Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to fly home with our DD?

816 replies

HomeWard93 · 02/03/2024 23:32

Backstory:
DD is 8 months old had started solids but is still breastfed.
I have very, very little to do with DHs side of the family. I don’t get on with them, I don’t like them and vice versa so I don’t believe in spending parts of my short time on this earth with them unless it’s a big occasion/will cause fuss if I don’t. Before anyone starts saying “LTB” over my DH- it affects about 5% of our relationship, the other 95% is all good so I’m not leaving my partner over wanting to spend time with his family

SIL announced at Christmas time she was getting married. It was DDs first Christmas so PIL and SIL came over from Australia, stayed in a hotel and I only had to deal with them for a couple of hours on Xmas day.

SIL asked me to be a bridesmaid which took me massively by surprise. I thought it was her way of trying to build bridges so I accepted. Then she said babies weren’t welcome at the wedding- I then pointed out it wouldn’t be feesable as I physically couldn’t leave my child for 2 weeks (which would of been the minimum we would of gone to the other side of the world for- those who have been will understand you need the first 4/5 days to get over the jet lag) as she relied on me for nutrition and I wasn’t comfortable leaving her for a prolonged period of time. Not to mention my parents are in their 80s and couldn’t cope with a near toddler for 2 weeks.

SIL at first caused a fuss, couple of days later ran and agreed DD as her niece would be welcome. Great- or so I thought.

Me and DH arrived here yesterday, the wedding is next weekend. We went round to PIL for dinner and to meet SILs fiancée, and she introduced me to a neighbour who “would look after DD while we were at the wedding”. I was gobsmacked.

Ask what she meant and she said DD would stay with this complete stranger I had only just met for the day while I was at the wedding. I believe my precise words in reply were “you can fuck right off”.

SIL is refusing to have DD at the wedding so I have three choices- a) try and get my DD used to a bottle while we are in a strange country, surrounded by people she doesn’t know and is struggling with jet lag b) I refuse to go to the wedding and let DH go (which of course I’m fine with) but enjoy the rest of our holiday with DH or c) I book me and DD flights home on our credit card and leave DH here to holiday alone, again which I’m fine with.

Apparently I’m unreasonable if I do anything other than option A. Couldn’t give a shit what the out laws think and DH is upset too and agrees I’ve been blind sided but understand he wants to spend time with his family.

AIBU to want to go home?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sae3005 · 09/03/2024 13:26

A silly row? Her SIL wanted to abandon her kid with a stranger!! Do you know how dangerous that is. She willingly wanted to risk her nephew for her own gain!! Nah. Don't trust her with any kids.

Voone · 09/03/2024 04:53

phoenixrosehere · 08/03/2024 05:50

OP had been reasonable from the very beginning. Did everything a reasonable person would do in her situation yet she’s unreasonable to be angry with someone who lied to her, disrespected her, and with people who don’t even really like her much that seem to be supporting this person despite the problem they caused because they couldn’t accept OP’s situation after they specifically told her it was fine.

It never ceases to amaze me that the person wronged usually has to be the bigger person and accept such things to make situations less uncomfortable while the person who caused the issue in the first place can get away with it with little consequence and that’s acceptable.

All SIL has to do was keep her word or accept OP declining and find someone else. That was it, very simple. I bet if SIL had asked OP instead of having the audacity to tell OP, she would have received a completely different response and accepted OP’s answer, it wouldn’t have gone this far.

All SIL probably has to do is apologise, say she was wrong, and allow OP to bring her daughter as promised and I bet that would smooth things over.

Edited

God forbid that the SIL could apologise and try to make amends even though she's the one who caused the upset.

Nope, OP is expected to go back and smile sweetly and accept the kind offer and apologise for being irrational and probably provide the wedding entertainment where she sits and engages in self-flagellation about how silly and OTT she was in front of the entire family

Voone · 09/03/2024 04:49

Blondebrunette1 · 08/03/2024 11:16

@the7Vabo for what it's worth I don't think she should refuse to let her dd have a relationship with them but I don't think they sound too bothered about their daughter, they live thousands of miles away and initially didn't expect them to bring her over for the wedding and when they've done everything they could to exclude her when she's got there-that would have devastated my husband as our kids mean everything to him. The OP hasn't at all tried to stop her DH seeing them, she said she feels bad for the affect it'll have on his relationship with them but I'd say that ultimately this is their own doing.

OP has blocked them in spontaneous fashion because she's hurt/angry and she will likely calm down and no contact won't be necessary particularly as they live so far away. I think the point is, the in laws have behaved disgracefully and she deserves an apology and it would help some way to civilise things. She shouldn't just accept what they've done and not make a fuss because they're her in laws is all a I'm saying, she deserves a proper apology and assurance that it won't happen again if bridges are to be built. My husband would in all honesty be livid if they treated us that way and he'd never leave our babies with a random, I wouldn't even have to say it because he would've... But again he's been raised by a family who are so family orientated and they are obsessed with the grandkids in the nicest of ways. I know not all families are the same, relationships with your in laws are important but no one should get a pass if they treat you badly.

Exactly.
She blocked them in the aftermath but an apology from them could go a long way. If they gave a genuine apology and she still insisted that they were not to have anything to do with her daughter until the daughter was old enough then maybe then people could say it was unreasonable, but when she wrote the thread there was no apology forthcoming.

If the in-laws don't attempt to apologise and they let the grandchild fly back to Australia without them even attempting to make amends then that really says an awful lot about them.

If they don't apologise and attempt to make amends and they end up not seeing their grandchild for years because they couldn't suck it up and attempt to make amends then again that says more about them and it's not the OPs fault.

puzzledout · 08/03/2024 16:50

@the7Vabo the SIL is the one that needs to be reasonable! Sone mothers won't leave their child, OP had been honest before travelling!

The in laws are a fucking disgrace trying to overrule that choice.

We know you left yours, by choice. OPs choice was a firm NO!

Stuckinthemiddle7890 · 08/03/2024 13:46

catscalledbeanz · 02/03/2024 23:57

"SIL and PIL are blocked and DH has passed on that neither I or my DD (until she is old enough to make the decision herself) will see them or have anything to do with them again. "

My god what an over reaction! Particularly in the week of a wedding. Why are you making it about you? Agree to disagree, say you can't attend without dd and graciously bow out. DONT MAKE A SCENE FGS! There's no need. They live literally on the other side of the world so this won't crop up often. Very time your invited claim prior commitment or poverty- when people live in Australia it's fucking easy to avoid them without the need for confrontation! Why on earth make such a drama?!?! You are making a villain of yourself!

Maybe the op is strong enough to know she don't want a bar of them. Why do we have to let someone get as bad as they can be before we cut them off?

Blondebrunette1 · 08/03/2024 11:16

the7Vabo · 08/03/2024 03:43

Absolutely do that - take another woman's son and brother (and his child) away from them because of a silly row over a wedding that could, if people were prepared to be reasonable and get a sense of proportion be put behind them.

@the7Vabo for what it's worth I don't think she should refuse to let her dd have a relationship with them but I don't think they sound too bothered about their daughter, they live thousands of miles away and initially didn't expect them to bring her over for the wedding and when they've done everything they could to exclude her when she's got there-that would have devastated my husband as our kids mean everything to him. The OP hasn't at all tried to stop her DH seeing them, she said she feels bad for the affect it'll have on his relationship with them but I'd say that ultimately this is their own doing.

OP has blocked them in spontaneous fashion because she's hurt/angry and she will likely calm down and no contact won't be necessary particularly as they live so far away. I think the point is, the in laws have behaved disgracefully and she deserves an apology and it would help some way to civilise things. She shouldn't just accept what they've done and not make a fuss because they're her in laws is all a I'm saying, she deserves a proper apology and assurance that it won't happen again if bridges are to be built. My husband would in all honesty be livid if they treated us that way and he'd never leave our babies with a random, I wouldn't even have to say it because he would've... But again he's been raised by a family who are so family orientated and they are obsessed with the grandkids in the nicest of ways. I know not all families are the same, relationships with your in laws are important but no one should get a pass if they treat you badly.

phoenixrosehere · 08/03/2024 05:50

the7Vabo · 08/03/2024 03:43

Absolutely do that - take another woman's son and brother (and his child) away from them because of a silly row over a wedding that could, if people were prepared to be reasonable and get a sense of proportion be put behind them.

OP had been reasonable from the very beginning. Did everything a reasonable person would do in her situation yet she’s unreasonable to be angry with someone who lied to her, disrespected her, and with people who don’t even really like her much that seem to be supporting this person despite the problem they caused because they couldn’t accept OP’s situation after they specifically told her it was fine.

It never ceases to amaze me that the person wronged usually has to be the bigger person and accept such things to make situations less uncomfortable while the person who caused the issue in the first place can get away with it with little consequence and that’s acceptable.

All SIL has to do was keep her word or accept OP declining and find someone else. That was it, very simple. I bet if SIL had asked OP instead of having the audacity to tell OP, she would have received a completely different response and accepted OP’s answer, it wouldn’t have gone this far.

All SIL probably has to do is apologise, say she was wrong, and allow OP to bring her daughter as promised and I bet that would smooth things over.

the7Vabo · 08/03/2024 03:43

Sae3005 · 07/03/2024 18:46

Stay, dont go to the wedding, have your family holiday and then cut full contact.

Absolutely do that - take another woman's son and brother (and his child) away from them because of a silly row over a wedding that could, if people were prepared to be reasonable and get a sense of proportion be put behind them.

Sako81 · 08/03/2024 02:25

Some of the women on this thread need to give their heads a wobble. You should be supporting other women, not tearing them down at every available opportunity.

ScottishWaylander · 08/03/2024 00:36

CommentNow · 02/03/2024 23:51

B.

And be cheerful about it. Very casual and "oh dear, such a shame, I'm sure you've just been so busy with wedding planning you didnt realise that saying niece can come meant...that she could come to the wedding. Totally respect her decision, you and DD will make yourselves scarce. Perhaps lovely neighbour can take your place as babysitting not needed."

Preferably said in front of dear neighbour, just for the fun of watching her squirm because clearly there is space for said neighbour with you not going and it would be a shame to waste the space seeing as it's all paid for and neighbour has cleared their diary.

See if she blinks first.

If not then at least you havent entirely wasted the travel costs, annual leave and travel time. Take DD out and be glad you dont have to plaster a smile on your face all day with people you dont like. As annoying as costs etc are, it couldnt have gone any better for you in some respects.

Edited

Yes and the neighbour clearly SHOULD be at the wedding because you would only countenance leaving someone else's baby with a very very close friend...

Rosscameasdoody · 07/03/2024 19:41

RainbowNinja77 · 06/03/2024 18:40

There was no ‘trick’. There has been no pressure - only a suggestion.

She said no to leaving her daughter behind and travelling to the wedding - which is originally what SiL wanted. SiL then told her that she had changed her mind and, as her niece, the baby was welcome. It was only after OP made the journey to Oz that she was told the wedding is still child free and a neighbour - complete stranger to OP - had been opted in to babysit. So the two options OP has are to leave her baby with a stranger and try to get her used to a bottle when she’s normally breast fed, or sit the wedding out to be with her child - which she could have done in the UK without all the added expense. Now in what world is that not a trick ?

Sae3005 · 07/03/2024 18:46

HomeWard93 · 02/03/2024 23:32

Backstory:
DD is 8 months old had started solids but is still breastfed.
I have very, very little to do with DHs side of the family. I don’t get on with them, I don’t like them and vice versa so I don’t believe in spending parts of my short time on this earth with them unless it’s a big occasion/will cause fuss if I don’t. Before anyone starts saying “LTB” over my DH- it affects about 5% of our relationship, the other 95% is all good so I’m not leaving my partner over wanting to spend time with his family

SIL announced at Christmas time she was getting married. It was DDs first Christmas so PIL and SIL came over from Australia, stayed in a hotel and I only had to deal with them for a couple of hours on Xmas day.

SIL asked me to be a bridesmaid which took me massively by surprise. I thought it was her way of trying to build bridges so I accepted. Then she said babies weren’t welcome at the wedding- I then pointed out it wouldn’t be feesable as I physically couldn’t leave my child for 2 weeks (which would of been the minimum we would of gone to the other side of the world for- those who have been will understand you need the first 4/5 days to get over the jet lag) as she relied on me for nutrition and I wasn’t comfortable leaving her for a prolonged period of time. Not to mention my parents are in their 80s and couldn’t cope with a near toddler for 2 weeks.

SIL at first caused a fuss, couple of days later ran and agreed DD as her niece would be welcome. Great- or so I thought.

Me and DH arrived here yesterday, the wedding is next weekend. We went round to PIL for dinner and to meet SILs fiancée, and she introduced me to a neighbour who “would look after DD while we were at the wedding”. I was gobsmacked.

Ask what she meant and she said DD would stay with this complete stranger I had only just met for the day while I was at the wedding. I believe my precise words in reply were “you can fuck right off”.

SIL is refusing to have DD at the wedding so I have three choices- a) try and get my DD used to a bottle while we are in a strange country, surrounded by people she doesn’t know and is struggling with jet lag b) I refuse to go to the wedding and let DH go (which of course I’m fine with) but enjoy the rest of our holiday with DH or c) I book me and DD flights home on our credit card and leave DH here to holiday alone, again which I’m fine with.

Apparently I’m unreasonable if I do anything other than option A. Couldn’t give a shit what the out laws think and DH is upset too and agrees I’ve been blind sided but understand he wants to spend time with his family.

AIBU to want to go home?

Stay, dont go to the wedding, have your family holiday and then cut full contact.

puzzledout · 07/03/2024 13:46

Blondebrunette1 · 07/03/2024 13:42

@Blackhorse32 you're right in fairness there is no point in arguing. We're all very different people and parents, it just really bothered me reading some of this nonsense because it feels very much like anti-women, victim blaming. Some people have unfairly blasted the OP for being a good mum, who has shown strength and been up front in not wanting to leave her baby and also to feed her as she has chosen, to lie to get her to travel and then do what they did was premeditated and nasty. I guess, I just hope that new mums or those in difficult relationships don't read these responses and think they should accept being manipulated and dictated to (when uncomfortable with it) to keep the peace and their other half comfortable. If your OH loves and respects you they won't tolerate this sort of behaviour towards you or your child. I love my in laws and we treat each other with kindness and respect, it's a two way street is all I wanted to put across.

100% this!

The OP is doing a great job and deserves respect.

Blondebrunette1 · 07/03/2024 13:42

@Blackhorse32 you're right in fairness there is no point in arguing. We're all very different people and parents, it just really bothered me reading some of this nonsense because it feels very much like anti-women, victim blaming. Some people have unfairly blasted the OP for being a good mum, who has shown strength and been up front in not wanting to leave her baby and also to feed her as she has chosen, to lie to get her to travel and then do what they did was premeditated and nasty. I guess, I just hope that new mums or those in difficult relationships don't read these responses and think they should accept being manipulated and dictated to (when uncomfortable with it) to keep the peace and their other half comfortable. If your OH loves and respects you they won't tolerate this sort of behaviour towards you or your child. I love my in laws and we treat each other with kindness and respect, it's a two way street is all I wanted to put across.

puzzledout · 07/03/2024 13:35

puzzledout · 07/03/2024 13:18

@the7Vabo it doesn't matter what you did, the OP stated prior to travelling thousands of miles she's not doing it!

Your decisions are yours, you may trust your sister to "vet" the babysitter, OP clearly doesn't.

She's got a few days to bottle train her baby, she doesn't want to, she doesn't want to be engorged or express.

She had made that all clear before travelling, would you honestly accept arriving and all your previous decisions and confirmation of what would happen be totally ignored? Just to show "respect" to your husband?

Sorry, but I think that's awful, I would know my husband would be saying the same thing, we made this clear before we travelled, you're very controlling and ignorant to think we've changed your mind.

We've changed our mind

puzzledout · 07/03/2024 13:18

@the7Vabo it doesn't matter what you did, the OP stated prior to travelling thousands of miles she's not doing it!

Your decisions are yours, you may trust your sister to "vet" the babysitter, OP clearly doesn't.

She's got a few days to bottle train her baby, she doesn't want to, she doesn't want to be engorged or express.

She had made that all clear before travelling, would you honestly accept arriving and all your previous decisions and confirmation of what would happen be totally ignored? Just to show "respect" to your husband?

Sorry, but I think that's awful, I would know my husband would be saying the same thing, we made this clear before we travelled, you're very controlling and ignorant to think we've changed your mind.

the7Vabo · 07/03/2024 12:48

puzzledout · 07/03/2024 11:09

Sorry, I'm not allowed to challenge other people? I'm not particularly angry, but the way people are saying

8 month olds are toddlers GrinGrin

Baby should have a bottle because their baby did, again 🤣🥲🥲

And the worst one, looking after your baby and not allowing them to be distressed with a stranger is disrespectful to their husband, even more GrinGrin

But thank you for your analogy.

My apologies I mistakenly read the OP thread as that the baby who was 8 months at the time of wedding planning is now a toddler. Obviously an 8 month old is different.

I never said, nor do I think, allowing a baby or a toddler to be distressed is the way to go to respect the OP's husband.

Having re-read the original post I still think the OP's attitude to her husband's family is unfortunate and I think she would be very upset if her future son-in-law decided to treat her in the same way - my wife's family don't like me and I don't really care.

While you have made it clear that you don't give a "flying fuck" about my life, I did leave my 3 month old with a babysitter vetted by my sisters wedding venue but a stranger to me minding my baby on the same premises as me. I didn't do so to have a "jolly", it was quite frankly a massive pain that my sister got married so close to me having a baby. I did it to be supportive of my sister and to try to make her wedding about her. I didn't mention it in my reply given others may not do the same. The babysitter was an older lady and she was absolutely brilliant. I left baby with my MIL at 5 months to go to a good friend's wedding again not because I wanted to have a jolly but because she has always been a good friend to me and it was her big day and she wanted me there. I mentioned leaving a 9 month old in creche because of the advice of a public health nurse. And btw I didn't want to leave my 9 month old in creche I did it to keep a roof over our heads.

People make decisions for a variety of reasons, some of it is to do with different attitudes to parenting but in a lot of situations people are doing things they'd rather not to facilitate others. I don't see my decisions as the "right" ones but they were made with the feelings of others in mind, If the OP's tone was I know my SIL will be upset but I can't leave my baby with a stranger and she may understand that when she has kids herself my response would be different.

My point to the OP, if she's even still reading, is I don't really understand why she doesn't care more about her husband's relationship with his family. It is unreasonable to want to fly home because it causes a lot of unnecessary drama and makes someone else's day about her and her feelings. Why she thinks she has the right to deny her husband's family access to her husband's child is beyond me. Over what - a row about a wedding that should be soon forgotten.

RampantIvy · 07/03/2024 12:36

8 month olds are toddlers

I don't think I know of anyone whose 8 month old was walking. DD wasn't even sitting up unaided at that age.

An 8 month old is a baby, not a toddler.

puzzledout · 07/03/2024 11:09

DaftFlerken · 07/03/2024 10:47

@puzzledout - why are you so angry about this ? You are coming across as really very aggressive

Sorry, I'm not allowed to challenge other people? I'm not particularly angry, but the way people are saying

8 month olds are toddlers GrinGrin

Baby should have a bottle because their baby did, again 🤣🥲🥲

And the worst one, looking after your baby and not allowing them to be distressed with a stranger is disrespectful to their husband, even more GrinGrin

But thank you for your analogy.

DaftFlerken · 07/03/2024 10:47

@puzzledout - why are you so angry about this ? You are coming across as really very aggressive

puzzledout · 07/03/2024 10:07

Blackhorse32 · 07/03/2024 10:00

Why are you starting to argue with yourselves? OP made 2 posts days ago, she clearly has sorted something out or just wanted a rant. No need for uninvolved people to start calling each other dramatic or cold, meek and insecure.

Honestly, please don't worry yourself about how I spend my time.

Whilst the OP is not interested, this post may help another mum to have the power to stand up to people trying to bully her into leaving her child.

phoenixrosehere · 07/03/2024 10:05

Blondebrunette1 · 07/03/2024 09:49

@Helenb70 She's not a drama queen she's got boundaries and has been lied to and duped out of thousands of pounds, her holiday/annual leave and hasn't been an absolute sap that's bowed down to her in laws who have tried to force her to dance to their tune. I feel sad for anyone who thinks they should accept this sort of thing to keep the peace for their husband, my husband (who btw has a great relationship with his family as do I) would not stand for it, he's been raised better than that.

You say you're sensible and not a drama queen, I'd say you're cold and meek, without boundaries if you'd accept this, maybe even a little insecure in your marriage if you need to give up every ounce of self respect to please DH. You slam OP for being a good parent and putting her child first, she's clearly got a strong bond with her baby and is not prepared to leave her with strangers in a foreign country to appease her deranged in laws.

my husband (who btw has a great relationship with his family as do I) would not stand for it, he's been raised better than that.

Knowing my DH, he would have been much worse. He would have cursed, and asked his sister if she had suffered a brain injury and to explain her thinking. He would not have cared one iota if people were there and I would have left him to it. I’m the polite one of us and will pick my words, he has no qualms about being more upfront especially when wronged.

the7Vabo · 07/03/2024 10:03

Blackhorse32 · 07/03/2024 10:00

Why are you starting to argue with yourselves? OP made 2 posts days ago, she clearly has sorted something out or just wanted a rant. No need for uninvolved people to start calling each other dramatic or cold, meek and insecure.

Fair point. OP probably doesn’t care about this thread at this point

Blackhorse32 · 07/03/2024 10:00

Why are you starting to argue with yourselves? OP made 2 posts days ago, she clearly has sorted something out or just wanted a rant. No need for uninvolved people to start calling each other dramatic or cold, meek and insecure.

Blondebrunette1 · 07/03/2024 09:49

Helenb70 · 07/03/2024 09:20

'Hope that gives you a better understanding of the situation, you're a very different type of mother to OP.'

Yes, a calm, sensible mother able to see both sides of an issue not a tedious drama queen like the OP!

@Helenb70 She's not a drama queen she's got boundaries and has been lied to and duped out of thousands of pounds, her holiday/annual leave and hasn't been an absolute sap that's bowed down to her in laws who have tried to force her to dance to their tune. I feel sad for anyone who thinks they should accept this sort of thing to keep the peace for their husband, my husband (who btw has a great relationship with his family as do I) would not stand for it, he's been raised better than that.

You say you're sensible and not a drama queen, I'd say you're cold and meek, without boundaries if you'd accept this, maybe even a little insecure in your marriage if you need to give up every ounce of self respect to please DH. You slam OP for being a good parent and putting her child first, she's clearly got a strong bond with her baby and is not prepared to leave her with strangers in a foreign country to appease her deranged in laws.

Swipe left for the next trending thread