Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled at these parents trying to force a girls football team to let their son join?

133 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 03/03/2024 11:34

The FA is threatening to suspend a girls’ football league after a boy’s parents complained because they wouldn’t let him join.

There’s nothing in the report about the boy being trans, or identifying as a girl- he just doesn’t want to play with boys and doesn’t have the ability level.

I’m just gobsmacked at the entitlement of these parents, which they are also teaching their son - that they expect a girl to have to lose her place on a team just because he isn’t good enough to play with the boys.

DM article- so far not being reported by any other news outlets but will keep checking.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13149771/west-riding-girls-football-league-boy-footbal-association.html

OP posts:
AuContraire · 03/03/2024 16:00

Stormwet · 03/03/2024 12:23

What difference does it make really if they’re below or just beginning puberty. Boys are not inherently better than girls at football or any sport and whilst it’s an absolute cheek that they think the girls team is where they should send the below par boys, I don’t see why the sport should be gendered. If they let him in, if he’s no good playing with boys, he’ll be no good playing with girls and will probably drag them down anyway.

Puberty begins about 12, this league is between 12-16 so right in puberty range.

Boys also have a physical advantage pre-puberty, boys are bigger from the day they are born (hence the different length and weight centile charts for baby boys and baby girls.

It's not "gendered", it's sex.

And for social reasons, girls have more of a chance of getting involved when they have a category of their own.

arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 15:58

Please @TheOriginalEmu, please do sone research. Take it from someone who knows. This is a disaster for girls sport. Really not helped by women who don't understand saying things like, but Sylvia is taller than Bob. Height and size is one tiny part of the difference.

Geepee71 · 03/03/2024 15:55

I'd be going back to the FA saying if he's not skilledenough to play on the boys team, he's not skilled enough to play on the girls team either.

arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 15:54

'He's one boy.'
What your number, @TheOriginalEmu, of how many girls it's fine to expose to injury/be pushed out by boys?
One is clearly fine. So is two? What about three? What about 200? What's the cut off for you?
How many boys should be able to take the places off girls?

arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 15:51

Rather obviously not all boys @TheOriginalEmu, but every cell of their body gives them a 20% advantage. Pound for pound they have 160 % more explosive power. So, even an identically sized boy and girl in a collision would see the girl flat on a back.
Anyone who can't see that this is so so wrong is one of two things - utterly ignorant about sport (which is fine just don't muscle in on an argument you know nothing about), or misogyny is so ingrained for them, that they're oblivious to it.

MumblesParty · 03/03/2024 15:50

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:45

And my 13 year old son was half the size of many of the boys he played with. At 13 he was much more on parr size wise with his twin sister than he was some of the other boys. My friends daughter of the same age was a 8 inches taller and dwarfed him in all ways.
not all boys are huge and not all girls are tiny.

@TheOriginalEmu how old is your son now? Is he still smaller than girls his age?

bombastix · 03/03/2024 15:50

At least you see some posters showing how we get into these messes. For me, inclusion in sport means single sex teams. Sport is competitive!

MumblesParty · 03/03/2024 15:47

My interpretation of the FA rules (allowing boys and girls to play football together until age 16) was that it was primarily to enable girls to keep playing. Often there aren’t enough footballing girls to keep teams going, so girls may find they have to quit. Allowing them to join boys teams means they can keep on playing. But that would be their choice - if they felt strong and capable enough to compete against boys, then it would be their responsibility to face any consequences.

Allowing boys to join a girls team is completely different. The girls then have no choice but to risk playing with someone physically bigger and stronger than them. It’s not fair. It’s no better than a 15 year lad deciding he wants to play in his 6 year old brother’s team!

lifeturnsonadime · 03/03/2024 15:47

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:46

He’s not stealing anything from anyone. Just because he is male it doesn’t follow that he is better than the girls. He has to try for his place the same as the girls. Don’t be so dramatic.

I'm not being dramatic. I have a daughter in sport. A boy in the girls league ruins sport for girls.

There are lots of options for boys which don't have to involve being in what should be a girls only league.

arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 15:47

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:36

I’ve known plenty of girls play in the boys league, why can’t a boy play with the girls?

Edited

Because they'd injure the girls...

arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 15:46

@Dotjones
Just to start you off. The women's world record 100m is 10.49. There are THOUSANDS of males who can beat this, including 14 year olds. In fact, there was a high school championships a few years ago just in the state of Florida where every single school boy in the final would have won that years womens 100m gold at the world champs.

lifeturnsonadime · 03/03/2024 15:46

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:45

And my 13 year old son was half the size of many of the boys he played with. At 13 he was much more on parr size wise with his twin sister than he was some of the other boys. My friends daughter of the same age was a 8 inches taller and dwarfed him in all ways.
not all boys are huge and not all girls are tiny.

It's not just size that makes boys stronger, it's testosterone levels and skeletal / muscle tone/ lung capacity differences.

There are always outliers who are smaller or bigger physically but this does not mean that girls teams and girls leagues shouldn't exist.

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:46

lifeturnsonadime · 03/03/2024 15:45

So one boy, who has the options of multiple boys teams because many more football teams exist in the boys than the girls league, gets to steal a place in a girls team in the girl league just because he fancies it?

And who cares right, if teenage girls want a space free from males for safety and dignity?

He’s not stealing anything from anyone. Just because he is male it doesn’t follow that he is better than the girls. He has to try for his place the same as the girls. Don’t be so dramatic.

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:45

AIstolemylunch · 03/03/2024 15:38

I have a 13y old son that plays football, rugby and hockey. He has a 13y old female friend who has a sport scholarship at her school and plays netball, football and hockey. They are both very, very fit and sporty. I am watching them in the park now and he is almost exactly twice the size of her. His shoulders are 1.75x the width of hers and he dwarfs over her. She is extremely slim and delicate looking, albeit fit and strong, her waist diameter is probably half of his.

It's absolute madness to let boys and girls play contact sport on the same teams post puberty.

And my 13 year old son was half the size of many of the boys he played with. At 13 he was much more on parr size wise with his twin sister than he was some of the other boys. My friends daughter of the same age was a 8 inches taller and dwarfed him in all ways.
not all boys are huge and not all girls are tiny.

lifeturnsonadime · 03/03/2024 15:45

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:42

Yes I did. I still fail to see what the issue is.
he’s one boy.

So one boy, who has the options of multiple boys teams because many more football teams exist in the boys than the girls league, gets to steal a place in a girls team in the girl league just because he fancies it?

And who cares right, if teenage girls want a space free from males for safety and dignity?

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:42

Hermittrismegistus · 03/03/2024 15:38

Have you even bothered to read the article?

Yes I did. I still fail to see what the issue is.
he’s one boy.

AIstolemylunch · 03/03/2024 15:38

I have a 13y old son that plays football, rugby and hockey. He has a 13y old female friend who has a sport scholarship at her school and plays netball, football and hockey. They are both very, very fit and sporty. I am watching them in the park now and he is almost exactly twice the size of her. His shoulders are 1.75x the width of hers and he dwarfs over her. She is extremely slim and delicate looking, albeit fit and strong, her waist diameter is probably half of his.

It's absolute madness to let boys and girls play contact sport on the same teams post puberty.

Hermittrismegistus · 03/03/2024 15:38

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:36

I’ve known plenty of girls play in the boys league, why can’t a boy play with the girls?

Edited

Have you even bothered to read the article?

Happyinarcon · 03/03/2024 15:38

How much of any of this sounds real

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:37

arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 15:26

😂😂😂
Maybe do even a tiny bit of research before you say this out loud.

As my job is sport, my hobby is sport, my life is sport- it blows me away that some people know so little about it. I just can't imagine how you can get through to adulthood without knowing, even at a most basic level, that boys are physically stronger than girls.

Some boys, but not all boys.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 03/03/2024 15:36

CurlewKate · 03/03/2024 14:29

It used to be mixed until 12, I think. Maybe 11? Is it 16 now? That's insane!

Actually it's u18s now!

My DD played with a boys team until she reached u16s. She was technically better than a lot of boys she played against at u15s but they didn't like that and targeted her physically. When the u16 league started they all realised she was still there and got it pretty nasty physically and we decided enough was enough as she was constantly being kicked and bashed in to by boys twice her size.

Looking back now she should have left before she did but she was close with a lot of the team and the manager asked her to stay on

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:36

I’ve known plenty of girls play in the boys league, why can’t a boy play with the girls?

BareGrylls · 03/03/2024 15:34

Seems very similar to girls joining cubs and scouts. There are some things, not just sports that are better kept separate.

bombastix · 03/03/2024 15:33

It is the selfishness of the parents. They should be ashamed, but they are not. What consequence is there for people like this? There should be some.

arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 15:26

Dotjones · 03/03/2024 14:53

This just shows up the nonsense of having separate teams for male and female players. It's perfectly acceptable until their 16th birthday, at which point it's completely unnacceptable. This makes no sense. Just make all teams mixed and the problem goes away.

😂😂😂
Maybe do even a tiny bit of research before you say this out loud.

As my job is sport, my hobby is sport, my life is sport- it blows me away that some people know so little about it. I just can't imagine how you can get through to adulthood without knowing, even at a most basic level, that boys are physically stronger than girls.