Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For this to be the reason for breaking contact?

135 replies

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 14:47

I had no sleep (literally) last night so my judgement may be clouded.

I gave my brother a lift into town as he cannot drive at the moment. When there he bought a slice of pizza and a doughnut- fine. My three year old needed lunch so we went to the M & S cafe. I bought a spaghetti bolognaise for DS - small portion as for a child. I then went to change my baby’s nappy. While I was doing that, my brother reached over and took a huge helping of DS’s food, probably half his meal.

I am furious but am I overreacting?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RenoDakota · 04/03/2024 10:31

I have a 'troubled' brother too, now in his fifties. If he had done this to one of my children I would have challenged him but he would have turned it around on me in a spiteful way, saying I was over-reacting etc. And probably would have continued to 'joke' about it in front of my children. This is giving me the rage just imagining it and writing about it. I hear you, OP.
But I do have a massive back story in that I have previously baled him out (more than once) under terrible circumstances, never had any thanks or appreciation and have ended up going very, very LC. My children, now young adults, won't have anything to do with him now either because of the toll he has taken on me.

Only you can decide whether, for the sake of your own well-being, you need to cut him out of your life.

All the best to you. I understand 💐

ILoveMyCatButHesAPervert · 04/03/2024 10:13

Just dismisses most things I say.

Well that's a massive problem, @Whyjustwhywhy.

As is often says on MN, you have a DH problem at the heart of things.

May be create a thread in Relationships on this.

cauliflowerqueen · 03/03/2024 22:13

Your brother should know better than to take food from anyone's plate, regardless of their age, without asking. I'd at the very least tell him you're not happy about that and expect it never to happen again.

I wouldn't be impressed by your husband constantly disregarding your opinions, either. In this case, I'd wonder if he's just trying to avoid drama, but he needs to back you up and present a united front.

jannier · 03/03/2024 21:02

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 17:17

I am a bit lost as to what you mean by that.

@Testina he is in a strange place. He has autism but is high functioning so no learning disability exactly but he isn’t really able to function. It’s hard, as he’s in that funny grey area where he isn’t really able to access support as he’s too high functioning but he also can’t really function independently which is why I’ve been roped in … but it is impacting my child negatively which is very hard to see.

Is adult social services involved? My nephew is 30 he's just lost his mother and we've called them in to help with housing.
You can still explain boundaries to him including other people's food.

FofB · 03/03/2024 20:19

I do understand what you are trying (badly) to get at.

Your brother is happy to take food from a child (to feed himself, when he already has his own food) and leave a small toddler hungry and with half a meal.

Toddler had no power to stop this and Father didn't step in. I guess it's the imbalance of power you are angry about. And because you weren't to speak up for your child, then this unfairness happened.

You aren't overreacting.

Frances0911 · 03/03/2024 19:57

How old is your brother?

Does he have any issues?

Mama2many73 · 03/03/2024 19:54

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 15:58

I genuinely don’t know why that’s a drip feed. I think DH was a bit like ‘wtf’. I mean, what SHOULD he have done?

Said

NO

PlacidPenelope · 03/03/2024 19:53

My concern for you @Whyjustwhywhy is that your husband is not supporting you or backing you up, why isn't he?

JCLV · 03/03/2024 19:51

Your brother was out of order taking any of your son’s food. Your husband is out of order for not saying anything. I can understand why you are annoyed. It must be hard looking after two children and also having your brother living with you. Add your husband into the mix and it sounds like you are looking after 4 kids.

Dutchairfryer · 03/03/2024 19:45

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 15:16

I am just trying to imagine how I’d feel if I was eating my lunch and someone twice my size took it off me and helped themselves.

But this is just a bit silly, your son is 3. There are many areas of a child’s life that, if that child was an adult would be unreasonable (heck even illegal in some cases) but because they’re children it’s really not that much of an issue.

Katemax82 · 03/03/2024 19:33

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 16:11

To be fair DH doesn’t understand why I’m upset or seem to think it’s a big deal so possibly I’m just being stupid.

I am just imagining trying to eat my lunch and someone just grabs it. It was a toddler sized portion and brother apparently reached across with a massive spoon and just dug in.

DH has said that we’ve both eaten bits of toddler food before which is true but not when he’s in the middle of eating it iyswim … it’s been when he’s finished or mostly finished.

My brother is a very troubled soul, not aggressive. DH is very laid back, I don’t think it would cross his mind to say anything. And to be fair it’s only on here people come out with pre recorded perfect responses, in RL I’m certainly often too taken aback of similar to deal with something well. I’m just very fed up today.

Just remind your brother of this if he asks for favours again, say its not ok

kittensinthekitchen · 03/03/2024 19:23

Welcome to Mumsnet.

This sounds like the weird post about someone's ILs helping themselves to the OPs child's leftovers without asking.

Zola1 · 03/03/2024 18:57

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 15:58

I genuinely don’t know why that’s a drip feed. I think DH was a bit like ‘wtf’. I mean, what SHOULD he have done?

Obviously he should have said,'What are you doing? Get off his dinner'

Not rocket science

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 18:49

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 03/03/2024 18:48

Him taking the lunch was not on but not serious enough to break contact over. You are coming across quite rudely though to people you are asking for help from.

The only posts I’ve been rude to are posts that are also rude.

OP posts:
Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 18:49

ILoveMyCatButHesAPervert · 03/03/2024 18:47

Why not? Does he ignore your concerns if you explain them to him? Would he not cooperate with you in setting boundaries for your brother?

Just dismisses most things I say.

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 03/03/2024 18:48

Him taking the lunch was not on but not serious enough to break contact over. You are coming across quite rudely though to people you are asking for help from.

ILoveMyCatButHesAPervert · 03/03/2024 18:47

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 18:44

Possibly but I can’t do much about DH

Why not? Does he ignore your concerns if you explain them to him? Would he not cooperate with you in setting boundaries for your brother?

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 03/03/2024 18:46

@Whyjustwhywhy why is it your responsibility to house a 45 year old man who should know better than to steal food from a toddler's plate??

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 18:44

Possibly but I can’t do much about DH

OP posts:
ILoveMyCatButHesAPervert · 03/03/2024 18:43

fluffycatkins · 03/03/2024 18:13

I know you keep saying that DH's behavior isn't the issue but it honestly seems like it is part of the problem.
Having an adult with additional support needs in your home and under your care is a massive extra responsibility.
Trying to do this alongside another adult who doesn't share your need for boundaries is going to be nearly impossible.
It is okay to say "no, I can't do this long term. I will support you in the very short term and help you move on. But you can't stay long term in my house DB"
You don't have to go no contact just move him back out of your house and active care.

This is also worth another read, OP.

ILoveMyCatButHesAPervert · 03/03/2024 18:42

CatsAddictedToDreamies · 03/03/2024 17:05

So if he isn't aggressive and has nowhere else to go (but is apparently a functioning adult) tell him not to take the piss. Tell him why you are annoyed and what an overstep it is. Tell him you are pissed off he is not respecting your child or indeed you.

DH has a best friend who stays with us once a year in order to participate in a stupid fucking sporting hobby. For the past 18 years. He similarly treats me and my Dcs with entitlement and disdain. So 3 years ago I finally got some balls courage and told him to stop treating me with such disrespect and to stop behaving like my home was a B&B and I was his hand maiden. He was so shocked that he actually teared up. I doubt anyone has told him how to behave since he was a tween. But he listened. And he is on notice. He is not staying this yeat as it happens. I told him I was done.

Men like this - PEOPLE like this only get away with it because they are allowed to. People in all walks of life tip toe around the most difficult person in the room. People cater to all sorts of crap because they are people pleasers.

Tell him what is what and assert your boundaries. TBH it does not really matter if your DH agrees or not. YOU think he has overstepped. Tell him that. If he is living in your home off largely your dime he can cop onto himself and be a bit more considerate.

This is a really good post, @Whyjustwhywhy. As are this poster's other contributions.

MrsWPooh · 03/03/2024 18:42

we all steal our kids’ food

Speak for yourself, that certainly never happened in our home and I’d have stabbed anyone’s hand with a fork that tried to. Anyone is welcome to leftovers after the meal is finished but someone taking food or trying to take food from anyone’s plate while they are eating is bizarre, rude and lacking in basic manners.

Devonshiregal · 03/03/2024 18:29

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 17:17

I am a bit lost as to what you mean by that.

@Testina he is in a strange place. He has autism but is high functioning so no learning disability exactly but he isn’t really able to function. It’s hard, as he’s in that funny grey area where he isn’t really able to access support as he’s too high functioning but he also can’t really function independently which is why I’ve been roped in … but it is impacting my child negatively which is very hard to see.

So your brother is very much disabled by his neurological condition.

your dc is impacted by him negatively? how?

if it’s one (large) spoonful of spaghetti then you are being unreasonable. And all the talk of imaging someone double your size taking your food is really a bit much. we all steal our kids’ food. And unless he literally took a spoonful of food out of your kid’s hand and put it into his own mouth, then no it is not a big deal. If he does it again just tell him not to do it.

if he’s doing lots of things that are negative and upsetting your child and this is just one of them then youre not unreasonable for being irritated but you’re unreasonable for not explaining the other things and focusing so heavily on a bowl of pasta.

RatatouillePie · 03/03/2024 18:22

Whyjustwhywhy · 03/03/2024 14:47

I had no sleep (literally) last night so my judgement may be clouded.

I gave my brother a lift into town as he cannot drive at the moment. When there he bought a slice of pizza and a doughnut- fine. My three year old needed lunch so we went to the M & S cafe. I bought a spaghetti bolognaise for DS - small portion as for a child. I then went to change my baby’s nappy. While I was doing that, my brother reached over and took a huge helping of DS’s food, probably half his meal.

I am furious but am I overreacting?

When you went to change your DS's nappy, had your DS finished eating? Or did you take him off to mid meal? Or before he had even touched his meal?

If he had finished eating then YABU.

If he was mid meal or hadn't started then YANBU but your DH should have stopped him.

clpsmum · 03/03/2024 18:17

Some of the reactions on here are just weird. If only we were all perfect. Sometimes things have happened to me that I've been too shocked or too embarrassed to say anything about. OPs DP didn't see a big problem with it so why would he have said anything.

OP I would broach it with brother and just say it like you e said here, how would he feel if someone twice his size stole half his lunch. People do strange things sometimes. I wouldn't go NC over it u less there's a big backstory but I would broach it with him