just stop him - I wouldn't go out and watch though as you might make him a target for bullying

MabelMoo23 · 04/03/2024 19:36

I have an 8 and a 6 yr old. No way in a million years would I let them out unsupervised - and we live on an estate with cul de sacs.

kids that age don’t have the ability to assess risk. They do stuff without thinking. A ball goes into the road and they go to retrieve without thinking. An older child says let’s go to the shop and off they go.

I live in the West Midlands - and the 4 boys in Solihull who died in the lake is literally very close to home. They were just kicking a ball about outside, playing having fun, and just through playing they got closer to the lake, well we all know the rest.

Kids that age aren’t responsible for doing a risk assessment on their fun. Because they are children. Things happen. That’s why they are called accidents
its my responsibility as a parent and an adult.

ducksinarow123 · 04/03/2024 19:33

I moved into my home when dd was 6 and instantly she was allowed to play out. we had only lived in a flat before and like OP it was a new build estate so all these new kids moving in trying to get to know each other. However I did make strict boundaries that she had to remain in the close and I would watch from the kitchen window. I feel like this is the perfect opportunity to start allowing your ds some freedom and independence but responsibility too. Ie play directly outside the house for now where he is always visible. Or insist on supervising but occasionally pop home for 5 or so minutes to get a cuppa or loo break etc. slowly build up him having a little time outside on his own

Ilovegoldies · 04/03/2024 19:33

I agree that people are virtue signalling about council estates. I'm from one, my best friend still lives there. She doesn't let her children play out.

MisshapesMistakesMisfits · 04/03/2024 19:21

I wouldn’t let my 5 year old out unsupervised. They are not able to assess risk so without the possibility of grooming from adults or older peers there is the risk of injury from road traffic accidents or not assessing how fast the swing is going and running past it for example.
I would also contact the local PCSO’s to discuss the unsupervised young children in the park out of sight. I work in health safeguarding though so I see the worst and am perhaps over zealous. 😥

Diamondshmiamond · 04/03/2024 19:20

Absolutely wouldn't let my dc. Older kids can supervise to an extent, but can also expose younger children to all sorts of inappropriate things. Not necessarily abuse, but swearing , smoking etc.

tearsandtiaras · 04/03/2024 19:17

NotQuiteNorma · 04/03/2024 18:09

When I was a kid we all played out in the streets, our parents had no idea where we were and nobody had a mobile phone. The sky didn't fall in.

There was a high amount of child sexual abuse that went under the radar though

Helpimfalling · 04/03/2024 19:15

puzzledout · 04/03/2024 18:20

If you can't say no to a five year old, good luck when they're teenagers!

Who is the parent?

It's irrelevant what other parents do, where they live or who they're happy to look after their children.

You make it sound like a five year old is entitled to an opinion of safety rules?

This 👏

tearsandtiaras · 04/03/2024 19:15

Applepastry · 04/03/2024 16:39

One of the parents said she’d had the police called on her because her 4 year old was out on his own with no adults to be seen. Apparently she told them he was out with older kids (6 and 7 year olds) and they said it was fine and left.

This is not true. She is lying .The police would not be allowed to do this

I think you need to educate yourself on safe age appropriate boundaries for children in the community

puzzledout · 04/03/2024 19:14

Helpimfalling · 04/03/2024 19:13

Oh my lord no no no, I'm shocked at how many are saying no problem.

I wouldn't give a shjt if my kids cried for a week, a month or a year, no chance and we live on a council estate not that that makes a blind bit of difference.

The voice of reason!

Helpimfalling · 04/03/2024 19:13

Oh my lord no no no, I'm shocked at how many are saying no problem.

I wouldn't give a shjt if my kids cried for a week, a month or a year, no chance and we live on a council estate not that that makes a blind bit of difference.

tearsandtiaras · 04/03/2024 19:12

Applepastry · 04/03/2024 16:18

My gut instinct tells me not to, but I feel awful that my son is missing out on local friendships and he sees them all playing outside together and gets upset that he can’t join them. As I said he’s an only child, so no siblings to keep him occupied either.

Why do you feel awful? In my own experience as a child protection social worker and parent to a 15 year old DD, local friendships can often prove to be a nightmare especially when you and the other child's carer have different parenting values/ safeguarding boundaries.

It gets harder as the children get older to reaffirm your boundaries when "local friends" are in your house/ at your door frequently .

In my honest opinion I would keep your child out of all unsupervised play at 5 and pick and choose the social interactions he has via play dates/ park dates

Horaced · 04/03/2024 19:06

Pootles34 · 04/03/2024 16:22

At a guess they probably all know each other. So the 4 year old might not just have a 6 year old sibling, but also their parents friends kids who might be a bit older.

Not saying I agree with it, but that's how it seems to be around here anyway!

Where I teach, it's just 4 year olds out with older, silly kids. There is absolutely no adult supervision and every few weeks the older ones get into bother. I've got a 6 and 4 year old and can't begin to imagine letting them play out like that. Some parents are strict about not letting even their Y6 children play out which must be very hard when there's so much peer pressure in the area. It's also an area where they are home a lot as lots don't have cars and the bus service is rubbish (rural area, not a lot to do).

puzzledout · 04/03/2024 19:03

@pensione where the fuck did I say it was funny! How fucking dare you make out I did! My point was that accidents happen to unsupervised children!

And the youngest was six and being "supervised" by his cousin, so very bloody relevant to the situation.

At least get your facts straight before you start posting!

PuttingDownRoots · 04/03/2024 18:59

50 years ago, at the age of 7, meant spent her summer hitching rides from lorry drivers with a similar aged friend. No harm came to them... would you be happy with your children doing that?

It doesn't matter what happened 40, 20 10 or 2 years ago. The world has changed. More traffic. Easier access for abductions etc (due to more cars). We hear more about disasters like the poor lads on the ice, or the rip tide at the beach.

5yos shouldn't be near a stream unsupervised. Nor 8yos... more likely to do silly things like trying to jump and fall in.

Bex5490 · 04/03/2024 18:49

FlissyPaps · 04/03/2024 18:46

From my experience: on the council estate I lived on, parents didn’t care where their kids were playing out. They would be in the pub, whilst we at 5+yo would roam the streets and the local park. This was the 90’s, Yorkshire ex-mining village and was just how it was. We were still loved and cared for. We were just more streetwise. Could handle ourselves. The community was tight-knit, people looked after each other. There were no neighbour or parking wars.

The parents from neighbouring and more affluent suburbs would look down on us and our families. They wouldn’t dream of letting their young kids roam the streets of their area. The roads were more busy, businesses were running. On our estate it was just houses, a pub and 1 shop.

I guess you’d only really understand if you experienced it yourself.

I think it really depends on the area because I grew up on a council estate in London and no kids played out by themselves who were that young.

In fact there was one girl who all the other mums would take in and feed because they were worried about her being out so young…

pensione · 04/03/2024 18:49

chingaling · 04/03/2024 18:43

How many people on here are seriously going to agree that 3-5 year olds should be running the streets, crossing roads and going to parks with streams? There is no real question here. You are not in a quandary about what's right.
Your post is literally about slagging off council estate kids, why dress it up as an AIBU?

I can’t imagine OP wants to slag off 4 and 5yos who just want to knock on her door for her son and to play.

ForgivenessHope · 04/03/2024 18:48

@Applepastry ignore the passive aggressive posts about why mention council estate.

They do similar if they are on benefits and one agrees with the gov that they are healthy etc and need to find work or better paying jobs and not be reliant on 'top ups' etc or lose the benefits.

Only on MN!

Crikeyalmighty · 04/03/2024 18:48

I was sent to the shop on errands when I was just 5 - in the mid 60s ! And was walking to school crossing a busy road at 6 - it was common - these days my parents would have been done for neglect - by 8 I was out for hours every day in the holidays !!

FlissyPaps · 04/03/2024 18:46

RantyAnty · 04/03/2024 18:31

What does that even mean? What are the differences?

From my experience: on the council estate I lived on, parents didn’t care where their kids were playing out. They would be in the pub, whilst we at 5+yo would roam the streets and the local park. This was the 90’s, Yorkshire ex-mining village and was just how it was. We were still loved and cared for. We were just more streetwise. Could handle ourselves. The community was tight-knit, people looked after each other. There were no neighbour or parking wars.

The parents from neighbouring and more affluent suburbs would look down on us and our families. They wouldn’t dream of letting their young kids roam the streets of their area. The roads were more busy, businesses were running. On our estate it was just houses, a pub and 1 shop.

I guess you’d only really understand if you experienced it yourself.

Scousefab · 04/03/2024 18:45

Oh that is mega hard maybe try and be out when they visit. My mum let me play out when I was five I went missing (police called and picked up by an neighbour) and also smashed my head open. It is far too young to be out on their own without an adult. Too many horrible people and cars about my DS is nine and it’s still a no!

chingaling · 04/03/2024 18:43

How many people on here are seriously going to agree that 3-5 year olds should be running the streets, crossing roads and going to parks with streams? There is no real question here. You are not in a quandary about what's right.
Your post is literally about slagging off council estate kids, why dress it up as an AIBU?

Bex5490 · 04/03/2024 18:39

My son wants sweets on the way home from nursery because his mate gets them…

But unluckily for him, he’s got me as a mum picking him up instead of his mate’s Dad!

Just say no and explain to him all the lovely things that he gets that his friends might not.

My son’s is Milkshake Mondays with his Dad. His little nursery mate doesn’t get that now does he? 😂

pensione · 04/03/2024 18:39

SemperOmnibusFacultas · 04/03/2024 18:34

Lovely bit of victim blaming 👏 👏

I also fail to see why you had to distinguish between your 'estate' and the council one.

There is a growing body of evidence that parents failure to accurately risk assess is resulting in anxiety ridden children who fail to flourish.

It’s not victim blaming to say 4 and 5yo kids need to be supervised. Kids that young can’t make decisions in their best interests.

pensione · 04/03/2024 18:38

puzzledout · 04/03/2024 18:26

And the whole family of children drowned under the ice!

Not particularly funny, given the 3 boys who drowned in an icy lake last winter. Those boys were around 10. These kids are 4 and 5 yos and even more vulnerable in age.