Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to fly home with our DD?

816 replies

HomeWard93 · 02/03/2024 23:32

Backstory:
DD is 8 months old had started solids but is still breastfed.
I have very, very little to do with DHs side of the family. I don’t get on with them, I don’t like them and vice versa so I don’t believe in spending parts of my short time on this earth with them unless it’s a big occasion/will cause fuss if I don’t. Before anyone starts saying “LTB” over my DH- it affects about 5% of our relationship, the other 95% is all good so I’m not leaving my partner over wanting to spend time with his family

SIL announced at Christmas time she was getting married. It was DDs first Christmas so PIL and SIL came over from Australia, stayed in a hotel and I only had to deal with them for a couple of hours on Xmas day.

SIL asked me to be a bridesmaid which took me massively by surprise. I thought it was her way of trying to build bridges so I accepted. Then she said babies weren’t welcome at the wedding- I then pointed out it wouldn’t be feesable as I physically couldn’t leave my child for 2 weeks (which would of been the minimum we would of gone to the other side of the world for- those who have been will understand you need the first 4/5 days to get over the jet lag) as she relied on me for nutrition and I wasn’t comfortable leaving her for a prolonged period of time. Not to mention my parents are in their 80s and couldn’t cope with a near toddler for 2 weeks.

SIL at first caused a fuss, couple of days later ran and agreed DD as her niece would be welcome. Great- or so I thought.

Me and DH arrived here yesterday, the wedding is next weekend. We went round to PIL for dinner and to meet SILs fiancée, and she introduced me to a neighbour who “would look after DD while we were at the wedding”. I was gobsmacked.

Ask what she meant and she said DD would stay with this complete stranger I had only just met for the day while I was at the wedding. I believe my precise words in reply were “you can fuck right off”.

SIL is refusing to have DD at the wedding so I have three choices- a) try and get my DD used to a bottle while we are in a strange country, surrounded by people she doesn’t know and is struggling with jet lag b) I refuse to go to the wedding and let DH go (which of course I’m fine with) but enjoy the rest of our holiday with DH or c) I book me and DD flights home on our credit card and leave DH here to holiday alone, again which I’m fine with.

Apparently I’m unreasonable if I do anything other than option A. Couldn’t give a shit what the out laws think and DH is upset too and agrees I’ve been blind sided but understand he wants to spend time with his family.

AIBU to want to go home?

OP posts:
Anniegetyourgun · 05/03/2024 09:57

I'm happy to agree with everyone who's said OP should have responded coolly and firmly without any cussing, but can't condemn her for coming out with an extremely blunt reply on the spot. I'd be bloody proud of myself if I managed not to cuss in that situation. The main triggers would be (more or less in order) my child being disposed of so cavalierly, the perception of being deliberately deceived/disrespected/set up, and being too tired and cranky after the (long, expensive, unnecessary) journey to hold it in. Like when you drop a hammer on your foot or stand up under an open cupboard door, swearing doesn't help at all, but you do it anyway because... well, you just do. Or maybe you personally don't, but many do. Even shouting "OW!" doesn't help either, for that matter. So you shouldn't make any noise, really, just assess the damage and go forward calmly and practically. Yeah, sure, that's the way it works.

As for the comments that OP should not have caused stress to SIL at this special time, one's own baby's needs and comfort should be far more important than ensuring a bride-to-be has a stress-free pre-wedding week. If a mother isn't putting the baby first she's not parenting properly, and if a bride isn't stressed during wedding preparation she probably isn't doing that properly either!

Lifetooshort23 · 05/03/2024 09:55

What in the actual F!!!!!

absolutely do NOT leave your child with a stranger! Mine are 5,3 and almost 2 and there is no way in hell I’d leave any of them with anyone other than grandparents (who they see regularly) and even then it’s for mere hours, would never be 2 weeks!!

I cannot believe any family would say no to relatives - her niece!! Being at the wedding. They are the problem, not you. Absolutely do B or C.

im utterly gobsmacked

Katiebaby3009 · 05/03/2024 09:47

I feel sorry for your husband really! You seem very dismissive of his family and it must be very difficult for him. However I have voted that YANBU because I wouldn't leave my baby with a stranger either and it’s a ridiculous idea from SIL. I would just do option B.

MiniPumpkin · 05/03/2024 09:39

Option b
who does sil think she is ? Surely she knew you were coming as agreed with dd. Completely unacceptable to force this neighbour upon you to babysit. No chance.
enjoy your hol x

phoenixrosehere · 05/03/2024 09:35

Vonesk · 04/03/2024 18:09

You have more choices than that:

  1. Contact the Allocated Babysitter and take control. Play it by ear. On the day: Prepare a Baby bag with foods suitable for baby, diapers etc.+ Bottles of milk ( baby wont get harmed from occaisional formulae.) Do all the things you planned to do at the wedding . Ask the Alloocated Babysitter to accompany you as a ' assistant' take a stroller for baby to wedding ; but on sidelines. Tell SIL your plan to have an assistant with baby at wedding. On the day, play it by ear, so that you have someone, or a Taxi number ready to take you back to hotel if needed ( if it kicks off or baby gets tired)
Edited

Bottles of milk ( baby wont get harmed from occaisional formulae.)

From experience, a breastfed baby can become constipated and/or vomit up formula if they have never had it or haven’t had it in a long time. Formula and breastmilk are not the same whatsoever despite people thinking it is and baby is old enough to refuse it if they don’t like the taste. That’s a lot of faff to attend a wedding for someone who could have chosen someone else to be bridesmaid or keep with what they agreed instead of trying to push a mother to leave her baby.

Doesn’t matter if SIL doesn’t understand it. OP told her from the beginning.

Diamondcurtains · 05/03/2024 09:32

Go with B. Don’t go to the wedding and just try to enjoy the rest of the time there for your husband’s sake.

Blondebrunette1 · 05/03/2024 09:30

Dery · 05/03/2024 09:20

@Sako81 - but why make a fuss in such aggressive terms? It’s possible to disagree with people and stand your ground without turning it into a battle. If OP was on here reporting that her husband didn’t get on with any of her relatives and did things like tell them to fuck off, blocked them and said her relatives would have no access to their shared child, people would regard OP’s husband as behaving very abusively. It’s not okay just because OP’s a woman. OP sounds quite tricky to deal with and convinced of her rightness. She repeated her words as if telling someone to fuck right off was something to be admired. DH already lives 12,000 miles away from his family. Why behave in ways calculated to cause alienation?

Edited

@Dery Telling someone they can f right off is not as bad as lying to someone to get them to spend thousands of pounds and their annual leave to fly half way across the world and then tell them they've arranged childcare for them with strangers and if she doesn't accept she's had a wasted trip. Can you not empathise that in this situation someone would feel hurt and angry and it would evoke a strong response. Narcissistic people manipulate situations and gaslight their victim into looking like the unreasonable one. My brother and SIL BIL would never treat anyone this way but my DH would not be concerned for having a relationship with them if they were this vile. How lucky we are that our siblings and parents are wonderful and moral. They'd never ever suggest our young baby is looked after by a stranger in a foreign country. .... What an absolute disgrace.

Dery · 05/03/2024 09:20

@Sako81 - but why make a fuss in such aggressive terms? It’s possible to disagree with people and stand your ground without turning it into a battle. If OP was on here reporting that her husband didn’t get on with any of her relatives and did things like tell them to fuck off, blocked them and said her relatives would have no access to their shared child, people would regard OP’s husband as behaving very abusively. It’s not okay just because OP’s a woman. OP sounds quite tricky to deal with and convinced of her rightness. She repeated her words as if telling someone to fuck right off was something to be admired. DH already lives 12,000 miles away from his family. Why behave in ways calculated to cause alienation?

Dery · 05/03/2024 09:08

“My god what an over reaction! Particularly in the week of a wedding. Why are you making it about you? Agree to disagree, say you can't attend without dd and graciously bow out. DONT MAKE A SCENE FGS! There's no need. They live literally on the other side of the world so this won't crop up often. Very time your invited claim prior commitment or poverty- when people live in Australia it's fucking easy to avoid them without the need for confrontation! Why on earth make such a drama?!?! You are making a villain of yourself!“

I agree with this. Why did you reply with “you can fuck right off”? That’s so aggressive and unnecessary. They probably thought that they had found a reasonable solution to the issue. It’s an inadequate one and they should be letting your niece go to the wedding but your response is so inflammatory. Is that how you speak to everyone you disagree with?

Eskimal · 05/03/2024 09:05

Option D, your SIL grows up and realises it’s ok to have a breastfed baby at a wedding.

Sako81 · 05/03/2024 09:03

catscalledbeanz · 02/03/2024 23:57

"SIL and PIL are blocked and DH has passed on that neither I or my DD (until she is old enough to make the decision herself) will see them or have anything to do with them again. "

My god what an over reaction! Particularly in the week of a wedding. Why are you making it about you? Agree to disagree, say you can't attend without dd and graciously bow out. DONT MAKE A SCENE FGS! There's no need. They live literally on the other side of the world so this won't crop up often. Very time your invited claim prior commitment or poverty- when people live in Australia it's fucking easy to avoid them without the need for confrontation! Why on earth make such a drama?!?! You are making a villain of yourself!

Yeah, I mean she shouldn’t make a fuss about poor treatment of her and her baby should she?

BrokenWing · 05/03/2024 08:50

They are behaving very badly, and so are you.

A calm, "there has been a miscommunication somewhere, the arrangement was dd is going to the wedding, she will not be going to a complete stranger for the day" and let dh and his family find a solution would have been more appropriate.

You wading in with swearing like a fishwife, blocking everyone and threatening never to see them again is very OTT and really not needed. Why would you put your dh in this position unnecessarily? The situation needs diffusing, while keeping your boundaries, not inflaming.

I feel sorry for your dh that he is stuck between two equally unreasonable sides cruelly trying to play top trumps with him.

Stressedoutmammy · 05/03/2024 08:02

B!!

Blondebrunette1 · 05/03/2024 07:33

catscalledbeanz · 02/03/2024 23:57

"SIL and PIL are blocked and DH has passed on that neither I or my DD (until she is old enough to make the decision herself) will see them or have anything to do with them again. "

My god what an over reaction! Particularly in the week of a wedding. Why are you making it about you? Agree to disagree, say you can't attend without dd and graciously bow out. DONT MAKE A SCENE FGS! There's no need. They live literally on the other side of the world so this won't crop up often. Very time your invited claim prior commitment or poverty- when people live in Australia it's fucking easy to avoid them without the need for confrontation! Why on earth make such a drama?!?! You are making a villain of yourself!

@catscalledbeanz agree to disagree with you. If someone got me to travel to the other side of the world, use to annual leave and spend that much money without telling me they expected me to dump my child with a complete stranger-they are the problem and they have caused their wedding week stress. Although I very much doubt they're stressed they got her DH back without his wife and child. My DH wouldn't have even entertained going to that wedding after that and for the record I have an excellent relationship with dh's side as does he but he also has strong morals and appropriate boundaries because he was raised by good people. Plus his parents and sister wouldn't let our kids out of their sight if they barely saw them even more so, let alone leave them with a neighbour.... 🤯

user1492757084 · 05/03/2024 07:32

Yes, and widening your vocabulary might help; learn some grown up language instead of offensive, hot headed, swearing.

Userxyd · 05/03/2024 07:20

I agree with others - you need to diffuse this as you're behaving like a spoilt child, being very rude and give the bride and ILs huge stress on what is a massive emotional time for them. Suck it up, blame it on your jet lag, tired from travelling, and say you and DD will skip the ceremony so there's no noisy distractions but you'd love to come and celebrate afterwards. Go for an hour or 2, smile be nice, pass around your DD for cuddles and photos then go home to put her to bed.
If you want a happy life do not alienate your DHs family- he won't forget it and it will put a crack in your marriage that could get worse over time.
Life is difficult enough, don't create drama just be a grown up and be nice

Clio82 · 05/03/2024 06:52

Option B.

You only want to fly home to enjoy a particularly triumphant “fuck you,” but you can do that by staying in Australia, enjoying it and avoiding them.

I am English and I moved to Australia to be with my ex fiancé. I know exactly how obnoxious people can be in that situation and it’s 100 times worse when you’re out of your comfort zone. Once I got there, he, his father (a perma drunk, Trump-loving cattle farmer) and some other friends and relatives treated me like shit and I was utterly miserable. I had a verbal showdown with his father in front of half the family not long before I left and never saw him again. My ex’s mum and siblings were lovely, at least.

It didn’t work out but I do regret not seeing more of the country on my own! Australia is very mother and child-friendly; enjoy the slower pace of life, the fantastic brunches, morning birdsong and beautiful sunsets. Make memories and give yourself a rest. Maybe spend the flight money on a nice resort!

Katbum · 05/03/2024 06:52

Just don’t go. No need to make a huge drama of it.

KarmaK8 · 05/03/2024 06:47

I’d go home. No way would I put myself through that. These people don’t care about you or DD.

AvaBates · 05/03/2024 06:31

It sounds like you’ve already dealt with this in your own way. Weddings are stressful things & your SIL has showed her kindness by asking you to be a bridesmaid.
She obviously doesn’t understand the breastfeeding thing, and nor did I before I had children. She has treated you badly by failing to communicate properly.
I’d look for a halfway house here. I don’t know how close you are staying to the ceremony, but I’d attend the ceremony, give them my best wishes & love & then slip away.
The more you can do to help their day go smoothly, the more bridges you can build & the more you can put your SIL at the centre, (it is her wedding day after all), the more you DH will love you & respect you for making the effort.
Blood is thicker than water, I can be as rude as I like to my own family, but woe betide anyone who criticises my siblings, I’ll always defend them, they’re my family. Good luck!

DreamTheMoors · 05/03/2024 06:09

Kjones27 · 03/03/2024 09:43

But it's not all about her and her toddler.

There are other people's feelings involved. There are people getting married. There are other family relationships going on. Op seems to think the whole wedding is about her. The way she reacted is nasty on the week of a wedding.

The tough girls in my town had a saying:

”Don’t start no shit won’t be no shit.”

OP’s SIL shouldn’t have started no shit.
And you shouldn’t put words into other people’s mouths.

Frangipanyoul8r · 05/03/2024 06:06

SIL and PIL are blocked and DH has passed on that neither I or my DD (until she is old enough to make the decision herself) will see them or have anything to do with them again.

Poor DH.

Yazzi · 05/03/2024 04:22

RandomForest · 05/03/2024 02:58

*Many of us know a person who acts irrationally, but to them, they are
the victim. There's no reason that that isn't plausible here as on the
only facts we have, things don't seem to add up. *

Has she acted irrationally though, from what I've seen op agreed to be a bridesmaid for her SIL, she was prepared to use up their limited vacation time for this wedding fortnight in Australia. The babe is only 8 months old, no mean feat travelling with a babe. She also knows there is an undercurrent of not getting on between them, she put this to one side and accepted graciously.

What has she asked for?

Just that her baby can be with her so she can tend and breastfeed the child, That's it.
She has not been demanding.

Your comment shows more about you, that if someone does not fall into line they are irrational and if they complain they see themselves as a victim.

Turn it round, if you expect someone to fall in line, without question, and not complain then you are a bully.

Your comment shows more about you, that if someone does not fall into line they are irrational and if they complain they see themselves as a victim.

Turn it round, if you expect someone to fall in line, without question, and not complain then you are a bully.

But that's not what I've said, is it? I don't think the SIL was right, and I don't think she should fall into line. I obviously don't think she should hand her baby to the neighbour. I've said as such in every comment I made.

I do think that we don't have enough information to be confident one way or another, but on what we have I am leaning towards the OP being over the top in her response.

RandomForest · 05/03/2024 02:58

*Many of us know a person who acts irrationally, but to them, they are
the victim. There's no reason that that isn't plausible here as on the
only facts we have, things don't seem to add up. *

Has she acted irrationally though, from what I've seen op agreed to be a bridesmaid for her SIL, she was prepared to use up their limited vacation time for this wedding fortnight in Australia. The babe is only 8 months old, no mean feat travelling with a babe. She also knows there is an undercurrent of not getting on between them, she put this to one side and accepted graciously.

What has she asked for?

Just that her baby can be with her so she can tend and breastfeed the child, That's it.
She has not been demanding.

Your comment shows more about you, that if someone does not fall into line they are irrational and if they complain they see themselves as a victim.

Turn it round, if you expect someone to fall in line, without question, and not complain then you are a bully.

BruFord · 05/03/2024 02:51

DH has passed on that neither I or my DD (until she is old enough to make the decision herself) will see them or have anything to do with them again.

@Rosscameasdoody I don’t think it was a mutual decision, she refers to “my DD” rather than “our DD”. Her DH is the messenger.