Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled at these parents trying to force a girls football team to let their son join?

133 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 03/03/2024 11:34

The FA is threatening to suspend a girls’ football league after a boy’s parents complained because they wouldn’t let him join.

There’s nothing in the report about the boy being trans, or identifying as a girl- he just doesn’t want to play with boys and doesn’t have the ability level.

I’m just gobsmacked at the entitlement of these parents, which they are also teaching their son - that they expect a girl to have to lose her place on a team just because he isn’t good enough to play with the boys.

DM article- so far not being reported by any other news outlets but will keep checking.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13149771/west-riding-girls-football-league-boy-footbal-association.html

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 17:54

@MumblesParty
I, genuinely, simply missed the word 'some' out of my post. Apologies. And, actually I was only referring to the one super ignorant poster who then went on to detail about her sons. It's the sign of the times, 'if it doesn't affect me, I don't care.'

Helleofabore · 03/03/2024 17:38

Indeed, lifeturns, I remember last year on AIBU a parent wrote that their daughter was upset that she seemed to have been beaten by a male who was identifying as a girl in primary school races. The amount of posts that were all 'it is just a bit of fun' or 'my daughter is faster than the boys so it is just false to say that boys are in general faster etc' and the list was endless. I was told off for being a parent who was obviously 'too competitive'. Just for stating that girls deserved to be recognised for their exceptional talents in sport.

I come from a sporting family that competed in different sports at all levels. Not me, although I did represent my school once. However, I cannot imagine my female cousins reaching the levels they did if their talent had been written off as some parents inadvertently do in their rush to dismiss the facts.

But fuck, there is now so much known about the dangers to female bodies when coming into contact with male bodies in sport or from an object being hit or kicked by a male body it seems absolutely inconceivable that a sport's organisation such as FA has simply ignored the risk. It is fucking negligent.

And that is even before considering the danger of a female body having to over extend to be competitive against a male body with physical advantages. Particularly during the menstrual cycle when connective tissue is at risk. This can be career shortening or completely career preventing if a girl's sporting career is just starting.

It is good to see though that each year, more and more parents are taking notice and reading studies and understanding the issues. But it feels slow.

Milkandnosugarplease · 03/03/2024 17:33

From a school perspective we regularly have boys coming in with weekend sports injuries, normally bruises and sprains, but fractures are not uncommon and there is the odd more serious break.

very very rarely does a girl come in with an injury

KTheGrey · 03/03/2024 17:27

Pretty sure that admitting that boy would breach the girls' rights under the EA2010.

lifeturnsonadime · 03/03/2024 17:21

Because if they were competing with a boy who had that girl's exceptional talent, that girl would not be winning. Yet, those parents would write that off as that girl not being good enough, or training hard enough in comparison to the boys she is competing against. And they would not even consider the impact that this would have on that girl. All because some parents will declare, it is just a bit of fun, or that 'girls can compete against boys at x age'.

Yes this is really often overlooked. Girls who are competitive in boys teams above the age of puberty are exceptional at their sport.

They often continue to play in those teams because there are not many opportunities in teams of their own sex and they do it for development reasons. They are there on merit and because they are prepared to take the risk that is posed by the power and strength of the boys on the team.

In my daughters sport, which is even more under represented for girls than for boys than football, other than county fixtures she doesn't really get all that competition/ development any more in playing in girls teams. She won player of the season in a local women's team when she was only 13. So she does play in boys and lower level mens cricket teams because she can cope at that level, whereas some of the boys in her boys mixed team aren't good enough at the sport yet to do that. But if any of those boys went and joined the girls team for the same age group it would be a massive risk to the girls on the team.

A boy of her age at county level wouldn't have any interest in either her boys or men's teams because they would be too good, they play in higher leagues because they have both the talent/ technique and strength/speed from being male/ going through male puberty.

I always think that the fact that Serena Williams says she would lose 6-0 6-0 to Andy Murray illustrates the point well. Serena is an amazing athlete but would not have a chance against ranked males. https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=1606459836413781

Serena Williams discusses how even she could not beat any ranked male tennis player. She says it’s because men are faster and stronger. 
Once her and her... | By Rachel JaneFacebook

Serena Williams discusses how even she could not beat any ranked male tennis player. She says it’s because men are faster and stronger. Once her and her... | By Rachel JaneFacebook

Serena Williams discusses how even she could not beat any ranked male tennis player. She says it’s because men are faster and stronger. Once her and her...

https://www.facebook.com/watch?v=1606459836413781

Mummyoflittledragon · 03/03/2024 17:11

My dd is 15. The thought of her playing competitively against the boys in her class is insane. Some of the boys are well over 6 foot with size 13 feet. There is a real trend these days to be buff and some boys spend hours perfecting their 6 pack. Fifteen year olds have no idea of their strength and that they could snap my dd in half!

Mummyoflittledragon · 03/03/2024 17:08

BareGrylls · 03/03/2024 15:34

Seems very similar to girls joining cubs and scouts. There are some things, not just sports that are better kept separate.

Cubs and scouts is completely different. It’s non competitive and cooperative.

newrubylane · 03/03/2024 17:01

VenetiaHallisWellPosh · 03/03/2024 14:07

Boys' football is very different from girls' football. You only have to watch it to know that.

I remember when I was a kid being banned from playing football at the age of 11 with boys because back then the FA said I had to join a girls team. How times change. This was in about 1989 I think.

I don't agree that pubescent boys and girls should play together now though. Teenage boys can be massive. Their muscle mass is greater, and they tend to be taller, and yes, more aggressive.

It was definitely still the case up until at least 2000 that 11 ish was the cut off point. Sensibly so, I think, even though it was probably massively frustrating for the girls who had to leave their teams, as the minority.

Helleofabore · 03/03/2024 17:00

There is also a very marked dismissal by some parents about boys and girls competing together. How often do we see, but my daughter is still better than the boys? The reality is that parent's daughter is an exceptional athlete and should be celebrated for being exceptional. Whereas they just dismiss that girl as being good because they beat unexceptional boys. It builds a very unrealistic narrative that is harmful for those girls.

Because if they were competing with a boy who had that girl's exceptional talent, that girl would not be winning. Yet, those parents would write that off as that girl not being good enough, or training hard enough in comparison to the boys she is competing against. And they would not even consider the impact that this would have on that girl. All because some parents will declare, it is just a bit of fun, or that 'girls can compete against boys at x age'.

The reality is that the research is now consistently showing that even from 6 years old boys out perform the girls at the same age. Because it is not just from puberty that boys have advantages.

caringcarer · 03/03/2024 16:58

No males in females' teams, races and spaces. If this boy is not good enough let him play in a lower league team.

bombastix · 03/03/2024 16:54

Competitive sport for girls and women is single sex. The end.

Smaller boys, boys with concerned mothers and boys who claim to be another gender should be told to go do one. Our society seems to have lost its marbles. We are all intelligent women and these rules don't even respect the idea of girls competing when our own female team nearly won the World Cup. Pathetic.

Helleofabore · 03/03/2024 16:52

OvaHere · 03/03/2024 16:47

Why are we still conflating height with strength? Short boys do not = girls and tall girls do not = boys.

One of my sons, in his late teens, is the same height as me. He's probably not as strong as his taller brother but I do know he's still significantly stronger than me.

Because OvaHere we see it all the time. It is a lack of understanding about the realities of male bodies vs female bodies.

Helleofabore · 03/03/2024 16:51

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:45

And my 13 year old son was half the size of many of the boys he played with. At 13 he was much more on parr size wise with his twin sister than he was some of the other boys. My friends daughter of the same age was a 8 inches taller and dwarfed him in all ways.
not all boys are huge and not all girls are tiny.

I think you need to read the research that is very easy to find.

Male people after starting puberty have many advantages that do actually matter for safety and for fairness. The number of twitch muscles and the ability of boys to jump and the power that they have available to kick or hit a ball. They have stronger neck muscles to even be able to do headers if they are doing them. They are on average faster, they have skeletal proportions that allow better leverage, they don't have to deal with menstruation where their bodies and ligaments are more prone to injury. Their bones are denser so when they hit a female body, they have more density.

This is just a sample.

Just because you consider your 13 year old son to be 'half the size' of the boys he played with, does not make him safe to be playing against female people. And being shorter and seemingly slighter doesn't make him at all safe because even being 'shorter' and 'smaller' doesn't mean he is not stronger and more powerful.

Just because you might deny that he is, doesn't mean that he is. It also doesn't mean that he doesn't suddenly have a growth spurt and become an even higher risk.

It also doesn't mean that because of the different types of muscle that him being on the field doesn't mean he is getting fitter and more powerful at a faster rate than the girls whose safety you are dismissing.

OvaHere · 03/03/2024 16:47

Why are we still conflating height with strength? Short boys do not = girls and tall girls do not = boys.

One of my sons, in his late teens, is the same height as me. He's probably not as strong as his taller brother but I do know he's still significantly stronger than me.

Hermittrismegistus · 03/03/2024 16:46

And my 13 year old son was half the size of many of the boys he played with. At 13 he was much more on parr size wise with his twin sister than he was some of the other boys. My friends daughter of the same age was a 8 inches taller and dwarfed him in all ways
not all boys are huge and not all girls are tiny.

Dont be so dense. Dont really not understand that male and female bodies are different? That girls/women are not the same as small boys and men?

MumblesParty · 03/03/2024 16:44

arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 16:00

Yup. And you'll notice mums of boys who don't have a fucking clue. It makes my blood boil on behalf of our daughters.

You see this is the kind of thing that doesn’t do you any favours. I’m a mum of 2 footballing boys. I don’t have a daughter. But I do have a “fucking clue”, as you so eloquently put it. I strongly disagree with allowing boys into girls teams, as do my sons. Don’t alienate parents who only have sons.

sheflieswithherownwings · 03/03/2024 16:41

I know this isn’t really the point of the thread but the girls on my DS’ predominantly male team often outplay the boys. They are 12 and enjoy the more competitive edge of a ‘boys’ team. I think the boy in question possibly thinks he’ll be the best on the team if he plays with the girls… highly unlikely from my experience. There are loads of lower divisions for mixed teams. Girls have had such limited options in football since the game was invented that they should be able to play wherever they feel comfortable.., girls only teams should be protected.

Helleofabore · 03/03/2024 16:40

One male athlete competing in a girls volleyball game in the USA resulted in a girl having her orbital bone fractured because he could spike with more power than the girls in the game.

One male athlete in a girl's teenage age range rugby team injured three female players in Guam.

One male athlete injured 3 girls in a basket ball team also in the USA just last month. And that was in the first half of the game and the injured girls' coach forfeited the game because of 1 teenaged male athlete.

It has now been proven that female people have much more delicate brain fibres. They also have more delicate bones, including in their skull. Female people have less speed on average than a male player and less power to kick a ball.

What part of all the research that is now available to read for free leads anyone, including the FA, to believe that they should continue to allow any female player to have their safety risked like this.

Yes, the FA rules need to be changed. Why do they think that male after puberty should be playing against female people in a team that has been set up for female people? I even question at what point should teams under the age of adult should be mixed sex because there seems to be little understanding of the risks and a whole lot of dismissal.

NewName24 · 03/03/2024 16:26

BareGrylls · 03/03/2024 15:34

Seems very similar to girls joining cubs and scouts. There are some things, not just sports that are better kept separate.

It really isn't.
It is completely different.

AIstolemylunch · 03/03/2024 16:25

And how do we ensure that your son playe with the girls and mine doesnt? Because my 13y olf and my 16y old would inadvertently hurt girls in a competitive situation. They hurt themselves playing football and rugby against other boys, they would really hurt girls at full contact force.

AIstolemylunch · 03/03/2024 16:21

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2024 15:45

And my 13 year old son was half the size of many of the boys he played with. At 13 he was much more on parr size wise with his twin sister than he was some of the other boys. My friends daughter of the same age was a 8 inches taller and dwarfed him in all ways.
not all boys are huge and not all girls are tiny.

And did he play football?

Sporty boys dwarf the girls from 13 up and it only gets more pronounced as they get towards 16. And even if your son is tiny and weak, doesn't give him or any male the right to invade women and girls spaces.

And the post puberty safety rules are there because the average 13/14/15/16 old boy is much stronger than the average 13/14/15/16 y old girl. Doesnt matter that yours isn't.

Ohwhatfuckeryitistoride · 03/03/2024 16:10

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 03/03/2024 11:40

To make it go away I would say yes to him joining and keep him on the bench every single match. And just say to his parents he isn't good enough.

Yes it's in the rules that at under 16 they can have mixed teams blah blah blah but it's just another way of a mediocre male taking over female sports. It sickens me.

How embarrassing for the boy as well, not good enough for the boys teams so wants to be the only boy on the girls team. The shit he would get at school would be horrendous, how any parent can do that baffles me.

No because he would get to train with them, change with them if he went down that line. And what if players were injured and they had to field him? And finally no, it’s a girls team. As girls keep being told- “try harder”

wiltonian · 03/03/2024 16:10

One of the key reasons that girls want all-girls teams is because the boys push them out of mixed teams - don't pass to them and don't really let them play. Which is why you don't want a girls team to become a mixed team.

And it's not like he doesn't have other places to go to. On average, across England, there are 9 boys teams for every girls team. And lots of 'mixed' teams too, which, when I look at the pictures, don't tend to have many girls in...

Stoodley · 03/03/2024 16:02

Happyinarcon · 03/03/2024 15:38

How much of any of this sounds real

It’s very real. My daughter plays in this league.

arethereanyleftatall · 03/03/2024 16:00

bombastix · 03/03/2024 15:50

At least you see some posters showing how we get into these messes. For me, inclusion in sport means single sex teams. Sport is competitive!

Yup. And you'll notice mums of boys who don't have a fucking clue. It makes my blood boil on behalf of our daughters.