Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BMW6 · 07/03/2024 19:07

Jonisaysitbest · 04/03/2024 18:25

They will happily chase after "benefit cheats" but do nothing about the many so-called loopholes that enable wealthier people and companies to avoid paying tax.
It's so disgusting. Always ready to kick the poorest, take away from the poorest and reward the richest. Please God we get a new bunch of people at the helm after the next election.

Tax Avoidance isn't a "loophole".

For example
Having ISA'S is Tax Avoidance.
Paying into a Pension Plan is Tax Avoidance.

These, and others, are entirely legal means to effectively manage your money and reduce your tax bill.

Tax Evasion is a different kettle of fish. It's illegal and gets investigated and prosecuted all the time.

Benefits Cheats are just that - Cheats. Liars. Just like people who Evade Tax. They are not using legal means to manage their money. They are simply lying to get money to which they are not entitled.

If you think any Government is ever going to turn a blind eye to any Benefit Cheats you are going to be bitterly disappointed.

Tiptoptum · 07/03/2024 19:07

Actually, posters saying they can see why benefit claimants need their accounts checked are not being reasonable.

I work, I work bloody hard, but because of the benefits system my employer doesn’t pay me a very good wage, knowing that makes up the shortfall. I need to earn about 10k more to get myself off them.

Just because I have to claim why is the general line that you need checking in case you are sitting on £££? UC is demeaning enough, if I had loads in savings I would not be on it.

I do not like the thought of anyone, human or AI trawling through my incomings and outgoings, because it’s the thin edge of the wedge, next they will start looking at spending and decide if you are spending in a frivolous way.

Everyone, even claimants deserve some privacy.

ShareTheDuvet · 07/03/2024 18:52

Jonisaysitbest · 04/03/2024 18:25

They will happily chase after "benefit cheats" but do nothing about the many so-called loopholes that enable wealthier people and companies to avoid paying tax.
It's so disgusting. Always ready to kick the poorest, take away from the poorest and reward the richest. Please God we get a new bunch of people at the helm after the next election.

This is the crux of it all isn’t it? The rich get away with paying little to no tax and cost the Chancellor billions yet once again we kick the little guy 🤬

Gloriosaford · 07/03/2024 18:52

barstewards! They will do whatever they think they can get away with😡

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 07/03/2024 18:50

IClaudine · 04/03/2024 21:39

I can't understand how that can be allowed. I can see how access to bank accounts can be made a requirement receiving benefit, but partners, parents and landlords.

They've stated the automated process will not only check the account you have your benefit paid into, but also any other accounts you have. If for example you have a joint account, this will then mean they'll check all that person's accounts. Anyone you receive payments from, even if small will have their accounts checked. Any payments you make to other individuals, rather than companies, will have their accounts checked.

So it will not only be trawling through all your own finances, but also those of anyone financially linked to you in any way.

When you sign up for UC for example, you accept these terms. But other people clearly do not!

It's obscene, and absolutely everyone should be complaining to the Information Commissioner before this even gets the chance to get off the ground, as it must clearly breach GDPR for innocent people connected to the claimant. They are already able to check accounts of claimants, so there is absolutely zero need for this.

We've all been told not to worry, as the AI used will only flag the possibility of fraud, and would always be double checked by a human. But those of us that have to deal with them know that will just not be the case. Entirely innocent claimants will be having their money stopped on a whim at a moment's notice.

As someone who can quickly die without my disability payment, this terrifies me.

This is absolutely nothing to do with fraud; it's about power and control.

Againsttheflow · 07/03/2024 16:13

alonglongshot · 07/03/2024 11:05

Did anyone hear Jeremy Hunt yesterday re child benefit.

' doing so requires significant reform to the tax system including allowing HMRC to collect household-level income '

They are not even trying to hide their intentions.

So long as it works both ways. That the monitoring picks up those under claiming as well as those over claiming. But it won't.

ShyMaryEllen · 07/03/2024 16:09

Yes, that wasn't lost on me either.

alonglongshot · 07/03/2024 11:05

Did anyone hear Jeremy Hunt yesterday re child benefit.

' doing so requires significant reform to the tax system including allowing HMRC to collect household-level income '

They are not even trying to hide their intentions.

Elleherd · 07/03/2024 01:26

It was an attempt at irony. Just the prospect of the excuses needed to justify ridiculous behavior in looking for 'suspicious' algorithms to use against family members. (Comfortably off - those with enough money to never have rely on anything via the state.)

Disabled people receiving PIP aren't receiving a means tested benefit either, but once they start poking around I can see them using it to justify making them so.

The point of bringing tax breaks under benefits, was deliberate, but those saying so at the time were seen as tin hat wearers.

It is indeed deliberate and sinister, but people are ok with it when told it only affects the poorer end of society and never see how it will affect them.

ShyMaryEllen · 06/03/2024 23:01

I don't understand how the new policy will catch out someone trying to make Auntie Marge's life a bit less grim, if 'comfortably off parents' (whoever they are) take out cash and hand it over for her to spend on sausages and gin.

Nobody should have their accounts scrutinised. I can sort of understand those on means tested benefits having to show that they qualify, but the State Pension isn't means-tested, so there shouldn't be a need to scrutinise the accounts of pensioners other than those on pension credit. If Child Benefit went back to being Family Allowance and was a tax cut rather than a benefit then parents wouldn't need to be scrutinised either.

It's deliberate. And sinister.

Elleherd · 05/03/2024 12:32

NamechangeForthisquestion1 why should pensioners specifically, escape being afraid and worried if surveillance of so many citizens fiances is to be normalized? (that bit's a genuine question)

I'm sure this place is full of comfortably off parents who aren't receiving any benefits, who regularly draw out £20/£30 to hand to old Aunty Marge when they get their kids dropped of to her after school on Thursday.
How else will they detect that Old Aunty Marge is getting more than her pension/ attendance allowance be discovered and removed from her, if they can't trawl through her relatives bank accounts? She's not even paying tax on it!

What about all the now retired hard working tax payer pensioners who aren't being subsidized for looking after their nieces, I'm sure they wont mind if it puts an end to Old Aunty Marge getting something they don't.

This is also why the desire to do away with cash and have every transaction between everyone digital and recorded. It all needs resisting.

NamechangeForthisquestion1 · 05/03/2024 11:06

If the bill passes, which it looks like it has/is going to.. there is going to be a 'test and learn' in 2025 before it starts to roll out in 2026/27, hopefully by then we'll have a new government- although there's no guarantee they won't decide to push through with it. Who knows. But the best bet we have is to vote out the current government. It's not about having 'nothing to hide' this is a very frightening move from the current government..... especially the checking of pensioners accounts.

Elleherd · 05/03/2024 09:25

LittleGreenDragons
I couldn't see the government's reasoning for this overreach. The overeach as you rightly call it, will create hostility, shunning, and resentment towards those seen as 'causing' others to 'have to have' their privacy breached, by needing any form of benefits in the first place.

It creates another social divide between those entitled to privacy as they have access to enough money, and aren't in relationships with, related to, or renting to those who do not.

Elleherd · 05/03/2024 09:06

The net would also trawl the private banking data of people related to welfare claimants including partners, parents and landlords.

How to further raise homelessness and further break up families and relationships, and isolate the individual while simultaneously further demonizing those who often government themselves have manipulated into the 'receiving benefits' trap.

Parents, pensioners, poorly paid workers, disabled workers, on top of those more traditionally reliant on 'welfare' such as disabled unable to work, or the unemployed.

That's before we get to the point of telling individuals they don't need some of what they receive because they have chosen to buy expensive books instead of putting the money into their funeral plan/pension, insurance ect.

XenoBitch · 04/03/2024 23:04

IClaudine · 04/03/2024 21:39

I can't understand how that can be allowed. I can see how access to bank accounts can be made a requirement receiving benefit, but partners, parents and landlords.

I can believe it, TBH.

I have a friend who has her adult son's UC and PIP go into her own bank account as he is unable to manage his own money.

I am on UC, and had to show bank statements etc when I claimed to prove I was under the savings threshold.

From what I understand, this monitoring is to make sure claimants still remain under this threshold and to see if they have any undisclosed savings.

But like many others, I worry it will be used to do more than that... monitor where our money is going and what we are spending it on. That is sinister.

NamechangeForthisquestion1 · 04/03/2024 23:04

So this would give a landlord even more power to evict a tenant claiming HB to pay their rent, as they wouldn't want to risk having their bank accounts snooped... and I wouldn't really blame them.

IClaudine · 04/03/2024 22:57

And as up thread, that’s seen as perfectly fine, and it all gives the impression that something is being done to clamp down on the 200’tvs, mobility lamborghinis and fainting goats

Oh yes, don't forget the goats!

OP posts:
NastyLittleNoseWrinkle · 04/03/2024 22:55

Pretty sure you already have to sign to allow dole to cross-reference/check claims

The LL and parent thing won’t happen, it’s designed to worry non-benefit claimants so that when it’s clarified they can be relieved that it’s only claimants

And as up thread, that’s seen as perfectly fine, and it all gives the impression that something is being done to clamp down on the 200’tvs, mobility lamborghinis and fainting goats

Againsttheflow · 04/03/2024 22:28

Doesn't it go against caldicott principles? Specifically numbers 1 and 4.

Principle 1: justify the purpose(s) for using confidential information.
Principle 2: use confidential information only when it is necessary.
Principle 3: use the minimum necessary confidential information.
Principle 4: access to confidential information should be on a strict need-to-know basis.

LittleGreenDragons · 04/03/2024 22:00

The net would also trawl the private banking data of people related to welfare claimants including partners, parents and landlords.

I couldn't see the government's reasoning for this overreach. Don't particularly like them doing it for claimants but can understand the reasoning is to catch someone claiming benefits despite having huge savings or a good job. But landlords??

Actually this probably won't happen, I'm sure I read somewhere that a lot of MPs are rental landlords. They won't like their bank accounts scraped either.

letthemalldoone · 04/03/2024 21:47

Jonisaysitbest · 04/03/2024 18:25

They will happily chase after "benefit cheats" but do nothing about the many so-called loopholes that enable wealthier people and companies to avoid paying tax.
It's so disgusting. Always ready to kick the poorest, take away from the poorest and reward the richest. Please God we get a new bunch of people at the helm after the next election.

It doesn't matter. They are all self-serving muppets.

HumanRightsAreHumanRights · 04/03/2024 21:45

This is ridiculous.

I expect people will die as a direct result of this policy when someone on PIP gets caught up in the mess it will cause and can't cope, and I can't see on what grounds one child of mine receiving benefits of any kind justifies the govt monitoring my bank account (not that I believe they should be looking in anyones).

Why would any private landlord rent to anyone who even might get a UC top up if it means the govt can monitor their bank accounts?

IClaudine · 04/03/2024 21:39

Spendonsend · 04/03/2024 21:35

I think this is really scary and will go wrong. I cant believe that they can start looking at partners and parents too.

I can't understand how that can be allowed. I can see how access to bank accounts can be made a requirement receiving benefit, but partners, parents and landlords.

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 04/03/2024 21:35

I think this is really scary and will go wrong. I cant believe that they can start looking at partners and parents too.