Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who pays for holiday/holiday expenses? Is this fair or just stingy?

205 replies

KThughes · 03/03/2024 13:57

NC/NA for this.

I’ve been dating a man for the past year (15 months to be exact). We both work full time jobs. We do not live together. I’ve never been married and don’t have children. He is divorced with 2 children.

He has always been wealthy. Earns over £2m+ per year. I have always been financially sound/worked. We take it in turns to pay for things and that works just fine for me. I have a good career, but obviously don’t make as much as he does. I pay for all my own bills myself and have never needed financial help from anyone, even my parents.

Since we started dating, he has acknowledged many times that he loves how independent I am as his previous partners were apparently ‘gold-diggers’. He repeats this sentiment often, but even if he didn’t, I love being independent and having my own income and career path. I have no debt and live alone - and within my means.

He’s since sold his company (which was after we met) and has become even more wealthy. Sunday Times Rich List wealthy. Not the top of such a list, but definitely on there.

He now wants to go on holiday to celebrate. As in a blowout celebration. I suggested somewhere more low key and not so crazy. He suggested St Bart’s etc…

He said he’d pay for my flight and we could ‘figure out the rest while we were there’.

I said no, as I am financially astute and would need to know what other expenses could amount to prior. Are we talking additional charges of £1k...? £5k…? £10k...? More?!

I also said I didn’t feel comfortable with this all. He told me to ‘relax’.

He acknowledged that I have a great career and job… but that doesn’t mean I should have to potentially put things on my credit card or dip into savings - for a destination that I didn’t choose. A destination that is astronomically expensive.

I’d happily pay my own way - even my own damn flight if the trip was less extravagant on the whole. I don’t even WANT my flight paid for, especially if it means I’m going to end up being ‘liable’ for many more charges as a result of this trip.

I also don’t want to be called a ‘gold digger’ by him. I can’t help but feel like this is almost a ‘test’ of sorts. It is a really bizarre situation and makes me feel… honestly… gross.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pipsquiggle · 28/03/2024 12:45

@KThughes

Thanks for updating and glad you decided to break it off and are in a better place x

LadyBird1973 · 28/03/2024 07:47

So glad to read this update. You absolutely did the right thing and I'm glad you are feeling better.

Hatty65 · 28/03/2024 01:02

@KThughes I'm so pleased to read your update! Thanks for letting us know. I admit I thought that he lacked empathy and you sounded intelligent, independent and rather fab - so I really felt that you could do better than this muppet.

Glad that you feel you made the right decision! 💐

KThughes · 28/03/2024 00:07

@Pipsquiggle I forgot to say thank you for asking for an update. I'm sure lots of posts like these are left on a 'cliffhanger' of sorts!

Thank you for thinking/writing. It is greatly appreciated. ❤

OP posts:
KThughes · 28/03/2024 00:03

Pipsquiggle · 08/03/2024 07:51

@KThughes any update?

@Pipsquiggle I didn't go on the trip. Neither did he. I ended the relationship.

I was becoming increasingly stressed and upset - and I never let it outwardly show. It was horrible. That said; one day, I looked at myself in the mirror - and all the colour had gone from my face/skin. My skin was dry and flaky and I looked a bit 'gaunt'. As pathetic as it sounds, I just got into the shower and cried.

Ended the relationship that day. I feel lighter and happier - and so thankful that I have my own money, am financially sound, didn't get into a terrible situation.

There were many things prior to ending the relationship that upset me too. Many comments that made it clear I wasn't to ever ask him for anything and go we were to go 50/50 on everything but that he'd be happy to 'share' here and there. To be clear, I'm more than ok with 50/50 (less so when it is a crazy expensive trip to St. Barts to celebrate his windfall - and a destination that I didn't plan/choose) and I would never ask him for anything anyway!!!!!!

He said RE: the trip that he does have 'a tendency to overspend' and I should 'rein him in sometimes' regarding his spending. That didn't answer the question on whether or not I'd be left with half the bill on said trip, but I'm assuming so, especially if I had 'given the go-ahead' on wine/food/activities etc... I'm so glad I declined.

He also said his ex had to 'screen' the women he dated to prove they weren't 'gold diggers' - which is ironic as he always said she was a 'gold digger' and how he got burned in their divorce. Yet I had to potentially meet her and 'prove myself'. I had never felt so insulted.

OP posts:
Pipsquiggle · 08/03/2024 07:51

@KThughes any update?

Dweetfidilove · 04/03/2024 21:17

pensione · 03/03/2024 14:36

Your instincts are 100% sound OP.

There have been quite a few threads by women who were so anxious to prove to a boyfriend that they weren’t gold diggers that they ended up subsidising the boyfriend or materially disadvantaging themselves.

Better a poor man who will share his sandwich with you than a rich man who will make you pay towards a posh meal you don’t want.

Better a poor man who will share his sandwich with you than a rich man who will make you pay towards a posh meal you don’t want.

All day, every day 🙌🏾

FOJN · 04/03/2024 21:03

He expresses contempt for the woman who raised his children.

He is conditioning you by complimenting your independence hoping that his compliments will be valued highly enough for you to learn not to become like his "gold digging ex".

He's pretending he can't understand why you need to know about the potential cost of the holiday up front, that's borderline gaslighting. Few people get to be that rich (in my experience) without knowing the cost of everything.

Tens of millions in the bank and won't even pay for a holiday. Someone needs to tell him there are no pockets in a shroud.

He doesn't sound like a keeper.

Hatty65 · 04/03/2024 20:52

He said he’d pay for my flight and we could ‘figure out the rest while we were there’.

I'd have laughed at this point and said, 'I can't afford a holiday in St Bart's and I'm not interested in spending stupid money just because you fancy going there. Have a good time'.

I agree with a lot of the others that he sounds unpleasant, to be honest. Massively wealthy but tight doesn't hold any appeal to me. He also sounds like he doesn't really understand the realities of life for most people and I'm turned off by men who are dim and lack empathy.

Pallisers · 04/03/2024 20:50

I'm not getting any sense of what he brings to the table for you OP. My red flags would be waving when he called other women gold diggers and would definitely be going off at him dismissing his wife's work as a SAHM. He doesn't sound like he likes or respects women much. Does he worry as much about male friends taking advantage - bet he doesn't.

Of course there is no need to pay for your holiday a year into the relationship. But pressurising you to spend more than your budget to go to the destination of his choice to celebrate wonderful him is not nice. I don't like him.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/03/2024 20:42

pensione · 03/03/2024 14:36

Your instincts are 100% sound OP.

There have been quite a few threads by women who were so anxious to prove to a boyfriend that they weren’t gold diggers that they ended up subsidising the boyfriend or materially disadvantaging themselves.

Better a poor man who will share his sandwich with you than a rich man who will make you pay towards a posh meal you don’t want.

Yes that's how the tinder swindler worked!!

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/03/2024 20:40

professorcunning · 03/03/2024 14:19

He it totally unreasonable to expect you to pay for half of a massive blowout holiday. Tell him either he pays for this one, it's his choice of destination after all, and you'll pay for the next at the destination of your choice, or you just won't go.

I like that idea - you get this trip I'll get the next one when I'm celebrating something for me - then you can celebrate your next promotion on a long weekend in Barcelona etc

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/03/2024 20:39

NeedToChangeName · 03/03/2024 14:09

Tell him your budget and don't exceed that

I agree. Eg 'I have a £3000 budget including everything and can't go over that.' If he wants to top it up he can do. But if a rich person insists on doing 50/50 with a poorer person then they need to slum it at the poor persons budget.

MakeItRain · 04/03/2024 20:36

I would now be worried, even if you had agreed to contribute your budget, that'll you'd get out there and be put in a situation where you have no choice but to use your credit card (because he won't for eg pay for your half of a meal/outing etc). So even if he offered to pay I think the trust would be gone for me, given that his initial decision was to "work it out when we get there".
I think this relationship would be over for me. It sounds like you've decided not to go - stick with that decision!

SuperGreens · 04/03/2024 20:19

I would just say to him....
I have £5000 (or however much you decide) to spend on holidays this year. I am willing to give that to you towards the St Barts trip if you cover the rest. Although its not a destination I would choose, I understand this is a big deal for you, and you want to celebrate in this particular place so I will go along with it. Its always my preference to cover myself financially, however I am only able to do that because I am careful and stick to my budget. So I hope you respect that, and if you decide you would rather not take me on this occasion I understand, and would be happy to have a Cotswolds holiday with you when you return.

Or something like that. Upfront, honest, and to the point. Any decent person would respect that.

Dacadactyl · 04/03/2024 18:54

What a total tightarse this bloke is! Can't believe he's trying to make you pay half for this trip. Lol! What a total joker.

He'd be getting dumped.

Candleabra · 04/03/2024 18:49

He sounds horrible. Sorry. It would no longer be about the holiday destination and expenses, or finances generally. If he won’t listen to you about this, and is nasty about women generally, do you want to go out with him at all?

So what if he thinks you’re a gold digger. Do you actually care what he thinks after all this? I’d get shot of him, life is too short for this level of anxiety (over a holiday for goodness sake! What will he be like over something more serious)

qualitystreetforme · 04/03/2024 16:47

The more you post the nastier he sounds Op. I think you might be coming to that realisation too.

Popquizzer · 04/03/2024 16:12

If he wants to celebrate a windfall by going somewhere few can afford, then he needs to pay for both of you. How can he expect you to have the same disposable income as him? It's nonsense that he won't even tell you what your share of the bill would be but he expects you to say yes anyway.

I'd be getting the ick from his sheer silliness.

ForgivenessHope · 04/03/2024 15:53

@KThughes What are you hoping to get from this st bart's convo with him?

why don't you say how you feel about him/he you; and generally how your relationship is?

everything sounds weird.

littlefireseverywhere · 04/03/2024 15:11

He’s so lucky to have you in his life. I’m not sure he’s going to come out on top over this though. His behaviour is very odd.

anon4net · 04/03/2024 15:05

I'm all for paying your way and not creating a situation where there's a power imbalance. In a situation like this though I'd expect him to pay for the holiday.

Blueberrymuffin8 · 04/03/2024 14:44

Here's a question. What would you do in his situation? The answer should tell you if you are both in alignment or not. If you're not, this won't last. Sorry.

savethatkitty · 04/03/2024 14:32

Tbh, you don't sound like a gold digger & I applaud you living within your means & doing well for yourself. The boyfriend on the other hand, sounds a right miser. Surely, if he's THAT wealthy or just on his $2m salary alone, he could treat you to the trip. I bet the other ex girlfriend's were not gold diggers either. He is just stingy.

CatLevelCare · 04/03/2024 14:23

He doesn't actually sound nice. I think you could do better, op.