Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This might save my marriage

137 replies

Hadenough2021 · 04/03/2024 08:02

Help me, would you have a cup of tea in your house with someone whose wedding you attended recently (within the year) I'm being vague on details because I genuinely don't know much more. Is it a stretch to assume that if you're friendly enough with someone to attend their wedding that you would be prepared to have a cup of tea with them?

Please vote accordingly.

Unreasonable: no I wouldn't have a cup of tea in my house with someone whose wedding I had attended.

Reasonable: yes, I would have a cup of tea in my house with someone whose wedding I attended.

OP posts:
NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 04/03/2024 10:50

Um, this really depends how social your parents-in-law are, and how local this woman is to them. Do they constantly have people coming over for tea, like characters in Coronation Street?

I've attended a fair few weddings now. None of the brides would drive all the way to my house for tea, though. They've got their own kettles!

TerrysCIockworkOrange · 04/03/2024 10:52

Hadenough2021 · 04/03/2024 10:43

You lot are brutal. If my father in law had an affair but managed to stay married to my mother in law but I remained friends with the OW you lot would be roasting me. Why is it because the situation is reversed am I getting a hammering. I'm not trying to punish them for anything, I genuinely don't care who they socialise with but I don't want to socialise with her surely I'm allowed to make that choice?

But OP you haven’t said the OW spends any time at their home?! Please explain more clearly to us if you want people to understand.
Does OW spend time at your in laws house?
Have you previously run into her at their house?
Have your in laws indicated they wish to continue socialising with OW in their home?

Your response seems OTT because it seemingly has no basis in reality!

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 04/03/2024 10:54

If the ILs were close friends with this woman yout stance might be understandable, given its not you're being very unreasonable to not visit the inlaws on the outside chance she might possibly one day have a cup of tea at their house at the same time you're there.

Stompythedinosaur · 04/03/2024 10:54

You forgave your dh but are still punishing your ils for not having cut contact.

I think you should probably get over it. I suspect your ils had a relationship with this woman that is separate to her fling with your husband (which, as pps have said, you should is at fault for far more than her, he's the one who betrayed you).

You are absolutely trying to control your ils. You are perfectly able to see them without seeming the ow.

HoppingPavlova · 04/03/2024 10:54

I'm not trying to punish them for anything, I genuinely don't care who they socialise with but I don't want to socialise with her surely I'm allowed to make that choice?

Sure you do, but it seems really odd. In 10 years you have never once bumped into this woman at your in-laws place, not once. Yet all of a sudden you need to boycott their house because otherwise you’ll be forced to socialise with her and don’t want to. Don't you see how insane that sounds? If your in-laws socialise with her, I’d say they would make sure your paths never cross, given what their toad of a son got up to, so I just can’t imagine she’ll ever be there sipping tea when you go around🙄.

You have made a choice to stay with your DH, that’s fine. But you can’t banish the woman from the face of the earth to play pretends that it never happened, and realistically you wont be meeting her at your in-laws so no need to be dramatic with them, and face it, they didn’t cause this drama!

Lastarse · 04/03/2024 10:54

You don’t trust your husband - time to stop deflecting perhaps, in-laws, tea, weddings et al - all irrelevant.

HaPPy8 · 04/03/2024 10:55

I think it’s a bit odd that your in laws have remained friends with her I’ll be honest. They have no other connection? They just knew her through your husband?

however the odds of bumping into her at their house are tiny so I think you are being unreasonable about never going to their house if as you say you otherwise have a decent relationship

StopTheBusINeedAWeeWeeAWeeWeeBagOChips · 04/03/2024 10:59

You haven't bumped into her there for the last decade, I think you're safe.

Calling her a random tart while staying with the actual person who should have been loyal to you speaks volumes.

You're not secure in your marriage, understandably, but you're putting responsibility on everyone bar the actual person who cheated on you.

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 04/03/2024 11:01

Kindly, if a mumsnet thread is potentially going to save your marriage, I think you should go for some couples counselling.

senua · 04/03/2024 11:03

Hadenough2021 · 04/03/2024 10:43

You lot are brutal. If my father in law had an affair but managed to stay married to my mother in law but I remained friends with the OW you lot would be roasting me. Why is it because the situation is reversed am I getting a hammering. I'm not trying to punish them for anything, I genuinely don't care who they socialise with but I don't want to socialise with her surely I'm allowed to make that choice?

People are being brutal because you came at this sideways with talk of cups of tea.Confused If you had spelled it out clearly in the OP you would have had more sympathy and, probably, helpful suggestions. As it is, you have got everybody's back up which is a bit self-sabotaging.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 04/03/2024 11:19

It seems a gross overreaction to never visit your in-laws. Whilst you might not be intending to punish them you are because you are negatively impacting their relationship with you. Out of interest, are you controlling the access your husband has to his parents because of the risk of him bumping into thsi woman at their house?

I'll be honest, I think you are being utterly unreasonable, not least for the overly cryptic OP and predictable drip feed.

justteanbiscuits · 04/03/2024 11:19

So you never go there just in case she might be there?! This is OTT.

JJathome · 04/03/2024 11:23

How did she attempt to ruin your marriage, and she’s the tart, did your husband have no agency in his own life? How’s it her fault?

and how will this save your marriage on whether your in-laws can have a cup of tea with her or not.

you clearly are not over what ever happened, as this reads like a panicked reaction,

Lougle · 04/03/2024 11:25

Can you not just have a quiet word and say: "The situation with Jane was really upsetting and although I have chosen to move past it, I wouldn't feel comfortable with seeing Jane at any point. Does Jane come here at all? If she does, can you warn me if she's going to come over and I'll avoid your house at that time. Thanks."?

It is very extreme to never go somewhere because you might see someone, and I would say that it is allowing yourself to be controlled far more by that person than if you occasionally risked seeing them.

mumda · 04/03/2024 11:26

I think it depends if you snogged them during the dancing and your husband didn't know.

Timeheals · 04/03/2024 11:32

Yes you can control who you see. But even if I were to invite someone around - I wouldn’t invite their affair partner around - or their wife at the same time. I can’t see a likelihood of you bumping into her at their house.

JustOneFootInFrontOfTheOther · 04/03/2024 12:07

Is it wild of me to assume this might include her visiting their house?

Yes. I’ve been to numerous weddings of people who I know but who’s house I’ve never been in.

I have a friend of 24+ years. She’s never been inside any of the 3 houses I’ve lived in. I haven’t been in the one she moved to 4 years ago but have occasionally been in her previous one. We meet out.

CJsGoldfish · 04/03/2024 12:16

So your inlaws have been friends with this woman for 10 years and you've never bumped in to her at their home before?
Now that you've seen pics of them at her wedding it means that you cannot visit them ever again in case you bump in to the person you've never bumped into there before?
Are you sure you're not just trying to punish them? Clearly your inlaws don't share your opinion so I guess it's pissed you off 🤷‍♀️

Pipsquiggle · 04/03/2024 12:17

@Hadenough2021 you are being OTT.

You are letting a hypothetical meeting dictate whether you visit your ILs house - which TBH is a bit ridiculous.

You not wanting to see this OW is completely understandable, however, you are conflating wedding attendance with frequent social gatherings at your ILs which may not be the case.

If your ILs are aware of the part the OW played in your marriage, I am sure they are as eager as you are, not to have you 2 in the same room together.

I think you are catastrophizing this situation. If you want a guarantee that you won't bump into the OW at the ILs, then maybe have a chat with your ILs. Ask them how often OW pops round for a cup of tea.

gannett · 04/03/2024 12:27

Hadenough2021 · 04/03/2024 10:43

You lot are brutal. If my father in law had an affair but managed to stay married to my mother in law but I remained friends with the OW you lot would be roasting me. Why is it because the situation is reversed am I getting a hammering. I'm not trying to punish them for anything, I genuinely don't care who they socialise with but I don't want to socialise with her surely I'm allowed to make that choice?

No, I'd think you were perfectly entitled to stay friends with whomever you liked. Maybe in that hypothetical scenario you'd been friends for years with the OW and you'd be able to get past what she'd done.

You're perfectly entitled to choose not to socialise with her, that's understandable and no one's taken issue with that. What I don't understand is why you then feel you need to stop visiting your in-laws completely. If you say you don't want to see her they should respect that and not invite you both to the same events. But if it's not an event she's been invited to, I can't think why you'd randomly see her there.

anyolddinosaur · 04/03/2024 12:28

Only read your posts. You are being weird. Visit your inlaws, if this woman happens to be there you can always walk out.

IWouldRatherBeOnHoliday · 04/03/2024 12:30

I'm not sure why you'd assume this woman would be at their house, so I think YABVU.

There are very few people who attended my wedding that I would drop in unplanned for a visit, so if another relative of theirs didn't want to see me then they could safely assume they wouldn't have to.

Given the presumed age difference, are your ILs friends with the woman's parents and attended the wedding that way? We had some friends of our parents at my wedding, none of then I'd ever see outside of being at mutual connections' parties or events.

Surely just ask your ILs to agree that if you did ever have plans to see them and by some chance this woman called, they would either let you know or turn her away if you were already at their house? Zero drama needed.

Roastiesarethebestbit · 04/03/2024 12:30

Ok your posts are quite confusing. Is the problem that you refuse to go to his parents house (in case you see this woman there), and your husband feels that you are being unreasonable?

I agree that if his parents went to her wedding, then they are friends who may spend time at each others homes occasionally. But it seems vanishingly unlikely that she may just happen to be there at the same time as you, as 99% of people plan ahead when they visit and don’t just ‘pop in’. So refusing to visit their home on that basis seems a bit ridiculous.

It Seems instead that you are choosing not to go to your in laws more as some sort of punishment for them choosing to
still have a friendship
with her. Which wouldn’t be unreasonable, but you’d be better off being honest about it.

notthatkindofFatCat · 04/03/2024 12:31

Sorry you're hurting but this feels like too much drama and not much sense.
I think avoiding your in laws is OTT and if it's encouraging your partner too then it's plain controlling.

You need to find a way to release the past.

MummyJ36 · 04/03/2024 12:36

OP this is the fallout of your husband having an affair (I assume it was an affair). It sounds like your in-laws were in friendly terms with her to begin with before the affair? If so I don’t think you can insist they cut contact, although I do understand your upset.

The thing with affairs is, you can forgive but very rarely do you forget. This is the price you are paying for forgiving and staying with your husband. If it wasn’t this incident with you in laws it would be something else. Affairs are a break of trust and once that trust is gone it is hard to fully “get over” it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread