Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to fly home with our DD?

816 replies

HomeWard93 · 02/03/2024 23:32

Backstory:
DD is 8 months old had started solids but is still breastfed.
I have very, very little to do with DHs side of the family. I don’t get on with them, I don’t like them and vice versa so I don’t believe in spending parts of my short time on this earth with them unless it’s a big occasion/will cause fuss if I don’t. Before anyone starts saying “LTB” over my DH- it affects about 5% of our relationship, the other 95% is all good so I’m not leaving my partner over wanting to spend time with his family

SIL announced at Christmas time she was getting married. It was DDs first Christmas so PIL and SIL came over from Australia, stayed in a hotel and I only had to deal with them for a couple of hours on Xmas day.

SIL asked me to be a bridesmaid which took me massively by surprise. I thought it was her way of trying to build bridges so I accepted. Then she said babies weren’t welcome at the wedding- I then pointed out it wouldn’t be feesable as I physically couldn’t leave my child for 2 weeks (which would of been the minimum we would of gone to the other side of the world for- those who have been will understand you need the first 4/5 days to get over the jet lag) as she relied on me for nutrition and I wasn’t comfortable leaving her for a prolonged period of time. Not to mention my parents are in their 80s and couldn’t cope with a near toddler for 2 weeks.

SIL at first caused a fuss, couple of days later ran and agreed DD as her niece would be welcome. Great- or so I thought.

Me and DH arrived here yesterday, the wedding is next weekend. We went round to PIL for dinner and to meet SILs fiancée, and she introduced me to a neighbour who “would look after DD while we were at the wedding”. I was gobsmacked.

Ask what she meant and she said DD would stay with this complete stranger I had only just met for the day while I was at the wedding. I believe my precise words in reply were “you can fuck right off”.

SIL is refusing to have DD at the wedding so I have three choices- a) try and get my DD used to a bottle while we are in a strange country, surrounded by people she doesn’t know and is struggling with jet lag b) I refuse to go to the wedding and let DH go (which of course I’m fine with) but enjoy the rest of our holiday with DH or c) I book me and DD flights home on our credit card and leave DH here to holiday alone, again which I’m fine with.

Apparently I’m unreasonable if I do anything other than option A. Couldn’t give a shit what the out laws think and DH is upset too and agrees I’ve been blind sided but understand he wants to spend time with his family.

AIBU to want to go home?

OP posts:
MumHereAgain2023 · 03/03/2024 09:05

Hell no. B

IDontOftenComment · 03/03/2024 09:01

You sound as if you’ve totally overreacted OP, I feel sorry for your DH who must have been looking forward to seeing his family and spending time with them. To swear at them, block them, and say your DD will never see them again is so overeactive, I think you sound awful. The whole drama could have been avoided if you’d calmly said the arrangement didn’t suit but was there a compromise instead of going in all guns blazing. You’ve cast a shadow over what should have been a very happy day. I would take a long hard look at yourself instead of blaming everyone else.

Willmafrockfit · 03/03/2024 09:00

@puzzledout
oh here we go

puzzledout · 03/03/2024 08:59

WimpoleHat · 03/03/2024 08:58

You’re not at all unreasonable to be upset. But SIL might just be clueless about babies/a bit of an idiot rather than genuinely malicious. A good friend of mine tells the story against herself of how she bitched like hell about another friend with a 6 week old baby who “wouldn’t make the effort” to come to her hen weekend. The day she found herself in the same position, she realised how impossible a position she’d put her own friend in and felt very bad about it. I wonder if, from SIL’s point of view, she’s sorted a problem - she doesn’t want kids at the wedding and she’s found a babysitter. Problem sorted! What she hasn’t realised is that no matter how nice the neighbour, no mother will want to leave their small child with a stranger and that breastfeeding is an intensely physical process for both mother and child which means that it’s not as easy as that.

You were absolutely right to say “no way” and to stick to it. But there’s no point causing bad blood for the sake of it - then you look like the unreasonable one. “Can’t leave DD”, “I’m sure the neighbour is lovely, but it’s not fair on either DD or on her as DD simply might not settle and might be distressed all day”, “I’ll be a leaky mess”, “DD won’t take a bottle”, “I have no pumping equipment”. All of these are reasonable, factual statements. Or it’s fine to say “I don’t want to leave her and I’m not prepared to do so”. But the “fuck off” and the blocking and the “never speaking to you again” just makes you look like the problem. Your stance isn’t unreasonable at all; don’t let your approach cloud that.

And with all that - option B. Flying home looks like a flounce. Just say you’re not going to the wedding and crack on with the holiday you had planned.

Not the only one clueless about babies judging by people like @Willmafrockfit!

MummyofTw0 · 03/03/2024 08:59

I'd love it if you just ignored what they said and just took the baby anyway

BarrelOfOtters · 03/03/2024 08:59

I wouldn’t have sworn at them either and wouldn’t have blocked them. But I’d be thinking how do you keep a long distance familial relationship goimg in clearly trying circumstances without gett Too involved. But I’m not an over dramatic loon.

Teateaandmoretea · 03/03/2024 08:58

BarrelOfOtters · 03/03/2024 08:21

Op is bonkers.

I agree.

The baby is 8 months old, so isn’t stuck to her all the time.

There is an option d which is ‘OP nips out a couple of times to feed baby’.

I learnt on mumsnet that babies should never be left with anyone else. It didn’t occur to me not to. I imagine the neighbour is a nice person and competent/ has experience of babies.

puzzledout · 03/03/2024 08:58

Willmafrockfit · 03/03/2024 08:57

how was her time off wasted?
surely it is still a holiday abroad, not a weekend!

Another silly comment t Grin

Cmon SIL, you're wrong .... accept it!

WimpoleHat · 03/03/2024 08:58

You’re not at all unreasonable to be upset. But SIL might just be clueless about babies/a bit of an idiot rather than genuinely malicious. A good friend of mine tells the story against herself of how she bitched like hell about another friend with a 6 week old baby who “wouldn’t make the effort” to come to her hen weekend. The day she found herself in the same position, she realised how impossible a position she’d put her own friend in and felt very bad about it. I wonder if, from SIL’s point of view, she’s sorted a problem - she doesn’t want kids at the wedding and she’s found a babysitter. Problem sorted! What she hasn’t realised is that no matter how nice the neighbour, no mother will want to leave their small child with a stranger and that breastfeeding is an intensely physical process for both mother and child which means that it’s not as easy as that.

You were absolutely right to say “no way” and to stick to it. But there’s no point causing bad blood for the sake of it - then you look like the unreasonable one. “Can’t leave DD”, “I’m sure the neighbour is lovely, but it’s not fair on either DD or on her as DD simply might not settle and might be distressed all day”, “I’ll be a leaky mess”, “DD won’t take a bottle”, “I have no pumping equipment”. All of these are reasonable, factual statements. Or it’s fine to say “I don’t want to leave her and I’m not prepared to do so”. But the “fuck off” and the blocking and the “never speaking to you again” just makes you look like the problem. Your stance isn’t unreasonable at all; don’t let your approach cloud that.

And with all that - option B. Flying home looks like a flounce. Just say you’re not going to the wedding and crack on with the holiday you had planned.

Clearinguptheclutter · 03/03/2024 08:57

b. Given the backstory I’m surprised you went in the first place. Surely you only went on the grounds that ifs a holiday that you could all enjoy? That’s still broadly true.

Willmafrockfit · 03/03/2024 08:57

how was her time off wasted?
surely it is still a holiday abroad, not a weekend!

Unusualactualname · 03/03/2024 08:55

Yalta · 03/03/2024 08:41

For those that think op is high drama and should apologise for swearing

What would you reaction be if someone lied to you, had you spend £thousands, wasted your time off and expected you to hand over your 8 month old breast fed baby to a stranger

I think Fuck Off was quite tame

I wouldn't swear at them.

FOJN · 03/03/2024 08:55

Your in laws clearly do not respect boundaries. You explained why you couldn't leave your baby in the original conversation and then SIL lied to you to get you to travel halfway round the world with an 8 month old.

I don't think fuck off is an over reaction. They think they can manipulate you into doing something you have already clearly stated you are not comfortable with and think nothing of handing a baby off to someone who is a stranger to you. No respect for boundaries or safeguarding, I wouldn't want to normalise that kind of behaviour for a child either.

Ignore the people who think it's your job not to upset someone who has no problem with upsetting you. It always seems to be a woman's job to keep the peace, not cause a scene and comply for everyone else's comfort and convenience. Fuck that.

This upset would not be happening during your SIL's wedding week if she was not such a manipulative liar.

And why does your husband think it's "YOU" that has been blind sided. Why isn't he bothered about the proposal to leave his child with a stranger?

Willmafrockfit · 03/03/2024 08:54

indeed @puzzledout
but i still feel the op overeacted and needs to eat humble pie
they meant well in their suggestion. and i cant understand all this horror about a stranger

puzzledout · 03/03/2024 08:52

Ahh @Willmafrockfit I see now you're comparing your bottle fed 7 month old to a breast fed 8 month old.

You know nothing about the differences, which makes your posts totally irrelevant

And just because your standards are to leave your baby with a stranger to attend a funeral, I presume for a much shorter time than a wedding, that's your choice and one a lot of mothers and certainly breastfeeding mothers would not choose.

Different mothers have different boundaries, some much more careful than others.

Moonpiecake · 03/03/2024 08:51

Don’t fight with Family in love and don’t go home. Keep the relationship respectful as this will eventually will impact your relationship with your husband. They live at the other end of the world anyway.

Don’t go to the wedding. Thanks SiL for the invitation and say I am unable to go as I don’t want to leave my baby with a stranger and she is being breastfed. Tell her, I hope you have a fabulous wedding. Don’t put on a tantrum returning home early.

Enjoy your holidays in Australia.

everythingthelighttouches · 03/03/2024 08:49

There’s a lot going on here both the background, the crux of this - being blindsided and asked to leave your baby/baby being uninvited, the future as a consequence of your actions (not saying these are right or wrong).

But this comment from a PP is the biggest gaslighting crap I’ve read on here for a while

”You’ve spoilt this trip and ruined what should have been a wonderful family celebration bc you didn’t clarify the situation and you’ve overreacted to a thoughtless suggestion.”

When you get home in a few weeks, I would sit down with your DH and have a serious chat about what he wants to do with regard to his family and him and DD seeing them.

It’s important that you support him in that, regardless of how you feel about his family. And it’s important that the pair of you are on exactly the same page as a family unit about how you handle them.

You indicated this causes tension in your relationship , which you mentioned was only 5%, but is it only 5% because they’re in Australia and actually you and your DH are not aligned?? I think as a couple you need to eliminate this as far as possible.

Ariona · 03/03/2024 08:49

Exactly. If OP doesn’t want to talk to them again that is up to her, but to stop her daughter meeting them (obviously her DH taking her)? That is a bit far

Oh FFS. Op needs to bend over backwards yet they don't want the DD at the wedding?? THIS is how you create toxic families. Op they wouldn't be spending time with me OR my dd, and thank your lucky stars that they live too far away to be in her life.

SanctusInDistress · 03/03/2024 08:48

Do the second option- just don’t go to the wedding but don’t leave your husband to come back to uk. In fact, say ok, I’ll leave my daughter with neighbour, then at last minute say you have diarrhoea and can’t go to the wedding.

puzzledout · 03/03/2024 08:45

@Willmafrockfit surely milk is still an very important part if nutrition at 8 months?

RubertRoo · 03/03/2024 08:44

Absolutely no way would I ever leave my baby with a neighbour I have never met. I wouldn't do it with my 7 year old. I would imagine the 'fuck off' response would be the absolute shock of flying all that way and then finding out they expected OP to leave her baby!! No way is that an option. I can't get over posters thinking of solutions that the babysitter could work - who would leave their child with a random person. Enjoy your holiday with DD and steer clear of the wedding

DazedandConcerned · 03/03/2024 08:43

@HomeWard93 I could have written your posts.

I am also the bitch who took their precious boy away. Even after twenty years they still have nothing good to say about me - they once told my DH he was welcome back after the rose coloured glasses came off.

I’ve not been to Australia in over 10 years and doubt I’ll ever return to see his family. I don’t speak with them and have absolutely nothing to do with them.

Over the years seeing how I was treated my husband has pulled away and is now effectively LC with his entire family. It’s sad - but it was their choice to react this badly to my DH moving to the UK with me. Don’t feel bad - they made their bed so let them lie in it. Protect your children because I imagine they’ll bad mouth you at first opportunity when they get them alone.

Good luck - I am sorry for how it turned out and what you’re currently going through.

Willmafrockfit · 03/03/2024 08:43

AffableApple · 03/03/2024 08:34

The baby is only eight months old. It will be the baby's main food source until the age of one.

surely weaning starts at 6 months? Confused

Peekingovertheparapet · 03/03/2024 08:42

Yalta · 03/03/2024 08:35

They are not interested in the baby. They didn’t actually want to see the baby they wanted baby left behind in the uk

Many (most?) brides are not interested in babies at their weddings, especially a family baby who lives overseas and so is likely to be the star of the show. But I’m not sure that OP has said anything that suggests her PIL think this, I rather suspect this is sibling rivalry playing out and other family dynamics are at play.

Mrseven · 03/03/2024 08:42

HoHoHoliday · 03/03/2024 00:45

I would propose a compromise of you missing the wedding ceremony while your husband attends without you, but you and the baby join for the reception afterwards.

Flying home is just cutting off your nose to spite your face. And all of the nonsense blocking and refusing access to the child just makes you seem childish and silly.

You don't want to spend time away from your baby - that's fine, SIL does not want a baby at her wedding - that's also fine. Be annoyed, but move on from it. Don't let your seemingly irrational dislike of your husband's entire family prevent your daughter from having a relationship with her grandparents, she is your husband's daughter too, he must want her to have a relationship with them.

nailed it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread