Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to fly home with our DD?

816 replies

HomeWard93 · 02/03/2024 23:32

Backstory:
DD is 8 months old had started solids but is still breastfed.
I have very, very little to do with DHs side of the family. I don’t get on with them, I don’t like them and vice versa so I don’t believe in spending parts of my short time on this earth with them unless it’s a big occasion/will cause fuss if I don’t. Before anyone starts saying “LTB” over my DH- it affects about 5% of our relationship, the other 95% is all good so I’m not leaving my partner over wanting to spend time with his family

SIL announced at Christmas time she was getting married. It was DDs first Christmas so PIL and SIL came over from Australia, stayed in a hotel and I only had to deal with them for a couple of hours on Xmas day.

SIL asked me to be a bridesmaid which took me massively by surprise. I thought it was her way of trying to build bridges so I accepted. Then she said babies weren’t welcome at the wedding- I then pointed out it wouldn’t be feesable as I physically couldn’t leave my child for 2 weeks (which would of been the minimum we would of gone to the other side of the world for- those who have been will understand you need the first 4/5 days to get over the jet lag) as she relied on me for nutrition and I wasn’t comfortable leaving her for a prolonged period of time. Not to mention my parents are in their 80s and couldn’t cope with a near toddler for 2 weeks.

SIL at first caused a fuss, couple of days later ran and agreed DD as her niece would be welcome. Great- or so I thought.

Me and DH arrived here yesterday, the wedding is next weekend. We went round to PIL for dinner and to meet SILs fiancée, and she introduced me to a neighbour who “would look after DD while we were at the wedding”. I was gobsmacked.

Ask what she meant and she said DD would stay with this complete stranger I had only just met for the day while I was at the wedding. I believe my precise words in reply were “you can fuck right off”.

SIL is refusing to have DD at the wedding so I have three choices- a) try and get my DD used to a bottle while we are in a strange country, surrounded by people she doesn’t know and is struggling with jet lag b) I refuse to go to the wedding and let DH go (which of course I’m fine with) but enjoy the rest of our holiday with DH or c) I book me and DD flights home on our credit card and leave DH here to holiday alone, again which I’m fine with.

Apparently I’m unreasonable if I do anything other than option A. Couldn’t give a shit what the out laws think and DH is upset too and agrees I’ve been blind sided but understand he wants to spend time with his family.

AIBU to want to go home?

OP posts:
Yazzi · 05/03/2024 02:51

Rosscameasdoody · 05/03/2024 02:40

OP gave the back story in her update, so why are you so eager to dismiss it as untrue ? Perfectly plausible for them to resent her for removing their ‘boy’ to the other side of the world. Their behaviour towards OP must have been pretty unpleasant for her to want to avoid them to the extent she does -and this latest episode seems to bear that out. Hence the split in responses.

Interesting also to note that people are assuming it was entirely her decision to stop contact for herself and DD, when what she actually said was that her DH had passed that on - suggesting a mutual decision. OP seems to be entirely reasonable in her attitude towards her DH continuing his relationship with his family so I’m at a loss as to why you would think she ‘lets’ him spend time with them, as though he has to have her approval, when she clearly has no problem with it.

Edited

Yeah, your interpretation of all the info we have is also the other argument of what reality could look like. And it's true that we really can't say- on the limited info we actually do have, I think mine is more likely but also it's entirely feasible that yours is.

I would say I dont believe that's how people usually use "pass on" in a sentence- to pass on implies you're a messenger and just passing the information you've been asked to.

Rosscameasdoody · 05/03/2024 02:40

Yazzi · 04/03/2024 21:18

This is one side of the back story- the only side we have.

Many of us know a person who acts irrationally, but to them, they are the victim. There's no reason that that isn't plausible here as on the only facts we have, things don't seem to add up.

  1. she says her in laws hate her for taking away their "boy". Boy is in quotes as though she thinks it shows how awful they are to still call him that. When in fact it's entirely normal for grown parents to refer to their grown son as their boy?

  2. in laws came from Aus-UK last year for Christmas because it was the baby's first Christmas. OP only saw them for 2 hours on Christmas. Presumably she "let" her husband and child see them for longer (you can hope, anyway) but even so that's pretty objectively rude unless there's a huge backstory (which we don't have)

  3. SIL asked OP to be bridesmaid indicating that no matter what OP thought, certainly her SIL loves her and wants her to be part of her wedding

  4. SIL suggested leaving baby at home and then arranged a babysitter without telling OP. Both stupid actions, which could be done either because SIL is malicious or because she simply has no concept of what kids are. I know people who would do the same without any nasty intent and simply need to be put right.

  5. No mention that PIL were involved in this.

  6. Instead of just saying "oh that can't work, but your brother can hold the baby while I be bridesmaid" OP has pulled out of being bridesmaid, swore at the bride, and announced to her in laws that they won't have any contact with their grandchild. Enormously upsetting for them and will now be a major memory associated with their daughter's wedding.

OP hasn't returned, and if there was a backstory that puts her actions into context to make them justifiable, you would think she would have done so.

There's a real split in responses between people who agree with the above take and people who think OP was entirely justified even on the limited facts we have. It's been interesting to read.

OP gave the back story in her update, so why are you so eager to dismiss it as untrue ? Perfectly plausible for them to resent her for removing their ‘boy’ to the other side of the world. Their behaviour towards OP must have been pretty unpleasant for her to want to avoid them to the extent she does -and this latest episode seems to bear that out. Hence the split in responses.

Interesting also to note that people are assuming it was entirely her decision to stop contact for herself and DD, when what she actually said was that her DH had passed that on - suggesting a mutual decision. OP seems to be entirely reasonable in her attitude towards her DH continuing his relationship with his family so I’m at a loss as to why you would think she ‘lets’ him spend time with them, as though he has to have her approval, when she clearly has no problem with it.

Rosscameasdoody · 05/03/2024 02:18

daisybrown37 · 04/03/2024 22:09

Good post.

point 6 though - we don’t know what SIL said to leave baby for 2 weeks. She said the wedding was child free and OP responded to say she couldn’t leave baby.

OP has been clear about what was said. SiL asked her to be a bridesmaid, but that babies were not welcome at the wedding. OP said she couldn’t leave baby, SiL said OK, as her niece baby would be welcome. No mention of the neighbour babysitting until OP arrived in Oz. So baby still wasn’t welcome at the wedding itself - a point which SiL neglected to mention until it was too late to do anything. If OP had stayed at home with baby SiL would have had to find another bridesmaid, so she lied to get OP there and expected her to fall in with what she had planned - leaving her exclusively breast fed child with someone she’d never met while she did SiL bidding at the wedding. As things stand OP is still not going to the wedding but it’s cost her a lot of money, a long flight with an 8 month old, and the prospect of two weeks with people she doesn’t like. And who don’t like her.

BruFord · 05/03/2024 01:51

When you choose to marry someone from another country there are compromises to be made on all sides. If you truly don’t get along then lucky you, you barely need to see them. But attempting to eliminate them entirely from your DD’s life is not fair on her or your DH.

@Remaker I’m also in a cross-cultural marriage and I completely agree with this. You have to make compromises and take very different perspectives to your own into account. Sometimes you fundamentally disagree on certain issues (I certainly do with DH’s family) so you need to find common ground where you can.

The OP may never like her DH’s family, but she shouldn’t try to eliminate contact between them and her DH/DD. She may find them crass and thoughtless, they probably don’t like her much either. But no one’s committed a crime, they’re just very different people.

BruFord · 05/03/2024 01:36

Their company is not a safe enviroment for op to be in.

@RandomForest How are they not safe? Unless I’ve missed something, they’re not wielding machetes.
I agree that they may not be particularly nice, thoughtless, and the OP appears to dislike them.

TeamGeriatric · 04/03/2024 22:48

That's rubbish, nobody is going to leave their baby with a neighbour of their in-laws, particularly in-laws you don't really have a relationship with. I also have much sympathy for you paying for flights and for travelling all that way to find out you've been tricked. However as others have said cutting off contact with them entirely is a bit extreme and is going to be a real strain on your husband and inevitably will impact on your relationship with him. Given you don't have to deal with them very often as you live a long way apart, I would try and be the better person and let the grandparents spend some time with their grand child in your presence. Although it sounds like the relationship was already very strained if they flew all the way to the UK for Christmas and actually only saw their grandchild for a few hours on Christmas Day itself. Is the wedding ceremony indoors? They are often outside in Australia in public places, at the beach or in a park. I've been to quite a few weddings in Oz (we lived there for a while and my in-laws continue to live there) and only one of them was an indoor ceremony. I realise you don't actually want to be at the wedding, but I am just wondering if you could actually go to the ceremony with the baby if it's in a public space, and just skip the reception.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 04/03/2024 22:21

I'd be on the first plane home.

RandomForest · 04/03/2024 22:13

Their company is not a safe enviroment for op to be in.

If a result of that is their relationship with their grandchild is affected

IT'S ON THEM

This whole episode shows me they are not reasonable people and the problems before the wedding should not all be attributed entirely at the op's door.

daisybrown37 · 04/03/2024 22:09

Yazzi · 04/03/2024 21:18

This is one side of the back story- the only side we have.

Many of us know a person who acts irrationally, but to them, they are the victim. There's no reason that that isn't plausible here as on the only facts we have, things don't seem to add up.

  1. she says her in laws hate her for taking away their "boy". Boy is in quotes as though she thinks it shows how awful they are to still call him that. When in fact it's entirely normal for grown parents to refer to their grown son as their boy?

  2. in laws came from Aus-UK last year for Christmas because it was the baby's first Christmas. OP only saw them for 2 hours on Christmas. Presumably she "let" her husband and child see them for longer (you can hope, anyway) but even so that's pretty objectively rude unless there's a huge backstory (which we don't have)

  3. SIL asked OP to be bridesmaid indicating that no matter what OP thought, certainly her SIL loves her and wants her to be part of her wedding

  4. SIL suggested leaving baby at home and then arranged a babysitter without telling OP. Both stupid actions, which could be done either because SIL is malicious or because she simply has no concept of what kids are. I know people who would do the same without any nasty intent and simply need to be put right.

  5. No mention that PIL were involved in this.

  6. Instead of just saying "oh that can't work, but your brother can hold the baby while I be bridesmaid" OP has pulled out of being bridesmaid, swore at the bride, and announced to her in laws that they won't have any contact with their grandchild. Enormously upsetting for them and will now be a major memory associated with their daughter's wedding.

OP hasn't returned, and if there was a backstory that puts her actions into context to make them justifiable, you would think she would have done so.

There's a real split in responses between people who agree with the above take and people who think OP was entirely justified even on the limited facts we have. It's been interesting to read.

Good post.

point 6 though - we don’t know what SIL said to leave baby for 2 weeks. She said the wedding was child free and OP responded to say she couldn’t leave baby.

VampireWeekday · 04/03/2024 21:41

SIL and PIL are blocked and DH has passed on that neither I or my DD (until she is old enough to make the decision herself) will see them or have anything to do with them again.

I think it's deranged to say that your DD's own grandparents can never see her again, until she's old enough to choose. If I was your DH I would never do that. Presumably your DH is Australian, why cut off your DD from half of her culture and family like that. If your SIL doesn't have children she may well not understand. Saying "You can fuck right off" is really aggressive, too, a simple "Oh there's been a misunderstanding, I'm not happy leaving DD. It's no problem, I'll just have to skip the wedding" would be fine.

I'd go for a non-theatrical version of B. Have a holiday, don't go to the wedding.

Yazzi · 04/03/2024 21:18

BusyMummy001 · 04/03/2024 12:46

Re a few PP: OP didn't say that she only ‘allowed’ IL’s to see her foe a couple of hours though, did she - just that this was how long she personally spent with them. They likely spent loads of time, days probably, wither DH and DD while she looked after baby or visited her family over Christmas.

The backstory is there - the IL’s resent her for seducing their son and his leaving Aus to get a job and marry her. That they are so disinterested in her child (their beloved bother/son’s child) that they thought he should leave the baby in the UK for 2 weeks to facilitate his visit in the first place shows where their priorities lie - and it’s not with OPs child.

I don’t think Op is over-reacting to say enough is enough. She and her child/children really are very unlikely to spend any time with overseas family during their lifetime anyway. The real issue here is that the DH is being made to choose between his Aus family and his wife and child - both now and in the future. If he choses OP/DC it may/will be a thorn in their marriage permanently.

This is one side of the back story- the only side we have.

Many of us know a person who acts irrationally, but to them, they are the victim. There's no reason that that isn't plausible here as on the only facts we have, things don't seem to add up.

  1. she says her in laws hate her for taking away their "boy". Boy is in quotes as though she thinks it shows how awful they are to still call him that. When in fact it's entirely normal for grown parents to refer to their grown son as their boy?

  2. in laws came from Aus-UK last year for Christmas because it was the baby's first Christmas. OP only saw them for 2 hours on Christmas. Presumably she "let" her husband and child see them for longer (you can hope, anyway) but even so that's pretty objectively rude unless there's a huge backstory (which we don't have)

  3. SIL asked OP to be bridesmaid indicating that no matter what OP thought, certainly her SIL loves her and wants her to be part of her wedding

  4. SIL suggested leaving baby at home and then arranged a babysitter without telling OP. Both stupid actions, which could be done either because SIL is malicious or because she simply has no concept of what kids are. I know people who would do the same without any nasty intent and simply need to be put right.

  5. No mention that PIL were involved in this.

  6. Instead of just saying "oh that can't work, but your brother can hold the baby while I be bridesmaid" OP has pulled out of being bridesmaid, swore at the bride, and announced to her in laws that they won't have any contact with their grandchild. Enormously upsetting for them and will now be a major memory associated with their daughter's wedding.

OP hasn't returned, and if there was a backstory that puts her actions into context to make them justifiable, you would think she would have done so.

There's a real split in responses between people who agree with the above take and people who think OP was entirely justified even on the limited facts we have. It's been interesting to read.

Tryingmybestadhd · 04/03/2024 19:45

Are you on separate accommodation and own car etc ? If so do t go to the wedding and enjoy a holiday , if but then I would be flying home and would never come back

hot2trotter · 04/03/2024 19:43

You've done the right thing. Fuck them.

Sceptical123 · 04/03/2024 19:36

Remaker · 03/03/2024 22:11

I have experience of this from both sides. I’m Australian, live in Australia married to an Englishman. My brother was married to an American and lived there.

I would vote option B but I think you’ve completely overreacted right before your SIL’s wedding. It should be about her, not you. Of course you should not feel obliged to leave your DC with a stranger but there was no need to be swearing. As for blocking all contact it sounds like you were just waiting for an excuse to do that. If you go ahead on this path it will reflect very badly on you and likely will drive a wedge between you and your DH over time.

When you choose to marry someone from another country there are compromises to be made on all sides. If you truly don’t get along then lucky you, you barely need to see them. But attempting to eliminate them entirely from your DD’s life is not fair on her or your DH.

Perhaps try to imagine telling this story to your DD in the future to explain why she has no contact with her GP. See if it makes you cringe, because it should. However there’s still time to turn it around into the story of why you didn’t go to Aunty X’s wedding.

I couldn’t agree more

Sceptical123 · 04/03/2024 19:25

Shutting · 03/03/2024 06:14

‘ I feel sorry for him too. And them. ‘

You feel sorry for the sil? Are you normally such a doormat?

By them I meant PIL, what have they done to warrant never seeing their granddaughter bc their daughter offended their DIL? How is that being a doormat?

puzzledout · 04/03/2024 19:15

alexisccd · 04/03/2024 19:13

did OP come back?

@HomeWard93 are we blocked too? Grin

No, she's on a flight home i expect!

alexisccd · 04/03/2024 19:13

did OP come back?

@HomeWard93 are we blocked too? Grin

puzzledout · 04/03/2024 18:25

Vonesk · 04/03/2024 18:09

You have more choices than that:

  1. Contact the Allocated Babysitter and take control. Play it by ear. On the day: Prepare a Baby bag with foods suitable for baby, diapers etc.+ Bottles of milk ( baby wont get harmed from occaisional formulae.) Do all the things you planned to do at the wedding . Ask the Alloocated Babysitter to accompany you as a ' assistant' take a stroller for baby to wedding ; but on sidelines. Tell SIL your plan to have an assistant with baby at wedding. On the day, play it by ear, so that you have someone, or a Taxi number ready to take you back to hotel if needed ( if it kicks off or baby gets tired)
Edited

GrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin

whatsmyname123 · 04/03/2024 18:12

B I think, it's a long way to go to not enjoy isn't it? Or C. But A is a no from me.

Vonesk · 04/03/2024 18:09

You have more choices than that:

  1. Contact the Allocated Babysitter and take control. Play it by ear. On the day: Prepare a Baby bag with foods suitable for baby, diapers etc.+ Bottles of milk ( baby wont get harmed from occaisional formulae.) Do all the things you planned to do at the wedding . Ask the Alloocated Babysitter to accompany you as a ' assistant' take a stroller for baby to wedding ; but on sidelines. Tell SIL your plan to have an assistant with baby at wedding. On the day, play it by ear, so that you have someone, or a Taxi number ready to take you back to hotel if needed ( if it kicks off or baby gets tired)
Chab92 · 04/03/2024 18:00

If DH is open to spending the rest of the trip with you and little one then go for option B. If he would be wanting to spend time with family post wedding day and expect you guys to tag along, absolutely option C!!! I have a terrible (non existent) relationship with my toxic in laws and my husband isn’t always understanding or accepting of this so if I had been in your shoes I’d have gone home where I’m comfortable and know I couldn’t be tricked/forced into spending time with them!

DottyLottieLou · 04/03/2024 17:44

Option b. Seems a shame to go all that way and not enjoy the holiday. Probably better for your husband too.

BusyMummy001 · 04/03/2024 12:46

Re a few PP: OP didn't say that she only ‘allowed’ IL’s to see her foe a couple of hours though, did she - just that this was how long she personally spent with them. They likely spent loads of time, days probably, wither DH and DD while she looked after baby or visited her family over Christmas.

The backstory is there - the IL’s resent her for seducing their son and his leaving Aus to get a job and marry her. That they are so disinterested in her child (their beloved bother/son’s child) that they thought he should leave the baby in the UK for 2 weeks to facilitate his visit in the first place shows where their priorities lie - and it’s not with OPs child.

I don’t think Op is over-reacting to say enough is enough. She and her child/children really are very unlikely to spend any time with overseas family during their lifetime anyway. The real issue here is that the DH is being made to choose between his Aus family and his wife and child - both now and in the future. If he choses OP/DC it may/will be a thorn in their marriage permanently.

RampantIvy · 04/03/2024 12:27

I think we are missing a huge chunk of back story here.

RampantIvy · 04/03/2024 12:26

Who the fuck lies to a woman that she can bring the baby to the wedding, gets her to fly to Australia and then tells her here's the neighbour that's going to be looking after your baby, and then expects the mother to get the baby used to the bottle by the weekend?

I think a lot of posters have missed this extremely salient point. Although who also has family (inlaws) fly over from Australia to only allow them to see you for two hours?

Swipe left for the next trending thread