Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do about new estate we’ve moved to?

229 replies

Applepastry · 04/03/2024 16:07

We’ve recently moved to a new build estate. It’s directly next door to a council estate (no issues with this as my mum was brought up on one and lots of my friends were and are from council estates. Everyone seems friendly enough.
My main concern is that all the kids play out in the street, I totally understand with the ones who are 7 or 8 +
However there are 4 and 5 year olds playing out alone, without any adult supervision at all. My DS is 5 and he doesn’t have older siblings. These children will often come and knock for him and he asks to play out with them when he sees them all out on the street. I have been going out with him, but he asks why I have to go, when none of the other parents do.
They all wander up towards the park which is around a corner and you can’t see it from the estate. When I’ve been up there, it extends quite far and joins on a stream and woodland. I’m not comfortable with my 5 year old going up there out of my sight.
Other parents don’t seem bothered and just say “Oh I wonder where G is…he must be at the park”

I’m not a helicopter parent, but AIBU about 4 and 5 year olds (one was 3) being out in the streets by themselves? Some wandering in and out of other houses and into the road?

I just don’t know what to do about my DS as he’s keen to be accepted in this new area and wants to play out with them. He’ll definitely stand out with me or his dad hanging around.

OP posts:
Canthave2manycats · 06/03/2024 00:42

@fliptopbin omg you shouldn't have to carry this guilt with you! You were a young child, you should never ever have been put in that position! It was 100% not your fault! You don't deserve to have "penance" either - that's not fair! 10 is no age!

Please speak to your GP and explain how you feel. You don't deserve to have to carry this burden with you. GP could refer you for counselling, and you wouldn't have to pay, though you might have a bit of a wait. I really truly hope you can make peace with yourself. That little one's death was totally not on you x

Bringtheweatherwithyou · 06/03/2024 00:28

fliptopbin I’m so so sorry you have had to carry this with you throughout your life. It wasn’t your fault. Any responsibility lies with the parents.
It’s awful you are living with this guilt to this day. I know what you mean in your last paragraph as I feel similarly about something entirely different.
This is trauma. If you ever get a chance, through work maybe?, counselling might help to process what happened and teach methods to change how you think about it.

A similar incident happened on my street. A young girl was supposed to be minding three or four younger siblings. One of them, he was only two or three, ran onto the road and got knocked down and killed by a truck. The driver couldn’t have stopped. He ended up giving up his job. The sister has lived with it since, she became so withdrawn and never made friends. She should never have been the person supposed to be looking after them. She was just a young child herself.

fliptopbin · 06/03/2024 00:16

I hate to say it, but I would be nipping these friendships in the bud. I wouldn't let your child play with these kids full stop, and I would try to avoid him going to the same school as them.
And before anyone asks, it is not because of the council estate thing.
I was one of those council estate free range kids from the 70's and 80's, and it was all normal, until I saw a group of the local younger kids playing chicken on a road and watched one of them be run over and killed right on front of me. I was 10 at the time and meant to be one of the responsible ones. He was 6 and I couldn't get there in time to stop him.
I still have to fight to stop myself from blaming myself now, and I hate myself for even feeling anything because it wasn't my family who died, so I don't have the right to any feelings other than self hatred, and that feeling is my penance so I never discuss it with anyone.
I feel dirty even mentioning my own emotions with regard to this, and I only do it because it may prevent someone else going through it.

Luckycloverz · 05/03/2024 23:51

Too little, it's hard but perhaps do some gardening or something to look busy out front with them rather than just watching constantly or get some fun things for your back garden and invite 1 or 2 in if their patents agree.

BarbieDangerous · 05/03/2024 23:34

This literally has nothing to do with a council estate:/

Canthave2manycats · 05/03/2024 22:54

Doone22 · 05/03/2024 21:55

When I was a kid this was totally normal all the time. Yes even 3yrs old. Out most of the day with older sister (5) and our friends. In woods, rivers, roads, whatever.
It's just a matter of perspective, you're not used to it so freaking out.

Its many people it's weird that you monitor your kids constantly it's a form of infantilisation that keeps them from growing up and makes them dependant on you for ever.

What a crock!

I didn't let my children roam the streets when they were youngsters.

They're adults now and far from "dependent on [me] forever"!!! Elder two lived away from home for years. One lived in France for a year, another is living in Italy.

That was an utter fucking disgrace that you were out unsupervised at such a young age, "in woods, rivers, roads" etc. Your parents were totally neglectful. You were fortunate you didn't fall in one of those rivers, or run across one of those roads in front of a car!! "Infantilisation" - are you mad? I certainly would not be vaunting that disgraceful parenting to anyone!

hamjamwitch · 05/03/2024 22:49

He's not missing out. Keep him safe and stick to what's best for his wellbeing

SomeCatFromJapan · 05/03/2024 22:43

OP I would agree with some of the other posters on here that have said it is probably best if your little boy doesn't get into the habit of playing out with this particular group of children. As well as the shorter term issue that you've assessed him as far too young to play out safely unsupervised, you'll likely be coming up against issues at every milestone where those parents allowed far greater freedoms than you would have done. There might also be behaviours he picks up that you're not keen on, as you've already seen from how they behaved at your house.
And once he's got to know them it will be far harder to curtain the situation.

BlueFlowers5 · 05/03/2024 22:40

Maybe put a table in your front garden with squash, plastic cups on it on a play out day..It may well keep some of the children nearer your house/the estate?
When I was an elder DC, I was 8-10 years before I was told to keep safe my younger DB and DSister. My DM would let us play out but with the principle "Don't go too far from the house!".

Lamelie · 05/03/2024 22:18

Doone22 · 05/03/2024 21:59

Yeh but they lived to tell the tale and learned from it. That's why our generation are actually capable of handling life.

I can’t let this pass. Whenever a group of my generation- 50’s- discuss the freedom our generation had it quickly descends into stories of missing children, sexual assault, grooming and worse. I wouldn’t say that equipped us to ‘handle life’ and your glib post suggests it’s not something you’ve thought deeply about- more a knee jerk ‘young snowflake’ response.
Out of interest what generation do you consider is so great at ‘handling life’?

SomeCatFromJapan · 05/03/2024 22:06

Won't be long before they're stuck in their bedrooms watching crap on the internet though.

Honestly loads of them will be wandering around in wee gangs vandalising stuff, unfortunately.

pensione · 05/03/2024 22:06

If 4 and 5 yos can successfully navigate hours and hours out of sight of their parents and also keep safe across streams and woodland without supervision then I’m glad for them but I certainly wouldn’t experiment whether this is safe on my dc.

Doone22 · 05/03/2024 21:59

Lamelie · 04/03/2024 18:19

Some children played out when I was a child in the 70’s others weren’t allowed to 💁🏻‍♀️
We weren’t, no harm done. I’ve been in social situations as an adult when someone starts reminiscing about the olden days and playing out. It always leads to recollections of flashers, car accidents, being trapped in a lift shaft and worse. Follow your instincts.

Yeh but they lived to tell the tale and learned from it. That's why our generation are actually capable of handling life.

Doone22 · 05/03/2024 21:55

Applepastry · 04/03/2024 16:07

We’ve recently moved to a new build estate. It’s directly next door to a council estate (no issues with this as my mum was brought up on one and lots of my friends were and are from council estates. Everyone seems friendly enough.
My main concern is that all the kids play out in the street, I totally understand with the ones who are 7 or 8 +
However there are 4 and 5 year olds playing out alone, without any adult supervision at all. My DS is 5 and he doesn’t have older siblings. These children will often come and knock for him and he asks to play out with them when he sees them all out on the street. I have been going out with him, but he asks why I have to go, when none of the other parents do.
They all wander up towards the park which is around a corner and you can’t see it from the estate. When I’ve been up there, it extends quite far and joins on a stream and woodland. I’m not comfortable with my 5 year old going up there out of my sight.
Other parents don’t seem bothered and just say “Oh I wonder where G is…he must be at the park”

I’m not a helicopter parent, but AIBU about 4 and 5 year olds (one was 3) being out in the streets by themselves? Some wandering in and out of other houses and into the road?

I just don’t know what to do about my DS as he’s keen to be accepted in this new area and wants to play out with them. He’ll definitely stand out with me or his dad hanging around.

When I was a kid this was totally normal all the time. Yes even 3yrs old. Out most of the day with older sister (5) and our friends. In woods, rivers, roads, whatever.
It's just a matter of perspective, you're not used to it so freaking out.

Its many people it's weird that you monitor your kids constantly it's a form of infantilisation that keeps them from growing up and makes them dependant on you for ever.

SemperOmnibusFacultas · 05/03/2024 21:47

Just think about April Jones. My husband was part of the teams that searched for her and he will never forget that awful experience

I am sorry for your husband and of course April's family but it needs to be put in proportion.
Roads are much more dangerous, but people don't think twice about driving. In fact a lot of parents don't even worry about car seat safety and move children to FF seats far too early, but have an irrational fear in relation to allowing kids to go to the park.

ColdWaterDipper · 05/03/2024 21:32

Just think about April Jones. My husband was part of the teams that searched for her and he will never forget that awful experience.

We live in the middle of nowhere but my children go to school in a village and the oldest was almost 11 before I let him go to the park after school with his friends without me. My youngest is almost 10 and he started walking to the village park after school last summer with his friends BUT one of the other boys mums and I would walk there too (separately but it’s only a short walk) and sit on a bench for a chat while the children played for an hour or so within our sight across the cricket field. There are children in his class who live in the village and have been walking alone to the park since they were 5 or 6! There’s no way I would let my children have done that.

Stick to your guns OP, personally I think it’s neglectful to let such young children play in a public area unsupervised. My children have a lot of freedom to roam independently as we live on a farm, but that’s very different to being in a public place like a park / public woodlands where any weirdo could be. They are also close in age, roam together on our land, and have ‘country sense’ knowing where is safe to play and where isn’t. They aren’t streetwise in any way and would be hopeless on busy roads rather than riding their bikes around bridleways and tracks. Aged 5 they played out of sight but had limits on where they could go and knew never to leave our land, or approach gates, water or anywhere where the machinery is. If we lived on an estate they would only have been allowed to play in sight of me - it’s too big a risk to do otherwise.

LaughingCat · 05/03/2024 21:24

I was out at that age (in the Eighties) but my mum got me a watch and said I had to come home every hour to check in with her and there were strict rules on exactly how far I could go, which increased as I got older. If I wanted to go outside those boundaries, I’d have to come back and tell her where I was going. I remember thinking that all of that was really unfair as none of the other kids ever had to do any of those. If she’d come with me while I was playing, I’d have been mortified.

A lot of places I’ve lived since have had kids running in and out of our house and up and down the streets in packs. They all look out for each other and it works. But I can appreciate someone not being comfortable with that…at the end of the day, parenting is massively personal and you have to just trust your own instincts, which you seem to be doing.

Casperroonie · 05/03/2024 20:07

Aliceisagooddog · 04/03/2024 18:14

I would nip this in the bud now. Kids that are out alone at 4 will almost certainly be in some trouble by 14. Just explain to your child that it is dangerous for him to be alone at this age and that just because other parents choose to do it it's not ok. Get school friends around for play dates, do after school clubs so he mixes lots socially.

Totally agree. Some things just are what they are. Sadly you just never know what might happen and if OP is uncomfortable it will be for a reason.

Sillyname63 · 05/03/2024 19:59

Please follow your gut instinct, I am a lot older than you and I remember Jamie Bulger taken by children not much older than himself. Children of that age are not old enough to think rationally and are led by peer pressure, an older child might think it is an innocent thing to take a younger child into the woods or down to the river to see the tadpoles / frogs, hunt for bears etc and once there they miss their footing and end up in the river, it literally takes 2 minutes .

Katbum · 05/03/2024 19:56

No I would not let my five year old play out with kids I don’t know out of my sight. Just no. Be the parent. Find him other things to do.

savethatkitty · 05/03/2024 19:49

Yeah. Hard No! I get it, about forming local friendship, but safety first

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 05/03/2024 19:38

Too potentially hazardous. That's very young

pollymere · 05/03/2024 19:37

I'd find the contact details for your local Safeguarding Team and mention your concerns. They may be families there are already concerns over.

payens · 05/03/2024 19:29

Don't let him, too dangerous

fruitypancake · 05/03/2024 19:06

Absolutely no way ! I would not be comfortable with this below age 11 tbh