Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sisters annoying habit making meeting unbearable

118 replies

FruitFlyPie · 03/03/2024 04:17

My sister and I are in our 30s, live in the same city and see each other every 2-3 weeks. We get along so well and always have. But she has an annoying habit that is so unbearable I feel I can't spend time with her anymore.

She hasn't been diagnosed or sought medical help for anxiety or any other physical or mental illness, but like most of us she has some level of anxiety and has some body focused repetitive behaviours. Since been a teen she has had a habit of pulling out individual strands of head hair and closely examining them. That's pretty annoying but it's bearable.

But the last few years she has a habit of pulling out individual strands, and poking them in between her teeth or using them to floss her teeth. She does this right in front of me, during lunch, while we are chatting, whatever we are doing. I find it so disgusting to watch I can't bear it. I try to ignore it but it goes on continuously. I've asked her to stop but she just gets angry and says look away if you don't like it. I've tried that but for example if it's at the dinner table, I can still see her doing it out if the corner of my eye.

I suppose it's not hurting me but I find it disgusting, and also disrespectful that she doesn't care enough about me to not do it in front of me. She wouldn't do it in front of her friends or at work, so I know she can stop. Why not wait until she gets home, or worst case go to the bathroom for a few minutes and do it.

Am I over reacting? I haven't told her this and I try to keep a blank but I hate it so so much and feel rage when I even think about it. I don't want to spend time with her anymore. It's such a shame though because we get on so well.

OP posts:
BreakingAndBroke · 03/03/2024 09:28

I would find it gross if anyone started flossing at the table, let alone with their own hair. I agree @FruitFlyPie it is rude and disrespectful.

Food particles and bacteria are being splattered out of her mouth. Yuk. What does she do with the hair when she has finished flossing? Just leave it for the waiter/waitress to clean up?

She might have a compulsion and not be able to help it, but if OP is telling her it is unpleasant, she surely can stand up and go to a bathroom to do it in private.

Createausername1970 · 03/03/2024 09:26

If this is a coping mechanism of some sort then she is perfectly entitled to do it.

But you are also perfectly entitled to dislike it and not want to see it.

Neither of you are wrong or unreasonable.

If she doesn't do it in front of others, then two things spring to mind. Is it that she feels safe with you? Or, conversely, is there something about meeting up with you that causes her to feel more stressed?

You won't know unless you address it. Bringing it up face to face causes friction, so can you message her? Say you understand it's something she does, but you would like to be able to talk about it as you have a couple of questions. Why does she do it more with you? What can you do to minimise the stresses in restaurants etc., as it is actually causing you anxiety when she does it at that those times

GoodOldEmmaNess · 03/03/2024 09:14

I'm sure it does, ventbox. How could it not?
We all suffer and we all have a range of strategies - many of them more-or-less dysfunctional - for medicating our suffering. The fact that the OP's sister has landed on this particularly salient strategy doesn't necessarily mean that her suffering is worse than others or more worthy of accommodation.
I chew my nails and fingers to the point of bleeding and it was only during covid, when everyone was more conscious of hygiene, that I really clocked how disgusting my habit might be for some people.
It sounds like these sisters do have mutual compassion and it is just a case of finding the right structure for talking it through. A suggestion above from a sufferer of trichotillomania (sp??) seemed a really good one - not to bring up the problem while the sister is actually engaged in the behaviour, but to choose a different moment

VentBox · 03/03/2024 08:57

Does it upset you that in the moment she may be suffering?

Does that add to your distress because it reminds you all is not well with her?

MassiveOvaryaction · 03/03/2024 08:21

How do you know she doesn't do it at work/with friends @FruitFlyPie? Presumably you're not with her at these times?
If she's doing it at family gatherings, what do others think/have they said anything to her about it?
Do you expect her to be psychic? If you've told her only 3 times in many years, she doesn't know the extent to which it bothers you does she? "Please don't do that" is really not the same as "That truly revolts me, churns my stomach. I hate that you do it and don't respect me when I ask you not to. Every fibre of my being is screaming STOP IT and I'm clenching so hard to avoid letting it out. I don't want to upset you. You don't seem to care much about upsetting me."

bloomtoperish · 03/03/2024 08:12

Bestyearever2024 · 03/03/2024 07:33

Honestly, the flossing thing is DISGUSTING

It's beyond me how flossing in front of other people is reasonable

It absolutely is NOT reasonable

Of course she can stop. You've told us she can

No way would I see someone who chose to do something which upsets me, in front of me, when I know she can choose not to do it

Yep, did most posters miss the bit after the hair comes out? Comparing it to biting nails or cracking knuckles? Yikes

TrichNamechange · 03/03/2024 07:46

NHS advice is basic but useful: https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/trichotillomania/

There is a lot of information available online, and also some quite useful Facebook groups and forums. It might be a good idea for you to have a read of some to understand your sister better.

nhs.uk

Trichotillomania (hair pulling disorder)

Trichotillomania is when someone cannot resist the urge to pull out their hair.

https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/trichotillomania

buzzlightyearsaway · 03/03/2024 07:37

Just reading that has made me nauseous

I think i would have to avoid seeing her and gently encourage some therapy

TrichNamechange · 03/03/2024 07:35

Ok, name changed for this as it would be outing.

I had trich most of my life - from around 10-40. It waxed and waned over the years, but when it was bad I found it very difficult to stop and I looked bald in places. Obviously I didn't want to do it... except I did it, because it made me feel 'better'. I could stop myself doing it in public most of the time, but if I felt stressed my hands would go to my head, at least. I did it around my parents and partner without thinking, because they were people I was comfortable with - I assume as a sister you'd be the same. I usually had very little awareness of having started doing it, you're zoned out a lot of the time.

If you haven't told her often how much you hate her doing it, she probably thinks it's ok around you. And if you tell her to stop while she's doing it, she will get angry - it feels horrible to stop when you're in the middle of doing it. I used to do the root/teeth thing too (it's not flossing, it's just running it between your teeth. It's very common.) and pulling out a hair but not doing that would make me feel excruciatingly uncomfortable.

Your best approach would be to gently say you're worried about her and want to help her to stop. Getting angry will just make her more stressed. She probably doesn't want to stop because it makes her feel good. It's known for being almost impossible to fully recover from, so she may be able to reduce it or stop for a while, it almost always comes back. You could suggest therapy, hypnotherapy, fidget toys, removing sugar from her diet, a supplement called NAC, or anxiety medication, which are all known treatments. Making it all about you (I find it disgusting, I feel uncomfortable with you doing it) is entirely unhelpful.

Bestyearever2024 · 03/03/2024 07:33

Honestly, the flossing thing is DISGUSTING

It's beyond me how flossing in front of other people is reasonable

It absolutely is NOT reasonable

Of course she can stop. You've told us she can

No way would I see someone who chose to do something which upsets me, in front of me, when I know she can choose not to do it

user1492757084 · 03/03/2024 07:27

As close family, you are one of the few people who can request that your sister addresses her flossing with hair in public issue.
Refuse to accept that she does this in your company.

If she will not seek help, fine, but you will not tolerate seeing it.
Meet her, every time, ask her to stop doing that in public and to go to the bathroom. If she continues, get up and leave.

It is in your sister's best interests that you love and accept her but not her antisocial and unreasonable behaviour.

Snowdrop80 · 03/03/2024 07:26

I don’t think either of you are being unreasonable but neither of you are fully understanding each other I don’t think.

And as a PP said, you’re taking it as something personal when it isn’t.

Luckydog7 · 03/03/2024 07:15

Grimchmas advice is solid. Have that conversation once, at a neutral time and place.

Then a gentle exercise in negative reinforcement. Don't name it but the moment she starts, walk away, go to the loo, say 'sorry I have to go now' if she asks why you can tell her but otherwise don't bring it up.

It's possible she has had negative feedback from others at eg work which has conditioned her behaviour to avoid doing it.

Here's the thing about families. Why are we expected to tolerate things just because we are related? If this was a romantic or plutonic friendship you would be allowed to set boundaries especially if the other person was doing nothing to address it. Why are you not allowed these boundaries in a sibling relationship?

FruitFlyPie · 03/03/2024 07:13

It occurs to me that deep down inside she doesn't feel comfortable with you and that's why she does it. Asking her to stop leaves her having to face up to that fact while shes talking to you ie it would stop her being able to talk to you.

It hasn't come across on this thread but apart from this we have a good relationship. It's not just forced small talk at family events. We are close and I've always considered us friends as well as sisters.

OP posts:
GoodOldEmmaNess · 03/03/2024 07:13

I hope you can ignore the few posts that are strangely harsh and focus on the more constructive ones, OP. Your feelings are completely reasonable here and I do hope you can manage to make a space where you can talk about this in a useful way with your sister.

I think it needs to be a really slow conversation, that gives time for her to feel the wave of defensive fury without backing out of the conversation altogether. I'm sure that part of the reason she feels this fury is that she knows that the behaviour is unacceptable, but just feels really threatened by the loss of comfort associated with stopping.
The sense of threat is probably really deep. I find it hard to articulate why it is so deep -- I just have this really strong sense of how threatened and angry I felt as a child and as a young adult when family members and boyfriends tried to stop me biting my nails. It felt almost violating. I guess this is because self-soothing is part of how we keep ourselves safe and separate.
And if your sister is like me, the anger creates a kind of shutting down, a refusal to take time to think about her own vulnerability and your legitimate needs and feelings. The shutdown of feelings is already present in the self-soothing behaviours, and it is intensified when your complaint about the behaviours threatens her with the thought that she might need to abandon them.
It sounds like you have a good relationship with your sister. So perhaps you will be able to find ways to surf that initial wave of anger on her part and stick with the conversation for long enough to acknowledge what I'm sure she knows - that it isn't ok to do this in front of you.

DodgeDoggie · 03/03/2024 07:05

Personally I’d do one of two things .. go to the loo or for a little wander so you don’t have to endure it. Alternatively give her something to hold when she starts, possibly something you have ready in your bag, a book you want her to read or a wrapped sweet or dental floss

PleaseBeHappier · 03/03/2024 07:01

Try and compromise. I have severe misophonia and my Dad agrees not to tut in front of me. In return I don't use the C word in front of him!

JourneyHomee · 03/03/2024 07:01

I think you are taking something personally that isn’t personal at all, and relating it to respect and who is more important and who is less important.
It sounds like a remnant of childhood dynamics.

Growing up, did you feel you were expected to put your sister first?
Did you find it arduous?
Is it bringing up an imbedded very old feeling of injustice and frustration?

Perhaps this is unearthing other feelings and the two have become wrapped up together.

You cannot change her begs, but perhaps you can change your reaction to it. Perhaps a few sessions with a therapist, for example a hypnotherapist might be helpful.

It may be more useful for you to look upon this as involuntary mental illness.
Your sister is not well and needs your compassion rather than criticism.
Might you speak very gently to her, ask her how she is, tell her you’re very concerned about her level anxiety and you would like to help by making her an appointment with her GP, or booking her a specialist appointment with a therapist.

The above my disarm her defensiveness.

Spudthespanner · 03/03/2024 06:57

Happyinarcon · 03/03/2024 04:36

I have never seen or heard of anyone ever doing this before. I would bring her a magnifying glass to examine the hairs more closely and then give her some dental floss to use instead

This is the weirdest solution ever 😂 really hope you're joking?

OP I'd stop eating out with her.

FruitFlyPie · 03/03/2024 06:52

Thank you Grimchmas, your post is very thoughtful. That is a good way to approach it.

Maybe from her perspective, I'm not bothered but I'm just saying it to annoy her. From my perspective, I've held back literally hundreds of times - what's the equilvant kind thing she has done for me?

I feel I can't win. If I say something, no matter now nicely - I'm nagging her, I'm bossing her around. If I say nothing - well how is she to know, I'm being unfair.

OP posts:
Willmafrockfit · 03/03/2024 06:51

can you talk to her about getting help
getting some sort of fidget toy, or whatever they offer for adults,

Grimchmas · 03/03/2024 06:34

I think I'm being quite fair. I've put up with it for years and said nothing. I let her do it for hours and say nothing.

I think this is part of the problem (problem isn't quite the right word so bare with me) - you have only mentioned it three times in all these years. From your perspective you've exercised huge restraint and tolerance, but from hers, it's been perfectly acceptable behaviour to you for years and you're therefore being totally unreasonable those few times that you do mention it.

I don't think you are being unreasonable at all, but I do think that's probably what's going on from her point of view.

I also think that hard as it's going to be you do need to have a talk with her at a time when you're going to remain calm and grounded and compassionate, and explain that it really does distress you to witness her flossing with her hair. Emphasise that you love her, that you're worried about her, and also that you'd like her to not do it when she's with you.

If she gets defensive as you suspect that she will, first tell her that you're worried about her mental health and would like to support her going to the doctor to see if she can get some help for it. If she says "but you normally don't say anything," it's time for compassionate honestly- that it really has bothered you this whole time and you've squashed your feelings down for her sake for years but can no longer do that and that your feelings matter too.

I'd also ultimately tell her that if she isn't prepared to seek help for it, and if she wishes to keep doing it in my company, that it will limit the amount of times that I want to spend in her company. And follow through - decide if you're going to leave when she starts, or after say 10 minutes of it, and stick to it. Stay calm, don't make a fuss, but just "I'm sorry, as I have said, this is distressing to me and if you're not prepared to stop doing it in my company then I'm going to leave when you do it."

MrMucker · 03/03/2024 06:33

Not sure its as simple as choosing not to when with others.
It occurs to me that deep down inside she doesn't feel comfortable with you and that's why she does it. Asking her to stop leaves her having to face up to that fact while shes talking to you ie it would stop her being able to talk to you.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 03/03/2024 06:19

FruitFlyPie · 03/03/2024 06:16

She isn't ND. I know you might say you wouldn't know etc and I suppose anything is possible, but she has never had any person throughout life suggest that, showed any symptoms or thought it herself.

shows her that there's not anyone she can just be her with

I guess the problem is, who can I be myself around? Why can't I have a relaxed time with my family? She should be coddled and I should watch my words. Why? Is she more important than me? Also I don't think our gross annoying habits are "ourselves". I fart a lot in private but thats not my personality!

I'd be completely fine if she used a fidget toy or suggested meeting a certain place or time. The problem is, she sees no problem!

Some of the things you're saying now really get to the nub of the issue, which isn't so much what your sister is doing as how it makes you feel, and how she is responding to those feelings. Maybe try writing her a letter/long text outlining these more vulnerable feelings? Might be more effective than the in the moment request for her to stop.

FruitFlyPie · 03/03/2024 06:17

Hopefully a really good talk, not at the point it's happening and not in front of others, will help at least to clarify your feelings and hers x

Yes, thank you for your thoughtful posts. I will try this. I suppose I don't bring it up when it isn't happening as I don't want ruin a good time. But yes that would be the calmest way.

OP posts: