Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Turning in a private road

214 replies

RoadyMcRoadUser · 04/03/2024 08:57

Preparing to get flamed for this…..There is a large private road literally next door to my kids primary school which is situated in a cul de sac. The public road gets massively congested in this cul de sac as you can imagine. I have sometimes had no choice but to turn my car in the private road. I have never parked there and doing the school run twice a day have never seen anyone else parked up there either. There’s a guy who lives in the road who will literally stand and glare at me if I turn the car round in his road on the school run. It’s like he comes out of his house specifically at school run times to observe this.
I know you aren’t “supposed” to put an inch of the nose of your car in a private road. But equally, there’s a part of me that thinks if you are that enraged by your private road being used by anyone other than the people that live there, then why would you buy a house directly next door to a school in a cul de sac with no other turning options? Am I being an arsehole? Or is this man overly precious?

OP posts:
Turtletoe · 05/03/2024 18:56

There's a school in my Borough that has this exact issue. The guy has has got the equivalent of parking eye to slap tickets on people. Some school mums actively go out their way to cause issues with him. End of the day, th9se residents pay to upkeep that road. If people were just turning around on your drive on the daily in their droves, you'd be upset having to re tarmac it more regular.
Do you need to park on the road of the school,? Is there a neighbouring road a couple of streets away you could park on then you wouldn't need to be turning around on their road.

SeraphinaValentina · 05/03/2024 18:25

I live on an estate where all roads are private, with parking restrictions. But people are still allowed to drive there - how can anyone possibly know who's the resident and who's visiting?
So I'm surprised that this is an issue tbh.

beanii · 05/03/2024 18:12

You are being unreasonable - it's a private road 🤷‍♀️ he must get sick and tired of it.

Park 5/10 minute walk away - you don't HAVE to park next to the school.

YireosDodeAver · 05/03/2024 07:31

A "private road" that isn't fenced off has the same status as the patches of open space all over cities that have discrete little plaques saying "This is private land and there is no public right of way" but are nevertheless an integral part of the built environment. Or of the road that I know well which is the standard route through an out-of-town industrial estate between a city and a nearby village - there's another route which takes 3 minutes more so people go through the industrial area. Every year on Boxing Day they put up barriers and close it except for people with ID connected to the site businesses and that's solely to stop it from becoming a right-of-way which happens if people are able to habitually use it unimpeded for 7 years without hinderence. The fact that these roads are privately owned does not stop them from being publicly accessible. The owner certainly has a choice to stop it from being publicly accessible.

The houses built on a private road will also have their own driveways which people will respect (or sometimes fail to, as some people are like that) to the same extent as the private driveways offf public roads. My own house has a driveway off a public road that happens to be the main walking route between a large residential area and the nearest pub and I do occasionally see evidence that people have used the accessible parts of my property in an antisocial way (taking a wee in the side alley, leaving beer cand on top of my bin shed) but trying to prevent this would be way too petty and far too much effort to achieve. I'm hardly going to sit on the porch till 3am with a pellet gun or garden hose at the ready to fight off trespassers just in case this happens. I'l get on with my life instead.

Dorisbonson · 05/03/2024 06:43

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 04/03/2024 16:42

@Dartwarbler you are the one who does not understand the law. They are public rights of way that anyone can drive on.
This is the equivalent of people who put cones on the road outside their house to bagsy "their" parking space.

Most private roads are "except for access" eg only residents or their visitors. Public highways are adopted roads not unadopted private roads. I suspect you don't understand the distinction.

NotTheCase · 05/03/2024 01:11

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 04/03/2024 22:20

@Gymnopedie people can still turn around in your road.

@NotTheCase if there is no gate across the road that is sometimes closed, it is incredibly unlikely to be a road without a public right of way. Lots of people on this thread do not understand the law. I drive down two private roads regularly. Even the one I drive down that is truly a private road with a gate that is closed every evening, still allows anyone to drive on the road. Although that is with the agreement of the landowner.

As you said ‘allows’ if there is no legal ‘public right of way’ (best to check with council) then it is at the preview of the owner.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 04/03/2024 23:31

@Hostilehabitat the public do have a right to drive on the road. You do not understand the law.

Hostilehabitat · 04/03/2024 23:10

I live on a private unadopted road. For those that don’t understand how they work, in our case we each own the section of road outside our homes within our boundary, diagram attached. There are 3 houses. We have ROW to drive over each other’s portion of the road for access but the public doesn’t have this right. It is a dead end so no need for the public to drive down here but they do to turn around and yes it’s incredibly annoying as we are responsible for the cost to upkeep the road. It also means we still have to be vigilant of our kids/pets getting knocked over on what is essentially a track.

Turning in a private road
TattiePants · 04/03/2024 22:56

BusyMummy001 · 04/03/2024 22:36

As far as I could tell, it was to do with the fact that delivery guys/royal mail etc have an implied permission to enter those roads unless you put a gate up, and this establishes a public right of way? It is definitely not clear. My dad lives in gated estate which means expressly that there is no right of way (and it’s a new road/estate, so I guess you couldn’t argue an established right of way before then). I think, perhaps, the rules on private roads need to be made clear on the highway code/theory tests but am guessing.

That said, I do think it is incredibly rude to enter the space to do manoeuvres or park any way. People three point turn in our non-private road and enter our drive when they do so - it pisses me off as we have dogs and used to have young children riding bikes on the drive that might not have been visible from the road, so I am guessing a lot of people on private roads live in the expectation that their children are safe there.

The kids being able to ride their bikes on a quiet road is about the only benefit of living on a private road. They loved it when we had the roads resurfaced and they had this new smooth surface to ride and skateboard on!

The odd parent driving into our road wouldn’t be a problem and no one would probably notice them but before we changed the entrance to the street we had 100+ vehicles every day that were linked to the school and the roads were a mess that took £50k to sort out.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 04/03/2024 22:55

@BusyMummy001 the rules are clear, just a lot of people do not understand them.
There are a few tiny exceptions, but generally if there is a gate that is sometimes closed across the road, there is no legal right of way for vehicles. If there is not, there is a legal right of way and that right of way includes being able to turn in the road.
You can not just decide to put a gate across an existing road.

BusyMummy001 · 04/03/2024 22:36

TattiePants · 04/03/2024 22:13

@BusyMummy001 I can’t speak for all private roads but my private road has no public right of access for vehicles. We’ve never restricted pedestrian access and never would so I imagine there is an established pedestrian right of way. In the time I’ve lived here we’ve changed the entrance into the road, changed it from a two way to one way system, reduced the speed limit and close our gates whenever we want to. We’ve also investigated electrification of the gates and having them permanently closed. None of this is a problem as we jointly own the land and there is no public vehicle right of way.

As far as I could tell, it was to do with the fact that delivery guys/royal mail etc have an implied permission to enter those roads unless you put a gate up, and this establishes a public right of way? It is definitely not clear. My dad lives in gated estate which means expressly that there is no right of way (and it’s a new road/estate, so I guess you couldn’t argue an established right of way before then). I think, perhaps, the rules on private roads need to be made clear on the highway code/theory tests but am guessing.

That said, I do think it is incredibly rude to enter the space to do manoeuvres or park any way. People three point turn in our non-private road and enter our drive when they do so - it pisses me off as we have dogs and used to have young children riding bikes on the drive that might not have been visible from the road, so I am guessing a lot of people on private roads live in the expectation that their children are safe there.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 04/03/2024 22:20

@Gymnopedie people can still turn around in your road.

@NotTheCase if there is no gate across the road that is sometimes closed, it is incredibly unlikely to be a road without a public right of way. Lots of people on this thread do not understand the law. I drive down two private roads regularly. Even the one I drive down that is truly a private road with a gate that is closed every evening, still allows anyone to drive on the road. Although that is with the agreement of the landowner.

PurBal · 04/03/2024 22:18

I live in a private road and repair is joint responsibility of the people that live there. There are 6 of us but realistically only 2 of us need to drive up to the end. There’s a right of way over my bit for the neighbour and that’s it. But… Delivery drivers in massive vans drive up it all the time even when not delivering to us and neighbour so it’s getting completely churned up. It’s going to cost a fortune to get it repaired. So YABU on those grounds. It’s one of the reasons we’ve discussed moving in the past, because people who don’t have a right to be on it, are on it.

ETA: delivery driver parking on it and obstructing our access when I was in labour and I needed to get to hospital was the one that really irked me.

TattiePants · 04/03/2024 22:13

@BusyMummy001 I can’t speak for all private roads but my private road has no public right of access for vehicles. We’ve never restricted pedestrian access and never would so I imagine there is an established pedestrian right of way. In the time I’ve lived here we’ve changed the entrance into the road, changed it from a two way to one way system, reduced the speed limit and close our gates whenever we want to. We’ve also investigated electrification of the gates and having them permanently closed. None of this is a problem as we jointly own the land and there is no public vehicle right of way.

BusyMummy001 · 04/03/2024 21:51

@NotTheCase just googled this but, apparently, private roads are privately owned/maintained roads which are nonetheless publicly owned rights of way. Never knew this until now, but yes we’re allowed into them.

NotTheCase · 04/03/2024 20:53

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 04/03/2024 16:42

@Dartwarbler you are the one who does not understand the law. They are public rights of way that anyone can drive on.
This is the equivalent of people who put cones on the road outside their house to bagsy "their" parking space.

No. That would only be true ‘if it had a ‘right of way’ on it.

it is always best to assume no right of way until proved otherwise. Check with the council

GnomeDePlume · 04/03/2024 20:34

I guess the glaring man is a very good deterrent to stop people thinking of parking on the road.

RMNofTikTok · 04/03/2024 19:31

I use whatever I need to in order to turn safely in a road, not just on a school run. Private roads, private drives, I really couldn't care less. I do what I need to do to be safe and keep other road users safe.

MississippiAF · 04/03/2024 19:26

Yabu, you do have a choice; you park further away

Gymnopedie · 04/03/2024 19:25

We live on a private cul-de-sac. Each of us own the part of the road in front of our property. So many people from other roads started parking on it that it looked like Asda's car park on a Saturday afternoon. They thought nothing of making it impossible to get out of our drives (their logic being that as we have drives to park in, they should have the right to park on the road). And each of those cars - it being a cul-de-sac - had to do a three point turn to get out. It got so bad we've employed a parking company that has the right to issue parking charge notices and follow them up through the courts if they're not paid.

For those saying that even if it is private there is a right of way, yes there is. It's in the deeds to the house that there is (deeds from 1898). But a right of way means that you have the right to use the road to get from A to B. It does not include the right to do three (or more) point turns.

Our road is in poor condition and even though it's only long enough for 10 houses we are looking at upwards of £80,000 between us to have it repaired.

MummyMummy01 · 04/03/2024 18:31

No you don't pay to re surface it. Walk your child And if you live 5 miles away why did you buy a house so far from a school.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 04/03/2024 18:20

@Notastripper you are wrong. Legal to use the road to turn around.

solarised · 04/03/2024 17:50

Stop tying yourself in knots no excuse

clarepetal · 04/03/2024 17:38

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 04/03/2024 16:51

A private driveway from a road to a house is not a public road. A private road is still a public right of way.

This. And people talking about OP contributions to wear and tear is ridiculous..it's a road! To be driven down!
She hasn't done anything wrong!
And I live on a private road and pay for upkeep.

clarepetal · 04/03/2024 17:33

RoadyMcRoadUser · 04/03/2024 09:39

Well that told me! 😂
just wanted to confirm I have never parked up in this road and have never used anyone’s actual driveway to turn around - there’s a turning circle type thing in the road.
yep ok I’ll take it on the chin that I’m being inconsiderate and bear that in mind for future school runs!

I don't think you are being inconsiderate if you are only turning around in the circle thing and not someone's actual drive. If the residents don't like it, they need to get over it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread